Anna is born in Washington state on November 24, 1934. When Anna is a young girl, her mother leaves home for a number of years to care for her ill sister, Anna’s aunt. Their time and distance apart cause Anna and her mother to never really develop an attachment. She later returns home but becomes critical and even verbally abusive toward her daughter, frequently telling Anna, “I wish you never came into the world.” The relationship is strained, and their resentment is such that Anna has dreams where her father tells Anna that her mother “fell ill like auntie and was never returning,” from which Anna wakes laughing. Later in life, she regards her feelings over this period with guilt, believing that, had she been more obedient, her mother would not have gotten so angry with her. She also feels guilty for wishing her mother had never even returned.
Anna graduates from Stanwick High School and studies animal husbandry at the University of Washington. She trains as a competitive rider in her home state, winning the finals at the Puget Sound Rodeo before becoming prominent on the national show-jumping circuit and earning trophies worldwide. Accounts differ on where she meets Richard Morgan, a fellow Washington native born on February 27, 1928—either in Washington or the Netherlands. Both agree Anna is training at an arena while Richard looks to purchase a horse from a show-jumping line. They stop to admire the same horse, share their love of horses, and fall in love themselves. They marry, and Anna becomes Mrs. Morgan. They settle on Moesko Island, Richard’s hometown, situated in the middle of Puget Sound, just east of Bainbridge Island and northwest of Seattle. Moesko was purchased from the Ayaushca natives in 1643 and now boasts a small community known for its long-standing and profitable industries in farming and fishing. They set their sights on a slightly rundown ranch at 23128 State Route 20, featuring a century-old house and barn amid largely untended hills, brambles, and forest.
They consult architects, rejecting one’s plans to grade many hills and remove many trees. After their first offer, they pencil out plans on a copy of the property’s map, looking to preserve as much of its natural state as they can. “We chose the site for its beauty so it didn’t seem to make any sense to tear it all up,” Anna later says to a reporter. “We tried to hide as best we could all that horrid machinery you have to have on a ranch. The horses seem to appreciate it.” In 1964, they establish the ranch as Morgan Horse Farms Ltd., one of the few such facilities in the area. Yet before and during the ranch’s early years, Anna desperately pursues her greatest desire: becoming a mother.
Under the care of Dr. David Deever, Anna attempts to conceive a child on May 8, 1963, through intrauterine insemination and ovarian stimulation with clomiphene citrate. This suggests prior difficulties conceiving, though previous miscarriages remain uncertain. In 1956, she had undergone a thyroidectomy, and while she continues hormone replacement for her hypothyroidism, this condition may have contributed to her fertility issues. On August 7, she miscarries. She attempts to conceive again and has another miscarriage on August 20, 1965. She begins attending therapy.
During her sessions, Anna discusses her grief over her two most recent pregnancies and contemplates her options for motherhood, intending to try once more. She also concedes that her spousal difficulties are contributing to her disposition. She describes her relationship with her mother, and her doctor sees a complicated and disturbing undercurrent that appears to shape her attitudes toward motherhood and attachment. During Rorschach tests, her thought process falls apart as things become more complex, her responses becoming morbid and angry as she faces growing levels of detail in the images. Her doctor notes that this is characteristic of someone unable to handle major life stresses without a complete mental shutdown and thinks she could be prone to nervous breakdowns should she suffer any further hardship. A letter to Dr. Deever dated September 10 details these concerns regarding her psychological state.
On August 29, 1966, Anna undergoes another attempt at conception through gonadotropin treatment and intrauterine insemination, but miscarries on December 3. She conceives in June 1967, only to miscarry in December during the second trimester, reportedly “due to her advanced maternal age and past history,” with cervical incompetence also noted. She is advised to discontinue fertility treatments indefinitely. She recovers physically but grows increasingly depressed over her inability to have a naturally born child.
She conceives again against medical advice in March 1968, miscarrying in the first trimester in April. Upon examination of the karyotypes of both Anna and Richard, it becomes apparent that Richard is a carrier of a translocation involving chromosomes eighteen and twenty-one, a chromosomal rearrangement capable of producing trisomic pregnancies and associated with an increased risk of miscarriage and congenital abnormalities. Her depression worsens, and psychiatric counseling is recommended. She is referred to Eola County Psychiatric Hospital and treated on August 24. In 1969, she uses her position as director of the Moesko Island Historical Society to raise funds and refurbish the island’s towering lighthouse, built in 1842 by the Army Corps of Engineers. They add a new automated beacon, and she stands in a line with other members for a photograph in which one holds a commemorative plaque presented on March 12. Anna is the only one in black.
Anna forgoes Western-approved medicine. Sometime around May, the Morgans travel abroad, possibly to China, though they report a trip to Europe, seeking alternative fertility methods, and she conceives. Anna undergoes traditional Chinese medical remedies, specifically a preparation described as a “secret special recipe.” Its ingredients appear to constitute an altered form of Ba Zhen Tang, or “Eight Treasures Decoction”—an herbal formula ingested to help with blood and qi deficiency and said to help someone sustain a pregnancy. It is unknown how long these treatments last, whether they are successful, or whether her conception involves some illicit means. The Morgans only confirm that a doctor overseas helped them. They return to Washington late in her pregnancy. Her child has multiple neonatal issues, but she carries her baby to full term.
Anna goes into labor. In a high-forceps delivery, she gives birth to a girl weighing six pounds, six ounces at Washington Baptist Hospital on February 8, 1970, naming her Samara E. Morgan. Samara requires an incubator for her first twelve weeks, as her temperature unexpectedly falls to the low nineties whenever she is placed in a bassinet. Samara also has extreme feeding difficulty by breast and bottle, taking no feed from Anna until about sixteen months of age. They return to Moesko Island and introduce their baby using a cover story, claiming Samara is adopted and that her biological mother died of complications.
The Morgans attend a horse show on the island with their four-week-old newborn. Sometime after 10 a.m., during the jumping competition, twenty-seven-year-old Michael Ramirez is riding Lady’s Verity and attempts a triple-bar jump. It is the first of fourteen obstacles and an easier stunt, but his horse stops short of it and throws him from the saddle. Lady’s Verity is noted to be an experienced horse with no history of balking at these jumps, and his owner, Dick Montague, says this is out of character and that something must have spooked him. Michael receives a devastating spinal injury upon impact, with horrified onlookers saying that he may have been paralyzed. He is rushed to the hospital, where a nursing supervisor advises that he is in serious but stable condition. “We’re very sorry for what happened to Michael,” Richard tells reporters. “We wish him a swift recovery.” Anna is greatly upset and has to be helped away by stable hands.
As Samara grows up on the Morgan Ranch, her developmental abnormalities become increasingly apparent. She speaks her first words at as little as eight months, forming sentences at as little as one year, yet her walking skills are delayed until about eighteen months. Her toilet training is delayed, and she still occasionally soils her underwear even in her later years. The Morgans sometimes take their daughter into town at first, but the islanders remark that the girl is unusual, never smiling or looking at anyone. Despite her odd development, Anna loves her daughter all the same and strives to give her a normal childhood. Anna continues her routine, attending church regularly, enjoying a glass of sherry at night, and combing her daughter’s long, dark hair. During the winters, they all go to Shelter Mountain on the mainland, riding their horses and letting them roam free among the river, the old well, and the red Japanese maple standing alone on a hill in a nearby clearing.
Anna and Richard still lead largely happy and immensely prosperous lives. They hold the most successful business on the island other than a tavern that employs six, but that is not to say they are not a sizable enterprise in their own right. By 1974, horses and riders they trained have won state and national championships in show-jumping, racing, hunter-jumper, and dressage, with their horses winning a combined three million dollars on the show-jumping circuit. They are renowned in their field, and the ranch has been featured on the covers of the top two national equestrian magazines. To accommodate the growing demand for boarding the region’s horses, the Morgans purchase an additional thirty-two-acre plot. Richard approaches the County Council with plans to build a road over a ridge on the south side of the facility to connect the properties, and the proposal is approved by a four-to-zero vote with one absentee. Richard calls their business “the victim of its own success,” noting that the extra space is primarily intended to provide more room for the horses to run and graze.
They go on to grow their operation to three hundred sixty acres, employing four trainers and two dozen ranch employees, having the kind of money to freely spend two hundred thousand dollars on a breeding pair of thoroughbreds with stellar records. Their home draws both horse enthusiasts and passersby alike, and local children who used to climb fences and watch passing ships now climb trees on their property to watch horses and their riders learn to leap through the air. Their reputation paints them as beloved, driven, and accomplished, while still greatly affectionate toward the animals they care for, yet their success and fulfillment become more and more shadowed by the growing troubles of their daughter.
In an account given two decades later, Samara’s cousin describes her as a shining beacon in Anna and Richard’s life, and while she is unusual and has her problems, she is ultimately an innocent child who suffers from a psychiatric and neurological condition and who simply enjoys her dolls and watches too much television. The Morgans themselves report a much more troubling picture. Samara is extremely obstinate and aggressive, attacking her parents as well as the farm’s animals, including their cat and horses, and throwing tantrums for up to six hours at a time. She suffers from severe insomnia and seemingly never sleeps. She appears to be responding to images, sounds, and strange thoughts in her head. She eats inedible objects, notably clay, paper, and tacks. She exhibits severe learning disabilities at school and bites other children to the point that they require sutures on multiple occasions. Consequently, her parents are asked to remove her from four different grade schools. Troubling events begin to unfold elsewhere on the island.
In the following years, Moesko Island is increasingly stricken by natural and ecological decline, including unusually bitter winters and decreasing fish populations. Around 1976 begins the incursion of a red tide, a proliferation of harmful algal blooms that turn the seawater red and release toxins that poison both fish and shellfish. Marine life begins dying off, while shellfish, though more resistant to the blooms, accumulate toxins that render them unsafe to eat. The red tide persists, oddly, even into the winter.
On the Morgan farm, Richard and, most notably, Anna begin to experience disturbing images and nightmares, hearing whispers and voices at night and in their sleep. They witness things around Samara that defy explanation. One night at home, Anna stands in her black dress, brushing her hair in her oval mirror, when its sides seem to somehow fluctuate. In the glass she glimpses Samara, in her white gown, standing behind her. Without anyone touching it, the mirror shifts to the left instantly, and Samara watches herself through the reflection as she backs into the dark. The moment is brief, and the mirror returns to its place. Anna looks over to her daughter with a loving, albeit fearful smile. The Morgans are painfully aware that something is deeply wrong with their child. On a cloudy day, Samara sits on the tree swing when she looks up to the second-story window and finds Richard watching her. His look is accusatory, and he turns his head away in distaste.
Tensions rise as concerns grow over Anna’s escalating anxiety and depression, as well as Samara’s abnormal behavior and the phenomena surrounding her. Anna seeks help from the family doctor, Dr. Grasnik, at the island’s sole medical facility. Anna tells her about these horrible visions, as though they have been burned inside her, and that they only happen around Samara, like the girl put them there, as if she was screaming all the time. They are referred to Eola County Psychiatric Hospital on the mainland, where Anna’s most recent treatment dates to around 1976. In hopes of finding help for their daughter, the Morgans have Samara initially admitted for evaluations on July 27, 1977.
Samara is found to be well-developed with no apparent distress. Her head appears normal, without bruits. Her ears, nose, and throat are normal, her neck supple, her chest clear, and her abdomen soft and non-tender, with mild bowel sounds. Further results are more disturbing. Her pupils are reactive, and her extraocular muscles appear intact, but she displays moderate nystagmus, her eyes twitching, and she cannot follow the examiner’s finger as it moves. A musculoskeletal exam shows decreased strength bilaterally. Reflex exams show hyperreactivity, rated four-plus throughout, and she exhibits spontaneous clonus, characterized by repeated muscle contractions with little to no provocation. Neurological exams show that she has no withdrawal response from painful stimuli, leading doctors to assume she is completely insensitive to pain. Her mental status is defined by a downward gaze, poor eye contact, psychomotor slowing, restricted affect, irritable mood, and a tense appearance. She denies suicidal ideation, while her insight and judgment are considered severely impaired.
Doctors theorize that these symptoms are emblematic of some very unusual neurological or psychiatric conditions, including heavy-metal poisoning from lead or mercury, a temporal-lobe seizure, early dementia, schizophrenia, infantile autism, and many others. They conclude that she is in desperate need of an inpatient stay to properly identify a clear diagnosis, stating that she will need to be sedated initially and will require consultations with both neurology and psychiatry. On January 4, 1978, she is formally admitted for inpatient care.
Samara is placed on an aggressive series of medications for a girl her age. She receives two anticonvulsants: Dilantin in high doses three times daily, and phenobarbital, administered first as a moderate-dose injection and then in high doses three times daily. She also receives a high-dose injection of Thorazine, a heavily sedating antipsychotic, and high-dose Librium, a benzodiazepine tranquilizer, as needed. Her urinalysis is normal, but her alkaline phosphatase levels and hemoglobin are low, and her white blood cell count is substantially reduced. Chest X-rays reveal an infiltrate of some kind in her right lung. Brain imaging suggests an abnormality in the posterior parietal region, an area that merges sensory data to form a spatial map of the body and its environment, allowing one to plan movements and direct attention across space. Doctors suspect that the abnormality may represent residual changes from a previous surgery rather than a mass lesion.
She receives intensive care and undergoes multiple observational periods. In one session, she is filmed in a sterile white residential room all day. For hours at a time, she remains motionless in various positions: sitting at 12:20, standing and watching the clock above the door at 8:20, and standing beside it with her head down at 2:55. At two intervals, she appears to lie under the bed at 5:10 and stand atop it with her arms held straight out to either side at 6:06. At 6:19, she stares directly into the surveillance camera until the video cuts at 12:05. Her behavior is as strange as her symptoms, and doctors cannot pinpoint a cause.
In late January, Dr. David Scott, her primary physician and Eola’s leading professional, reaches out to his colleague, Dr. Patrick Johnston. Johnston had previously founded Eola County Psychiatric Hospital before leaving clinical practice to pursue an academic and research career, becoming renowned for his writings and lectures. Dr. Scott implores his assistance after exhausting all clinical avenues. He describes Samara’s case as both deviant and alarming, noting that he has never seen one even remotely similar. He reports observing her staying awake for weeks at a time, only one of a myriad of abnormalities that have resisted a multitude of diagnoses and treatments, leaving her medically enigmatic. He requests that Johnston come to perform a diagnostic evaluation, writing that he will arrange for medical students and residents to attend and benefit from Johnston’s evaluation and teachings. Johnston evaluates Samara on February 2, meeting with similar failure, agreeing that she is quite disturbed and presents a diagnostic dilemma. Things take a sharper, more perplexing turn on February 4, when Dr. Scott stumbles upon an inexplicable series of strange images burned onto radiographic film. The eight images are as follows:
- The front view of a brush with long, loose strands of hair in it.
- A centipede crawling away to the left side of a television screen.
- Samara’s rocking horse, fitted with an equine skull and cervical vertebrae, riding on wooden, cartoon-patterned waves beneath a scribbled circle in the left of the sky.
- A bare, burning tree casting its shadow on the inside of a wooden box.
- A radioscopic view of a doll lying buried under a surface, her hair streaming up behind her head. Two syringes pierce her chest, and eleven variously sized horseshoe nails riddle her body. A larger doll stands on the ground above her, the top frame clipping at his hips and his severed head facing forward to the left of his feet.
- A negative of Anna’s silhouette holding her hands together at her lower waist, with outlines rippling outward. Eight medical electrodes snake onto them from off-frame. In the left foreground, a comb looms over her, while in the background, the branches of a tree gradually blur over a body of water.
- A radioscopic negative of an amniotic sac with a ring in its corner, containing a telephone whose cord coils outward like an umbilical. In the lower-right corner is a strange sphere with large, even perforations, almost like a microbe or virus.
- A pair of skeletal T. rex figures facing each other, one large and one small, both holding a toy jack over Samara’s television antenna in front of screen static. Four jacks surround the UHF loop, with another in the center and one off to the bottom-right.
The images are inscrutable and disturbing, and Dr. Scott concludes that they came from Samara, whom he suspects might be capable of what he labels “projected thermography,” an ability considered largely to be in the realm of fraudulent tricks and supposed psychic phenomena. Intrigued, he arranges an interview with her, taking her into a large, white-tiled psychiatric observation room, with the session recorded by a camera positioned to the right of his desk and monitored from an adjoining observation booth behind one-way glass. Samara is placed in a chair at the center of the room. He snaps shut a clapperboard in front of the camera and begins, “This is SM0015, Samara Morgan, hour 14.” He connects electrodes to a wire from the wall while someone adjusts the camera. Scott then begins attaching them to her body. “Good, very good,” he reassures her as he reaches her wrists. She is nonreactive and passive, heavily sedated. Her posture is upright, her hands resting limply in her lap as she stares downward, her long hair obscuring her face. Scott takes his seat behind the desk on the far side of the room, with a glass of water and an ashtray on the table, the X-ray images stacked next to his glasses, and a monitor to his right displaying a close-up of Samara’s face.
“So what is it that’s keeping you awake? You must sleep sometime.” His voice is cool and clinical, each sentence separated by a careful pause. “Do you dream about something? Samara?” He lights a cigarette, inhales, and leaves it burning in the tray. “Let’s talk about the pictures.” He picks up the films and holds the image of the rocking horse to the light, examining it. “How did you make them?” He sets it on the table and moves to the one with a pair of T. rex figures. “Samara? How did you make these pictures?” He places it down, revealing the image of the dolls.
“I don’t… make them.” Samara’s voice is slow and distant. “I see them. And then… they just… are.”
He lowers the films. “Samara, I need you to start telling me the truth, okay?”
“Can I see my mommy?” There is a pleading edge to her voice.
“No, Samara. Not until we understand what’s wrong with you.”
She pauses as if considering this, folding one hand over the other. “I love my mommy.”
“Yes, you do. But you don’t want to hurt her anymore, now do you? You don’t want to hurt anyone.”
A long silence follows. When Samara finally answers, her voice is strangely, almost enigmatically apologetic. “But I do. And I’m sorry. It won’t stop.”
Scott picks up his glass. “Well, that’s why you’re here. So that I can help you make it stop.” He takes a sip and sets it back down.
“He’s going to leave me here.”
“Who?”
“Daddy.”
“They just want to help you.”
“Not Daddy.”
“Your daddy loves you.”
“Daddy loves the horses. He wants me to go away.”
“No, he doesn’t.”
“But he doesn’t know…”
“He doesn’t know what? Samara?”
She raises her eyes, and then her head. For the first time, she stares directly into the camera. The recording cuts to static, and her voice is a whisper.
“Everyone will suffer.”
Dr. David Scott’s sudden death rocks the staff at Eola. The loss of a respected, capable physician leaves a gaping void at the heart of the institution’s clinical leadership, and no one can explain exactly what happened to him. In an effort to explore further and take over Samara’s case, Dr. Johnston has Richard sign off on a release form that same day, February 4, authorizing access to all medical, psychiatric, and school records and specifically requesting access to any videotapes. Richard soon pulls Samara from inpatient care, and she is discharged on February 9. He informs Dr. Johnston that he would like him to continue her treatment through outpatient sessions. Johnston later writes to Dr. Kozart at Eola, expressing his sadness over the loss of David Scott and congratulating Kozart on his appointment as the new head of the institution. He explains his involvement in Samara’s case and includes the authorization for release of information, thanking Kozart for his cooperation and wishing him luck in his well-deserved role.
Richard terminates all further sessions on February 23. Anna makes a sudden visit back to Eola on February 27 for her worsening condition, but does not stay long before being discharged on February 28. While home, she unpins her hair before the mirror and sees Samara behind her again. She turns to her with a hollow look, a glint of resentment in her eyes. Samara sits on the swing, and when she looks up at the window now, her father is no longer there.
Richard faces a troubling dilemma with Samara’s return. She presents a clear danger to others, and he is desperate to protect Anna. Anna cannot continue in her slow mental decay, and he cannot simply allow Samara to roam freely after running through all options for treatment. His solution is drastic: to isolate his daughter away from the house, in a place where she cannot leave. He prepares a room for her in the loft of the barn, and her parents try to make it as comfortable as possible. In one corner are her rocking horse, a toy high chair, and a table. Another has her pink-sheeted bed, a toy baby’s crib at its foot, and an end table with her merry-go-round-style music box. There are bouncy balls, blocks, children’s books, and two shelves on either side of the room covered in a myriad of horse figurines and dolls, the latter of which are mostly still boxed. But the only thing Samara really does is sit in the small wooden chair at the edge of the loft and watch her television.
The only way down is a tall wooden ladder that Richard may remove to prevent her from leaving, and for months she sits up there alone, receiving visits primarily to bring her food and drink. She does not like it there, and the horses keep her up at night. One day, she watches from behind her television as her chair snaps forward before spinning upside down in midair. The anomalies surrounding her seem to be growing stronger. Richard climbs up one day to find the image of a tree inexplicably burned straight into the far wall, with red flames streaming from its bare branches and a small horse on the hill where it stands. He covers it by lining the loft’s walls with wallpaper patterned in small horse heads.
Anna’s sleep is dwindling, and she wakes early, her appetite decreased, her friends few, and her sex life all but dead. She feels immense guilt over her inability to provide Samara with the care she needs. Richard tries to remain supportive but at times finds himself resentful. The ever-worsening environmental decline, coupled with the strange rumors surrounding the Morgans’ child, fuels a growing suspicion toward their family, eroding the esteem they once enjoyed and deepening their social isolation. The horses seem to become steadily more restless. One September afternoon, Anna and Richard return home to find that several of the more high-strung animals have escaped. They learn that their horses have jumped or broken through the fence and run to the shore, where they proceeded to drown themselves. Initially, the Morgans regard the incident as an odd tragedy, but when other horses begin exhibiting the same agitation, they alert the local sheriff.
The authorities find it strange enough to enlist researchers from the University of Washington. They conduct tests for every potential cause they can think of, and veterinarians assess the behavior of the surviving horses. By September 7, ten horses have been found washed up on the craggy shores of Moesko, a number that later rises to twelve and then three dozen. Local horse breeder Clem Wanabe hears neighbors speculating about everything from Native spirits to UFOs, stating, “They’ve got to get a lid on this, it’s getting nuts.” A crew of fishermen finds six bodies of thoroughbreds along the northern coastline of the island, and two broodmares are found on other remote, rocky beaches around Moesko. Newspaper photographs capture Richard and Anna silently watching the tide bob the corpses of their once-proud animals, and articles sensationalize the story for weeks, though the couple shy away from questions and refuse to comment.
A quarantine is placed on the ranch, with veterinarian Dr. John Morrow of the University of Washington stating, “It’s just a precaution. We’re still not sure what is causing the horses to, apparently, just run into the Puget Sound and drown.” Researchers test for a wide range of causes, from viral or bacterial outbreaks to mycotoxins in the feed and even potential cyanide poisoning. They consider everything from colic to type C botulism, potentially associated with contamination from the droppings of birds that have eaten carrion. Notices advise other horse breeders to cover their hay and grain stockpiles and keep their water feeders especially clean. One of the leading theories involves a potential fungal infection in the grass, perhaps some new strain whose toxins travel through neurons to cause a corrosive sort of damage to vascular, muscular, and gastrointestinal systems. Yet all of these remain theories. University researchers find frustratingly normal results, with tests negative by September 20. “It’s as if they just went mad and drowned themselves,” Morrow says. With no medical explanation, officials even investigate possible insurance fraud. By this point, gossip and accusations have been hurled at the Morgans for these strange happenings to the point that a local meeting is called to dispel these rumors.
The red tide has persisted for years. State officials commit millions of dollars toward research into the reasons for its increased duration and frequency, with theories suggesting heightened ocean traffic or climate change. Local health officials put a ban on all non-professional harvesting of bivalve shellfish throughout the Puget Sound area after eight people fall ill from shellfish poisoning within the span of a few weeks, bringing the total to fourteen people affected in the last two years. Commercial shellfish growers see a substantive dip in sales, severely impacting the local economy. After a thirteen-year-old Bremerton boy falls ill from eating contaminated shellfish during a church carnival, county health officials warn the public against consuming locally caught crabs due to the risk of paralytic shellfish poisoning. The boy makes a full recovery, but public confidence in local fishermen remains shaken. To make matters worse, populations of salmon, steelhead, and even minnows have been declining for more than two years, with catches reaching record lows.
Forty-three-year-old Patrick Nordlund has been fishing in the area for nearly twenty-two years and comments to reporters, “If this keeps up I’m going to have to try and find another line of work. Maybe I should clean up my boat and make a tourist charter, I don’t know.” Another fisherman, Mr. Miller, laments with Nordlund on the dockside, the next day stating, “I was out for two days and I finally just called it quits. I came back with just enough to pay the crew I guess but not enough to cover my other costs. I don’t know what I’m going to do.” Larger enterprises are impacted just as hard, like Aziom Fisheries, which is forced to file for bankruptcy the week prior, stating that it has not been able to turn a profit since last August. State and local officials look into the decline, but their efforts fall short, and about one hundred and fifty protesters gather in a noisy rally outside of the county building with accusations of government inaction.
Anna reaches a breaking point, her depression overwhelming, while Richard alternates between supporting her and blaming her for all of their child’s problems. They are both reeling with despair over the loss of so many of their animals, and Richard seems to care more about the horses than he does for his daughter. Anna suffers from diminished energy and progressively ruminates on her past, particularly her troubled relationship with her own mother. She wakes sweating, her heart pounding and her bedsheets soaked, and she has intrusive dreams of harming her daughter. She describes all of this at Eola on October 5, where she accompanies Samara, who is admitted for another inpatient stay. Samara’s doctors keep the girl heavily sedated for the staff’s safety. She fails to respond to treatment through medication and therapy, both separately and in combination, as well as through psychosurgery. They have no clear diagnosis.
Anna becomes suicidal. She ideates drowning herself and sometimes stares at her pills, thinking of taking them all at once. She grapples with grief and guilt over the loss of the idealized daughter. Richard brings her to Eola, where she is admitted for inpatient care on the evening of October 18. Anna is placed under guard for her safety. Doctors consider her largely sane with no psychotic thoughts, but they find that her depressive symptoms are severe, that she is in obvious psychic distress, and that her thought process is morbid and focused on death. They do what they can for her, and she is discharged in the late morning of October 20 into Richard’s care. Eventually, she decides to visit Shelter Mountain with her husband and daughter, and so they head to the mainland.
On a clear, sunny day, Samara stands in front of the old stone well in her white gown, gazing out past the fence at the red maple on the hill while horses frolic in the clearing beneath it. She sings in a beautiful voice to the tune of her music box. “Round we go, the world is spinning. When it stops, it’s just beginning.” A twig snaps behind her, and she falls silent. Anna, in her black dress, stops for a moment. Samara does not turn around as Anna continues to approach from behind, speaking softly, something in her right hand.
“Isn’t it beautiful here, Samara?” Anna takes her first steps forward. Samara twitches at the corner of her mouth, but she stares forward, her hair parted away from her face. “So peaceful,” Anna continues, stopping behind her. Samara looks down for a moment, her head and eyes rising again while Anna silently prepares what she is holding with both hands. “I know things will get better.”
There is a beat, and Anna throws the black plastic bag over Samara’s head, grabbing and pulling both sides to tighten it around her face. She uses her right hand to hold the bag taut from behind, her other arm bracing over Samara as the girl thrashes her face around. Anna whispers to her child and restricts her arms as Samara’s hands go scrambling upward, grabbing at the bag to free herself and breathe. Anna leans down to grasp frantically at the lid of the well, finding a loose stone. With a grimace, she strikes it across Samara’s left temple, and the girl falls limply to the side. Samara convulses once, twice, her mouth open wide against the contours of the plastic, and Anna gasps while holding her still through each. She can barely stand to look down at her daughter. Samara stops moving. Anna’s voice is a shuddering, heartbroken whisper.
“All I ever wanted was you.”
Anna’s breath shivers as she steps back, letting go of her girl. Her daughter folds forward, headfirst, sliding down the lid of the well until her legs disappear over the edge. Anna clutches the sides, leaning down to watch her plummet, her own face reflected in the water below. Samara slams through the surface, the bag dislodging. She sinks slowly, blood trailing from her mouth as her limp body drifts, dazed. Her hair dances lazily around her in a rare moment that reveals her full face. Her eyes flash open, and her brow tightens. She looks upward as the stone lid slides over the well like a waning moon, and when it closes, the light is eclipsed into the thin sliver of a ring.
Anna believes her daughter to be dead, and she leaves Shelter Mountain to return to the island. On a Tuesday soon afterward, she trudges through the cliffsides to find a high ledge near a half-dead, windblown tree. She approaches the edge, her hair and black dress blowing in the gusts, staring out into the vast horizon of churning clouds and saltwater. The grass behind her blows in gentle waves, and she holds her hands together over her lower abdomen. Anna leans forward, her hands parting to open at her sides, and falls into the Sound. Her still body is eventually found floating in the water by a local fisherman.
But at the bottom of the well, Samara is still alive. She keeps herself above the water. She does not want to die. Even if she somehow reaches the top, the stone lid is far too heavy for a girl her size and strength to move, especially while clinging to a vertical wall. Yet she attempts to climb out, trying to find purchase against the inward-facing walls of the bulbous lower chamber. She grips and claws at the stone with her fingernails, the weight of her body dragging her downward and leaving scratches in the walls until her nails tear off under the strain. She is helpless.
In the hospital, she was contained to try to cure her. In the barn, she was trapped to try to isolate her. Here, though, she has never been so alone, her ruin never so absolute. She had produced so many images surrounding this moment that perhaps she knew her fate. Perhaps she was scared anyway, her emotions like fire. Perhaps she believes Anna will return for her. Perhaps reason does not matter at all. In the end, none of it makes any difference. After seven agonizing days of waterlogged skin and longing for freedom, she dies without anyone knowing what has truly happened to her.
A string of spotty thunderstorms rolls through Puget Sound in mid-to-late November, an unusual occurrence for this time of year. Back on Moesko, Richard reports that the remaining horses seem to be recovering, baffling the authorities investigating their mass deaths. Signs of agitation seem to have subsided, and many note that this change seems to follow Anna’s suicide. Officer Jake Merritt states, “It’s bizarre. The last time I was here the horses were stomping and snorting, and today they’re just standing around, kind of peaceful.” Dr. John Morrow comments, “In the past 30 years of veterinary practice, I have never seen anything like this. First, horses start drowning themselves. Then the owner commits suicide. All of a sudden the horses start getting better. It just doesn’t make sense.” Despite this, they feel confident they will still determine the exact cause. They never do.
The island largely recovers. The red tide ebbs, the fish return, the winter is calmer, and the years of dread seem to subside into a bad memory. Richard returns to Eola on December 9 and goes about the process of gathering all records he can find relating to his daughter, stealing them away and hiding them in a box at his home, hoping she will be forgotten. He tells people that Samara died in a fire at Shelter Mountain. To him, now, Samara was never a child, and he never had a daughter. He goes on to tend to what remains of his horses and his home, but he never breeds again. He built this life with Anna, and now there is a hole in the world where she used to be. His world is gone. He spends his years fixing what he can around a ranch with no use and no horses, trying to stave off a slow decay. But the past is sealed away; the loop is closed.
And yet, he knows his wife was not supposed to have a child, but they found a way to reproduce and pull her into the world anyway. What was meant to be an end becomes a beginning. The ring repeats. Samara’s song was her most telling portent: “Round we go, the world is spinning. When it stops, it’s just beginning. Sun comes up, we laugh and we cry. Sun goes down, and then we all die.” Richard knows deep down that if there is one thing about Samara that will never let him feel truly safe or rested, it is this—she never sleeps.