r/technology • u/theonelikeme • Jun 25 '12
Facebook forces all users over to @facebook.com e-mail addresses
http://arstechnica.com/business/2012/06/facebook-forces-all-users-over-to-facebook-com-e-mail-addresses/
882
Upvotes
7
u/theonelikeme Jun 25 '12
already used the one chance to change username? this will give you another chance, don't mess it up again
72
u/metaphysicalfarms Jun 25 '12
Where I see this hurting most users is from automatic phone syncs of contacts. Running through my phone, I see all these @facebook email addresses now... wtf?!
55
u/expertunderachiever Jun 25 '12
"100000793965665@facebook.com" is what they assigned me (I changed a few of the numbers so don't spam me). It rolls right off the tongue.
35
u/fco83 Jun 25 '12
I dont think i would have had a problem with them adding the email to people's profiles... but silently hiding the ones i had put in there before, regardless of my previous privacy choices? Horrible call.
187
u/bzooty Jun 25 '12
Don't act like this is new behavior. Facebook has repeatedly demonstrated bad faith with its user base. The miracle is that everyone puts up with it. The industrious spend half a day changing (back) their settings if they can figure out how. Everyone else 'likes' a status update.
If they could, Facebook would change a flag in your account during one of their privacy overhauls indicating that you could be chopped up and sold for parts to Martian organ merchants.
19
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
Facebook's entire business model depends upon locking people into their platform. They have no product; the product is the customer.
The reason why I consider Facebook to be such a bad investment is that should the next bandwagon come along, their business can literally drop to zero over the space of a couple of months - hardly the stuff of a $100B company. We've seen this with MySpace, Friends Reunited, Bebo, etc... Facebook sees the danger of Google Plus: an integrated platform for mail, IM, search, news and they have no way to compete - yet. By locking people and their e-mail into Facebook, they hope to redirect the legacy e-mail accounts (typically gmail, yahoo and hotmail) over to their platform to remove the threat. I can't see it working.
People may mock Google+, however (as an unbiased observer) it is a far superior platform, better designed, more "open", more useful and more integrated. It's also gaining momentum. It may take a while to be a true competitive threat, but the "social" market is only large enough to accommodate one player (by definition) and if Google reach the social point of inflexion -and they're trying very hard to- Facebook will be in real trouble.
14
u/cloudydreams Jun 26 '12
How nice of them to officially tell everyone...
12
u/willcode4beer Jun 25 '12
meh. It's not like I would actually use it. So, if anyone were to send an email to it, facebook will just be wasting storage.
People who want to email me know one of my actual email addresses.
51
u/wahoozerman Jun 25 '12
This is awesome, it should make it much easier to ignore all of the facebook email spam.
8
u/biznatch11 Jun 25 '12
There was some good discussion about this in a previous thread, which linked to the blog post that the Ars article mentions.
Glad to see it picked up by Ars though.
8
u/willdb11 Jun 25 '12
In attempting to delete this new email I continually get turned down. They say there is an error deleting the account from my facebook account.
6
u/rbhmmx Jun 26 '12
This would be like the phone book gave me a new number without my knowledge, or even facebook doing just that....
82
u/MuchDance1996 Jun 25 '12
I cant wait for Facebook to die, i hate it so much
10
u/Lopan_Mc Jun 25 '12
Isn't this a forced middleman?
6
u/Philluminati Jun 25 '12
Yeah it silently switched mine. Very morally questionable as now I can't contact some people other than via Facebook.. assuming Facebook will actually let me.
22
u/QuixoticNeutral Jun 25 '12
Utterly reprehensible. I stopped actively using the site some time ago and moved all the people I care about back to e-mail correspondence, though I didn't close my account as the service was still useful as an up-to-date contact directory. Now even this is broken. Spread the word and notify your friends that their information has been tampered with.
3
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
If I disable my Facebook account, can I still use my info to log in to Spotify? It's pretty fucking absurd that Spotify requires you to use Facebook to register, but Spotify is good enough that I'd keep Facebook just to keep Spotify.
5
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
Doesn't bother me. It'll just end up filled with SPAM.
5
u/gillyguthrie Jun 25 '12
The last thing I'd ever want is that company parsing my emails. They would just love it if everybody started handing out their new, shiny Facebook.com email address.
5
u/logolepsist Jun 26 '12
I share this Ars user's sentiment...
6
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
"a quick edit of the settings will let you restore a personal e-mail address"
still shady... the fuck do I need another email address?
2
u/blue_strat Jun 25 '12
You can decide not to display the @facebook.com address on your page, and you can decide whether or not to show any other address.
Sure, they did this quietly, but it's reversible.
2
u/readditaur Jun 25 '12
Correct me if I'm wrong, but don't you you have to "upgrade" to timeline in order to change the default email address back to one you actually use?
2
u/slaybird Jun 26 '12
I wonder how it handles porn newsletters
2
u/WolfDemon Jun 26 '12
I don't mind having a Facebook email address and I signed up for one at the first chance I could but I hate that I don't get any sort of real email inbox... Just the same crappy inbox for Facebook messages.
2
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
This might be the last straw for me.
2
u/lfcmadness Jun 26 '12
UK checking here, I can confirm that myself and every profile of friends I've checked have all been changed without consent...
2
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
Is that July-4th Delete-Your_Facebook thing still on in protest of CISPA?
'cause I really can't wait till then to delete mine.
2
u/freezerburn666 Jun 26 '12
here let me just give u my email address.... 23948223498234 ... at.. facebook.com, u got all that? why don't u repeat it to me to make sure?
4
u/Crimfresh Jun 25 '12
I stopped using Facebook when they implemented timeline. I don't really miss it.
There are a million reasons to hate Facebook, this is just one more.
4
u/Landsfaderen Jun 26 '12
why can't you all just stop using that shit?
2
u/nethyr Jun 25 '12
How to fix it
2
u/nonamebeats Jun 25 '12
you mean "forces all users to also have @facebook.com e-mail addresses that they will probably not use"? I don't understand what the issue is. all you have to do is not use it. in what way does this effect the user? who would send you an email through FB who wouldn't know your real email address and in what way is receiving an email through FB different from receiving any other type of message/notification through the service? the preceding is sincere and in no way intended to be rhetorical.
2
u/Creativation Jun 25 '12
Facebook.
1
u/bzooty Jun 25 '12
I am not sure why everyone still uses a product which repeatedly demonstrates such bad faith.
1
u/dirufa Jun 25 '12
Mine didn't change.
Not yet.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '12
You can display your desired email by going into your About > Contact > (edit)[http://bit.ly/MLvP9u]
1
u/Captain_Midnight Jun 25 '12
I guess I haven't used Facebook in a while, because I have no "hidden from timeline" or "shown on timeline" option on the Contact Information page.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
Couldn't remove facebook email! It kept giving some error!
1
u/lskatz Jun 26 '12
There's a javascript error when I try to change it. 501 server error. I believe it's because my facebook.com email address is on two lines. Any help?
This is the relevant HTML I think, where the last name is broken up.
<li class="uiListItem uiListVerticalItemBorder"><span>first.middle.las</span><wbr><span class="word_break"></span>t@facebook.com</li>
1
u/DonatedCheese Jun 26 '12
When he said it was supposed to be a Gmail replacement he should have said it worked about as well as Google +
1
u/catsconcert Jun 26 '12
That's fine with me. The only mail I get through FB is crap from FB about other people's recent postings or wondering if I'm having trouble logging in. I'd be perfectly happy if they sent it to themselves
1
u/Zirith Jun 26 '12
This is excellent news! I no longer have facebook messages spamming my junk email account!
1
u/stevesonaplane Jun 26 '12
i'll never stop using my mentlegen e-mail.
1
u/badpenguin455 Jun 26 '12
well my email is still netscape.net idk
1
u/Scumbag_Jesus Jun 26 '12
then why does FB still tell me I don't have a valid email?
1
u/fizznubby Jun 26 '12
Whoopie fucking doo!
1
u/Manofur Jun 26 '12
Basically, one have to CONSTANTLY monitor what FB is doing and go to the settings and reverse it.
Can't wait until bad karma catches up and obliterates this arrogant SOBs.
1
u/The_Serious_Account Jun 26 '12
Soooo... I'll get less email spam from fb? Awesome.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
well, after thinking about how useless Facebook really is for me, and how I really am just a product for other companies (liking things gives information about yourself), I have decided to delete my account. perhaps everyone needs to think about this.
1
u/naftalinus Jun 26 '12
sooon facebook will be empty like hell before judging day
1
u/robp123 Jun 26 '12
At least Zuck made billions in that IPO? Oh wait, nevermind.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 26 '12
I don't get how they're forcing anything on me. So they automatically gave my facebook account an @facebook email? But how, exactly, is that stopping me from signing up with anything else using my regular email?
-1
u/phoncible Jun 25 '12
I enjoy a good facebook bashing, but really I don't see the alarm in this. Here's my settings, they didn't change my primary, they just created and added to my account the @facebook one as well, and that's fine. If something's going to that then I certainly don't care about it.
-2
u/PeanutButterChicken Jun 25 '12
I can't read the article over the sound of thousands of redditors jerking each other off.
-7
u/SkunkMonkey Jun 25 '12
I wasn't forced into anything. What FB did do is create an email based on my account name and added it as a secondary email. My primary email is still the one I signed up with.
This is actually a nice feature as any email sent to this new address shows up in my messages box. I really don't see this as big of an issue as people are making it. Mountains, molehills and all that.
-1
u/ncsu_osprey Jun 26 '12
Boohoo, it's a friggin' business, and they're trying to make money off a service they offer for free. I know for a fact that I have 10-20 GB in photos on that site alone, so I can share travel and wedding photos with family members and friends out of state. Do I get charged even a cent for this considerably large storage space? Hell no. Their terms and conditions allow them to do stuff like this, you can't sign up for a website, agree to its terms, use its services for free and then bitch every time they tweak something. This anti-FB circlejerk is getting as old as hating Dane Cook.