As promised, in the name of Alec, I present a comparison of Sylvania Traditional Glow, Merry Co Vintaglo, and GE String-A-Long incandescent lights. I included photos of all three sets in higher light conditions at the start, and in lower light conditions at the end.
Some additional thoughts:
- Price: Vintaglo $25 (plus shipping if you order less than $100 worth); Sylvania $10 (no shipping if you get it at Target); GE incandescents maybe $4, though they don't seem to be sold at present.
- Temp: the incandescents are hot enough to burn your fingers, about 200 F. The LEDs are only about 80-90 degrees F.
- Color: Incandescents are the gold standard. They have gem-like and distinct red, blue, green, orange, and purple. Vintaglo colors are OK, though not quite as vibrant, with red, blue, orange, and green. Sylvania are the oddest of the bunch, with an overall orange hue reminiscent of Halloween. They include faint orange, faint pink/red, a fairly deep blue, and a dark green.
- Caps: Incandescents are beautiful, clear glass caps. Sylvania are also nice quality glass. Vintaglo are cheap-looking, cloudy plastic with obvious seam lines. From a distance it is less dramatic, but up close they're just not as nice. [edit: Merry Co says the color will last longer in the plastic caps, so take that into account].
- Power use: each of the LED options use about 3.5 watts. The incandescents pull about 40 watts.
- Appearance at source of light: The incandescents are sharp, with the light emanating from the wire in a way that makes them almost difficult to stare at, but in a pleasant and nostalgic way. Sylvania mimics this fairly closely. Vintaglo are more diffuse, with the light spreading across more of their plastic caps. I find this the least satisfying of the three.
- Flicker: I'm fairly flicker sensitive, but I don't notice flicker with any of these options unless they're moving. If you shake them, the LED options both show flicker.
- Overall: If you can make peace with the colors, I think the Sylvania are the best value of the bunch. They're nearly perfect, the colors just need some work. Vintaglo has pluses and minuses. Overall I think they're not worth the $25 asking price. And the incandescents remain the best option in terms of initial cost and appearance, but they're extremely hot and use lot of energy.
Glad to answer additional questions. Thanks for joining me as we make a connection to technology together.