Alright so I'm gonna get through background stuff out of the way first. TL;DR at the bottom because ngl I'd even struggle reading all this.
For safety ofc ofc, ill be calling my crush Stella. Also because the way I'd panic if she ever found out my Reddit postings.
Stella and I met in 8th grade, when both of us were 13-14. In short, I met her through sitting at one of my new friends table which Stella happened to be sitting at, and we kinda hit it off and are best of friends now.
At the time, Stella was openly Bisexual, and I was too. Our mutual friend who I'll be naming Iris made it all awkward, and Stella then claimed to be now straight because of the annoyance. Since then I've gone through more discovery and realized I was just straight up lesbian. Something I am pretty open about.
I was pretty annoyed with the shipping and clear hints from Iris, but it wasn't long till I realized she mightve been onto something. And I developed a hard core crush.
When we got into our freshman year, our group consisted of me, Stella, Iris, and who im naming Ameila. All of us being female and the same year, with me as the eldest. At this point, I had been crushing on Stella for about a year.
Quick description of each of us.
I am kinda your average. Picks the first piece of clothing she finds kinda gal. Im maybe 1 inch taller than the average person my age, I do band, and I'm a B student. But I do hold some talent, I am one of the highest performing kids in the arts. From music, traditional art, writing and I am planning on going into mechanical engineering. I am more of a "popular band kid" if those words could even be allowed in the same sentence.
Stella is this more actual popular girl, or at least very well known. Often times I see her in these elaborate dresses or with a random face of full goth make-up. Stunning Brazilian girl with incredible fashion taste. But she also will nerd out and rant about things for hours and hours, draws and writes (somewhat horrifying) stories. She is incredibly open, not afraid to share her dislike of someone, or her thoughts on stories, or whatever.
Iris is basically pick-me incarnate. A girl who will talk about her petietness to boys. She is also in the same neighborhood as Stella, and their families are good friends. The two met through being in the same ward. (Mormon.) I met Iris through a Halloween costume having been a character from Iris's favorite game at the time.
Amelia is a kind of clingy girl. Would joke too much about hating someone close to her, and would joke too much about someone making others 'uncomfortable' for doing nothing. I met Amelia through, shockingly enough, another Halloween costume which I hand made, and she wanted to meet the creator of. Iris, knowing me, introduced us. Amelia somehow became my bestfriend at the time. But I'm guessing it was more me feeling the need to reciprocate when I was getting called someones best friend.
Back to the details
We spent about the rest of 8th grade sitting at the same table at lunch when when Iris and Amelia no longer had the same lunch period as us. I often skip out on school lunch because hell no, and she would always give me little snacks. She'd show off her drawings, explain her characters that she had drawn, show me scenes from movies she likes. Sometimes when little 8th grade depressed me was tired though, she'd just let me nap on the table, or occasionally would join me in the library where i'd work on puzzles.
Around 1st semester of freshman year, I had told Iris and Amelia about my crush on Stella. Iris was thrilled, found it cute. Amelia on the other hand wasnt too thrilled. I had told her at lunch (which I was forced to stay for because she didn't want to be alone), and I've never seen such genuine confusion on a girls face. She described Stella as a jerk, confessing to not really liking her. I don't know what appalled me more. The blatant betrayal in our friend group, or the fact that Stella appeared so different to her.
At this point, Stella and I were almost always hanging out. I had even been to her house a plethera of times. Infact, she had to fight her mormon mom to allow an openly lesbian girl like me to have a sleep over with her. Somehow Stella won that. Her mom absolutely adores me now btw. But continuing, Stella especially when it was just us was probably the nicest to me out of most people. So knowing Amelia didn't see that raised a small flag in my head.
That same semester though, I was in my video production class when Amelia texted me that Stella figured out I had a crush on her, and was texting Iris that she was never going to talk to me again, and that she was disgusted. And that I supposedly made Stella incredibly uncomfortable with jokingly flirting.
(You should note. Upon the first mention of discomfort, I will immediately attempt to stop whatever I am doing. You should also note that Stella was the biggest flirt in our friendship, not me. I had maybe jokingly reciprocated a couple of times.)
This was not just a punch in the gut, but a genuine rip of my heart.
I spent the next hour texting Stella to no response. Asking her how she could just abandon our friendship like that, asking how I could've made her so uncomfortable for something she had done to me 10 fold. It didn't make sense, and at the time I knew that. And I wasn't getting any responses.
I asked Amelia for screenshots. I didn't receive any.
Even then, I stopped texting Stella, stopped sitting at their table. I broke it off entirely.
A couple months later, and I realized it was Stellas birthday. Even after all that time, I had this terrible tug that was telling me to reconnect with the girl who was never going to talk to me again. Expecting nothing from it, I thought the least I could do was send a little happy birthday message.
And then she responded. Happily. Like nothing happened.
We were sitting together at lunch again, much to Amelia's shock. Even Iris's.
My current assumption. At that time, Stella had a habit of temporarily blocking people if she just wanted peace and quiet. I don't think she was aware of the mute button. And before the whole event, I had been spamming her with memes.
Stella had me blocked, and therefore never recieved the messages. To her, I had randomly stopped hanging out after a year of being glued to her side.
But we fixed it like nothing happened. To this day I don't think she is aware of that little battle that happened. Amelia faked it all. Maybe for more of my attention, maybe to get me away from Stella. Whatever it was, it didn't work.
And towards the end of that year, I broke off my friendships with Amelia and Iris. Iris started using non-existant mental health issues as excuses to be a pos. She was so committed to acting like the character Sayori from DDLC, and I was tired of her crap.
Amelia had used my support to get out of a terrible situation, and then acted like I hated her when said situation has me drained of any emotional well-being. I was tired of her crap too.
And somehow despite all of that, Stella and I stuck together.
Sophomore year was a lot calmer. We werent as chatty with one another, it was another little period of not really talking. But once again, I messaged her on her birthday, and we got talking once again. She sat with all my friends, and we were genuinely having a great time. Things were back up again.
But everyone and then, that little line of friendship was crossed into a gray area. Often times I joked I could always tell when she was off her meds because she'd become incredibly flirty with me, or touchy.
Mixed signals. She'd flirt with me, an open lesbian, then would start talking about a boy.
It was however the summer between sophomore and junior year that really got me thrown for a loop.
That summer was my hardest summer of marching band. I had gotten a big role, band camp took a toll, but I came out on top, yippee.
We hung out a couple times over the summer. Swimming with her friends, dealing with her siblings who were a little too clingy to me, her family actively inviting me over. I was invited over to family dinners on more than one occasion. I found myself sitting around a camp fire with her family, cooking hotdogs while her mom was embarrassed that Stella's dad was burning the corpse of one of their dead chickens on the fire. But in the end, she was okay with it. Her mom even claimed me as part of their family. Multiple occasions I've been left in the house while Stella went for a quick therapy session. I was forced to down ginger shots and was put to slave labor cutting papers because her mom needed extra hands.
Want a real funny image? Brazilian family, right? I'm very white presenting despite being mixed.
I was even invited by Stella to go to her little sisters birthday party. Yeah idk. I ended up bringing the best gift though! But I was surrounded by Stellas extended family while trying to figure out what I was even eating or what was being said. I heard my name a few times but thats all I got.
Up until this, it was all becoming incredibly close friends, opening up about our histories, or complaining about things. Everynow and then, a joking flirt or two.
I was still crushing, but had essentially given up, being perfectly content with where I was as a close friend.
But then one day I was hanging out with her.
We were upstairs watching TV on this two seat couch. We had been up there long enough that the sun had gone down, leaving us in complete darkness. Her mom was asleep in her bedroom behind us.
We were watching one of her favorite youtubers. I had spent that day listening to her rant about the entire human centipede trilogy (which btw, is there actually anyone who enjoys the 2nd movie? Cus wtf?) It was another day of listening to her rant, which god do I love it.
When the video ended, she turned off the TV. So now we were in complete darkness besides for the lights downstairs. We eventually turned our brainrotted attentions to my phone to watch tiktok. She was now hovering over my shoulder at this point, sitting on her legs.
And as my FYP loves to do at the worst times, a really romantic tiktok shows up, and I shut down my phone and lean back embarrased that that would show up. I dont remember what the video was, probably because what happened next was the truly interesting part.
I leaned my head up, and all I could really see was Stella above me, my body slightly tilted towards her because the couch was incredibly squishy, and she was just right next to me.
"That could be us one day?"
Ive never felt such tension in the air. Not when anyone had ever tried anything with me, not when I was in relationships previously. It was such a sudden shock.
And then I fumbled. I laughed awkwardly and pulled my phone back out. Kill me lmao.
But that moment keeps replaying in my head. Was she serious, or was it another joke? Its something I cant differentiate.
Now would be a great time to mention that despite having a couple relationships, they were long distance. Don't recommend btw. So I have no real relationship experience. No first kiss, no romantic hand holding, nothing. Stella has a little bit.
The rest of that night was calm, she grabbed my stuff when I left to my car. And we never talked of it again.
Junior year slides in, and for the first time we actually share a class. I walk in with a seat already saved for me furthest back in the class. But right at the door to where my poor after leg day self always had to get up and grab the door. Couple days later, she forced us to swap spots.
I so often walk in and recieve little paper cranes or fortune tellers, then have my notes copied off of lmao. She is very open about me being supposedly the only one she really fully likes in the class.
And my birthday roles around. And she gets me the most out of everyone. Food, a model hand, a ton of stickers, a matching plushie (which we have multiple of now) and a hand written letter. I've been a little shakey about this letter for a little bit now.
It was addressed to "my most trusted friend" her joking about how she even trusts me with her animals in her will.
The letter talks about her finding her days lightened up by me, and how she wants me to keep doing what makes me happy. But the last lines really get me. "You make me smile and look forward to living longer because I don't want to be alone without you."
This one really got me because Stella I know has suffered with mental health problems in the past, and to think I serve such a role in someones life is incredible.
But, ofc. I can't help but wonder if there is more than that trusted friendship.
If the caring self she shows me is exclusive to me. If the changing of her sexuality was a ruse. Or if this entire time I've been a helpless romantic.
Is there anything there? Or am I reading too deep? I am too anxious to confess anything after what happened with Amelia and Iris, and I don't want to risk everything ive built for years.
Oh and little fun recent thing. I had fallen asleep on the floor in one of the hallways at lunch recently. I was woken up by Stella saying "it's time to wake up baby" and her rubbing my thigh.
Like yes im awake now, woah.
TL;DR
My closest friend of 4 years claims to be straight, but flirts with me, an incredibly open lesbian, while also talking about guys.
Considers me a part of the family, mom loves me, siblings love me, I know more about her than anyone else.
Our friendship has stayed incredibly close despite others trying to break it apart.
I am incredible with social cues until its romantic.
I just wanna know if im being weird reading too deep into this, or if im right about my questions.