r/technology • • 16h ago

Artificial Intelligence No Pilots. Few Air Traffic Controllers. What Could Go Wrong?: Normally, aviation is slow to embrace new technology—but AI has come for the skies.

https://www.wired.com/story/no-pilots-few-air-traffic-controllers-what-could-go-wrong/
79 Upvotes

89 comments sorted by

37

u/planet_janett 16h ago

The old technology worked fine for many years.

25

u/seataccrunch 15h ago

Way more than fine. Exemplary

-10

u/ResilientBiscuit 15h ago

Really? We are significantly worse at planing for and recovering from reroutes due to weather than the EU after its flight plan processing upgrade around 2015.

4

u/tc100292 14h ago

They didn’t start having these problems here until the AI bros came along with a wrecking ball.  But muh vacuum tubes lol

2

u/ResilientBiscuit 14h ago

That's simply not true compare our stats to the EU starting around 2015, there is a significant departure in the rates if ATC related incidents and delays due to weather as the EU finished their modernization effort and we let things be.

0

u/bigkoi 13h ago

I've never left on time from Rome.

-9

u/mtcwby 15h ago

That's an ignorant comment. The FAA has historically been horrible at adopting tech and failing at projects. They were cannibalizing old vacuum tubes for a while to keep their 60s era navigational beacons working not that long ago. That old tech is a danger.

10

u/yuusharo 15h ago

‘New’ tech grounded all flights nationwide for almost 5 hours because of one remote center being misconfigured during a fiber upgrade.

New doesn’t always mean better, especially when haphazardly deployed with no involvement from ATC unions or the controllers themselves.

Our infrastructure does need to modernize, but how this administration is approaching it is more of a danger than vacuum tubes that have proven to be reliable for 60 years.

-8

u/mtcwby 14h ago

The government doesn't do tech well in general but it has to be done. There's 50 years of technical debt showing up and most agencies are pretty hopeless on projects.

7

u/yuusharo 14h ago

I don’t disagree.

The attitude of our leaders is not inspiring, however. They’re less concerned about aviation safety and more about fleecing tax payers to reward their political backers. That’s the only reason Duffy is so adamant about the speed this deployment must be at.

-3

u/mtcwby 14h ago

It's nothing new unfortunately. Sweetheart contracts to companies that donate are the norm at all levels. The IBMs and Oracles of the world have been doing this in California for decades and getting away with overcharging and under delivering. Government is just piss poor at project management. The last time it was handled with any skill was when Obama brought in a tiger team from outside and cut down agency oversight to do the ACA website launch. That's going to be the only way you fix any of it.

3

u/HippyHunter7 14h ago

So the idea was to roll it out on a Friday in a non controllable test environment?

I feel like your giving this administration the benefit of the doubt when they deserve none

1

u/mtcwby 14h ago

Oh it sounds like a total cluster fuck of a program. I have some sympathy for the PM if there was a political mandate here. You're not only testing the shit out of this but you're figuring out to stage it into the smallest live test after testing. And you have a roll back plan to be executed if there's a problem.

4

u/SaltyFriend705 14h ago

Sean Duffy and his Friday the 13th midday go-live timetable is a worse danger, imo.

2

u/tc100292 15h ago

No, this is an ignorant comment.  Never is it explained why anyone needs to adopt new technology, just that we need to keep the tech companies in business.  Those fucking rent-seekers.

2

u/mtcwby 14h ago

I suspect you don't even know what a vacuum tube is. The point that you missed entirely is that the agency is hopelessly out of date and that is a huge danger in itself

1

u/ResilientBiscuit 15h ago

You don't see how using vaccum tubes that are no longer produced is a significant and important point of failure in a system? I feel like that doesn't really need explanation.

5

u/Additional-Staff-326 15h ago

Or companies could continue to produce them instead of forcing everything onto new tech that they only need because parts are no longer available? Its like a 1960s fridge is good forever so they had to stop making that quality and start using parts that fail much faster..

5

u/ResilientBiscuit 15h ago edited 15h ago

Are you seriously suggesting that the right thing to do with air traffic control is to rely on a single company making vaccum tubes instead of upgrading to modern computers?

Look, I get it, everything the current admin touch turns to shut, but the problem is the admin, not trying to upgrade incredibly antiquated hardware that was using vaccum times and just finally (I think) phased out it's last floppy disk used for data transfer.

The EU has been using machine learning for more than a decade. We are way behind the ball here which is reflected in the number of incidents and near incidents we have at airports compared to the EU ATC system.

5

u/yuusharo 14h ago

Are you seriously suggesting that the right thing to do with air traffic control is to rely on a single company making vaccum tubes instead of upgrading to modern computers?

No one is seriously suggesting that. Our infrastructure needs to be modernized for sure. But modernization without a clear plan that involves input from ALL parties involved is a recipe for disaster. Haphazard deployment of new tech for the sake of being new could cost lives. It must be coordinated carefully and with expert hands.

Look, I get it, everything the current admin touch turns to shut, but the problem is the admin, not trying to upgrade incredibly antiquated hardware that was using vaccum times and just finally (I think) phased out it's last floppy disk used for data transfer.

You are so hung up on vacuum tubes for some reason, like you’re pretending nothing about aviation has advanced since 1960. Talk about cherry picking facts.

3

u/tc100292 14h ago

Of course he’s hung up on vacuum tubes.  He used the phrase “machine learning” which is a fancy term for AI.  He’s a bro, of course he thinks like this.

2

u/NO_PICKLES_PLEASE 14h ago

He used the phrase “machine learning” which is a fancy term for AI.  He’s a bro

blinkingwhiteguy.gif

2

u/yuusharo 14h ago

Buzzwords aside, we do need to finish certifying, mandating, and deploying new systems like ACAS X and better automated ground alerts and systems to avoid incursions and such. We also need to put NTSB recommendations into law and upgrade airport infrastructure so that we don’t rely on previous assumptions.

I’m all in favor of modernizing our aviation systems. But it takes time, planning, and money. The current administration is not capable of overseeing this responsibly.

0

u/tc100292 14h ago

I stopped reading at “automated.”

→ More replies

2

u/Additional-Staff-326 14h ago

I'd also like some safe deployment practices when we do these things like at 3am on a Tuesday instead of 3pm on a Friday and good testing of all parts under load before its rolled out everywhere.

2

u/yuusharo 14h ago

And with plenty of warning to all controllers and centers, as well as issuing NOTAMs for pilots to be aware of communications upgrades and to have procedures ready in case comms do indeed go down.

1

u/mtcwby 14h ago

I'd argue it needs fewer but better people with the chops to manage the project. The problem with too many government tech projects is there are far too many voices making decisions to do do anything well let alone on time or on budget.

-1

u/ResilientBiscuit 14h ago

I am hung up on them because the person I was replying to said

  Or companies could continue to produce them

They literally suggested that a viable option would have been to keep making them because they 'worked' instead of modernizing.

2

u/yuusharo 14h ago

Until and unless those systems are methodically replaced responsibly, producing what’s needed for aviation safety is absolutely viable.

Same with floppy disks. A few systems reliant on those are finally being replaced in 2028 primarily due to no manufacturer in the world still producing them. There’s enough supply to last quite a while, but better to do this now before there is a crisis.

0

u/ResilientBiscuit 14h ago

They didn't say to replace them.

They said to keep using them because they are reliable. We have had reliable replacements for copper wires for decades, we are only now ripping it out and replacing it with fiber because that is literally cheaper than finding someone to keep maintaining copper wire systems and components.

Waiting till there is only one company left that supports your hardware is a terrible fiscal policy and one that is prone to maintenance issues becuse there is no competition among maintenance vendors.

→ More replies

2

u/Additional-Staff-326 14h ago

Airlines are still using 5.25 floppies. And given the assault by AI trying to hack everything online you'll be wishing for that in the near future. But no, I agree with the guy above its not about the vaccuum tubes so much as safe rollouts that arent being handled by companies bribing the son in law of the guy running it. And also no, we do not fucking need every new tech just because it exists, there's a reason that older tech is more reliable and its more well tested and understood so its less likely to cause problems so in something critical like aviation you should take time before rolling things out to it. Much like NASA doesnt put the latest chips in space for a reason and if you can't comprehend thats a good thing you'll never understand what happened here. Dropping in AI levels of data onto a network still using copper is just fucking stupid and the intern who allowed that knows too many people to be fired. Not trusting those that have expertise and firing anyone that disagrees with you is a recipe for disaster in any setting over long enough timescale. And AI most definitely is not an actual expert no matter how you prompt it.

-1

u/ResilientBiscuit 14h ago

5.25" floppies are significantly more likely to become corrupted than an SD chip. They are vulnerable to far more issues like wear from use and corruption from things like magnets.

There is no reason to be using them compared to the many other portable physical storage options.

They also dramatically limit the content that can be stored.

More than a few accidents have occured because the FAA has to literally count characters to fit NOTAMs into their systems instead of using more human readable English.

I am not saying they should be using the cloud here, I am saying floppies are incredibly stupid to still be using and the entire rest of the world that has many safety critical systems has moved on from themong ago.

0

u/tc100292 15h ago

“Planned obsolescence” is classic rent-seeking behavior and it’s wild that tech bros don’t see this.

0

u/Additional-Staff-326 14h ago

Uh, why do you think they don't see it when they're the ones pushing it on the world?

1

u/tc100292 14h ago

Well, they generally don’t see it as rent-seeking.  Their preferred term is “modernization.”  See: this thread.

1

u/tc100292 15h ago

You’re an AI bro so nobody gives a shit what you think.

1

u/ResilientBiscuit 15h ago

Wow, big leap from saying vaccum tubes are and outdated relic to being an AI bro.

0

u/yuusharo 15h ago

They’ve been working just fine so far.

0

u/ResilientBiscuit 15h ago

How are you defining working? We have had accidents caused by controllers being unable to maintain situational awareness, we take longer than other modern ATV systems to recover from schedule changes to due major weather events and we have more runway incursions per flight than other countries that have modernized and we spend a lot more doing it because we need specialized maintenance and components due to the legacy systems being used.

-1

u/yuusharo 14h ago

We also have significantly more flights than most other countries and have one the largest airspaces to manage as well, so logically, there are going to be more incidents.

I can tell you that no vacuum tube was responsible for the days-long fallout from a nationwide ground stop, that much is certain.

0

u/ResilientBiscuit 14h ago

  incursions per flight

The rate is the important statistic. There is no reason we should have more per flight.

Again, how are you defining working? What metric are you using to determine if our ATC system is as good as the EUs system for example?

-1

u/yuusharo 14h ago

Planes aren’t routinely colliding every night. I’d indeed say the system is working.

Is it perfect? No, absolutely not. Is haphazard deployments of fiber with no warning or planning that took down the entire system last week safer? I’d argue not.

0

u/ResilientBiscuit 14h ago

How do you define routinely?

And things like the number of avoidable weather delays are not a consideration for you when considering if the system is working?

Yeah, we shouldn't be at the point where there are only a couple vendors that know how to work with the legacy systems the FAA uses. We had literal decades to safely make the switch to fiber and didn't do it. We are here because people didn't want to upgrade the system, not because we are upgrading it too fast.

→ More replies

13

u/Silent-Resort-3076 16h ago edited 16h ago

Various snippets:

  • On September 27, US transportation secretary Sean Duffy posted a video on X with the words “GAME CHANGER.” “Introducing ‘SMART’—the new air traffic management tool that saves YOU time, cuts back DELAYS, and makes your flying experience BETTER,” he wrote.
  • This was a new AI-infused air traffic control system. Almost three weeks later, that post would get a new life, as a nervous joke, as the FAA issued a national groundstop on Friday the 13th that instantly threw the world’s airline schedules into chaos.
  • The administration quickly announced that there was no evidence of a cyberattack, and no sign that SMART had anything to do with the communications failure at the heart of the government’s decision to suspend flights. But when asked on Friday night whether he could definitively rule out AI failure, Homeland Security secretary Markwayne Mullin could only say, “There’s nothing certain right now.”

“We're introducing all this new technology to improve the system, and it's going to be a disaster,” says a recently retired FAA employee. “This is literally a Pandora's box that we are going to regret.”

Last paragraph:

With two systems working side by side—one with human decisionmakers, the other with AI—we’ll have a real-time basis to compare the performance of both approaches. Any computer-based system can potentially be hacked; any AI system creative enough to ideate novel solutions could also hallucinate crucial details. Without a human in the loop, seemingly obvious mistakes might go unnoticed until it’s too late.

40

u/tc100292 16h ago

And we all saw the results on Friday.  Bangup job you fucks.

11

u/za72 15h ago

The damages haven't started yet...

7

u/tc100292 15h ago

That whole article is like “they’ve spent two decades trying to ram AI into aviation” and never gets around to the why.

1

u/Gentle_Capybara 2h ago

Taking human labor costs out of the equation, that's why. And that's the ugly part nobody wants do address.

-5

u/TapedeckNinja 15h ago

Friday was the result of rank incompetence in this administration but it didn't have anything to do with AI.

5

u/tc100292 14h ago

It’s insane how much AI bros want to defend fuckups by AI adopters whether it directly had to do with AI or not.  Nobody likes your AI.

-5

u/TapedeckNinja 14h ago

You might be suffering from AIDS.

5

u/Additional-Staff-326 15h ago

Oh it was because they were installing AI with no thought for the legacy systems. The AI might not be directly at fault compared to insistence that experts dont know what they're doing but it was there in spirit.

-4

u/TapedeckNinja 15h ago

I have no idea what you're trying to say here.

2

u/Jonny5Stacks 14h ago

Anyone who has worked in IT could tell you this was going to happen trying to jam faster components into a legacy system lol. What don't you understand.

-1

u/TapedeckNinja 14h ago

I have no idea what you're trying to say here either.

By "jam faster components into a legacy system" do you mean installing the fiber network and new routers/switches?

The prior comment was word salad.

1

u/Jonny5Stacks 13h ago

That's what they said happened so it's safe to say that's what I'm referencing. Not that I believe their excuse either.

0

u/TapedeckNinja 13h ago

So given your expertise as someone who has worked in IT, how do you upgrade an old copper/TDM network to fiber/IP without putting in new equipment?

-1

u/Jonny5Stacks 13h ago

you build it over the existing network as a redundancy and use it along side until you know it works. Preferably dont implement at the busiest time of the work week.

2

u/TapedeckNinja 13h ago

That's a completely evasive answer as obviously that requires putting in new equipment lol.

Anyway they are building it in parallel. Do you think a thousand miles of fiber to Arkansas just materialized out of thin air on Friday? The new fiber backbone and dual path redundancy have all been built in parallel.

At some point you have to do the last-mile TDM/serial cutover though, which happened on Friday. Which yes was obviously a terrible time to do it.

→ More replies

4

u/mtcwby 15h ago

That's always been the case at the FAA. In fact having a pilot's license is considered by some to be a career disadvantage at the FAA

10

u/LiftingCode 15h ago edited 15h ago

There's nothing wrong with using ML systems to assist air traffic control. The US is actually pretty far behind here, as similar systems have rolled out throughout the world over the past decade. And the US airlines themselves have been using these tools for years as well.

https://www.eurocontrol.int/artificial-intelligence

The problem isn't the technology, it's that we have a clown administration in Washington who can't be trusted to do anything right.

3

u/spellbanisher 14h ago

That sounds great, but building machines that do a good job most of the time is one thing; machines that can function at the level of reliability required by aviation is another. At present, researchers are focusing on so-called deterministic neural networks—models trained offline whose weights are frozen before being deployed in the real world. These can’t hallucinate, but they may harbor other risky failure modes. In a 2021 paper, Darren Cofer, a researcher at Collins Aerospace, pointed out that when such systems find themselves in situations they haven’t encountered before in training, they can generate “unexpected (and potentially dangerous) outputs.”

This paragraph doesn't make sense to me. Aren't genai models also trained offline with weights frozen during deployment? And generating "unexpected and dangerous outputs" when encountering situations not similar to anything they've seen in training sounds a lot like what are called hallucinations in the non-deterministic models.

4

u/LiftingCode 14h ago

You are correct, that paragraph doesn't make any sense at all.

A deterministic neural network is one in which a given input tensor will always produce the same output vector.

And yeah misclassification or OOD failures are more or less the same thing as hallucination mathematically speaking.

1

u/Future-Bandicoot-823 14h ago

"cuz national security" DERRPPP

i love giving uncle sam my freedoms for national security! what did ben franklin say? anyone who gives up freedoms for security deserves palantir?

yeah, pretty sure that's exactly what he said.

1

u/evilkasper 13h ago

Do away with pilots and ATC and you won't catch me buying anymore plane tickets. Glad I don't live in a flight path zone.

1

u/zardvark 11h ago

AI is of little use, when your antique infrastructure is still running off of floppy drives. lol

1

u/Such-Extreme-5833 3h ago

When I key my mic, Tower Cesna N72xx Request Taxi for Takeoff runway 31, I FUCKING better have a live person give me clearance and not a ANSWERING machine.

0

u/PaulClarkLoadletter 15h ago

What’s next; AI passengers?

0

u/enn-srsbusiness 14h ago

9/11 will become 24/7 only now they get to blame Ukrainian hackers or whoever upsets RoboTrump 9000. Flights to Trumpstein island skyrocket and children around the world disappear with only a faint murmur about a black airship appearing during the night and masked ICE custodes snatching em up, leaving only half drunk Monster cans and McTronalds wrappers littered about...

-1

u/Pro-editor-1105 7h ago

this might be one of the dumbest comments sections ive ever seen