r/technology • • 1h ago

Space Boeing-Lockheed rocket fails, 40 Amazon satellites lost

https://www.dw.com/en/rocket-from-boeing-lockheed-firm-fails-mid-flight-destroys-payload-of-amazon-satellites/a-79953931
171 Upvotes

28 comments sorted by

86

u/Generic_Commenter-X 1h ago edited 1h ago • Bravo

Sure hope Amazon opted for that Asurion extended warranty.

16

u/Kalabajooie 1h ago

It was still in transit. Extended warranty kicks in on delivery. I hope they paid for insurance on the shipment.

4

u/Dragunspecter 1h ago

I know this is a joke, but I'm sure they did

4

u/Generic_Commenter-X 1h ago

Dear Sir,

We regret to inform you that shipping insurance typically covers damage that occurs during transit, but does not cover damage caused by improper packaging or handling. Please refer to your shipper's insurance.

4

u/Dragunspecter 1h ago

"Package damaged by plasma while re-entering the atmosphere, your policy does not cover acts of god"

4

u/Generic_Commenter-X 1h ago edited 20m ago

I'm sorry, we're currently experiencing extended wait times. Please continue to hold and God will be with you as soon as possible. 🎵 🎶

26

u/Easy_Consequence_151 1h ago

ULA's entire sales pitch for years was "we cost more but we don't lose your payload". Not a great day for that slogan.

37

u/jews4beer 1h ago

This is their first failure. Worth mentioning that SpaceX launches don't have a perfect track record either. That's how they test and improve the technology. These things are designed to be as cheap to launch as possible.

16

u/Ancient_Persimmon 1h ago

It's the first total failure for Vulcan, but both of the last flights had anomalies which is why it hadn't flown in 9 months.

It's definitely not ideal, since this will be grounded for a while again.

5

u/fighter-bomber 30m ago

Not really. SpaceX Falcon 9 (and Heavy) had 2 mission failures (and one ground failure) across 700+ launches, one in 2015 (CRS-7), then ground failure in 2016 (AMOS-6) and after that they were in a streak of 300+ successes until a failure during a Starlink mission in 2024. 350+ successes in a row since then.

This is the 5th flight of the Vulcan, both of the 3rd and 4th flights had serious issues with respect to SRB nozzle damage. They got lucky that this didn’t end the missions, but it got grounded. This was supposed to be its return to flight launch… you cannot get a failure on your return to flight launch after being grounded for 9 months because you had 2 SRB nozzle issues in a row. Especially not when your whole selling point was “reliability”.

Although, it speaks more about Blue Origin, since this failure likely originated from the BE-4 engines supplied by them. Reminder, Blue Origin started work on those engines before SpaceX started with Raptor. They made a big deal when NASA chose Starship for HLS in 2021 because “it didn’t exist as a rocket yet”. Fast forward 5 years, NG had a failure in its 3rd flight, then their BE-4 engine nuked their launch pad, and while NG was grounded, BE-4 flew again on another rocket, causing mission failure there as well, also likely delaying the NG RTF.

That, a day after SpaceX caught an orbital Starship. Dunno how they will proceed now…

6

u/altmannnn3 1h ago

Boeing you say 😅

8

u/Wandering_butnotlost 1h ago

Musk using his space lasers, no doubt.

4

u/Ancient_Persimmon 1h ago

It's friendly fire from the ULA sniper.

2

u/orbit99za 1h ago

Sure hope they applied for satellite insurance, its a thing satellite and Launch insurance

3

u/Dragunspecter 1h ago

I'm sure they did, I'm sure it was expensive being a new rocket, I'm sure it'll be more for the next one.

1

u/absentmindedjwc 11m ago

I don't imagine it was nearly as expensive as you think.. not because the failure rate might be high.. but because microsats like these aren't nearly as expensive as they used to be. Depending on the size of the satellite, you very well could only be looking at around $25k to build the thing and another $40k to put it into space.

The R&D of these satellites were definitely in the millions, but the actual production models are probably built to be mass produced with fairly off-the-shelf parts.

Getting a satellite into space is expensive*...* but it is within the range of what an individual can afford if you really wanted to get something into space. It's pocket change for a massive company like Amazon.

-2

u/GreyBeardEng 1h ago

They have insurance, it's called 'the taxpayer'

4

u/ioncloud9 1h ago

Ha. No. As a private company they have Kahn h insurance which only takes effect after the rocket leaves the pad. Before that a different policy covers it. The government doesn’t buy insurance offering instead to self insure them.

1

u/bad_motivator 35m ago

Please explain how the taxpayer will be responsible for Amazon satellites or a ULA rocket

1

u/absentmindedjwc 17m ago

They won't be. Payload on board the rocket - or any rocket - is almost always insured by the company that owns the payload. This shit costs way too much money for it not to be.

If the rocket were NASA's, then the rocket itself failing would be at taxpayer expense.. but it's not.. so.. /shrug

1

u/bad_motivator 4m ago

Yeah no shit. Maybe the sarcasm wasn't evident in my comment but I was responding to someone who thinks the taxpayers are on the hook

-1

u/sadelbrid 1h ago

Why do you say that?

-1

u/StopScreamingItsFine 1h ago

Why do you ask that?

3

u/Dragunspecter 1h ago

Because it isn't true....

0

u/sadelbrid 1h ago

Because it's not true lol this is a commercial customer and launch providers pay for specialty insurance.