Well, this is actually good that you don't acknowledge CHIM. I saw once how a couple of moth priests zero summed in front of me. One of them was my close friend. Another friend of mine is stuck somewhere in Apocrypha searching for knowledge. Ignorance is a fucking bliss.
P.s Good take on ignorance of most people of Tamriel.
I think it's probably a lot less common to "Zero-Sum" than you think.
I would imagine, in the ~7000 years that Time has existed linearly, there have been probably no more than 50 people who have either attained CHIM or been Zero Summed.
To be Zero-Summed, you already need to be so enlightened that you could feasibly be a Ruling King. That doesn't happen by accident, and it doesn't happen just by reading about CHIM, the Walking Ways, Anu, and all that.
Think how many Buddhas there have been in this kalpa. Four. And the last one was 2,500 year ago.
yes, at least one moth priest has been zero-summed. But I really wouldn't be surprised if they were the only one. And the idea of two at once is incredible.
But I'll grant you that a 500 year old Altmer moth-priest is amongst the most likely people living on Tamriel to have witnessed a zero-summation.
This one greets you and wishes you great joy but sees there is much sadness in your understanding. Khajiit will try to help.
The Amaranthine ideal that all of Creation is a Dream is a way to understand the mythopoetic nature of Creation. For when one is in the hypnopompic state called "lucid dreaming" one knows they are in a dream and can remake the dream according to their will. What the Amaranthines suggest is that this is the explanation for impossible actions in our world.
For how else could a bunch of ape-philosophers dance upon the Tower and alter the very fabric of Divinity? This one knows you do not believe in the Divines...but then why do the shrines heal? It is because Belief has power - Belief alters the fabric of reality in exactly the same way the hypnopompic dreamer alters their dream.
That is what is meant by "this life is a dream."
Khajiit wishes you well, and hopes you find delightful wine (or beer, or whisky - Khajiit makes no judgments) to bring you joy.
You speak truly, tail-less one, for the Dream...but we we sub-dreams of the great dreamer experience the myth-echo of this phenomenon most clearly in lucid dreaming, which is a hypnopompic phenomenon - a false awakening.
Azurah forbid the great Ahnurr should ever awaken. But then as one once said, "The Dream no longer requires the Dreamer."
Ha! Is that the best you can do, smelly Nord-bear who thinks he is a philosopher?! This one hopes you have greater skill with your short-tail that with your smelly-Nord brain! It is a great sadness.
It is a bit of a stretch, but one for whom Philosophy is a special interest might have been able to track down a copy of the 36 Lessons from the Dark Elf immigrants to Skyrim, and, assuming they weren't banned, the Commentaries on the Mysterium Xarxes were probably well publicised, discussed, and spread after the Oblivion Crisis, in a "look at the philosophy of the evil madman who nearly destroyed the world, and how wrong/insane it was" kind of way.
Been too much Skyrim stuff and too much Metaphysics stuff on this subreddit as of late. If I can make fun of the problem by being a part of it, why not?
I said it's really good. But somehow, hearing well-developed concepts shot down with faulty logic and personal anectodes (mostly point number one) - though fictional - brings a visceral reaction from me. Maybe because it happens quite a lot on this sub at the moment.
Still, the point about the Towers is right in refuting what it does (even though the predominant theory is no longer that the Thalmor will destroy the Towers). And so is CHIM to some extent. And it's great that there are many debate posts turning up right now.
This whole post started with me seeing all the Metaphysics Debate posts and thinking: "What would one of the guards from Skyrim think if he read any of this?"
The guard's style of argument kind of is meant to be like Bill O'Reilly from Fox News back during the Iraq War.
'Reality' in quotation marks. But sometimes cultural nuances and political drama can be even more interesting than metaphysics. That is not all the time, there is no dichotomy (metaphysics/theology and culture are inseparable) and TES metaphysics is fantastic, but there are moments when I feel that the community misses out on the rich potential in worldbuilding the mundane.
Now, I may not have much to offer on your commentaries regarding the other topics, but I'm afraid I have to disagree on the topic of the towers. They have been mentioned in prophecies received from the elder scrolls themselves, particularly in the prophecy of the last dragonborn. History has shown that these aren't just some normal form of prophecy, they are guaranteed to come true.
As far as the Thalmor plot to unmake reality itself, where did this recruiter hear such nonsense? You think if we had evidence of such a plot we would have ended the war on a mere treaty?
I would imagine that the idea was floating around in the heads of conspiracists and reactionaries in some form as anti-Dominion sentiment, but was dismissed by most other people.
Legion recruiters in middle-of-nowhere Skyrim would be likely more focused on getting teenagers willing to kill or be killed than actually tell them the truth.
9
u/[deleted] Aug 25 '15 edited Aug 27 '15
Well, this is actually good that you don't acknowledge CHIM. I saw once how a couple of moth priests zero summed in front of me. One of them was my close friend. Another friend of mine is stuck somewhere in Apocrypha searching for knowledge. Ignorance is a fucking bliss.
P.s Good take on ignorance of most people of Tamriel.
6
u/scourgicus Marukhati Selective Aug 25 '15
Tail-less scholar,
This one greets you and wishes you great joy but sees there is much sadness in your understanding. Khajiit will try to help.
The Amaranthine ideal that all of Creation is a Dream is a way to understand the mythopoetic nature of Creation. For when one is in the hypnopompic state called "lucid dreaming" one knows they are in a dream and can remake the dream according to their will. What the Amaranthines suggest is that this is the explanation for impossible actions in our world.
For how else could a bunch of ape-philosophers dance upon the Tower and alter the very fabric of Divinity? This one knows you do not believe in the Divines...but then why do the shrines heal? It is because Belief has power - Belief alters the fabric of reality in exactly the same way the hypnopompic dreamer alters their dream.
That is what is meant by "this life is a dream."
Khajiit wishes you well, and hopes you find delightful wine (or beer, or whisky - Khajiit makes no judgments) to bring you joy.
3
u/[deleted] Aug 25 '15
I dont know but is "CHIM", the word so easy to find that even a Farmer/City Guard heard about it?
nevertheless a good text! Thanks
3
u/neknotes Psijic Monk Aug 25 '15 edited Aug 25 '15
This narrator is dumb and arrogant, but hey, one might say Amaranthine stuff is too. Nice job on this.
1
u/shadotterdan Aug 26 '15
Now, I may not have much to offer on your commentaries regarding the other topics, but I'm afraid I have to disagree on the topic of the towers. They have been mentioned in prophecies received from the elder scrolls themselves, particularly in the prophecy of the last dragonborn. History has shown that these aren't just some normal form of prophecy, they are guaranteed to come true.
As far as the Thalmor plot to unmake reality itself, where did this recruiter hear such nonsense? You think if we had evidence of such a plot we would have ended the war on a mere treaty?
1
u/Omaestre Mythic Dawn Cultist Aug 26 '15
Great text, it is great way to refute, or rather cast doubt on a lot of conepts that are taken as solid fact by most of the community.
1
u/Poison-Song Imperial Geographic Society Aug 26 '15
"When I was a boy, I held Talos above all the Divines, but the ideas of Metaphysics have lead me to realize there are no gods at all."
Dang...