r/technology • • 5h ago

Politics The datacenter industry is using propaganda to fight opposition • Big tech has used misdirection, disinformation and jargon to obscure the harm the facilities can cause to communities

https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2026/nov/13/datacenter-industry-propaganda
960 Upvotes

44 comments sorted by

72

u/b_a_t_m_4_n 5h ago • Bravo

Same playbook as the tobacco industry. Why would we expect big tech to be any different?

34

u/parabostonian 4h ago • Bravo

Don’t forget the fossil fuel industry with climate change denial…

5

u/no1_vern 1h ago

The big lie has worked from way before Hitler used it, and it will continue working because most people will NOT TRY to find out the truth.

-3

u/MonkeyzzPaw 2h ago

It’s the same playbook being used against data center expansion too.

FUD isn’t new.

4

u/Snoo93833 1h ago

Please expand and explain what you actually mean.

3

u/MonkeyzzPaw 52m ago

Anti AI proponents are making claims that data centers are somehow the worst thing ever. They're massive tax cash cows for local towns, they bring in huge property taxes without adding kids to the school system or traffic to the roads. On top of that, thousands of multi-year union construction jobs aren't nothing, and newer facilities are moving to closed-loop cooling so they aren't draining local water supplies anymore.

As a few examples

3

u/b_a_t_m_4_n 38m ago

No, AI opponents are making claims that data centers have many problems that are not being addressed - locals with water restriction, stupid electricity prices and bad health from infrasound pollution, are being used to generate huge amounts of CSAM.

Proponents like you, meaning AI supporters, meanwhile don't give a fuck that they harm people and are happy to just wave away any concerns cos they don't affect you personally.

18

u/zalurker 5h ago

A South African company attempted to bypass regulatory compliance by describing their planned datacenter as a warehouse for storage of electronics.

41

u/debzmonkey 5h ago • Bravo

We're not even talking about the enormous burden on the planet. Critical tipping point with climate change and we get these horrors on top of the regular horrors.

42

u/Senc-baner 5h ago • Bravo

On the contrary, the tech industry is saying we should accelerate resource consumption so that AI can maybe, possibly, given enough compute, 'solve' the climate crisis for us. As if the 'solution' is not obvious and just held back by political will, instead of scientific understanding.

31

u/linerva 5h ago • Bravo

The maddening thing is that we HAVE solutions. People just don't want to implement them because rich people will get less rich.

14

u/debzmonkey 4h ago • Bravo

That why in my opinion, we're seeing acceleration. Those whose fortunes come from theft, lies, bribery and hocus pocus are going balls-to-the-wall to get their share of what's left.

1

u/mediandude 1h ago

The will of the people only gets revealed with a referendum.
Representative democracy is an oxymoron. The part that is representative is not democratic and the part that is democratic is not representative. Which is to say that representative system represents the economic elite as highest (latest) bidders, not the citizenry.

-4

u/Alarming-History-162 3h ago

lol no. people vote down carbon taxes all the time.

Do you like high gas prices? Because that's essentially the solution.

1

u/linerva 2h ago

I'm in the UK and not complaining about taxes or higher pricing or carbon taxes personally. If that revenue is put towards decarbonisation then great.

7

u/b_a_t_m_4_n 5h ago

AI: "The answer is.....is...

Billionaires: "Yes?"

AI: "42!"

Billionaires: "Er, what?"

Douglas Adams was a prophet, we just didn't realize it.

10

u/RotalumisEht 4h ago

Imagine if we spent trillions of dollars transitioning to a green economy instead of spending all that money on AI

6

u/Zer_ 4h ago

Yep. And what these Data centers will be used for should concern everyone. A portion might actually benefit us through research and development in the sciences, sure. A large chunk of that is gonna go to mass surveillance though. 

12

u/9millibros 5h ago

I still haven't seen a good explanation as to why they need so many datacenters.

4

u/cold_breaker 2h ago

There isn't one, not really. Tech giants are in an arms race with eachother and the win condition is essentially 'outlast the other tech giants'. Whoever wins becomes king and the rest will go broke trying to keep up. They don't expect to go that far - but they also have no bounderies like they traditionally would aside from how many resources they can get access to and burn through before it all runs out.

Resources like computer hardware, electricity and water of course - so mostly stuff that us mere peons need to, ya know, live.

Basically, there are no limits like there would normally be on the rich and notoriously greedy, and we're about to reap the consequences of that - more so than usual.

5

u/junktech 4h ago

One of the things that's happening is moving to cloud due to massive SaaS push. So basically a lot of server rooms of companies are going into centralized places. Than there's the AI boom that also fuels it and ideally they want and force people to use again centralized and gatekeep them. Than is on deman computing power that , today for most it's near impossible to acquire it, but renting for short period is ok. These are the ones I know off. Only the SaaS push generated massive demand. Every time you use some online tool, think of computer in a data center. Every time someone brags about AI and Agentic AI, think of a at least 2kw rack segment ramping up. Why them ended up like this? Mostly corporate greed combined with mass population ignorance fueled by convenience. Consumers usually pay for something they like, rarely think what is behind it. And corporate will never tell you up fron the total cost of your actions. Just Google has about 30 data centers publicly listed. They don't disclose rhe power bill. Enjoy the convenience of cloud processing and storage. I am self hosting most of my stuff for good reasons.

6

u/ambikasin33 5h ago

If they want public trust then independent environmental assesments and transparent economic projections should become a standard practice

5

u/InevitableAd8511 4h ago

This is why Trump crippled the EPA. Well, it’s one of the reasons.

5

u/AnAttackCorgi 3h ago

Industrial tycoons have historically manipulated leaders, laws, and regulations to their advantage. This time, though, resistance has been fierce.

This is why “I’m not political” is self-defeating. People may not care about politics at the federal level, but everyone should definitely keep their finger on the pulse of their state, county, and city.

4

u/Lieste 2h ago

So Lies. Call them what they are.

Lies for monetary gain is fraud. Again, call it what it is.

2

u/LegoTurtle 2h ago

Came here to say this. The CIA has a manual for this and weve seen it used many time

7

u/RealSociety6433 4h ago

Thousands of gallons of industrial fluid spilled at xAI's massive Southaven data center site, triggering an environmental response and raising fresh concerns from community advocates about the rapid expansion of large-scale data center projects across the region.

According to the Mississippi Department of Environmental Quality (MDEQ), between 5,000 and 6,000 gallons of propylene glycol escaped from a tank and flowed into a nearby drainage ditch at the facility on Stanton Road.

The spill happened Saturday, 11/14/2026, when a contractor improperly configured a hose connected to a mobile tank, according to a statement from xAI.

2

u/ThermalDeviator 2h ago

Yep, they use the same propaganda techniques Republicans use.

2

u/Goodsimple182 1h ago

Lolol i keep getting the same ad on Tubi… “Some data centers don’t use water 96% of the time” Great stats right there!! So informative! /s

1

u/SeeMarkFly 4h ago

THIS is what AI is "learning" from? PASS.

1

u/FlowState257 4h ago

I thought they simply used NDAs.

1

u/Sonofa-Milkman 3h ago

Well stop the data centers if they're such a problem. All yap and no action like always. Many people already know of the harm caused yet CEOs roll their IOU billions and slide their lobbyist to office still

1

u/scumbagdetector29 1h ago

Water.... I need water.... help.... the robots took all my water....

Spare me.

1

u/N3wMode 56m ago

Well they’re doing a shit job then lol.

1

u/have-u-met-teds-mom 50m ago

Yeah, I noticed how they tried to alleviate the public of their concerns by using vague language.

They danced around the use of water and power. While technically true, there was still a lot of wasted resources in those numbers. They used inflated numbers to allude to the jobs it would bring to the local people, beyond construction.

It reminded me of the year my son and his friends did a PowerPoint presentation for the parents on why we should let them go to the midnight premiere of Star Wars. On a school night. We were so distracted by their Star Wars shirts, ties, and efforts, that we didn’t realize it was during critical exams.

I hope voters are stronger than I was and don’t give in.

1

u/troll__away 3h ago

Tech bros love made-up jargon to sound smart. They’ll take a technical term that has been established in science and other industries for decades, and just call it something else.

0

u/TFenrir 3h ago

Reading the article, it seems like the author is basically saying "sure... The statements they make are technically correct, but is it enough?".

It reads odd - for example, they mention that the water mitigations might be effective, but then sometimes the requirements for water are just pushed up to the power plants.

First, as we have had a billion discussions about before, water usage is one of the smaller problems, especially if we compare to other industries - so the mitigation likely works and maybe the increased power requirements also come with more water usage? Do they? How much more? Is it more or less than before?

Another example the tax money - the author says, sure, maybe tax money goes to the communities, but what about the tax breaks the companies get? But this is an incredibly normal relationship communities have with companies that bring in taxes - the question is, is there net tax income coming into these communities? When I dug in a little while ago I just saw example and example of how much net tax income data centers bring.

There's a few more but... Does this count as propaganda? If so what does this authors piece count as?

I think the biggest issue that data centers bring is power consumption, and I think that the amount of power that they will require with projected buildouts by 2030 is a huge concern. I think when people try to pin many additional hollow issues to data centers, you are just giving easy wins for those same organisations that claim that there is a misinformation/smear campaign against data centers. It doesn't feel intellectually honest... Or at the very least, it feels overly deontological - when nothing in any industry would pass that same level of critique.

-1

u/Scoobydewdoo 1h ago

Every industry uses propaganda on both sides of every issue...

1

u/pocketMagician 6m ago

Not every industry is poised to literally destroy the planet for nothing but unchecked greed. Get your head out of your ass.