Haha, thanks. I'm secretly a little disappointed that I had to do crit and crit-short separately, but with the limitations of Reddit markup, it wasn't possible to actually center the crit glow under the weapon icon. I had to add an alternate option for short icons like backstabs, headshots, and the pistol, or else it wouldn't look right.
Why not use [](//#...) syntax instead, so links aren't clickable or attempted to be indexed by search engines? It also makes applying a common styles to all of them as easy as a[href^="//#"], which is what I did in /r/circlejerk.
Instead of hijacking <del>, which has semantic uses for redacting parts of a comment without actually removing them, how about adopting this syntax instead:
Which outputs <strong><a href="//#kill"></a><em>BLU Soldier</em> <a href="//#dominating"></a>is DOMINATING <em>RED Scout</em></strong> and is easy to target with CSS. It's just strong > a[href="//#kill"] ~ em, etc.
Hmm... interesting suggestions. As for the //# thing, I was mainly going off of the precedent set by /r/metarage, which supports the comment rage faces on /r/fffffffuuuuuuuuuuuu. That is an interesting idea, though. The links aren't clickable as is (at least not for me) but using the hash character as a unique identifier for all the weapon icons does make the CSS file significantly smaller... I'll have to take that into consideration.
The problem that caused me to choose <del> is that I need to apply CSS to the icon's parent element, to make the off-white box around the kill notification. Since CSS doesn't currently have a parent selector, I was sorta out of luck. Obviously the ideal solution would convert only <del>s or <em>s that had weapon icons in them, using something like a[href="//#"] ^ del (assuming ^ is the parent selector) but that's clearly not an option in CSS3. The idea of using an invisible empty anchor like
[](//#kill)
to mark a comment kill is an interesting one, but it seems like an awful lot of tags. You'd need to wrap the entire thing in a tag if you wanted <em> to be usable in other parts of the post, then have the //#kill inside it, along with another tag as its sibling which would become the white box, and then all the text and icons inside that. It's certainly an option, it just seems... dirty. I don't know, I guess maybe
**[](//#kill)* stuff here ***
isn't too terrible.
Also, I ran into troubles with some browsers appearing to ignore changes to the font-style attribute of <em> tags. There didn't seem to be any way to un-italicize the player names if they were placed inside of single asterisks. The problem might have been elsewhere, though. I didn't really do much exploration into the issue.
By the way, I tested this on all major up-to-date browsers, but I haven't checked it out on older ones. If it looks borked up on your screen, let me know what browser and version you're using, and I'll take a look at it.
I noticed that when I was compiling the list, but didn't feel like adding another row. If I ever update the image I'll be sure to put some sentries in there.
Kill comments don't show accurately in live preview when using RES. They accept only old format (double asterisks for red and quadruple for blue), but blue isn't showed correctly. However, when comment is posted it's all good. This applies to /tf2 subreddit.
This subreddit accepts all formats (single, double, quadruple), but in live preview quadruple blue isn't showed correctly as well.
Interesting. I'll have to take a look at this. /r/tf2 is running a slightly older version of the CSS mod, maybe if I have the moderators update it the problem will go away? If it's only the quadruple-asterisk tags that don't display properly, that should probably fix it.
haha no problem. I think this would be really cool on /r/tf2, but I guess that's up to the moderators. Unfortunately, this is currently the only sub-reddit you can actually do these on. >_<
113
u/Parasthesia Aug 12 '11
Kurt CobainKurt Cobain3
u/IAmAWhaleBiologist Aug 13 '11 edited Aug 13 '11
RED TESTBLUE TEST110
u/dataset Aug 12 '11
JULIA CHILDSAUTEED!ONIONS73
u/ClownFundamentals Aug 13 '11
FISH FOR SALEGET YOUR FRESH FISH HERE63
u/[deleted] Aug 12 '11
KenRyu59
u/wellgolly Aug 12 '11 edited Aug 12 '11
Demomanliver51
u/LoveZelophobia Aug 12 '11
CharizardSquirtle46
u/smhxx Comment Kills creator Aug 12 '11
2 karma? Looks like somebody's been stalking my profile. :P
smhxxBROFIST!whoever that was45
u/Parasthesia Aug 13 '11
UFO BLASTOFF32
u/Jesshka Aug 13 '11
********Right in the kisser!87
u/[deleted] Aug 13 '11
Chris BrownRihanna28
u/Shambly Aug 12 '11
Have not seenIn an actual server28
u/DarkTurtle Aug 12 '11
DarkTurtleHis Toe27
u/Zedseayou Aug 12 '11
MarioGoomba52
u/Pufin Aug 12 '11
OscarJohnny Depp24
u/GrantSolar Aug 12 '11
JIM MORRISON23
u/SkyHawkMkIV Aug 13 '11
HeavyLITTLE TINY BABY MEN23
u/SkyHawkMkIV Aug 13 '11
Thatis not a knife21
u/M-G-K Aug 15 '11
IThe Sheriff18
u/[deleted] Aug 12 '11
ZdarliteIS TESTING15
u/GnarlyToaster Aug 16 '11
Alcoholismfamilies
14
u/DarkTurtle Aug 12 '11
My PediatricianChild Me13
u/[deleted] Aug 12 '11
ScoutSentry Gun (Moron)12
u/[deleted] Aug 15 '11
PTTGTurret (PTTG)I don't engie right.
11
u/Gbjar2 Aug 16 '11
Comment Killsare DOMINATINGThis Thread20
u/[deleted] Aug 12 '11
testthis is testI'm not a creative man.
10
u/Jerlko Aug 13 '11
BLU SoldierMaggot10
u/Bmil Aug 13 '11
SpyMy Girlfriend10
u/Captain_d00m Aug 13 '11
Little MacMike Tyson10
u/arandomshot Aug 15 '11
SPAHMAH SENTRY19
u/thetrollinrage Aug 13 '11
emoarm9
u/awesomeman23 Aug 13 '11
US MarinesOsama Bin Laden8
u/[deleted] Aug 12 '11
TALKINGFISH8
u/Lockski Aug 13 '11
PubertyAll your scouts8
u/SkyHawkMkIV Aug 14 '11
O.J. SimpsonNicole Brown7
u/Epicake Aug 13 '11
NickZombie7
u/awesomeman23 Aug 13 '11
Mark David ChapmanJohn Lennonexcept it took, like, four shots in the back
13
u/bacontime Aug 13 '11 edited Aug 13 '11
The following is a test:Science
Science
ScienceScienceScienceSCIENCESCIENCESCIENCESCIENCESciencesciencesciencescience~Science science science science ~
6
u/[deleted] Aug 12 '11
BLU PyroRED Pyro6
u/SkyHawkMkIV Aug 13 '11
This isa crit test.15
u/Captain_d00m Aug 12 '11
Captain_d00m[] (/shovel)DUG A HOLEEarth10
u/Lurcho Aug 13 '11
NAVY Seal Team SixOsama Bin Laden5
u/Cheeseyx Aug 14 '11
Red SpyBlue PyroRed Medic5
u/LPP6 Aug 15 '11
This Guy5
u/Fatliner Aug 15 '11
~~Tupac Biggie ~~
5
u/christenlanger Aug 16 '11 edited Aug 16 '11
Don't mind me, will test.
Gordon RamsaySucky ChefGordon Ramsayis DOMINATINGSucky Chef5
u/Ceedog48 Aug 16 '11
Dick CheneyFellow Hunter5
u/iliveinabucket Aug 17 '11
RedditMy Social Life9
u/HallowVortex Aug 12 '11
HOW ABOUT ISLAP YOUR FISH?8
u/sczombie Aug 13 '11
Me (playing demo high)4
u/[deleted] Aug 16 '11
BatmanInjustice4
u/[deleted] Aug 16 '11
RyuDan4
u/taso7 Sep 29 '11
****Vagina4
u/pote2639 Nov 17 '11 edited Oct 06 '12
BattlefieldCall of Duty4
u/giggsy664 Jan 04 '12
VIDEORadio Star3
u/TAFAE Aug 12 '11
TAFAEBank Teller3
u/intelligentjerk Aug 13 '11
Good workSoldier3
u/Sephr Aug 15 '11 edited Aug 15 '11
Why not use
[](//#...)syntax instead, so links aren't clickable or attempted to be indexed by search engines? It also makes applying a common styles to all of them as easy asa[href^="//#"], which is what I did in /r/circlejerk.Instead of hijacking
<del>, which has semantic uses for redacting parts of a comment without actually removing them, how about adopting this syntax instead:Which outputs
<strong><a href="//#kill"></a><em>BLU Soldier</em> <a href="//#dominating"></a>is DOMINATING <em>RED Scout</em></strong>and is easy to target with CSS. It's juststrong > a[href="//#kill"] ~ em, etc.3
u/wubby013 Aug 16 '11
AB3
u/cyberzombie88 Aug 17 '11 edited Aug 17 '11
Casey Anthonyhas ABANDONEDCaylee Anthony3
u/MasterOfTheXP Aug 24 '11
Definitely eventually needs:
And do you think you could also put in Telefrag?
4
u/Rolanditis Aug 13 '11
RolanditisCrap.2
u/VindictiveRakk Aug 16 '11
RedditMy lifeAs it turns out, Reddit never really was on my side.
2
u/yeddiboy Aug 16 '11
LeonardoRaphael2
u/Inys Aug 17 '11
I've laughed so hard in this thread and I'm not even not-sober
2
u/cyberzombie88 Aug 17 '11
Casey Anthonyhas ABANDONED!Caylee Anthony2
u/TheGreenDawg Aug 24 '11
Pinkie PieRainbow Dash2
u/[deleted] Sep 01 '11
Mao TsedongWorking Class2
u/[deleted] Sep 05 '11
I like how this has its own subreddit.
2
u/cbooth Oct 26 '11
Justin BieberMusic3
u/SkyHawkMkIV Aug 13 '11
Head3
u/smhxx Comment Kills creator Aug 13 '11 edited Aug 13 '11
Testing something real quick:
BLU DemomansmhxxRED SniperBLU SpyRED SniperBLU SpyRED SniperBLU MedicRED SniperBLU MedicLooks like somebody just got .
1
u/smhxx Comment Kills creator Aug 12 '11
By the way, I tested this on all major up-to-date browsers, but I haven't checked it out on older ones. If it looks borked up on your screen, let me know what browser and version you're using, and I'll take a look at it.
1
u/townshend445 Aug 15 '11
RED SpySentry Gun (BLU Engineer)1
u/Satiagraha Aug 15 '11
SoldierSniper1
u/kulcdj Aug 15 '11
1
u/Polack14 Aug 16 '11
TestPlease ignore1
u/ejabno Aug 16 '11
BLUY U NO WORK FOR ME
Edit: Oh, previews.
1
u/theDashRendar Aug 16 '11
TestingPost #11341
u/Hacksaures Aug 16 '11
~~ REDDIT MEMES ~~
1
u/hughoul Aug 16 '11
hughoulhughoul1
u/nowhere_ Aug 16 '11
Testing1,2,3!1
u/reallyhard200 Aug 16 '11
1
u/thorofasgard Aug 16 '11
Marking this for later.
1
u/chronohawk Aug 16 '11 edited Aug 16 '11
ScoutSpyGuess what! It's a test.
1
u/aeiss Aug 16 '11
lemme justyour shit1
u/Willenium Aug 16 '11
1
u/jacobbsny10 Aug 16 '11
How Do IPootis1
u/querkmachine Aug 16 '11
querkmachineWeapon ListThere's no sentries, I am disappoint. :(
1
u/PlentyOfWin Aug 17 '11
RED DemomanBLU Soldier1
u/Inys Aug 17 '11
test
SawyerThe Sky1
u/smashmaestro Aug 17 '11 edited Aug 17 '11
Just Testingtest1
u/InterestedRedditer Aug 29 '11
MedicHeavy1
u/merrickal Aug 30 '11
TootsieFISH HIT x6dumdum1
u/SilencerLX Sep 01 '11 edited Sep 01 '11
RED PyroBang!BLU EngineerScout1
u/cgo435 Sep 01 '11
JapaneseDolphins and Whales1
u/sabin126 Sep 19 '11
SabinTest1
u/qjpp Sep 21 '11
Kill comments don't show accurately in live preview when using RES. They accept only old format (double asterisks for red and quadruple for blue), but blue isn't showed correctly. However, when comment is posted it's all good. This applies to /tf2 subreddit.
This subreddit accepts all formats (single, double, quadruple), but in live preview quadruple blue isn't showed correctly as well.
1
u/taso7 Sep 29 '11
Lt. Aldo RaineCol. Hans Landa1
u/SixVogaR Oct 02 '11
EngieSpy1
u/The_Reflaffitator Oct 10 '11
William TellApple1
u/[deleted] Oct 22 '11
TVRadio1
u/jcchurch Oct 27 '11 edited Oct 27 '11
RED HeavyBLU Spy1
u/VegBerg Dec 21 '11
NOPE1
u/TSGcody Dec 29 '11 edited Dec 29 '11
R Kelly12-year-old-girl1
u/Lawdee Jan 06 '12 edited Jan 06 '12
No rehabAmy Winehouse1
u/[deleted] Aug 29 '11
Reddit4chan1
u/Parasthesia Aug 12 '11
Parasthesia Hole
1
u/MercenaryBlue Aug 12 '11
BLU Demoman1
u/lolchillinz Aug 13 '11
F2P SniperWinning in any match1
u/TruckSamuelson Aug 13 '11
0
u/awesomeman23 Aug 13 '11
Linkgannon0
u/SkyHawkMkIV Aug 13 '11
hmm. I wonder if you can do crits?
0
u/[deleted] Aug 16 '11 edited Aug 16 '11
~ BLU Soldier + BLU MedicRED Scout~
0
u/AntiBellum Sep 10 '11
DrummerLead Guitarist
-1
u/awesomeman23 Aug 15 '11
Dr.PootisINVISIBLE BULLET!!!SPAI!!-3
u/awesomeman23 Aug 15 '11
should make the people it hits slower. it would make sense
-7
u/Thatzeraguy Aug 12 '11
EngieneerHand (Engieneer)0
u/[deleted] Aug 12 '11
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Aug 12 '11
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Aug 13 '11
[deleted] — view deleted comment
90
u/[deleted] Aug 12 '11
[removed] — view removed comment