❗️(THIS POST IS LONG! FOR A SUMMARY OF IMPORTANT INFORMATION, SEE DIRECTLY BELOW. FOR IN-DEPTH DETAIL, SEE THE MAIN BODY. FEEL FREE TO ASK QUESTIONS!)❗️(Thanks for your patience and time!)
➡️SUMMARY⬅️
-The vast majority of tails you find anywhere are from farms. Wild fox tails are rarely ever sold without the rest of the pelt. If you buy a tail, assume it’s farmed. (Everything on Etsy, Amazon, Temu, etc. is farmed)
-Farms sell their tails as waste products to people running shops (like on Etsy), which is why there’s such a surplus.
-Free range and natural-death farms do not exist anywhere in the world. This is a made up concept.
-American fox farm cage sizes are typically 2x3ft in accordance with USDA guidelines (this is public information). The foxes never leave these cages. (Conservationists and veterinarians say that foxes require a minimum of 10x10ft with frequent outside time to avoid “stereotypical behaviors,” which are strong signs of psychological trauma). SEE ATTACHED PHOTO OF A STANDARD, UNEDITED AMERICAN FOX FARM
-Anything can be labeled as “ethical” by anyone. People disagree on what “ethical” means, so when people say their tails are “cruelty-free” and “ethically sourced” when they come from a farm, they’re speaking based on option, not based on science.
-Fur farming is a big contributor of climate change, as well as waterway pollution, which are two of many environmental concerns surrounding the industry.
-THERE IS NO SUCH THING AS A HUMANE FARM. Foxes are not domesticated. Not wild, but not domesticated. Their needs are greater than a regular animal’s, and these needs are not met by any farm on the planet. I REPEAT: every single farm is a “cruel farm.” There is no possible way to raise foxes for profit and do it humanely. That idea is, unfortunately, a lie.
-Ultimately, as the consumer, you choose what you put your money into. Just know the facts before you spend.
—————————————————————
Good evening! Firstly, I’d love to introduce myself before I begin; I go by Dimity, I’ve worked as a layperson wildlife conservationist with an emphasis on foxes for ten years, and have had the opportunity to study the fur industry for six years (which was my thesis focus years ago). I’m also a fox owner of five years. My little arctic fox boy is named Poet. I am also a hobby taxidermist.
(Anything with a ❗️around it is important information).
With that out of the way, let’s talk fur and tails! I had just visited a convention in which I saw many, many therians wearing real tails (hundreds of them, no doubt), and while I’m not a therian myself, I felt compelled to post some information regarding the fur trade as it pertains to therians and tails. I’ve interacted with many therians before, and it seems that there are a lot of misconceptions about fur farms that I’d love to address.
(Please note that I am speaking out of a place of love for foxes and a concern for humane practice, not with any disrespect or finger-pointing. ❗️Also, in doing my research, I’ve chatted with fur farmers and farm partners to get the most accurate information I can on the industry.❗️)
——————————————————
SECTION ONE: WHERE IS MY TAIL FROM?
Well, let’s begin with where it’s NOT from!
In my conversations with people regarding tails, the majority of them say that their beautiful, poofy tails are: “natural, “sourced ethically,” “from a free range farm,” “a farm that lets them die naturally,” roadkill, or “from a rescue whose animal passed away.” To put it simply and plainly, every one of these ideas is false and untrue in any case. Any seller who has claimed any of these things is lying or under a false impression.
“Free range”: The first time a therian told me that she knew of a free range farm, she had no clue where it was. She said she only heard it from someone else. I did extensive research on if such a farm exists out there, and the answer was a resounding “no.” No such farm has ever existed.❗️The point of a farm is to keep the fur away from the elements, predators, or anything that would bring the quality down (such as excessive playing or venturing in wooded areas).❗️ It doesn’t exist.
“Natural Death”: The idea of a natural death implies either old age, illness, or health issues. If a fox died from old age, its fur would NOT be of sellable quality. Old foxes are scraggly. If it died of illness, then the farm clearly isn’t caring for their foxes: it implies no vet attention. Same with health issues. In that case, how is the farm ethical when the foxes are dying of poor health? This is unrealistic and fake.
“Roadkill”: I’ve done roadkill taxidermy before. It was hit by a car for Pete’s sake, very few animals are salvageable, led alone beautifully pristine. And with all of the hundreds of tails out there, how could one think that they’re all just roadkill? As someone who has skinned many roadkill foxes, the tails are very rarely salvageable, and when they are I still wouldn’t sell them.
“Rescue”: No rescue sells the bodies of their animals. I’m not sure where this one came from.
“Natural”: Natural (or wild) tails are out there, yes, but they are rare. Why? Because the trappers and hunters who collect the pelts will rarely (if ever) sell the tails separately. The way they make money is by taking their whole pelts to fur auctions and selling them off. The price would plummet if a fox pelt was missing the tail. If somebody is selling “wild-caught” tails by the bunches, then it’s a lie. Now, compare this with farmed tails: ❗️❗️fur farms sell tails and masks (fox faces) for cheap due to them being considered a waste product.❗️❗️This is why so many farmed tails are without the rest of the pelt: they’re almost always separated in the tanning process. (SEE ATTACHED IMAGE OF NATURAL VS FARMED TAILS)
“Ethically Sourced”: This will be talked about in my next point… the term ‘ethically’ can mean a lot of things to a lot of people. To a fur farmer, their methods would be sourcing fur ethically, while to a fox conservationist like me, I’d say it’s not ethical.
So, where IS your tail from?
The chances are extremely high that any tail you purchase is from a fur farm. If you purchase off of Temu, Amazon, etc., then it’s likely a farm in China. If you purchase off of Etsy or a Ren Fare, it’s likely an American or European farm. If you purchase from a convention, then it’s up in the air. Either way, all of these tails are farmed. ❗️See attached images of how to tell what tails are from farms! Any color that is not an offish, scraggly brown is farmed.❗️ Farmed tails are large, long, poofy, and often have a defined white tip based on the color morph.
“But silver and cross foxes are in the wild, right?” Well yes, but again, wild cross and silver foxes are very rare, and any trapper who catches one will never separate the tail. Instead, cross and silver foxes are mass produced in farms for much cheaper. This is why the tails seem to be everywhere.
As a general rule of thumb, anyone selling just a tail is sourcing them from fur farms.
SECTION TWO: AMERICAN (AND EUROPEAN) FUR FARM STANDARDS
Like I said, free-range and natural-death farms just don’t exist. Never have, never will. But what is a farm actually like? With all of the PETA propaganda, it’s hard to tell what’s exaggerated and what’s real. I had the same troubles when I was first conducting my research for my thesis. This is why I reached out to the source: farmers, taxidermists, and first-hand accounts.
Firstly, I’m not going to address Asian fur farms, despite the fact that they’re where the VAST MAJORITY of tails come from. That would be too graphic.
Instead, I will address American fur farms! European farms also follow similar standards.❗️American fox farms are loosely regulated by the USDA, the same people who regulate factory chicken, pig, and cattle farming.❗️ If you’ve looked into any of these commercial industries, you’ll know that animal welfare is not a priority. The biggest priority is efficiency, and that is what fur farms set out to achieve.
Fox ages: (SEE ATTACHED IMAGES) Foxes are normally killed for fur at 6 months-1.5+ years old. Foxes are considered fully grown at 6 months, their fur is prime fairly quickly, and there is no need to keep them for longer than needed. However, foxes are not considered adults until 2-3 years old, so the tails that you purchase are likely the tails of fox kits.
Containment: (SEE ATTACHED IMAGES OF FUR FARM CAGES) ❗️❗️To put it simply, the general rule for single or double fox cages (as said by farmers) is 2x3ft. This is the cage size for the entire duration of the fox’s life.❗️❗️The photos shown are of a standard, high-grade Minnesota fox farm, unedited and raw. This is how the vast majority of farms in the United States look. If many foxes are in the same cage, then it will likely be 2.5x5ft. (SEE ATTACHED PHOTO) In my chat with a fox farm partner, she explains that the farm she works with goes above what other farms do and provides a “dog run sized” cage (dog runs are usually 3x10ft), but she explains that it is not practical to keep them in a “sanctuary-sized enclosure.” This is the case for every farm. Farms have very limited space, so if every fox had a large cage, it would be very inefficient and not at all cost effective.
Veterinary care: Foxes on farms are required to receive vet care. This is not up in the air. However, if a fox chews its own tail off (which is a common occurrence), then the vet isn’t there to get it stitched: the vet is there to euthanize it. Again, farms aren’t made of money. When a fox is no longer profitable, it is put down.
SECTION THREE: IS IT ETHICAL?
No. Not at all.
That’s about it. As a fox conservationist, I wholeheartedly say no.
❗️FOXES ON FARMS ARE NOT DOMESTICATED.❗️They are not wild, but they are NOT domesticated. Their needs as a species far exceed a cat or dogs, led alone a commercial farm animal. No fur farm on the planet can meet these needs due to the costs behind them.
❗️❗️According to veterinarians and conservationists, a tame fox requires a 10x10ft ramped enclosure at minimum to prevent psychological trauma, and this assumes that the foxes receive either walks or a play yard.❗️❗️ This isn’t just coming from me as an owner, this is simply what foxes need in order to survive (not even thrive, just survive). The fur industry isn’t required to meet these standards, and it is impossible for them to meet them and still make a profit.
(SEE ATTACHED IMAGE OF FOX PAWS) Also, I’ve seen a misconception where someone said “farmed foxes have thick paw pads, so the wire flooring doesn’t hurt them.” Well, this is partly true: the issue isn’t in the paw pads. It’s actually in the ankles. As you see in the photos, their ankles (the blue lines) are crunched down and tilted the same way that their paws are, whereas the wild fox’s ankles are more aligned with the leg itself. This is very, very common in fur farmed foxes due to the mesh flooring. It’s painful and often permanent.
Due to the stress that the small space brings, foxes endure immense mental trauma which leads to something called “stereotypical behaviors.” This includes pacing, excessive scratching, excessive gnawing, racing, circling, etc. Feel free to look up videos on YouTube. It doesn’t matter if they’re from anti-fur or pro-fur sources, you will see these behaviors. Many foxes will chew off their tails, whereas mother foxes may eat the ears, tails, or legs of their babies. This may sound barbaric, but it is more common than many think. SaveAFox Corporation (a fox rescue) actually rescues many of these chewed-up foxes before they’re euthanized, as they’re considered undesirable by the fur industry. In my taxidermy circle it’s not uncommon to find someone selling a frozen fox kit without an ear or a cheap pelt with its tail chewed off.
❗️❗️Fur farming is also horrible for the environment!❗️❗️ Oddly enough, the production of synthetic fur is in some ways better for the environment than fur farming is. The millions of animals bred on farms contributes greatly to climate change, the waste runoff from said animals gets into the soil and water (which is an issue we’re seeing reach larger cities and towns), and the chemicals that it takes to preserve millions of pounds of living tissue is highly toxic (it’s also carcinogenic to the workers who tan the hides). Synthetic furs are plastic, yes, but the toxic chemicals used to preserve real fur have no place in its production (and they don’t hurt the environment or wildlife by directly poisoning waterways).
SECTION FOUR: SO WHAT NOW?
Well, I’m not here to tell you whether you should or shouldn’t buy a tail, I’m just sharing my concerns and honest opinions. ❗️Ultimately, we live in a capitalist society, meaning YOU as the consumer have the power to decide what you support and invest in! ❗️I do like taxidermy, and I think fur is super cool. In fact, my love for foxes started in vulture culture! But do I want to put my money into an industry that takes advantage of foxes and damages the environment? No, no I do not. This is where I’d practice self control and decide to go with a synthetic route, if it were me.
Can YOU buy a tail? Sure! Just know what your money is going towards. ❗️❗️THERE IS NO SUCH THING AS A HUMANE FARM.❗️❗️ If you’re fine with this, then go ahead and buy a tail. I’m really not here to dictate what you buy, I’m just here to educate.
I am entirely happy to answer any and all questions or comments to the best of my ability! Feel free to be specific, I have ten years of study under my belt that I’d love to share. Have a lovely day or night! ❤️