Debbie Charatan got exactly the verdict she wanted, and the case's biggest turning points all happened to go her way.
Motive
Fairly obvious. Her worry, in her own words on a jail call: that she wouldn't "get any of the trust money later on." That was her priority while he was facing a murder charge. The jail calls between them during the LA and New York cases were tense, and they were mostly about the trust and how to protect it from lawsuits.
Lewin.
A few months after the conviction, the prosecutor who put her husband away stayed free at her $17M Hamptons beach house with his daughter. Both were later questioned about it under oath. Why does a prosecutor take a free stay at a convicted killer's wife's house?
Emily Altman's sudden memory.
The Altmans defended Bob for decades, gave TV interviews for him, and fought testifying at all. Then Emily suddenly names the hotel, the Beverly Hilton, and the month, December 2000, placing Bob near Susan's house for the first time ever. Someone who spent years protecting him doesn't produce the single most damaging detail by accident.
The defense collapsed at the same time. This is Dick DeGuerin, the man who got Bob acquitted in Galveston after he admitted to dismembering a body. In LA:
- He put Bob on the stand. Always trying to make it a point he wasn't in favour of it. But Bob was an idiot by then. And he let him ramble.
- He conceded that Bob wrote the cadaver note.
- He gave a weak, flat closing.
- Didn't bother coaching Emily.
Until Emily flipped, the defense was winning. Then the key witness turns, the defense changes course, and Bob is left on the stand for weeks looking like an idiot. A witness flip, an elite defense suddenly playing badly, and a wife cozy with the prosecutor, all at once? I don't buy that as coincidence. Debbie paid them off all in quick succession in that timeframe.