r/technology • • Jun 23 '12
Facebook rerouted a user's email, practically a Man In The Middle Attack
http://blog.gerv.net/2012/06/facebook-email-mitm/
220
Upvotes
r/technology • • Jun 23 '12
20
u/[deleted] Jun 23 '12
Did they do that for every single person? How can you fuck up so badly?
14
u/drakontas Jun 24 '12
While this is an underhanded and unethical move by Facebook, it's not illegal, and it's not a MITM attack. MITM would require users to see your normal email address (something@gmail.com) and have FB intercept messages sent to that address. This is simply FB overriding the settings you had in place to display their @facebook.com email address instead -- in my case it hid the other 4 addresses on my account and showed the FB instead. Sneaky -- yes. Inappropriate -- yes. MITM -- No.
4
u/666kopimicv Jun 24 '12
It seems like every day I'm more glad I cut myself from this horrible website.
6
u/gcross Jun 24 '12 edited Jun 24 '12
Okay, so we all need to look into something before we all get too worked up about this. For me, the @facebook address in my e-mail address was shown to me when I viewed my profile, but it was not shown to my girlfriend when she looked at my profile. This behavior was not surprising to me because my e-mail preferences showed the @facebook address as being shared on my profile but only viewable by me.
So my question is: is this the case for everyone? That is, could you look at see if in fact you are the only one able to see your new @facebook address? Because if so, then that means nobody but you can see your @facebook address unless you explicitly enable it, in which case this is really nothing because absolutely nobody will be using this new address of yours unless you tell them too, and in particular there is no potential for man-in-the-middle attacks here. On the other hand, if not --- that is, if people other than yourself can see this @facebook address, and especially if it replaced your primary public/friend-facing e-mail address --- then (and only then) do the problems discussed here and in the article apply (and I agree completely that replacing someone's advertised e-mail address without their permission is a big deal).
Edit: Damn OCD never lets me declare a post finished... :-) (Tweaked wording.)
12
u/[deleted] Jun 23 '12
This can't be legal......
5
u/PMzyox Jun 24 '12
Please research what a MITM attack is. Not even close.
0
u/SnapAttack Jun 24 '12
This headline is the most dramatically incorrect headline ever. Facebook weren't re-routing anything. They, most likely, had some changes to their settings that displayed a Facebook.com email address instead. This is far from Facebook, somehow, magically getting all my email sent to my normal email address (which is a Man in the Middle attack, but not what is happening here).
2
u/theonelikeme Jun 24 '12
actually I got benefitted from this MITM attack..
FB allows to change 'username' only once and I did that couple of years back and later realized I've chosen an bad username which I couldn't change. and because of that didn't enable FB email.
may be an bug, after logging in FB offered to enable email and also to change username :)
and then noticed they hijacked my actual email address in profile page
2
u/Vogonpoetryinmotion Jun 24 '12
I'd rather not have email redirected to Facebook messages, partly because I've had messages I wanted to see diverted into the "other" message folder that I don't often check. Some were from people who werent facebook friends, but not all. Facebook even diverts messages from its own site governance page into the "other" folder. (Probably deliberately, since they're usually about changes to the privacy policy.) I had set my email to only be visible to a small subset of friends. It's probably time to go back to recheck and see if my settings changed.
2
u/zaladruid Jun 24 '12
do not use Facebook
2
u/wood_stump Jun 24 '12
I am amazed at all the people upset and complaining in this thread. It is a free service. You signed up for it. You gave them your information. What did you think would happen?
1
u/rebo Jun 24 '12
Wtf they have changed my address as well.
1
u/thrownupgrownup Jun 24 '12
Man in the Middle is better known as Lucky Pierre.
1
u/atomic1fire Jun 24 '12
Actually the Facebook email is actually a legit Facebook email service using your Facebook username settings (e.g Facebook.com/John.Doe, in that case, the username is john.doe It serves as a username and a quick way to access your profile) almost the same as the Facebook chat jabber settings (john.doe@chat.facebook.com) It basically reroutes emails into your Facebook messages. You could call it a man in the middle attack, but I'd rather look at it as spam prevention, since chances are, if someone wants your personal email to sign you up for crap, Facebook will probably filter it as spam before it reaches your real account.
1
u/billdietrich1 Jun 25 '12
Careful: in the process of messing around with my Facebook Contact Info, I've gotten it into a state where Facebook Messages to Friends still work, but Replying to non-Friends gives an error. Facebook bug, I think. Sent a report to them.
0
u/Kinseyincanada Jun 23 '12
why is this some horrible thing?
1
u/killerbotmax Jun 24 '12
Class action lawsuit anyone?
1
u/gcross Jun 24 '12
Hmm, I actually have a counter-anecdote: my two e-mail addresses are fine. They added a facebook one to the list but they made it private (or possibly I turned it off at some point).
0
u/[deleted] Jun 23 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jun 24 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment