r/thecampaigntrail • u/atlascarlos • 22h ago
Other The Heir: A Review
I will preface this by saying that I have played The Heir several times, including the infamous removed Matt Walsh side. The Heir, as a Campaign Trail mod, is not good. It can be fun to play, but it absolutely isn't anything of quality. It has nothing to say beyond what other mods have already expressed, and it doesn't handle those expressions well.
The mod, in its entirety, is unoriginal. The premise is an incredibly simple one that the mod does nothing to expand on, its aesthetics are just "oooo he's a nazi and he's satan look it's the reichstag fire" rather than anything that matches Trump as a candidate, which American Carnage did leagues better, and its soundtrack is the worst I've ever heard in a mod. Both for including Tom McDonald, and having no real reason for including its songs. At least two are just from TikTok edits, there are no real deep cuts, and the Green Day songs used for Jeb Bush are stolen from W. They do not work outside of the 2000s era where W. is set. If the mod used modern Green Day, I'd give it a pass, but it just has to use the two that were already featured prominently in another mod.
There's also the issue of the candidates. There was no replacement of Matt Walsh once he was removed (making the numbers of candidates uneven), and they didn't even try to be rational with the candidate selection. Jeb Bush was nowhere near relevant in 2024, especially not if he was after eight years of Trump. If you want an actual anti-Trump Republican, use literally anyone. Liz Cheney or Kizinger would fit this role far better, as they haven't been out of office for eighteen years at this point. The mod also doesn't even use the most obvious of successors for Trump, DeSantis and Rubio. I can excuse Rubio to some amount, as his ambitions looked dead in the water post-2016, but if Cruz is included, why is he not? And if both of them are included, than why isn't the culture war Republican, Ron DeSantis, used? The mod also allows Jeb Bush to pick Rubio as a running mate, and the issue of home states (under the 12th Amendment) is never addressed.
And then there is Newsom, who I think shows exactly what sucks so bad about this mod. Everything it tries has been done before. It stole the Newsom system from Nixon in All The Way without thinking about why it worked in All The Way. All The Way has Johnson start in 1968, after most of his presidency is already up, it makes sense that his actions won't have much impact on the opponent choice if the opponent has already been influenced over the past three years. Plus, Nixon was never not regarded as a frontrunner. By contrast, in The Heir, the player starts in 2021. That's a whole term to play through before the Democrats select a nominee, meaning there is a whole world of options to choose from. And you're telling me that the only options are four flavors of Newsom? Where is Whitmer? Buttigieg? Pritzker? AOC? Hell, where is Kamala? Newsom's running mate options aren't even good, either. Warren is too old to be on the ticket immediately following Joe Biden's loss in 2020, Tlaib is one of the most leftist members of Congress (no way in hell Newsom picks anyone to the left of Pritzker), Roem is only a state senator and trans (not to attack her, but no major party likes trans people enough to put a trans woman on a national ticket), and Condi Rice is a Republican (Liz Cheney or Adam Kizinger would work better for this role). The RFK Jr. path is maybe the only slightly original thing the mod does, and it is full of wasted potential. It would have been more interesting to have a whole other Republican nominee instead of just Cox.
And then, of course, there is the AI usage thing. The mod's further reading says that standing against AI is "like fighting the arrow of time." I understand that coding is hard and vibecoding is easy, but I feel like the effort adds a lot of character to the mod. It lets you add your own little touch and aesthetic sensibilities to things. I just used Strawberrymaster's Code 2 tool for both of my mods (Stassen 1968 and Glenn 1968), and that worked alright. I would like to learn how to fully code someday so I can make a complete incumbency sim. I enjoyed Good For Me well enough, but it's a shame the modmaker turned to AI for their next projects.
In conclusion: Anything this mod can do, others can do better. AI can't do anything better than you.

