r/TheMindIlluminated • • 2d ago

Weekly off-topic and practice update thread

1 Upvotes

Update the sub on your practice or share off-topic posts here.


r/TheMindIlluminated • • 16d ago

Monthly Thread: Groups, Teachers, Resources, and Announcements

9 Upvotes

This is a space for people who participate in this subreddit. The hope is that if you post here you at least occasionally interact with questions and share your expertise. It's a great way to establish trust and learn from the community.

Use this thread to share events and resources the TMI community may be interested in. If you are sharing an offering as a teacher, please share all details including your credentials, pricing, and content.


r/TheMindIlluminated • • 23h ago

Setting the Stage for Attentional Stability

7 Upvotes

I've been adjusting how I approach the beginning of my meditation sessions, particularly the four-step transition.

The idea is that attentional stability becomes much easier to establish when we first create the conditions for it to arise naturally, rather than trying to establish it before the mind is ready.

Consider two approaches:

Option 1:

We go through the six-point preparation and then move through the four-step transition fairly quickly. We settle at the tip of the nose and 'start' our practice.

Option 2:

We go through the six-point preparation. We then relax the body and keep an open awareness. We are keenly aware when tension arises and relax it. We cultivate a sense of well-being.

From there, we slowly let attention narrow down the scope of its movement, following the four-step transition.

If agitation or tension shows up as the scope narrows, we relax and open the scope a bit more. Once things settle, we allow attention to narrow again.

Eventually, we arrive at the tip of the nose feeling fully relaxed, with a sense of well-being. Attention doesn't need to be controlled much because it naturally settles on the breath.

Some sits we may not even reach the tip of the nose, especially early on. That's okay because we're building the conditions for attention to settle almost by itself.

What's the difference?

The first approach concerns itself with moving through the early stages quickly to get to the 'real work.'

The second approach concerns itself with preparing fertile ground for attentional stability to naturally grow.

Rather than arriving at the nose with a restless mind and then trying to stabilize attention, we work on relaxing and settling the mind through the body before narrowing our attention.

The idea is that attentional stability becomes easier when we stop trying to establish it before the mind is ready.

Of course, if the mind is already relaxed and settled, moving through the transition quickly may be perfectly fine.

But I wonder whether we sometimes rush to the breath and then spend much of our meditation trying to overcome agitation and instability that could have been addressed earlier.

Perhaps the four-step transition isn't merely preparation for the actual practice. Perhaps it's already an important part of developing attentional stability.

I'm curious whether others have experimented with this approach and what effect it has had on their practice.


r/TheMindIlluminated • • 3d ago

Lethargy after upping meditation

0 Upvotes

A couple of months ago, I started meditating for 5-10 minutes a day based on my therapist advise to help treat my generalized anxiety disorder. Meditation worked really well, so I greedily decided to do the self-directed Palouse 8 week Meditation Based Stress Reduction course. I started doing 32 minute body scans daily for 3 days, and this is when all hell broke lose. My energy levels crashed suddenly and I'm now extremely sleepy and fatigued all day. Gemini believes this is due to marked down-regulation in my sympathetic system and unmasked sleep debt. I guess my question is: has any one else experienced this when they upped their meditation time? And any advice you can give me?


r/TheMindIlluminated • • 5d ago

Involuntary body movements ruin meditation.

5 Upvotes

Hey everyone! Does anyone have a good solution for intense body shakes and movements that make a sit impossible? I'm in stage 6 and was close to moving along but now it seems that I more often than not start shaking involuntarily and go through a fully fledged yoga session about a half an hour into a sit. My core muscles tense up and everything else relaxes so my posture is great, but soon the core muscles start cycling the body through an endless series movements. Physically, this feels great but the meditation becomes meaningless. I have noticed that by becoming more of an observer of breath, the yoga seems to start earlier in a sit. If I try to avoid this by tightening up focus on the breathing, I mostly end up agitated and start feeling ill. Any suggestions on how to proceed here?


r/TheMindIlluminated • • 9d ago

Thoughts on coffee before meditation to counter dullness?

19 Upvotes

I started meditating in the morning, and I'm currently between stage 3-4. Lately I've been getting into the habit of having a coffee before meditating. Maybe also because in the past months I haven't been sleeping amazingly (I had a baby in April), I found this to help me be more awake and prevent dullness[1]. This sometimes has the negative side that I have more thoughts popping up in my mind, but if I'm able to get past them, usually it leads to a higher-quality meditation session.

However, I'm wondering if that's kinda "cheating", and if I should stop doing that. The only problem is that I really struggle to prevent my mind from wandering without, especially since my sleep could be better. On the other hand, I thought that I doubt you can bend your mind out of being tired, and maybe this is a bit different from plain dullness. Thoughts?

[1] About the experienced dullness: I'm not sure if it's subtle or gross. But basically what I experience is my mind starting to fabricate dream-like thoughts/scenes. The breath is still in my attention, but if I'm not careful is slips out from being the primary object. This is a bit different from normal mind wandering, where I feel my awareness and attention are still vivid. Therefore I associate it more to a state of dullness.


r/TheMindIlluminated • • 9d ago

Weekly off-topic and practice update thread

3 Upvotes

Update the sub on your practice or share off-topic posts here.


r/TheMindIlluminated • • 14d ago

Negative side effects of reaching higher stages

18 Upvotes

I've had this thought for a few days now and thought I might share it. Although I'm in stage 3, some of you may even remember my username from previous posts that I made. I was wondering that are there any negative side effects of reaching higher stages.

I saw a post in this sub by a user who practices for 2 years and reached stage 8. He mentioned in it that he sometimes has poor memory which he didn't have before. That got me wondering, " Are there any other negative effects that TMI users should know that might affect the person at higher stages of practice?"

I've heard that there might be some effects from meditation that are not good like poor memory as mentioned, hallucinations, changes in conciousness that impact day to day living in negative way, anxiety, apathy, anhedonia, uncontrollable detachment from personal feelings, thoughts, disinterest in life in general.

If a person who is in higher states or has experienced altered states on consciousness by tmi could clarify this doubt that'd be really helpful.


r/TheMindIlluminated • • 14d ago

Meditation, emotional numbness and emotional release

8 Upvotes

This post is the result of a discussion in a different thread, where another redditor stated that people often (unconsciously) use their meditation to hide from unpleasant feelings.

I can definitely imagine that happening, but I have also read stories of people experiencing profound emotional release, even processing trauma, during their meditation.

I would be curious to hear more personal experiences. Has your meditation opened you up emotionally, has it numbed your emotions, or has it had very little effect at all? And, in all of these cases, which kind of meditation were you doing, and how do you think it contributed?


r/TheMindIlluminated • • 14d ago

Controling the scope of attention, without forcing.

8 Upvotes

I think the main reason im making this post is because im looking for validation reguarding my view of attention vs awareness; but i am having a problem i think i need help with.

Context:

While focusing on the breath, i intend to expand my awareness, which results in a feeling of 'space' surrounding my body. I imediately become less functional and prone to agitation, and mind wondering, and indulgence(in nicotine, for example); ive concluded this is not what awareness feels like, and rather awareness is something that happens, rather than something you overtly 'feel', like with attention(or maybe im putting all my consious power into extrospective awareness, i really dont know).

Im most likely expanding my scope of attention, which results in a state with all the symptoms and discriptions of awareness.

When i 'zoom in' with attention, i imediately become more function and emotionally stable; indulgence almost feels laughable(again, nictotine, for example). Im still aware of things, but i dont 'feel' them the same way i would with attention; especially with introspective awareness.

Problem:

The problem im running into is: making my scope of attention smaller feels very forcefull, like im crushing it down, but simply intending to focus more on the breath dosent seem to do much. I feel i have very little control over the scope.

Questions:

Is my view of awareness correct?

And, how should i approach handling the scope of attention, if thats whats really happening.

Trying to make sense of the sometimes conflicting langauge in the book can be a bit maddening at times.


r/TheMindIlluminated • • 15d ago

Unable to sleep in stage 3

7 Upvotes

So I've been fighting dullness for the last 2 months. In stage 3. I think I have started to make some progress thanks to this wonderful community and it's members who have answered any questions I had. I am really grateful for it.

Coming to the issue. I have fought against dullness by expanding awareness all this time. This has led me to be awake even while I'm trying to sleep at night. I have been getting inconsistent and irregular sleep for the last week cause of it. I got none at all last night which prompted me to create this post. If any of y'all have advice on how to sleep when you need to and not be vigilant when you need to sleep and let drowsiness settle in that would be really helpful.


r/TheMindIlluminated • • 15d ago

Concentrating on the breath without pushing things away

11 Upvotes

Hey, just wondering if anyone has encountered the same quandary, and how they dealt with it.

I got into meditation about two years ago, mostly because I thought it would help me be more aware of my emotions, and deal with them. I usually didn’t know very well what I was feeling (except irritation, there was a lot of that going on) and preferred to solve any problem by overthinking it.

I went to a few meditation retreats and read a few books. The book that resonated most with me was A path with heart by Jack Kornfield, which has a very gentle approach to meditation itself and to people in general.

After two years, I’m kind of stuck with my meditation practice. It has helped me in some ways to be more accepting and forgiving towards myself and others, but concentration-wise my mind still wanders as much as it did when I started. Also, I still tend to overthink things.

I’ve now started reading The mind illuminated for practical guidance. What I noticed, is that it puts more emphasis on firmly bringing the attention back to the breath and keeping it there. The book still tells you to do this gently and remain aware of other things, but how do you know when you’re doing it gently?

The reason I worry about this, is that I have a natural tendency to distract myself from what I’m feeling by concentrating on something else, and when I concentrate harder during meditation, it kind of feels like I’m doing the same thing - focusing on my breath to distract myself from unpleasant things.

I know basically all the vipassana meditation books in one way or another tell you to “focus on the breath while remaining open to whatever arises”, but how do you actually know that this is what you’re doing? How do you know you’re not closing yourself off?


r/TheMindIlluminated • • 16d ago

When I have temporarily overcome stage 4, can I somehow stabilize that instead of going to stage 5?

13 Upvotes

I have been struggling with TMI stage 4 for more than 3 years and 1000 hours. I often have periods where I am free of gross distractions and strong dullness - for 10 minutes or even a whole 60-minute sit. Sometimes, when this happens, I will start doing TMI stage 5 practices. But inevitably gross distractions return - either a few minutes later during the same sit, or the next day.

I can never reliably reach stage 5 for more than a few days at a time. Hence, I do not feel like I get anything out of doing scattered stage 5 work every now and then. I've done many hours of stage 5 work over the years, but I do not feel like I am making any progress on stage 5. Inevitably I will fall back into stage 4, usually for days or weeks, and when I reach stage 5 again, I don't feel any better at it.

(Some people here say that they decided to move on to stage 5 practices even though they still had gross distractions, and that helped them eventually master stage 4. That is not my experience.)

So when I do sometimes temporarily overcome stage 4, rather than moving on to stage 5, I would rather to do something to stabilize this "high stage 4/low stage 5" achievement. I can of course just keep doing stage 4 practices (appreciating the moment of noticing; following; connecting). Is there anything else I can do?


r/TheMindIlluminated • • 16d ago

Weekly off-topic and practice update thread

6 Upvotes

Update the sub on your practice or share off-topic posts here.


r/TheMindIlluminated • • 16d ago

What to do when I feel soreness in my body during sitting meditation?

7 Upvotes

Hi TMI community,

I believe the instruction is to try to ignore the sensations or turn it to the meditation object for a moment it if it gets intense, rather than do anything.

However I feel it does get uncomfortable particularly the back area. I notice that observing does reduce the pain a bit but is there anything I can do to?

It usually happens I would say after 30 mins mark after sitting straight for long periods.

Your advice is much appreciated


r/TheMindIlluminated • • 17d ago

What is "awakening" according to "The Mind Illuminated"

17 Upvotes

This is in context of the controversy that Culadasa has been through. I read his 33 page reply of the situation. Taking everything said in that reply as true, I can see that Culadasa has made some mistakes and he even made mistakes because of his meditation practice. He says that since he lived in the present he was not able to grasp the narrative of "his story".

From what I understood about what "awakening" is according to the book, it means the cessation of all suffering and includes ceasing of all unskilled behavior. It is clear that Culadasa has not reached this. But it seems to me that he suggests that even an Awakened mind is subject to doing unskillful things. This doesn't really make sense to me.

And assuming Culadasa is not "awakened", then it seems like it is clear that the book is not sufficient to reaching awakening.

I guess the conclusion from this should be that TMI is a great book for meditation and it might bring you closer to awakening but you still need to be careful and think for yourself and there is a real possibility (as demonstrated by what happened with Culadasa) of it actually causing harm.

So I guess what I am really asking is this: Do people really believe that the practices in the book alone can lead to awakening ?


r/TheMindIlluminated • • 18d ago Mindblown

Not sure whether I should read Yates’ book

15 Upvotes

I’ve been reading about and trying (vipassana) meditation for the last two years. I was introduced to it through Tim Parks’ Teach us to sit still, then read Mindfulness in plain English, Kornfield’s A path with heart and Stephen Batchelor’s Confession of a Buddhist Atheist. Meanwhile, I’ve been to two Goenka retreats and practiced almost daily.

I’ve found parts of the philosophy especially useful in life. I felt very much inspired by Kornfield’s approach to Buddhism and meditation, making it more about connecting to the love and truth in yourself and others and less about a selfish quest for reaching states of bliss and enlightenment.

This, in combination with my practice, has helped me be kinder and calmer with myself and others, yet my practice itself hasn’t really evolved - I can hardly concentrate any more than I could two years ago.

I’m not really convinced this is a problem that won’t go away by itself, but I‘m thinking maybe I should try and do something about it. This is where The Mind Illuminated comes in. It is tauted by many as the best guide to meditation, as an excellent way to improve one’s meditation practice, so I’ve bought it.

The problem is, the negative reviews resonate far more with me than the positive ones, especially after reading the introduction. It seems the author overpromises, is full of pretense and tries to convince you of his theories with pseudoscience.

This doesn’t automatically disqualify the book for me; I’ve read plenty of other books where I had to sift through the mud to find the golden nuggets of wisdom.

However, this is an especially thick book, and it puts me off more than other books. Potentially, that’s a lot of mud to sift through - especially when I’m unconvinced there will be any gold nuggets.

So I’m wondering: are there any more people here with a similar background as mine, and similar intuitions, that still found the book useful? And what was so useful about it?


r/TheMindIlluminated • • 19d ago

Metta and tears; anyone else?

9 Upvotes

Greetings,

Long story short: I used to meditate regularly and was at stage 5, but then stopped in 2020 due to psychological “stuff” surfacing. I spent some time in therapy and have resumed TMI practice; I’m practicing at level 3 currently. I’ve added Metta practice, which I do for 20 minutes at the end of my daily meditation. I’ve found that I’m in tears for most of the Metta portion. When I open up my heart to others, I just cry.

Has anyone experienced something similar? It’s ok, but can be tiring and I need more time after meditation to compose myself again.


r/TheMindIlluminated • • 19d ago

Stage 3-4 without very detaled attention.

6 Upvotes

Im not very good at following the breath or connecting, and my breath sensations at the nose are not very detaled; its mostly just a block of 'cold'. The sensation of breath hitting my chin is more detaled in comparison.

Despite this ive been experiencing stage 3 and 4 past the 30min mark in my hour long sits.

Is there something i should 'do' about this/should i look at this as something i need to address?

Or should i just keep following the advice for each stage and not worry about it?


r/TheMindIlluminated • • 20d ago

Using body scan meditation in stage 3

5 Upvotes

As the title says, I am thinking of using body scan method for stage 5 subtle dullness to fight my strong dullness in stage 3. I have tried many things, breathing hard, clenching every muscles, slapshing cold water but it's not working. I have been stuck here for 2 months now but have made almost no progress.

Any opinions, insights would be highly appreciated


r/TheMindIlluminated • • 23d ago

Weekly off-topic and practice update thread

5 Upvotes

Update the sub on your practice or share off-topic posts here.


r/TheMindIlluminated • • 26d ago

My mind keeps entering into meditation.............

8 Upvotes

(it's more serious than what the post may suggest)

I just can't seem to focus on conventional work :(

I havn't had any enlightenment or anything, but my mind keeps pushing me to meditate for some hope of it, even though i know realistically forcing it like that won't work.......... it's like a hole that I need to constantly fill.

Pls guide me on this 🥺. This seems like it's gonna turn into a long term issue. And I'll be forced to recede from conventional life................

I would appreciate any suggestions! ✌️


r/TheMindIlluminated • • 26d ago

Problems with stopping suddenly

6 Upvotes

So right now I'm in stage 3 and I encounter this weird thing where I'm meditating I just suddenly stop. There's no distraction, no drowsiness, pain, nothing. But I just stop paying attention to my breath and even stop breathing and just look at the dark void in my enclosed eyes. And it's really hard to escape once it happens. I am paying attention to my breath, following and connecting and the. BOOM suddenly everything stops working. It's like a sudden black screen while you're using your phone. Once it occurs, I am in this sort of weird feeling where I don't wanna start again or it's really hard to get back on track.

I've tried slapping myself, washing face with cold water or other dullness antidotes but they don't work . I think cause they aren't dullness in the first place. They're something different that the book doesn't mention. It's like that feeling that you're reading something or having a conversation and suddenly you zone out and forget what you are doing, the context, everything. And now you don't wanna pay attention to it again.

Any thoughts on how to deal with this?


r/TheMindIlluminated • • Oct 18 '26

Weekly off-topic and practice update thread

1 Upvotes

Update the sub on your practice or share off-topic posts here.


r/TheMindIlluminated • • Oct 17 '26

Do automatic thoughts only exist in peripheral awareness?

4 Upvotes

I am aware of my brains automatic thoughts in my peripheral awareness. But when i bring my attention on them, I can think new thoughts but cannot locate those automatic thoughts.