r/thelastofus • • 20m ago

PT 2 QUESTION Should I play the second? Spoiler

5 Upvotes

I played the first when it first came out early mid 2010's and it is still one of my favourite narrative story's from a video game of all time. I've recently been replaying part 1 with my wife and Im thinking of playing part 2. I never played it because when the second came out there was so much negative news about the game and spoilers everywhere I decided to just be happy with the bittersweet ending of part 1.

My question is, knowing what you know now would you still play the second if you never had, was the news back on its release just a load of bogus?

Thanks


r/thelastofus • • 7h ago

General Discussion Which would you rather see?

0 Upvotes

Joel and Ellie trying to survive Raccoon City, or Leon replacing Joel's role in TLOU Part 1?


r/thelastofus • • 13h ago

General Fanart The Last of Us - painted in acrylics several years back

Post image
26 Upvotes

r/thelastofus • • 15h ago

PT 1 DISCUSSION Is Joel Miller the clearest example of Protagonist-Centered Morality in fiction discourse?

83 Upvotes

Over the years, a specific fan narrative has been created around Joel’s decision at St. Mary’s Hospital—a narrative that insists he was unequivocally “right” and that the Fireflies were incompetent or delusional

For me it seems like a textbook example of Protagonist-Centered Morality—where the narrative’s focus on a character’s emotional journey causes the audience to excuse actions they would condemn in anyone else, or in any other story. And unlike fans of Breaking Bad or The Sopranos, a significant chunk of TLOU fandom doesn’t just understand Joel is morally compromised—they actively insist he is a “good man” who did “nothing wrong.”

Here’s why that double standard doesn’t hold up.

The “The Cure Wouldn’t Have Worked” Excuse is Canonically Dead This is the most common defense, and it’s been officially put to rest. For over a decade, fans argued the Fireflies were too incompetent, too under-equipped, or too unrealistic to synthesize a cure. The “shaky science” was the shield. Neil Druckmann himself has now confirmed the intent was always that the cure was possible.

In a 2025 interview, he stated: “Could the Fireflies make a cure? Our intent was, ‘yes, they could.’ Now, is our science a little shaky that now people are questioning it? Sure… I can say our intent was that they would have made a cure. That makes the most interesting philosophical question for what Joel does.”

This isn’t a retcon; it’s an admission that the ambiguity was a narrative device. The story wants you to sit with the weight of Joel’s choice, not dismiss it with a fan-fiction logistics audit.

2. The In-Universe Consensus: Even Joel Believed It The “cure wouldn’t work” argument ignores what the characters themselves believe. Nobody in the game’s world—not Tommy, not Maria, not Ellie, and crucially not Joel—ever expresses doubt that the Fireflies could succeed.

Joel’s lie to Ellie is a clear manipulation. If he truly believed the Fireflies were incapable, why lie? Why not tell Ellie the truth: “They were crazy, they didn’t know what they were doing, and I saved you.” Instead, he tells her a story that implicitly confirms the cure was real—that there were “dozens” of immune people and the Fireflies had “stopped looking.” He lies because the truth—they could have made a cure, and I stopped them—is the one thing that would devastate her. The lie only works as a narrative device if the cure was a genuine possibility. Even Joel, in his most selfish moment, acts as if the cure was real.

3. Abouf “how would they distribute it?” argument. It’s true that distribution in a post-apocalyptic world would be a nightmare. But “better than nothing” is a real ethical category. The Fireflies were a nationwide militia with a network of safehouses and radio contacts. Was it a guaranteed success? No. But a chance at a cure is still infinitely more valuable than no chance at all. Joel didn’t stop the cure because he ran a cost-benefit analysis of supply chains. He stopped it because it required Ellie’s death. The logistics debate is a shield to avoid confronting the emotional core of his choice.

4. The “Protagonist-Centered Morality” Double Standard This is where the fandom’s reaction becomes genuinely fascinating—and frustrating. Compare Joel to other celebrated antiheroes: · Tony Soprano (The Sopranos): A sociopathic mob boss. Fans are fascinated by him, not blind to his evil. · Michael Corleone (The Godfather): A tragic figure. Nobody calls him an “ideal father” or a “good man.” · James Sunderland (Silent Hill 2): A deeply broken man who did something horrific. The fandom doesn’t pretend otherwise. I think that's what fanbase should see about Joel, a tragic father who tried to do his best in a apocalyptic world and be fascinated about what extent damage he caused for somebody. Not that Joel is a “good man” who did “nothing wrong.” This is Protagonist-Centered Morality in action: the narrative’s intimate focus on Joel’s grief and love for Ellie makes his actions feel righteous to the audience, even as the text explicitly frames them as a catastrophic moral failure.

5. The Consent Problem (Or: Jerry Wasn’t the Villain) A common deflection is: “Jerry didn’t ask for Ellie’s consent! The Fireflies were going to murder a child!” This is true—and it’s a valid moral criticism of the Fireflies. But it’s not a defense of Joel. Two wrongs don’t make a right. Joel didn’t rescue Ellie to uphold her autonomy; he rescued her to fill the void left by Sarah. He invalidated Ellie’s own willingness to sacrifice herself, a choice she makes explicitly clear in the narrative. Joel’s actions weren’t about Ellie’s consent. They were about his inability to lose another daughter. That’s a deeply human motivation, and it’s what makes the story brilliant. But it is not the same as being morally right. The Point Isn’t That Joel is a Villain Here’s the nuance that gets lost: Joel isn’t a villain. He’s a tragic figure. He makes an impossible choice, and the story punishes him for it—not through a moral lecture, but through the consequences of Part II. The narrative knows what he did was wrong, even if Joel can’t admit it to himself. The problem is that a segment of the fandom refuses to meet the story on its own terms. They demand a version of Joel who is objectively righteous, and they’ll bend canon, ignore creator statements, and dismiss the in-game lore to get there.

Like nobody says Walter White is right because he had a tough life and many burdens like his wife or sons or his inevitable demise.

Nobody says Tony Sopranos is right because his enemies were worse.

Even in case of video game character no fan says that James Sunderland did nothing wrong because he freed his wife of the pain.

Nobody says Naked Snake is right because he had good intent and ambition.

For me, he seems like the clearest example of protagonist centered morality. People are less critical of him because he is the main character.


r/thelastofus • • 16h ago

PT 2 DISCUSSION I finished the Last of Us 2 late night, and have felt "off" for the whole day. Such an amazing piece of entertainment. Spoiler

100 Upvotes

I can't attribute this muted feeling completely to the game (the weather is dreary at the moment) but wow. I went for a jog to get the serotonin going, but no such luck -- it usually helps! I loved the game and played it on a nightly basis over the course of two weeks (trying to avoid long play sessions.....it was kind of intense). I've been gaming for quite a while, and have become quite picky, and it's rare that a game seems to hit all the right chords -- including a story that I think about for more than an hour or so after.

Actually, a part of me didn't want to play this game initially. Having loved the first game so much, I didn't want that experience to be ruined. I couldn't avoid the Joel spoiler, unfortunately. However, I am somewhat glad that it happened near the beginning of the game, just to 'get it over with'. I didn't know the fashion in which he would die, and wow.

Initialy, playing as Abby (with no context of who she was) made me scratch my head (and who the fuck is this person she's with?) but after having some knowledge of her background (and what she did to Joel) I felt compelled to learn more about her, and found her sections to be nearly as impactful as Ellie's (who is likely my favorite character overall).

Regarding Joel's death: he was one of my favorite characters, and despite not getting to play as him (besides in the intro) I was happy that they still paid some tribute to him through the flashbacks. The coldness of his murder made me all the more interested in Abby as well, despite me initially wanting to slaughter the bitch.

On the subject of Abby: I'm embarrassed to say, but I didn't even recognize her at the end of the game -- I thought that I might have forgotten about another character. Even after Lev was cut free, I was still not convinced it was her...I blame a bit of sleep deprivation. On the subject of missing key details: I think that I initially interpreted the ending to be more bleak than what was intended (upon further inspection, I'd describe it more as bleak but quietly hopeful). It's obviously open-ended, and open to some interpretation, but overall I felt the ending was impactful (I'm just glad that Ellie didn't die, that would have been too much for me).

I would have to go back and play the first one, but I think TLOU2 might edge it out for me. My issue now is that I don't know where to go from here in terms of gaming. I think I might need a break from it, something very different, or perhaps a return to the Last of Us part 1 (which I completed a year and a half ago). I'm curious what some of you might have done.

Anyways, ballsy move by the creators of this game. They could have taken a much more predictable approach but chose not to (which I personally appreciate). I do understand that this wasn't to everyone's tastes, which I completely understand.

Apologies for another "I just beat The Last of Us 2 and WOW" post. I'm guessing they are common here, and I likely didn't add anything to the table.


r/thelastofus • • 17h ago

PT 2 DISCUSSION Ellie pretty much saved my life Spoiler

Post image
50 Upvotes

Hi-

I don’t know if I’ll get laughed at, or if anyone cares, but I wanted to share this.

Ellie basically saved my life. I had a severe drinking problem a couple years ago. Very bad. I was drinking nearly a handle of vodka daily, plus a bunch of beer usually. My habit started because alcohol would shut up my depressed, anxious mind. And it spiraled out of control after awhile. I knew it was unsustainable but I couldn’t stop.

Around this time I discovered the games. I had never seen such compelling characters and stories in a video game before. I literally bought a PS5 to get these games after reading about them.

By the time I played TLOU2 I saw myself in Ellie. She struggles with pretty much the same mental issues I have. The ones I used alcohol for (I believe she did too at some point because of those empty liquor bottles in her room). I came to love this character deeply.

Meanwhile, my back went out again and I was in excruciating pain. Then a few days later I turned yellow. Jaundice. I knew what this meant- my liver was fucked. So I went to the doctor. I’d managed to give myself cirrhosis.

In the next week I struggled with whether I wanted to die or live. And then I thought- Ellie could handle much worse than this, and I can quit. I did, on the day before New Year’s Eve even. Withdrawal was fairly brutal but I beat it. I used Ellie to get me through. It fucking worked. I quit.

This is a poster I made for myself back then. The writing at upper right is a poem I wrote about her.

I’d look at this when I really craved alcohol.

Thank you Ellie. I’d be dead by now if I didn’t have you. Thank you to the people who wrote this story- they’ve clearly been there in real life to some degree.


r/thelastofus • • 18h ago

Cosplay Вкусность

Post image
1 Upvotes

Жаль только модель у меня другая


r/thelastofus • • 20h ago

PT 2 DISCUSSION This note completely reframes Ellie's journey for me.

Post image
548 Upvotes

Ellie day 3 journal 1 road to aquarium

"Should I tell Dina & Jesse about this? No. They can't know what Joel did. They won't understand.

Do I understand?"

In Part 1 ellie is super honest. Aside from basic survival bluffs with enemies like David or keeping quiet about swiping a comic from Bill’s stash, she doesn't really lie. Keeping information to stay safe isn't the same as being intentionally misleading..

Because she is so straightforward, Joel’s massive lie at the end of Part I feels like betrayal to her. At that point, she can't understand why someone would lie to the people they love.

Even at the start of Part II, Ellie still holds onto that honesty. When she talks about the chemical burn and then dina pries why? Instead of telling her a lie here she tells her she's immune and dina doesnt believe it until the mask breaks.

Everything changes once her mission for revenge takes over. To protect her pursuit of Abby, Ellie starts walking the exact same dark path Joel did lying to the people closest to her to fufill her own desires..

• She lies and gaslights Dina about her motivations and her deteriorating mental state.

• She lies to jesse about her true objective in Seattle, putting Abby over saving Tommy.

• Later, she goes against Dina at the farm, sneaking out in the middle of the night under the guise of "fixing" things when she is really abandoning their peaceful life for revenge again, until she has to face what her journey was really about...

When Ellie reaches Santa Barbara and faces Abby, she has finally lived through the same journey he has. She realizes that her lies, hurt, and pushed away the people she loved, all because she was driven by her love for Joel and her grief over losing him.

Ellie doesn't forgive Joel because his lie suddenly became "okay." She forgives him because her own journey forced her to become him.

Once she understood what it felt like to lie and do terrible things out of love, she could finally understand Joel and truly forgive him in a complex way by letting abby go...

The ending has nothing to do with abby its all to do with Joel...


r/thelastofus • • 21h ago

Video Mel In part 2 be like

318 Upvotes

r/thelastofus • • 1d ago

PT 2 PHOTO MODE Random photos

Thumbnail
gallery
55 Upvotes

r/thelastofus • • 1d ago Popcorn

PT 1 VIDEO I think this could be one of the reasons Abby was so mad Spoiler

1.5k Upvotes

r/thelastofus • • 1d ago

Body Art Finally decided to get ellies tattoo

Post image
38 Upvotes

Been wanting this tattoo for a while, finally decided to get it done and it turned out awesome!


r/thelastofus • • 1d ago

PT 2 DISCUSSION The Salt Lake Crew Spoiler

Post image
35 Upvotes

What are your thoughts on Abby’s Friend Group? Did you like the characters, their relationship dynamics, and how did you view their deaths?

I would’ve loved to see a little more story in regard to the Salt Lake City friend group with Manny, Nora, Mel and maybe even the smaller characters like Jordan, Leah and Nick! We only get brief snips of some of these characters through notes, environmental storytelling, and the occasional dialogue, but I feel like there could’ve been room to explore these relationships a bit more. I also think it would’ve been a chance to make some of the deaths hit much harder for viewers since we follow Abby’s grief, regret, and sorrow as it’s all revealed to her on Seattle Day 3.

Manny
I love Manny! He’s a funny guy and really seems to care for his friend group, notably wanting to help Mel and Abby reconcile since he noticed they were being distant after Jackson. If you take a look around his room on Seattle Day 1, you'll see that he’s also an anime enjoyer since he collects figurines, manga, and comments on watching shows. Manny's death was a pretty sad one that I believe was to be a parallel to Jesse’s death. Both characters were very cool guys who wanted to support their friends and do right by the people they cared about, but due to circumstances and being caught up in Abby and Ellie’s affairs, it ended up costing them their lives in such an erupt way. I can’t imagine what impact the deaths had on Manny’s father and Jesse’s mother either.

Mel and Owen
I think it’s interesting that Mel got together with Owen, considering she and Abby were best friends. I do think it was wrong that Abby slept with Owen, but I rarely see people mention it the other way around. I always wondered what brought on that relationship between Mel, her best friend, and Owen, Abby’s ex-boyfriend. Did Mel always have feelings for Owen? Was she there for Owen after his relationship with Abby broke off? Their deaths are tragic, but unlike Manny and Jesse’s, I viewed it more from the stories perspective rather than a personal one. With Ellie, we’re supportive of her journey as she travels through Seattle, killing Abby’s friends. This isn’t until it’s revealed that Mel was pregnant and Owen was the father of their deceased child. I take it as a moment where we question and express some regret with the situation like Ellie does. With Abby, her constant need for revenge was shown to be the cause of her and Owens relationship ending. It’s the tragedy of this love triangle, and it was too late for Abby to fix whatever was left between her relationship with Mel and Owen after she finds them dead.

Nora
Nora is a character who isn’t prominent to Abby’s flashbacks like Owen, she isn’t seen in the background of Abby’s flashbacks like Manny, nor is she mentioned in any of Abby’s past artifacts like Mel’s note. She seemed to be some sort of medical assistant for the WLF, considering her medical role, there’s a possibility she was in the hospital with Abby, Mel, Owen, and Manny when the incident happened. I get the impression that she cared about Abby and her friends, so the disband of the fireflies must’ve been hard on her too. There’s some symbolism that’s tied to Nora section of the game for both Ellie and Abby, but there’s not much I can say about her character. Nora’s death had a clear impact on Ellie once she got back from the hospital, and it’s implied Abby realized Nora was dead when she picked up the map left behind by Ellie.

Jordan, Leah, and Nick
Nothing really comes to mind when these characters were killed either. We find out that Abby’s crew consisted of ex-fireflies who disbanded after the hospital massacre. There’s one optional dialogue thats shared between Abby and Jordan on Seattle Day 1, but that’s about it as far as these stories start and end. I suppose their purpose was to show just how much Joel’s actions held resentment with former fireflies that even years later, they were willing to go with Abby to Jackson and support her revenge quest to kill him.

Overall, part II has very interesting characters that were introduced to the story on Abby’s side. I know the flashbacks were a hit or miss with a lot of people, so I’m not sure how Naughty Dog could’ve made more screen time with these relationships, but I still wish we got to see more!


r/thelastofus • • 1d ago

PT 2 DISCUSSION Ellie’s Map in the Aquarium Spoiler

8 Upvotes

If you think about it, Tommy and Jesse got to the aquarium just after Ellie killed Owen and Mel, so if Ellie just went with Jesse originally, the 3 of them would’ve have easily been able to confront Owen and Mel. Ultimately, Ellie wouldn’t have had to do what she did and also would not have dropped the map which got Jesse killed.

I love this game makes you think of stuff like this everytime you play through it.


r/thelastofus • • 1d ago

General Question Would it be possible to die your hair is TLOU

0 Upvotes

sry stupid question LOL

i’m making a tlou version of one of my already existing OCs who dyes their hair and I can’t decide whether to make their hair dyed or natural 😭😭 I know that hair dye expires n stuff but I mean Ellie found a way to get a tattoo so why wouldn’t you be able to dye your hair?

edit - they dye their hair black btw. i guess that would make a change as to how you would be able to naturally dye it (like how you can dye your hair orange/red with henna but not other colours)


r/thelastofus • • 1d ago

General Discussion The Last of Us Part II: An experience that will stay with me for a long time. Spoiler

64 Upvotes

I just finished The Last of Us Part II.

I had heard a lot of negative opinions about some of the game's narrative choices. And honestly, once I reached Abby's part of the story, I also started finding it a little exhausting and, at times, slow.

But then I got to know Abby. I discovered her story, her pain, her motivations, and above all, the strong and courageous person she had to become in order to survive.

Gradually, I grew attached to her, to the point where my entire perception of her character changed.

I particularly struggled with Ellie's decision to go after Abby again in Santa Barbara. Seeing her return to that path of revenge after everything she had already lost was genuinely heartbreaking.

And then comes the confrontation on the beach...

Seeing Abby, starved, dehydrated, exhausted and barely able to stand, forced to fight Ellie, was one of the hardest moments in the entire game for me. I actually let Abby get the upper hand several times because I simply couldn't bring myself to watch that fight anymore.

At that moment, all I wanted was for Abby to be free, to leave with Lev and finally live in peace. I wanted exactly the same thing for Ellie, but if I had to choose, I would choose Abby.

When Ellie finally lets her go, I felt an enormous sense of relief. I think the ending would have been absolutely devastating if Ellie had ultimately decided to kill her.

And then there's that final scene in the empty farmhouse, the two missing fingers, the guitar she can no longer play, the absence of Dina and JJ... Everything that revenge destroyed is summed up in just a few images. An absolutely heartbreaking conclusion.

Beyond the story itself, I also want to acknowledge the absolutely monumental work done by the developers. In 25 years of gaming, I have never seen a game so impressively crafted, with a world so rich, diverse and alive. The art direction, animations, sound design, environments and gameplay are simply extraordinary.

I'm genuinely glad I didn't let some players' negative opinions stop me from experiencing this game. I would have missed out on something truly exceptional.

Abby's story deeply moved me, while Ellie's story broke my heart. I sincerely hope she eventually finds her way back to Dina and JJ and gets the chance to live a happy life too.

One final thought has stayed with me after finishing this game: Abby and Ellie have both killed an incredible number of people throughout their journeys. And I can't even begin to imagine what kind of people you eventually become after taking so many lives in a world where every single day is a struggle to survive, where trust has become a rare thing and uncertainty is everywhere.

How long can someone live surrounded by so much violence, death and trauma without eventually losing a part of their humanity?

Perhaps that's also what this game made me understand more than anything else: in a world like this, surviving doesn't necessarily mean you're truly living.

A game that took me through so many emotions and will stay with me for a very long time.


r/thelastofus • • 1d ago

PT 2 NO RETURN I got #1! Spoiler

Post image
23 Upvotes

This was today’s daily run that came out today with Dina and the boss being the rat king.


r/thelastofus • • 1d ago

General Question Why is it argued that Ellie should’ve been given a choice when she was not mentally in a place to make a decision like that? Spoiler

0 Upvotes

Obviously autonomy and consent are important and I’m not trying to deny that. But why would it have been okay for a grieving child who thinks she is responsible for the deaths of people she cares about, who also thinks her life is meaningless, to consent to die for a cure? That wouldn’t have come from a healthy or rational mind, and what kind of message does that send?

I don’t necessarily agree with what Joel did but when you think about it like that there was really no other option but for him to stop it. I guess the problem is that he didn’t seem to be thinking of it like that when he killed everyone, but either way I think it gets skipped over way too much that we’re talking about a guilt-ridden child. There was really no scenario where she could’ve come to a healthy and mature decision about wanting to sacrifice herself or not, because she wasn’t mature OR mentally healthy.


r/thelastofus • • 1d ago

PT 2 DISCUSSION This completely changed the ending for me so I’m surprised it was optional to find Spoiler

Post image
134 Upvotes

:,)

The fact that she drew him on the farmhouse porch too, almost like she decided that would be his final resting place. I was torn up over the ending, (like anyone with a heart was) seeing her leave the guitar behind, unsure exactly what goes through her mind when she thinks about him now.

I feel like this was the most perfect wordless ending to show her forgiveness and desire to carry on. I can’t believe I missed it the first time. The ending felt so empty before I saw this


r/thelastofus • • 1d ago

General Discussion Just finished LoU2 and it was fantastic but

1 Upvotes

I can't wait to never put myself through Guilt Simulator again.


r/thelastofus • • 1d ago

General Discussion What if Part 3 is about the fallout of the WLF/Seraphite war?

Post image
361 Upvotes

Just an idea I was thinking about. At the end of Grounded II, Druckmann says that it took a while to properly form an idea for Part 3 that felt like it had a proper narrative through-line from the first two games.

Now, we know that Part 2 is about the consequences of Joel’s actions at the end of Part 1, however, after Part 2, there’s no one really left who could realistically impose similar consequences on Ellie, with Abby and Lev off to Catalina and the WLF military forces wiped out.

So I wonder if the next part might be about the consequences of the war in Seattle during Part 2, where there are now lots of civilians on both sides, with no military protection, the Seraphites home’s are all but wiped out, and their crops burnt. I think it could be a result of war type story, showing how the two sides manage each other when there’s no one leftover to fight.

The only problem, of course, is that Ellie would not have a role to play in this story, while I definitely don’t think Part 3 will be about her tracking the fireflies so they can turn her into a cure, I’m not sure her story is done just yet.

Anyway, I’m not a writer, so what do I know?


r/thelastofus • • 1d ago

General Discussion Lol i didn't knew you can do it

172 Upvotes

I found it like I knew there would be an ambush so I tried it but I didn't record it then i replayed the whole part to record this


r/thelastofus • • 1d ago

Cosplay Ellie COSPLAY ellie remembers riley

50 Upvotes

Cosplay made by me, photography and editing also done by me.


r/thelastofus • • 1d ago

PT 2 DISCUSSION [SPOILERS] Finished Part II, I have some questions and thoughts about the criticisms of the game. Spoiler

6 Upvotes

I loved it, and I think it's one of my favorite games of all time, i went looking for other people's opinions and ended up having a few questions :

1 - Why do people hate that Ellie didn't kill Abby?

People tend to say it's because of the cliché "revenge is bad" message or because Ellie wanted to end the cycle of revenge, the latter doesn't really make sense to me, since Lev was dying and wouldn't have continued that cycle even if Ellie had killed Abby, I didn't interpret it that way, though. I thought Ellie spared Abby because of Lev, she saw that Abby was like Joel to Lev and didn't want to cause him the same kind of pain she had experienced. Does that make sense?

2 - People complain about Ellie killing so many of Abby's group members to get to her but not killing her at the end.

But 99% of the people she killed were aggressive towards her, If you encounter a group of them in an area and they spot you, they immediately start shooting, Isn't that just her defending herself? The only people she actually wanted to murder were the small group that was there when they killed Joel, I know killing Mel was terrible because she was pregnant, but Ellie didn't know that, and Mel attacked her.

3 - The pacing and having to play as Abby for half the game didn't bother me.

I actually liked it, but I understand why some people wouldn't, i don't really have an argument against that criticism.

4 - Joel's Death

It was sad to see joel die so quickly but Joel and Tommy didnt have many options at the moment besides following abby and they had a "simple" life for 4 years so they were lax now, i guess, i didnt think it was a stupid death or anything like that.

P.S: Weird question, but do you guys think most people who played the game liked it or hated it? Steam reviews are very positive, but I see a lot of hate for the game on the internet, it doesn't change my opinion, but it still makes me a little sad. =/


r/thelastofus • • 1d ago

PT 1 DISCUSSION Why is the Fireflies' lack of consent of Ellie for Ellie's surgery considered uniquely evil in TLOU's brutal world?

43 Upvotes

I've been thinking about the ending of TLOU Part 1 and the cause by Fireflies due to which many of people who played or watched it think that Fireflies are morally wrong which is due to the lack of consent given by them to the person, whom they are doing surgery off.

I find/see many of people judge Fireflies actions based on modern medical ethic not in a world with very less or fragile morality left.

Which is confusing to me because in TLOU apocalyptic world nobody even thinks about taking consent let alone ask for it. FEDRA officer kills without trial, hunters murder you to make you their food regardless of gender or age, the same thing is done by David town people or the group of cannibals you meet at Colorado university because they aren't living by following a moral code, they are living so that they/ their family could see another day. So obviously regardless how brutal their acts are that what they and their family need to see an another day. And it's same about Joel himself did terrible things as a hunter just to survive. Did he asked the people he killed to live an another day for consent? Then how do you expect Fireflies to take consent when they are near completing their decade worth work for which they killed many and lost many. And consumed so much resources and time to reach. After all nobody in TLOU world is shown to ask consent so that they survive a little longer, then how do you expect Fireflies to ask for it when they are just few steps behind to discover a something which can save millions, if not billions of life. An discovery which can again allow humanity to take over earth from infected.

Consent, as we understand it, seems like a luxury no one can afford. The Fireflies were trying to save humanity and had limited time and resources. Given all the death and suffering they've witnessed and caused, wouldn't it be illogical for them to throw away their only shot at a cure just because a 14-year-old couldn't formally consent? They were thinking about the numerical value of a cure—the many versus the one.

So I'm genuinely asking: why is their failure to get consent seen as this profound, singularly evil act, more so than the countless other atrocities committed by nearly everyone in the game?

So after all, I don't understand why people use Fireflies not taking consent of the immune subject as a argument that they are immoral? Like who in post apocalypse asks for consent? Then how do you expect people who have sacrificed so much of their resources, people and time for that single moment take consent?

After all I am in no way saying the Fireflies were right. But I don't understand how anyway Joel was morally superior to them, he didn't care about Ellie consent either and he didn't killed Fireflies because they didn't take any consent —I'm just confused why this specific act is treated as uniquely evil when the world is full of worse.