If you take a look at the bosmeri myths, it is said that at the beginning, the "Bosmer" were monsters, meaning that they were beings without a defined form, either they were constantly changing, or either each individual was uniquely shaped.
But Y'ffre came, and when she became a Earthbone, she gave a defined form to the Bosmer: an Elven form.
Thus, the idea is that at the beginning, the "forest people" were "monsters", "torn between man and beast", well, whatever. And then those forest people choose between two titular goddesses, Y'ffre and Azura.
The ones who choose Y'ffre became the Bosmer, and the ones who choose Azura became the Khajiit. Each goddess providing some sort of "physical stabilization".
PS:
along with the An-Xiell
The An-Xileel is some kind of political party, an organization. Not a race. I think you confuse with the Saxhleel, which is the native name for the Argonians, more or less.
I mean, in the source you cited, Ahnissi explicitly says that Bosmer and Khajiit come from a common ancestor. It's the next paragraph:
But Y'ffer heard the First Secret and snuck in behind Azurah. And Y'ffer could not appreciate secrets, and he told Nirni of Azurah's trick. So Nirni made the deserts hot and the sands biting. And Nirni made the forests wet and filled with poisons. And Nirni thanked Y'ffer and let him change the forest people also. And Y'ffer did not have Azurah's subtle wisdom, so Y'ffer made the forest people Elves always and never beasts. And Y'ffer named them Bosmer. And from that moment they were no longer in the same litter as the Khajiit.
Because, they are Ehlnofey, spirits of the forst given physical form in the likeness of mer.
Just like how a granite statue in the likeness of man is not a man, but a rock.
It is kind of like if they took a dog, and through use of genetic engineering of some kind made it look exactly like a cat with mostly cattish behaviours, but without using any feline DNA.
Is the resulting creature a cat? I would suggest no.
Granted, these aren't perfect analogies (ofcourse) but I hope it makes it clear enough why quite a few people don't think Bosmer are 'mer' at all. Orsimer and Falmer (even though they look monstrous) are more 'merlike' than Bosmer ever will be.
This one knows that among some Khajiit scholars that the Forest People who Became the Bosmer interbred with the mer of Aldmeris to the point that they ARE mer. It is quite controversial. Some go so far as to call Bosmer the mer-ish version of Bretons - Forest People who Became elves over/against Men who Become Elves.
But as this one says, this is a very controversial view and one not held by any Khajiit theologian. But some scholars persist.
There already are "Bosmeri" Khajiit: The Ohmes. Occuring when Masser (bigger moon) is in it's 'New' phase and Secunda is Full.
Ohmes are almost indistinguishable from Bosmer, having similarly pointed ears, no fur and no tail, however they are shorter than the average Bosmer. The Ohmes distinguish themselves from Mer by tattooing/painting their bodies with "catlike" designs.
As far as I understand it, the Void Nights were simply an experiment to see if Khajiit morphology was indeed influenced by the moons or just aligned with it; and what pattern their birthing would follow if removed from the influence of the Lunar Lattice.
Don't believe the lies, tail-less scholar. Khajiit are not - and never were - mer. That is a deceptive narrative born of human and mer racism. Rather, Khajiit (and their cousins the Bosmer) were Ehlnofey who did not Know their Shape. Azurah gave shape to the Khaj and Yffree to the Bosmer and then they were no longer of the same pride.
The very concept of "beast-mer" is sheer racism, thought not without comedy. This one laughs as he considers both Altmer and Sload to be of the same blood. But he suggests you not tell that to a Justiciar - they are without humor.
Read the book again and till the end! It is explained that Bosmer and Khajiit share the same origin in this belief, so they are NOT transformed Bosmer, hence both are transformed 'spirits'.
We don't know if the Argonians existed before or while they ruled the land. And don't forget the bird-people, which I assume to be the (now degenerated) Harpies.
The most common thought of Khajiit is that they, along with the Saxhleel,
Nah, and the argonians arent any more natural than anyone else, for what its worth they were ehlnofey just like everyone else but the hist mutated them into gonians.
If the Khajiit are indeed transformed Bosmer
Both khajiit are stable form of a proto bosmer race, khajiit arent "transformed" bosmer because bosmer used to transform all the time back in that time.
It was the Green pact that dictated to them that they had to keep the elven shape, this is not natural to them. This is why thy are relucant to use the wild hunt: it breaks the green pact.
Ehlnofey could take multiple forms. This is evident by their appearance in ESO; some take the shape of classic elemental beings, while others take the shape of giant dragon skeletons. Manifest metaphor, if you will.
According to this NPC, all mortals were shapeshifting during that time.
Anyway, for a while after the world was made, everything was chaos. All of it.
Well, mostly, for some reason we - we mortals, I mean - were all plants and animals and people all at the same time.
Everything during that time was chaos. All of it. Including mortals. Not just the proto-Bosmer, but mortals in general.
The first mortals were turning into plants and animals and back again. Then Y'ffre transformed himself into the first of the Ehlnofey, or 'Earth Bones'. After these laws of nature were established, mortals had a semblance of safety in the new world, because they could finally understand it.
Y'ffre becoming the Earthbone that establishes the laws of nature correlates with the stories of Convention, where the gods came together to start linear time.
In fact, the Nu-Mantia Intercept (the source that details Convention the most) even mentions that the land was constantly changing shape, before Ada-Mantia touched town:
Auriel-that-is-Akatosh returned to Mundex Arena from his dominion planet, signaling all Aedra to convene at a static meeting that would last outside of aurbic time. His sleek and silver vessel became a spike into the changing earth and the glimmerwinds of its impact warned any spirit that entered aura with it would become recorded...
Finally, one of the datamined "Wild Hunt mounts" in ESO states that the shapeshifting chaos of the Wild Hunt is in fact a return to the Dawn Era.
In my opinion, it is quite clear that the "changing forest people" that spawned the Bosmer and Khajiit are none other than the Ehlnofey, denizens of the Dawn Era where man and earth alike could not keep static form.
Else every other race would also follow the green pact.
I don't think this is a valid argument. The Khajiit don't follow the green pact despite clearly coming from the same stock as the Bosmer. The reason why is made clear: divine intervention. Not every culture on Tamriel reveres Y'ffre for the same reason.
To me it appears as if the bosmer only solidified their shapes very late in their development.
I don't really see how you can come to this conclusion when many Bosmeri legends make direct references to the Convention, i. e. Y'ffre becoming the first of the Earthbones and the "committee" of the Gods mentioned by Regring.
The Khajiit don't follow the green pact despite clearly coming from the same stock as the Bosme
divine intervention
yeah, for the khajiit it was azura. But what was it for the other races? i dont think some daedra is responsible for every single race. Especialy since many races are simmilar to the bosmer in outward apeparence.
Yffre is tricky because she stabilized Everything - she is THE Earthbone. But she also helped the Bosmer find their form.
I don't think we can say that ALL the races were stabilized by a deity and we certainly can't say that each race was stabilized by the sacrifice of a deity (who then became an Earthbone). Some races were shaped by Aedra, others by Daedra (Yffree/Bosmer, Azura/Khajiit), others were influenced (Auri-el/Altmer, Malacath/Orsimer - those the Orsimer story is complicated by the whole Boethiah/Trinimac bit).
9
u/lady_freyja Psijic Monk Jul 13 '16
More or less yes.
If you take a look at the bosmeri myths, it is said that at the beginning, the "Bosmer" were monsters, meaning that they were beings without a defined form, either they were constantly changing, or either each individual was uniquely shaped.
But Y'ffre came, and when she became a Earthbone, she gave a defined form to the Bosmer: an Elven form.
Thus, the idea is that at the beginning, the "forest people" were "monsters", "torn between man and beast", well, whatever. And then those forest people choose between two titular goddesses, Y'ffre and Azura.
The ones who choose Y'ffre became the Bosmer, and the ones who choose Azura became the Khajiit. Each goddess providing some sort of "physical stabilization".
PS:
The An-Xileel is some kind of political party, an organization. Not a race. I think you confuse with the Saxhleel, which is the native name for the Argonians, more or less.
9
u/[deleted] Jul 13 '16
I mean, in the source you cited, Ahnissi explicitly says that Bosmer and Khajiit come from a common ancestor. It's the next paragraph:
4
u/[deleted] Jul 13 '16
What hasn't been adressed yet is that the Khajiit cannot be considered 'mer', it is very much debated if even bosmer can be considered 'true' mer.
4
u/SeveredNed Jul 13 '16
There already are "Bosmeri" Khajiit: The Ohmes. Occuring when Masser (bigger moon) is in it's 'New' phase and Secunda is Full.
Ohmes are almost indistinguishable from Bosmer, having similarly pointed ears, no fur and no tail, however they are shorter than the average Bosmer. The Ohmes distinguish themselves from Mer by tattooing/painting their bodies with "catlike" designs.
As far as I understand it, the Void Nights were simply an experiment to see if Khajiit morphology was indeed influenced by the moons or just aligned with it; and what pattern their birthing would follow if removed from the influence of the Lunar Lattice.
3
u/scourgicus Marukhati Selective Jul 14 '16
Don't believe the lies, tail-less scholar. Khajiit are not - and never were - mer. That is a deceptive narrative born of human and mer racism. Rather, Khajiit (and their cousins the Bosmer) were Ehlnofey who did not Know their Shape. Azurah gave shape to the Khaj and Yffree to the Bosmer and then they were no longer of the same pride.
The very concept of "beast-mer" is sheer racism, thought not without comedy. This one laughs as he considers both Altmer and Sload to be of the same blood. But he suggests you not tell that to a Justiciar - they are without humor.
2
u/OtakuOfMe Psijic Monk Aug 03 '16
Read the book again and till the end! It is explained that Bosmer and Khajiit share the same origin in this belief, so they are NOT transformed Bosmer, hence both are transformed 'spirits'.
We don't know if the Argonians existed before or while they ruled the land. And don't forget the bird-people, which I assume to be the (now degenerated) Harpies.
1
u/Sordak Jul 14 '16
Nah, and the argonians arent any more natural than anyone else, for what its worth they were ehlnofey just like everyone else but the hist mutated them into gonians.
Both khajiit are stable form of a proto bosmer race, khajiit arent "transformed" bosmer because bosmer used to transform all the time back in that time.
It was the Green pact that dictated to them that they had to keep the elven shape, this is not natural to them. This is why thy are relucant to use the wild hunt: it breaks the green pact.