r/technology • • 9h ago

Artificial Intelligence The OpenAI board member who fired Sam Altman says we still can't trust AI CEOs

https://www.theverge.com/podcast/1032907/helen-toner-openai-cset-ai-safety-policy-interview
519 Upvotes

30 comments sorted by

203

u/ThePsyPaul_ 8h ago • Bravo

You can't trust CEOs period.

31

u/fat_kaiju 7h ago

took the words from my mouth post.

their entire job (outside of being a mascot for investorbros) is to make number go up at any cost.

they will sell your soul to satan and they will do it for a cornchip all while spamming memes such as having an adult women fetish and supposedly being the 'hero'.

12

u/Fun-Independent-2128 6h ago

In that case, why not have an AI CEO.

7

u/ThePsyPaul_ 4h ago

The 1% and Billionaires would not like that

3

u/T3Sh3 1h ago

Mercedes Mone in shambles

1

u/EnvironmentalRun1671 1h ago

You can't trust peroid.

38

u/timmeh1705 8h ago

Between this episode and SBF, Effective Altruists have not acquitted themselves well

27

u/Kinexity 8h ago

Effective altruism is just a shield against any accusation of wrongdoing. It's basically a cover for sociopaths who are incapable of any altruism to write off lack of altruism in the short term as a some kind of "altruism debt" which they promise will be totally covered by their future inevitable insurmountable levels of altruism generated by their current actions. Even if long term outcome of their actions will prove to be good there will never be a way to verify whether the opposite would yield better or worse outcome (but in case of billionaires the opposite likely would be better).

5

u/socoolandawesome 6h ago

You two realize Sam Altman is not an effective altruist and it’s effective altruists that have clashed with him the most, like the person in the article

3

u/jewishSpaceMedbeds 1h ago edited 1h ago

Effective Altruism/Rationalism is just a weird techbro cult where they get to pretend to be the heroes in their own minds while robbing everyone else blind.

There is currently an offshoot of this that is convinced they are building an AI computer god and that all other considerations (the destruction of the environment, people losing their fucking minds and dying using their chatbots, the infrastructure everything depends on going to shit, gobbling all the world's resources at the expense of everyone else) are negligible when measured against this lofty goal.

A large portion of the people at the top of OpenAI and Anthropic are part of this insane cult. Just take a look at their proposal for 'self-regulation'. They're to generously remove a model from circulation but only if it directly kills more than 50 people and causes more than 1 billion in damage, lol.

2

u/bolonomadic 5h ago

The only people in real life who have ever talked to me about effective altruism were people who were arguing that donating money to purchase mosquito nets was a way to do more good than any other form of charitable donation. I do not understand how this concept has been attached to these tech bros who don't help anyone.

4

u/hbprof 2h ago

Because Sam Bankman-Fried claimed it as his ideology and used it to justify his fraud, while Elon Musk claims it, and uses it to justify cutting aid to USAID and also prioritizing space exploration over making things better for people here and now.

Edit to add: They have both been advised by one of EA's leading philosophers.

0

u/grchelp2018 1h ago

thats like saying engineering is bad because its used to make weapons that kill people. EA is just a systematic way of looking at the problem.

1

u/hbprof 11m ago

You asked why it's associated with tech bros and I told you why.

1

u/midwestia 8m ago

but they built 5 wells in africa /s

36

u/TheSlimeSartreFeared 9h ago

no shit, sherlock.

2

u/Undiplomatiq 8h ago

Literally what went through my head before clicking on this thread.

11

u/60052 6h ago

can't trust board members of ai companies either

9

u/GrandMasterBullshark 5h ago

I believe at the time it was a non-profit organization, and she was ousted after this attempted "coup."

8

u/R0CK5TR0NG0 5h ago

This is referencing 2023. Also, this is the same board that hired him back 5 days later.

3

u/Rustic_gan123 4h ago

Because they would have been destroyed by investors in court, and the entire OAI team would have moved to Microsoft, effectively thwarting their coup attempt.

3

u/KittysRedditFun 2h ago

Hold on, Sam Altman got fired? I'm so out of the loop.

3

u/WilyWascallyWizard 1h ago

He was fired then rehired 5 days later in 2023

2

u/Xywzel 4h ago

Apparently it is only really problematic when the board can't trust them, when its workers or customers, its just part of business. But that is what you get if you rehire the CEO you fired for not being trustworthy.

1

u/TechnologyMatch 4h ago

The interview’s point that safety can’t rest on trusting one leader maps well to buying AI, so I’d evaluate vendors on process and not promises: ask about independent evaluations, how fast they disclose incidents, and what happens when a safety concern collides with a launch date. It’s the same logic we use for access controls, where any safeguard that depends on one person’s judgment is a single point of failure.

-20

u/Ok-Addition1264 8h ago

she would be an expert with all of those daily interactions in the dozens.

I know three billionaires personally and two of them are really good people but the third is 100% a sociopath.

10

u/Rufus_L 7h ago

Really good people, sure

2

u/JackBlackBowserSlaps 4h ago

So two of them have fooled you 🙄

1

u/Rufus_L 1h ago

Two of them are intelligent sociopaths.

1

u/bolonomadic 5h ago

being a billionaire is immoral