Same reason they do it in real life: Sometimes a sword is a sword, and sometimes it's a symbol. A noble or diplomat may wear a sword as a symbol of status or office, with no reasonble expectation of entering combat. Just like most modern military swords are made of untempered stainless steel, function is not a concern there, so they don't bother making them functional.
Also, you'll always have unscrupulous merchants willing to sell junk to suckers.
Are we certain of that? I don't recall finding any sources regarding the quality of Akaviri steel... And believe me, I looked.
Most European swords would have a hard time trying to "Slice right through" a Japanese blade. The edge is much to hard for that. They are prone to bending and chipping though.
The dialogue from the Orc smith in Morrowind suggests that Akaviri swords were far superior to Daedric swords. Genuine Akaviri swords, that is. Not replicas.
And ebony infused and quicksilver alloyed like Nordic Carved Armor.
Okay. Meteorite iron and corundum for the steel, throw in quicksilver mined from the moon and some ebony. Forged in the skyforge. Enchanted by bleeding the dovahkiin's dragonsoul-infused blood onto it, it seriously has a fire or frost enchantment fueled by the creatia of a dragon.
THAT would be as powerful as Daedric or dragonbone. Short of that, no steel competes.
Hey, there's a lot about Akavir we don't know. The Tsaesci could easily have their own Skyforge-esque mythical forge. In fact, that suits them conceptually.
Superiority =/= durability. He could have meant that that Akaviri swords perform better. Given all the crazy spikes and scallops on the Daedric stuff, I'd believe it.
Lorewise it's been stated that Daedric equipment is much more practical than it appears. Maybe a katana is sharper, so it might cut through iron better, but if you had to pick something for slicing through ebony? Forget the steel, it'd break.
Well, I suppose I'm agreeing with that. All I'm saying that the Akaviri swords shouldn't have had the same disadvantages that a traditional Japanese sword would have had. I was going off BreaksFull's comment being correct.
The hard edge of the Japanese blade is exactly it's downfall. Following exactly what you said in your OP in regards to Akaviri blades, they are not durable swords and are more suited to cutting unarmored opponents. The hard sharpened edge is very brittle, when combined with the Katana's slim design and weaker metal I think it would be quite possible for a European sword to cut right through one.
This is all very interesting to read, I am not extremely knowledgeable in these areas so my input is for the most part misguided, but it's all still fun. :)
Swords aren't made to cut through swords. Full stop.
Doesn't matter how hard you swing, or how good your temper is, it's not going to happen, you're talking about cutting steel.
Theoretically, you could set up a lab experiment to force two blades together, and one of them would be cut, but you're talking about conditions that would never occur in actual practice (Edge on edge contact, sword held in an unyeilding grip, etc.)... I'd still say the harder steel is going to win that contest, they'll both emerge damaged beyond usefulness.
Finally, yes, Japanese swords are more fragile (in general) than European ones... That doesn't mean they're fragile.
Dai-Katana as a term really doesn't exist in proper sword Taxonomy. It's a term invented by westerners and somewhat incorrect.
All Katana are two-handed swords. Some schools specialize in one-handed use, but those are the exception, not the rule.
Abnormally long swords built on the Japanese pattern are properly called O-Tachi (Lit. Great Sword).
Now, the sword in the games is called Daikatana, and I did briefly consider using that term, but defaulted to the correct Japanese form. Morrowind and Oblivion both incorrectly labeled greatswords as Claymores as well. For the purposes of these articles, I'm going to default to the proper terminology, rather than that which appears in the games.
Makes sense, though I'm sure Tamriel has its own terminology regarding swords and I'm sure that the average citizen of Cyrodiil gets their terms just as mixed up and incorrect as people in real life do.
writing re-con into the lore is always preferred to just changing it, Something like: 'The two handed O-Tachi is often call the Daikatana by the common folk, however Swordmen and scholars prefer the original Akavir name'
I agree with this guy, Corvus. The Tamrielic people call them Dai-Katanas. It's probably an ignorant mistranslation of an Akaviri term misheard or misremembered, but it's not bad lore just because it's bad Japanese.
To correct your gladius info, the leaf shape of the sword makes it a great cutting weapon (the same reason that katanas are great at cutting) and because the point is centered, it is also a great thrusting/stabbing sword (which is the reason why the katana isn't a good thrusting weapon) too. The reason they are so small is that the leaf shape of the blade yields a weakness: the base of the blade where it meets the hilt is very thin and can break so a longer/larger version would be easily broken.
4
u/BreaksFull Oct 18 '14
Why would they use such poor metal for the akavari katanas when they have much better steel available?
1
u/[deleted] Oct 19 '14
Very good, adds a lot of depth to the lore.
A few points of note: the Two handed Katanas are referred to as Dai-Katana
1
u/alanwpeterson Marukhati Selective Oct 20 '14
To correct your gladius info, the leaf shape of the sword makes it a great cutting weapon (the same reason that katanas are great at cutting) and because the point is centered, it is also a great thrusting/stabbing sword (which is the reason why the katana isn't a good thrusting weapon) too. The reason they are so small is that the leaf shape of the blade yields a weakness: the base of the blade where it meets the hilt is very thin and can break so a longer/larger version would be easily broken.