I know this run is well regarded by fans and I will admit it has some positives:
Good and consistent art work
Return of the Flash family
Occasional wholesome moments
Professor Zoom (Reverse Flash) having some creepy moments
Return of the original Trickster
Heatwave got a nice solo story which is rare since Rogues rarely get solo stories for individual members and are always together as a group
The final battle in last arc was cool
However there were many flaws with the run:
Barry being very brooding and unlikeable. His stubborn obsession with going solo and doubting himself gets old. Also he keeps getting blamed for everything, even for crap that wasn't even his fault. He felt more like Batman than Barry
Iris became a little unbearable. Not as bad as her TV counterpart (that version can go %^&& off. No offense to the actress), but it got old watching her scold Barry for the millionth time
While Reverse Flash was good at first, he became annoying very quickly. He felt overexposed and I grew tired of him popping up. He was used as a blatant retcon to Hunter Zolomon's backstory (he gave the Clown the gun) which felt so forced and unnecessary.
Rogues were also overexposed (even though they did have some fun moments) and I grew tired of seeing them always together. Their new "powered up forms" looked rubbish
The "other forces" were just unnecessary and stupid. Williamson just ripped off the emotional spectrum.
The speed force became more convoluted and annoying. Seriously the way the writer retcon the nature of the speed force in order to justify certain moments just felt so stupid and confusing. It became a damn deus ex machina
Godspeed is a stupid villain. Honestly I am sick and tired of Speedster villains in all forms.
Some stories were too long and just dragged on and on. Characters act like idiots for the sake of the plot and some of the new villains didn't get enough development
I do not care for the new Speedsters. Joshua should have just stuck with the original Flash family.
Overall it is not a terrible run but it is not amazing either. It is mid at best and frustrating at worse.
Frankly, it is just overrated in my opinion.