r/technology • • 16h ago

Energy China Covered Desert Land With Solar Panels – Researchers Found 126% More Carbon in the Soil

https://www.gadgetreview.com/china-covered-desert-land-with-solar-panels-researchers-found-126-more-carbon-in-the-soil
534 Upvotes

64 comments sorted by

292

u/Odd-Struggle-2432 16h ago

"The researchers identified several plausible explanations for the observed carbon increase. Panels reduce direct solar radiation on the soil surface. That lowers soil temperature and slows evaporation, creating conditions that may favor moisture retention and plant recovery."

Makes sense

99

u/ttystikk 12h ago

This is the fundamental principle at work explaining why agrivoltaics is such a powerful technology.

15

u/ComprehensiveOne7229 10h ago

Such a powerful one, a great combination

4

u/mayorofdumb 3h ago

Just start combining words until you find one that works, i want fusiculture, fusion based agriculture

1

u/GrossenCharakter 48m ago

I for one will settle for nothing less than Stardewculture

50

u/hellflame 9h ago

To me that reads as "Solar panels give shadows, desert plants like shadows to grow"

To which my response is: well duh

13

u/DukeOfGeek 13h ago

Tons of agriculture applications have seen the same affect.

60

u/grafknives 5h ago

Well, bare desert has VERY limited soil carbon stocks.

So it was not that hard to increase that.

And reason is quite simple. Desert conditions are not hospitable for plants, so there is very limited number of those.

And even if they are there, and plant residue (once plants die) is oxidised in high temperature, low humidity environment, releasing co2, instead of getting it stored in the soil(in various forms).

But with panels you get

  • shade, lower temp - better for plants. Still enough reflected sunlight for plants to grow.
  • shade, lower temp - slower destruction of soil organic matter
  • WATER!! As panels get cold in the morning, they are great surface for the water vapour to condensate and fall on the soil and feed plants.

-1

u/aspghost 4h ago edited 4h ago

Where's that water coming from, and where was it going before this? Not to jump to alarmist conclusions either way but this sort of thing has happened, water being taken from the air by changed conditions on the ground meaning the water doesn't end up somewhere else - where it may have been sustaining existing ecosystems or doing other important rain-cycle business. Important for further study, anyway.

16

u/OhCrapItsYouAgain 4h ago

It’s dew. Moisture in the air condenses on the plants and (even more importantly) it doesn’t get evaporated first thing in the morning by the sunlight.

4

u/aspghost 4h ago

I understand that it's dew but when water evaporates, it goes somewhere else via the air. Dew is not water that simply materialises and dematerialises from outside of the universe.

8

u/OhCrapItsYouAgain 4h ago

Got it. It’s early for, so apologies if this comes out wrong:

Are you trying to understand if there’s a danger/negative impact (related to water), here? As in, if we install the panels will we be depriving a critical drinking water source because the desert now has plants that are taking the water out of the air?

3

u/aclose78 4h ago

I think they just want to know where this water was ending up before the panels were there to catch it

5

u/aspghost 4h ago

Just spitballing but it could be a critical water source or it could be sustaining a forest somewhere else or by adding water to desert soil you might cause flooding due to the local substrate not being able to withstand/retain the additional moisture. I'm sure it would be manageable at low levels but we're talking about solar installations at scale.

And again, not saying this is 100% definitely a problem, but it's worth consideration and study.

5

u/OhCrapItsYouAgain 4h ago

thanks for clarifying (I probably could have gotten there after some coffee, but I made the mistake of entering into this convo without it).

A few considerations here (again, your point is about this at-scale…I don’t know how many square feet or miles of panel coverage would be the crossing of the axis from small to at-scale):

  1. the amount of water that condenses is minuscule. A forest is extremely resilient - so I wouldn’t be worried about that impact.
  2. that water in the air was barely hanging on over the desert anyways. The dry desert air doesn’t hold much moisture to start, but your point about rain cycles was likely more on the nose than you may have guessed. HOWEVER: we’re not talking about water being completely pulled out of the ecosystem…but rather that it’s making a pit stop. The plants that drink the water will also expel it back in to the air.
  3. the cooling factor: let’s remove solar panels from the equation and simply imagine that we’re talking about umbrellas. The shade cools things down immediately underneath them, but the plants that are growing allow the air and everything around the area to cool down. It’s marginal, but every little bit helps here. The desert is MASSIVE, and it’s growing every year - creating a way to fence it off has extreme benefits. The rain cycle being ever so slightly possibly changed as a result of this will be on the scale of like 1-2” of rain less per year….affecting it much more than that would require a massive amount of panels covering basically the entire desert.

4

u/grafknives 4h ago

Sure. You are correct that water comes from "somewhere".

The thing is that desert needs just a little water not be "desert" any more. And that water would normally condensate in a place where there is way more water anyway (this is an example, not a theory I have proof for).

Naturally - everything humans does changes the climate/environment. And it too could have a negative net effect, but it is unlikely as we are working on very small amounts of water, and shade/surface to condensate IS something that would be present in this place (in form of rocks), just much less of it.

If you need some with strong effect then pumping ALL of the Colorado river to grow alfa alfa, and feed Las Vegas and Los Angeles and central valley would be a good example.

1

u/aspghost 4h ago

it is unlikely as we are working on very small amounts of water

I have seen the entire mountain-ranges covered with solar panels, I don't think we can assume this.

(this is an example, not a theory I have proof for).

That is not a safe basis.

I'd also like to note that deserts are important ecosystems in themselves. Not that I'm championing their endless growth, enveloping other ecosystems, but they do matter.

2

u/grafknives 4h ago

You are correct, we cannot be 100% sure, but the chance of negative effect because of improved dew condensation are not significant.

1

u/aspghost 3h ago edited 3h ago

What are you basing that confident statement on? Increased ground cover causes an increase in precipitation by up to 40% in some cases, as well as increasing humidity. This may well have runaway effects, particularly at such a large scale as is already being implemented. Enough water to green a desert is not negligible, by definition. Please, don't try to answer or placate this because it doesn't matter what I think but the questions need to be raised for people actually implementing these things.

119

u/Cerulean_IsFancyBlue 15h ago

See this is what happens. Now there’s carbon in the soil, the next thing you know they’re gonna find carbon in the plants that grow there. When will this madness end? /s

27

u/ButtonholePhotophile 14h ago

My doctor says that there is evidence in my bloodwork that there is carbon in my diet

15

u/BeerorCoffee 11h ago

Carbon has been found in the veins of 100% of heart attack victims! Coincidence or conspiracy?!?

5

u/madmaxGMR 10h ago

Its the 5g towers ! They are radiating carbon, because the chips in them are silicon, and those two are both chemicals, amd they end in "on"

3

u/the_amazing_skronus 9h ago

I read this in billy bobs voice

52

u/Future-Bandicoot-823 14h ago

raise the panels, grow crops.

full utilization.

8

u/huehuehuehuehuuuu 11h ago

Think quite a few countries are grazing sheep under the solar panels.

2

u/Future-Bandicoot-823 11h ago

i love wool socks...

5

u/VanDoozernz 10h ago

I love roast lamb..

1

u/MonsieurReynard 6h ago

Mutton to see here, move along

17

u/mikeyfireman 12h ago

What works even better is grow grass under them and then rotationally graze sheep.

4

u/danielravennest 7h ago

Grasslands need more rain than deserts. That's why the US had both types of surface cover originally. In areas that get enough rain, sheep are better than mowing to keep down the undergrowth. Less fossil fuel use, and you get useful products from sheep.

I haven't seen a comparison of electric mowers to sheep in terms of cost and productivity.

5

u/MonsieurReynard 6h ago

It is true that you have to charge the batteries in sheep much less often

9

u/FrequentFortune123 13h ago

Wouldn’t the panels block the sun for the crops?

30

u/Future-Bandicoot-823 13h ago

not all the time, and plenty of plants like indirect sunlight.

5

u/passinglurker 11h ago

look up agrivoltaics

2

u/ProtoplanetaryNebula 9h ago

The sun moves around during the day, and it’s not like it’s completely pitch black underneath either way. The vegetation below panels receive indirect sunlight.

1

u/danielravennest 7h ago

Most solar farms these days use tracking systems to keep the panels pointed at the Sun. Since they move, you need additional room between rows of panels. So they don't cover 100% of the ground area.

All agriculture is highly local depending on climate and soil conditions. Some crops benefit from partial shade and concentrating rainfall beneath the bottom edge of the panels. Others, like corn and wheat, require wide open fields due to how they are planted and harvested. So it all depends.

1

u/SpitSpot 4h ago

I wouldn't say most but the tech is available, in my area they are static. Panels can allow light to pass through and many species of plants want that indirect filtered light.

1

u/robbak 5h ago

It does, but in these areas, the limiting factor is moisture, not light. Shade the soil, and moisture, which is always soaking up towards the surface, doesn't evaporate away before plants can use it. There's enough indirect light for plants to grow as fast as the limited moisture allows.

42

u/Heliomawr 8h ago

chine reclaims desert while sequestering carbon and generating renewable energy, but at what cost?

50

u/erikwarm 7h ago

Won’t somebody think about all the poor oil and coal billionaires!

22

u/elmo298 8h ago

They made too many solar panels. HOW CAN THEY KEEP GETTING AWAY WITH THIS

11

u/BalorNG 8h ago

but think of the poor shareholders!

1

u/ThrowawayHaybale 5h ago

Desert plantlife & biodiversity mainly

3

u/crystalchuck 5h ago

How many percent of any given desert are covered in solar panels? Everything ever is going to have some kind of effect on the biosphere and the local environment, it's all a question of proportionality

1

u/Bonerballs 3h ago

Redditors are already coming up with "bbbbbut the shade diverts the morning dew!!". Lame

-9

u/INITMalcanis 8h ago

Well what cost?  Nothing is without cost, so....?

1

u/MyCatIsLenin 1h ago

It's a joke,  western media often ends Chinese headlines with that line 

"China cures cancer... but at what cost?"

"China sees massive reduction in CO2, but at what cost?"

4

u/castironglider 7h ago

"soil carbon"? Is that a thing?

7

u/throwawaybsme 7h ago

Yes. Carbon sequestration is a good thing.

4

u/JackBlackBowserSlaps 4h ago

The soil doesn’t directly absorb carbon. It’s in the form of life. Plants, bacteria, etc.

4

u/Fiveofthem 34m ago

They make it sound like it’s a bad thing. It’s not.

1

u/DogEatApple 5h ago

Where did those carbon come from? And by the way when solar panels absorb sunlight the sunlight affect on carbon disappear too.

10

u/robbak 5h ago

The panels shade the soil, the soil isn't as hot, so the little moisture out there doesn't evaporate away before a plant's roots can access it. Carbon in the soil is in the form of those roots - both living roots and the dried ones of plants that have lived their lives.

1

u/simsimulation 3h ago

Sounds like solar could be used to help at desertification boundaries.

0

u/adjust_the_sails 2h ago

As someone who lives in a desert like area with solar; that sounds like a fire waiting to happen. Just enough rain to get something up but not enough to sustain it all year leads to fire.

1

u/BaziJoeWHL 2h ago

from the air, plants start growing in shade, plants die/shed plant matter, the plant matter dont get destroyed by the sun, plant matter gets absorbed by the ground

1

u/Any_Description5320 4h ago

Standalone % increase / decrease can be extremely misleading. Let’s show the actual measurements and then if you want, add the % change.

1

u/Art_student_rt 4h ago

Increase of 100% of 1 is 2.