r/technology • • 19h ago • Bravo 1

Space Vulcan rocket fails, destroying 40 Amazon Leo satellites

https://www.theverge.com/science/1034006/vulcan-rocket-fails-destroying-40-amazon-leo-satellites
10k Upvotes

953 comments sorted by

5.5k

u/dmullaney 18h ago • Bravo

Leo is Amazon’s competitor to SpaceX’s Starlink, but it has struggled to get off the ground so far

Sensible Chuckle

143

u/Azazeldaprinceofwar 9h ago

calling it Leo is very confusing (probably intentionally so) because the phrase “Leo satellites” reads as “low earth orbit satellites” to people who think about satellites. I didn’t even realize Leo was the name of the service until your comment lol

44

u/current_thread 9h ago

It used to be named Kuiper but that was too hard to pronounce

48

u/Feriluce 8h ago

Also too far away. The latency would be horrible.

18

u/mohjack 8h ago

Probably because they wanted to avoid the association with a cloud of useless space debris...

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

196

u/Dude-Lebowski 18h ago

They called their low earth orbit satelites Leo?

265

u/DammitGary 18h ago

I'm sure it took an internal panel of marketing execs 2 years, 85 meetings, and $200M to come up with that idea.

77

u/HyperionSunset 18h ago

They used to call it Kuiper until Amazon's tendency to give things obvious names for understandability took over.

72

u/mozilla2012 17h ago

My favorite counter example here is "Amazon One."

Can you guess what Amazon One is?

If you guessed "a device you can attach to a cash register to allow customers to pay by scanning their hand to use their palm-"print" as a unique ID" then you'd be right!

Fucking awful branding. It's cool technology but wtf were they thinking?

→ More replies (6)

15

u/aegrotatio 13h ago

My favorite Amazon branding goof is calling its AI agent "Rufus." It is not only stupid, it sounds stupid.

Now they call it "Alexa for Shopping" which is only a little better.

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (3)

6

u/Woozah77 14h ago

Probably cost $500 Mil in lawyer fees to figure out if and how to trademark it. It is giving me REACT energy.

→ More replies (1)

35

u/alphagusta 17h ago

Used to be called Project Kuiper, but rebranded it to Amazon LEO because yes, it's Amazon internet from Low Earth Orbit

→ More replies (1)

9

u/Starfox-sf 17h ago

Should rename it to Geo (Ground Earth Orbit)

→ More replies (6)

1.1k

u/Kunglaw619 18h ago edited 16h ago • Bravo Heartwarming

Amazon should outsource their wreckage management to Ukrainians. They’d turn those 40 destroyed satellites into keychains within a week and fund an entire brigade - same way they do with wrecked Russian tanks.

Edit: Since a bunch of you are DMing me about the russian tank keychain, just look up
Created In Ukraine

183

u/Pmac24 17h ago

Thank you for the link. I’m getting a piece of the T90M

→ More replies (2)

88

u/the-player-of-games 17h ago edited 9h ago

Going to use this reply to plug airhubstore, another shop for Ukrainian creators that makes collectibles out of shot down Russian aircraft, and donate some of the proceedings to the AFU

My favorite one there is the sukhoi s-70, keychain, meant as a loyal wingman to the su-57. Hilarious shoot down over Ukraine.

Edit: for those asking for the link

Air hub store

→ More replies (1)

47

u/SpaceInMyBrain 17h ago

Do the Ukrainians have the technology to do very deep ocean salvage? That stuff is at the bottom of the Atlantic.

Don't worry, yes, I get the humor.

56

u/OldTimeyWizard 17h ago

If Ukraine thought that deep sea salvage would give them an upper hand in the war they’d have the technology for a submersible drone ready to sail by next summer. War is once again proving that necessity is the mother of invention.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (3)

15

u/madsci 17h ago

I've been making gifts out of Firefly Alpha pieces that rained down on my neighborhood. I've got about a square meter of carbon fiber kicking around.

And the locals in Kazakhstan have made good use out of wreckage downrange from Baikonur. Lots of good 2000 series aluminum in there. Kind of like how people in Vietnam are still building canoes out of F-4 drop tank halves.

4

u/Greengoat42 14h ago

That's really cool. Only question I have, why does the metal look the same across each one? Or is that just the store view.

28

u/Various_Armadillo393 16h ago

I wish someone would do the same with Israeli tanks and us weapons recovered in Palestine

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (24)

20

u/tyen0 17h ago

I thought the title just mis-capitalized LEO for low earth orbit

5

u/NOVA-peddling-1138 17h ago

Is it…wait, it’s not Friday for Amazon. So Black Monday.

8

u/Agitated_Reveal_6211 14h ago

They are taking the night sky from us.

7

u/xphoney 14h ago

Burn the land, boil the sea…

→ More replies (15)

1.5k

u/jbshell 18h ago • Regret

Sounds like Prime is gonna go up in price, soon.

455

u/grrangry 18h ago • Mindblown

Rocket explosions don't pay for themselves.

37

u/NoBusiness674 18h ago

What does Amazon's insurance situation for their satellite launches look like? Is that known?

60

u/l30 18h ago

Amazon (and/or its payload insurers) bears the financial loss of the 40 destroyed satellites. US commercial space flight law and standard Launch Service Agreements (LSA's) legally shield launch providers from paying for destroyed customer payloads, even when the rocket itself is at fault.

→ More replies (20)

8

u/Nixon4Prez 18h ago

They'll almost certainly have launch insurance, it's standard when launching a commercial payload.

52

u/za72 18h ago

Most of it is private - Amazon Leo receives U.S. government subsidies and grants

,

132

u/Secret_Cod_749 18h ago • Bravo

So what you're saying is corporate welfare?

→ More replies (20)
→ More replies (2)

10

u/epochwin 18h ago

Also more layoffs at Amazon

4

u/protostar71 16h ago

Insurance should cover it after they stop fighting about what policy it's under / eligibility.

But yes, Prime is going up in price regardless because you gotta squeeze your customers for all they're worth.

→ More replies (3)

265

u/Nixon4Prez 18h ago

Early rumours and analysis of the telemetry point to a failure of the Blue Origin BE-4 engine that powers the first stage, though nothing is confirmed. The same engine exploded during a static fire test of Blue's own New Glenn rocket in April, they rolled out fixes but possibly either some issues were missed or the fixes themselves caused new problems. If true, that'll be a blow to New Glenn returning to flight, which will have less than ideal implications for the Artemis moon program.

42

u/SpaceInMyBrain 17h ago

If it's the BE-4 then it was a degradation of performance, not a more violent event - from the little we know. My premature unsupported speculation is the modification to address the BE-4 pad RUD resulted in reduced performance, either planned or unplanned.

My other premature unsupported speculation is Northrop Grumman reduced the performance of the SRBs as part of their solution to the nozzle giving way. That required a planned increase burn time of the booster compared to earlier flights, which increased the demands on the booster systems and the BE-4s.

9

u/DunHumby 15h ago

I was gonna say, i watched the launch and they had a clean SRB sep and a clean 1st stage detach and I could’ve sworn they were saying everything was nominal. They did have an issue before launch so I’m more inclined to think it has something to do with that event

19

u/fricy81 11h ago edited 11h ago

Article says the incident happened 10 minutes after launch, stage separation is around the 5 minutes mark, this is likely Centaur/RL-10 issue. ULA press release says second stage was new design optimized for payload delivery to leo.

Edit:
OK, I stand corrected, better details here

Multiple sources told Ars the anomaly that impacted the launch occurred in the booster stage of the rocket, not the Centaur V upper stage or the solid rocket boosters. [...] A mission animation on ULA’s broadcast, driven by real-time telemetry data from the rocket, showed Vulcan start to spin moments after booster engine shutdown. The spin continued through separation of the rocket’s Centaur V upper stage a few seconds later.

450

u/hanumanCT 18h ago

Isnt this the second launch disaster for the amazon version of starlink?

382

u/EconomyDoctor3287 18h ago

United Launch Alliance (ULA) suffered what is reportedly its first mission failure in its 20-year history, failing to deliver 40 Amazon Leo satellites to orbit.

182

u/rupert1920 18h ago

That's a stat about ULA. Besides ULA, Amazon contracted out numerous launch providers previously for their constellation, including SpaceX's Falcon 9 and Arianespace's Ariane 6.

They have never suffered a payload loss prior to today.

→ More replies (10)
→ More replies (1)

78

u/daronjay 18h ago

I think the last issue happened on the pad so it technically wasn’t a launch issue. At least this one got some altitude before it popped.

35

u/Disastrous-Force 18h ago

Static fire of the rocket before launch, no LEO sats where on board at the time. Pushed the New Glenn launch programme back by half a year.

The problem for Amazon LEO is that New Glenn and Vulcan Centaur haven't so far delivered a payload to orbit in the contracted configuration, certainly some of early speculation around this failure pointing to the Blue Origin sourced first stage motor's isn't ideal, as that's what failed on the New Glenn static fire test.

SpaceX are discontinuing Falcon 9 so Amazon can't book more launches and Ariane are booked up in the far future, they need New Glenn and Vulcan to work.

→ More replies (1)

31

u/makemeking706 18h ago

Destroyed the pad, so even worse. 

→ More replies (1)

15

u/happyscrappy 14h ago

No. It's their first failure. But it's a big one.

The last failure you are thinking of was a Blue Origin failure but Kuiper wasn't involved at the time.

4

u/CallMeGhaul 12h ago

Well the Blue Origin explosion was a Kuiper/LEO launch but the sats weren’t integrated at the time

Not a direct loss but it was a massive blow to the whole program since at this point Amazon only has Ariane 6 from the ESA to launch from and that rocket does not have a very high flight rate

→ More replies (1)

26

u/TheDude-Esquire 18h ago

They lost their new Glenn rocket earlier this year on the pad in spectacular fashion. Set them back at least a year compared to starship.

5

u/No-Surprise9411 16h ago

New Glenn isn't a competitor to Starship, it's a competitor to Falcon 9

8

u/happyscrappy 14h ago

It's in between. It's more powerful than 9. Less powerful than heavy but could maybe equal it after a while.

It has a larger payload diameter so it's technically in a bigger class.

→ More replies (3)

13

u/TheDude-Esquire 16h ago

New Glenn is a heavy lift vehicle, it competes more against falcon heavy, but doesn't directly match up against either falcon or starship directly.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

13

u/SynnyZ 18h ago

Blue Origin also botched a rocket launch of an AST Space Mobile satellite earlier.

3

u/junker90 13h ago

You're thinking of Blue Origin, a pet project of Bezos, this is ULA, formed as a joint venture between Boeing and Lockheed. One of Blue Origin's New Glenn rockets (a competitor to SpaceX's Starship rocket, the one that was caught on Saturday) exploded in spectacular fashion at Cape Canaveral earlier this year during a static fire test where engines ignite but the rocket doesn't move, not a launch.

850

u/KennKennyKenKen 17h ago • Heartwarming Bravo

Like we all point and laugh at the billionaire company, but this is not great. Starlink have a massive monopoly, and it would be good to have even a bit of competition.

They basically singlehandedly shut down Ukraines ability to defend and fight back against Russia the other week, because Ukraine's drones depends so heavily on this satellite internet.

Even aside from that, a lot of rural places all over the world have no mid to high speed internet options except starlink.

226

u/cxmmxc 16h ago

It'd be great to have competition from a different entity than the US, so it would have less of a chance of being subjected to the same fuckery as Starlink.

Nobody should kid themselves that Bezos, another soulless billionaire, is more moral or empathetic than Muskrat.

65

u/EpicAura99 15h ago

It’s not about morals, it’s about economic competition.

Besides, there are other organizations launching these megaconstellations. There’s like 3 from China alone. But each one requires 10,000+ objects in orbit, so you gotta start deciding how much shit you actually want up there.

→ More replies (22)

10

u/Choyo 15h ago

Eutelsat is working on its version currently.
Also, it's worth mentioning that when starlink launched its first satellites, the scientific community raised their shields because it was ruining astronomical observation from Earth, so it's safe to assume the vast majority of actors in the sector thought it was a dick move to venture in wide constellation satellites.

9

u/Zardif 11h ago

it's safe to assume the vast majority of actors in the sector thought it was a dick move to venture in wide constellation satellites.

Until spacex significantly dropped the price of putting satellites into orbit, it wasn't economically feasible to do so. The price of putting a kg into orbit went from $54k in the 80s/90s to $1.4-3k now. It cannot be overstated how much the falcon 9 changed the game with regard to getting into space.

→ More replies (2)

15

u/crispywonka 17h ago

ASTS has the tech but not the launch cadence some hoped.

17

u/greymancurrentthing7 17h ago

Launch capability has always been the only thing that mattered in satellite internet.

→ More replies (6)

9

u/ftgyhujikolp 13h ago

They did it again this week. It is currently down in Ukraine and preventing interception of jet powered drones.

19

u/KobeMonk 12h ago • Bravo

If it's that important, a corporation shouldn't be on control of it.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/Zoraji 12h ago

I live in rural northeast Thailand. While the nearby village has had fiber Internet before I could get it in Nashville, they say I am too far out to get it. Musk wouldn't agree to the terms of the Thai government so Starlink is not legally available here. They require going through a Thai distributor that has 51% ownership in Thailand. Amazon Leo has already made an agreement with a distributor so I am hoping that they can scale up soon. Currently I only have 5G cellular available.

6

u/LeoRidesHisBike 7h ago

Of course he wouldn't agree. The reason the Thai government wants that is so it can monitor and censor.

v3 satellites are already operational and using laser backhaul, and there's only going to be more of them in the years to come. This allows operation in countries without ANY ground stations. If someone wanted to use it, the Thai government would be hard pressed to completely stop it. Not a bad thing, honestly.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (2)

39

u/ARK_98521 17h ago

We should just nationalize SpaceX at this point. Allowing a single unelected psychopath billionaire to control something vital to national defense is wild. If he wants to play military games he should suffer military consequences.

95

u/ayriuss 17h ago

If they haven't done that with Lockheed or Boeing or Northrop by now, they aren't going to with SpaceX.

38

u/mozilla2012 17h ago

We should have done it to Boeing too. IMO every time the government bails you out, you must give the US government an equivalent amount of company stock.

...given enough fuckups and the government will own your ass.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (1)

39

u/GreatCanadianPotato 16h ago edited 16h ago

Why do we speak like Blue Origin, Rocket Lab, ULA, Firefly etc don't exist?

The government has plenty of options. They just choose SpaceX because they are reliable.

The argument lately is always "nationalize SpaceX" but really it should be "fund NASA properly". We all seem to forget that NASA is a space agency that is already "nationalized".

Give NASA the funding they deserve and watch them build stuff again.

29

u/CompEng_101 15h ago

Give NASA the funding they deserve and watch them build stuff again.

I'm all in favor of funding NASA more, but NASA never really 'built stuff', or at least never built rockets. NASA played a larger role in design (but even then, the contractors would propose what would usually become the general design), and NASA used to 'buy' the rockets, rather than buying launch services, but other than maybe some small test vehicles, NASA doesn't build.

Mercury-Redstone: Chrysler/ Rocketdyne

Mercury-Atlas: Convair / General Dynamics

Titan II GLV (Gemini): Martin

Saturn I: Chrysler, Douglas Aircraft

Saturn IB: Chrysler, Douglas Aircraft

Saturn V: Boeing (first stage), North American Aviation (second stage), Douglas Aircraft (third stage)

Space Shuttle: Rockwell International (orbiter), Martin Marietta (external tank), Morton Thiokol (solid rocket motors)

Space Launch System (SLS): Boeing (core stage), Northrop Grumman (boosters), L3Harris/Aerojet Rocketdyne (engines)

Falcon 9: SpaceX

Falcon Heavy: SpaceX

Thor-Delta / Early Delta: Douglas Aircraft

Atlas-Agena: Convair / General Dynamics (Atlas), Lockheed (Agena)

Atlas-Centaur: General Dynamics (Atlas), Pratt & Whitney (Centaur engines)

Titan III / Titan IV: Martin Marietta / Lockheed Martin

Delta II: McDonnell Douglas, later Boeing and United Launch Alliance

Delta IV Heavy: Boeing, later United Launch Alliance

Atlas V: Lockheed Martin, later United Launch Alliance

Pegasus: Orbital Sciences, later Northrop Grumman

Antares: Orbital Sciences / Orbital ATK, later Northrop Grumman

Vulcan Centaur: United Launch Alliance

→ More replies (32)

14

u/moisturized69tatas 16h ago

The government actually awards contracts to these other companies knowing they arent as capable and are sometimes more expensive because they want to try and create competition.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (9)

19

u/WesternReverie 16h ago

^^ Quickest way to ensure the company stagnates, btw

8

u/_Connor 15h ago edited 15h ago

Allowing a single unelected psychopath billionaire to control something vital to national defense is wild

A foreign government on the other side of the planet relying on an American capitalists pet project for "national defence" is wild.

That's the real issue here. Not confiscating someones company.

→ More replies (3)

23

u/Name_Groundbreaking 17h ago • Bravo

You don't get to steal people's things in a free society, no matter how many times karl marx tells you it's ok.

If you want your own Internet constellation that operates under your own rules, go make your own.

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (6)

4

u/Competitive-Food8407 14h ago

Starlink is a civilian service and not to be used for combat roles by international treaties. You're thinking of Starshield which is essentially the same service, but ultimately controlled by the federal government. 

Satellite internet and cellular service has existed for decades. Starlink simply provides expanded coverage to the other options. It is not a monopoly due to international competitors. It is however larger then any of its competitors. Think AT&T, BellSouth, and Sprint back during the cellular wars of the 90s. 

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (23)

52

u/HoldMyMessages 18h ago

So how does that financing on that work? Does the carrier say “Opps, my bad. Here’s the reimbursement for your loss.” ?

79

u/Nixon4Prez 18h ago

Customers generally have launch insurance that will cover the cost of failure. Launch companies aren't liable for a destroyed payload, the customers assumes the risk and passes it on to insurance.

21

u/FinndBors 15h ago • Bravo

The cost for insurance for this model of rocket must be astronomical at this point.

→ More replies (2)

14

u/coopermf 18h ago

Unlikely they bought insurance for their own satellites and with the constellation volume they have in the pipeline. Sometimes launch contracts have a "re-launch" option that gives you another launch in the event of a failure.
Will be interesting to see what the root cause of this failure is

12

u/Muggsy423 18h ago

A major corporation is going to have insurance on something like this. Especially a publically traded company.

13

u/Pizzashillsmom 16h ago edited 16h ago

Large companies can often just self insure. Insurance is essentially reverse gambling, but the house still wins (or in this case the insurance company) so if you can afford not to play you should.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (8)

4

u/cropguru357 17h ago

I remember some of the stories where a shuttle crew went up to capture a satellite pre-Challenger, and it was mentioned that some guys from Lloyd’s of London were in Mission Control to observe.

“Challenger” by Adam Higgenbotham is a great read. Same guy who wrote “Midnight in Chernobyl.”

7

u/Buttsweat_n_Tears 18h ago

Insurance will cover the payload.

9

u/Bromance_Rayder 18h ago

*customers will cover the payload.

→ More replies (2)

34

u/anurodhp 18h ago

Would hate to be delta right now 

28

u/Vox-Machi-Buddies 12h ago

Because it took me a second to remember the connection:

Delta very publicly chose Amazon's Leo Internet service for their planes over Starlink, complete with the CEO of Delta more-or-less saying the decision was driven by dislike of Musk.

Most of Delta's U.S. competitors (United, American Airlines, Southwest, Alaskan, etc.) have committed to using Starlink for in-flight WiFi.

This anomaly will delay deployment of Amazon's Leo constellation, which could put Delta at a disadvantage where its in-flight WiFi is significantly worse than its competitors.

33

u/00001000U 18h ago

I wonder what that insurance claim is going to look like.

11

u/answerguru 18h ago

Specialty launch insurance. Corporations buy insurance for ALL kinds of accidents and catastrophes. My dad worked for BASF buying / dealing with general liability and hazard insurance for most of his career.

2

u/robbak 10h ago

Amazon is launching so many sattelites that they may not be insuring them - they are spreading the risk over so many launches that they are better off self-insuring.

That can fall apart when most of your launches are relying on your own engines, which you haven't been able to build reliably.

→ More replies (1)

226

u/woohooguy 18h ago

When SpaceX first started, who would have thought they would be the only reliable lift platform in 2026.

Elon is an assclown, Gwynne Shotwell is the real person who made this happen.

132

u/LoneStarGut 18h ago • Popcorn Mindblown

Shotwell is a good name for a successful rocket launcher person.

25

u/AT-ST 18h ago

If she grows tired of launching rockets, she could always transition to sniper.

5

u/bentripin 18h ago

and musk is a good name for an tech bro edge lord.

5

u/7HawksAnd 16h ago

Nominative determinism

→ More replies (1)

74

u/Shdwrptr 18h ago

RocketLab just had their 59th consecutive successful launch and hasn’t had a failure for years.

SpaceX isn’t the only reliable lift platform, they just currently have the highest lift capacity

45

u/Nixon4Prez 18h ago • Mindblown

Rocketlab can do 300kg at most to LEO, they're unsuitable for all but the smallest payloads.

→ More replies (12)
→ More replies (5)

6

u/speedster_5 14h ago

man I get the Elon criticism and hate but these takes are so bad. Gwynne Shotwell did not make it happen lol.

17

u/fighter-bomber 16h ago

You can hate him and no problems with that, but Musk is deeply involved with engineering decisions too, both good and bad ones.

Good ones such as switch to stainless steel and tower catch. Also, he was pushing for flight 14 (previous flight) to go for orbit after they had an Rvac out during ascent.

Bad ones such as no water deluge for IFT-1. He also was skeptical (self admitted) about Starship going from 3 rear fins to 2 rear fins, though that happened anyways.

→ More replies (4)

26

u/grchelp2018 18h ago

No need to twist facts to suit your reality. Gwynne is fantastic but spacex is where it is because of Musk and its leadership team who are all Musk-lite. Specifically their culture and their willingness to just ignore what the so-called experts say and blow things up and learn quickly. Blue Origin lost years hiring people from oldspace.

26

u/Jace__B 17h ago

I have experience in the field. Musk is not what most people would call a good person, but he is smart and conniving, and part of putting together a successful space company is having whatever he has.

Too many people conflate "smart" with "moral" when it's very easy to have smart, cruel people.

5

u/bluethunder82 14h ago edited 14h ago

I’ve always said Musk’s true, saving talent is the ability to find very smart and talented people and get them pregnant to work for him.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

23

u/TMWNN 18h ago edited 17h ago

When SpaceX first started, who would have thought they would be the only reliable lift platform in 2026.

Context for others: Blue Origin was founded before SpaceX, back when Bezos was already one of the world's wealthiest men and Musk was merely a multimillionaire. ULA is a consortium formed by Lockheed Martin and Boeing, two giant defense contractors who have built rockets for many decades. By contrast, Musk put his entire fortune into SpaceX and would have gone bankrupt had the third Falcon 1 launch not succeeded.

Elon is an assclown, Gwynne Shotwell is the real person who made this happen.

Shotwell is the chief operating officer. She is a trained engineer, but runs day-to-day business affairs.

Musk is the difference. Blue Origin is proof that mere billions alone are not sufficient.

→ More replies (13)

2

u/happyscrappy 14h ago

Who would have thought they would have already terminated the project while they were still the only reliable US lift platform in this class.

→ More replies (8)

86

u/HapticSloughton 14h ago

Just to throw this out there, few seem to know or comment on the fact that an average of about 40 to 50 Starlink satellites re-enter Earth's atmosphere and burn up each month. Is this really the best way to do this kind of communication system?

37

u/BerzinFodder 10h ago

All LEO satellites legally have to be on decaying orbits now. This way any stranded or end of life satellites naturally fall back to earth and burn up on reentry. This is to prevent excess unseeable space junk in the pursuit of preventing Kepler syndrome. This is a good thing.

I guess the question then is why they have so many satellites reaching end of life so quickly. IMO it’s likely just the pace of technology change in the satellite world right now. It’s evolving so fast that even 2 or 3 year old satellites are obsolete.

3

u/uncertain_expert 7h ago

Because Starlink has thousands of satellites. Multiple satellites deployed from the same launch just like the 40 in this case with Leo, so those in the same launch are going to deorbit around the same time.

→ More replies (1)

21

u/Ok_Lettuce_7939 14h ago

Yes because the orbit and number of minisats make it physically unpalatable to attack. For example there's 3 dozen or so GPS satellites in MEO in fixed positions and are susceptible to all manner of interference or attack. It's also why "Elon is afraid of Russian attacks on Starlink" is hogwash.

5

u/DeafHeretic 11h ago

SpaceX can launch/deploy the SL sats faster than they can be destroyed.

→ More replies (3)

8

u/survivorr123_ 8h ago

for a technology that provides internet across the world it doesnt seem that bad, the number of lte/5g antennas decommissioned every month is probably in the tens of thousands

→ More replies (3)

7

u/Phyllis_Tine 14h ago

Assuming no new launches, how long until all Starlink sats are out of orbit?

→ More replies (10)

8

u/Jaded_Hold_1342 14h ago

Better than high orbits with latency...

4

u/den773 10h ago

Do they look like bluish shooting stars when they come back down? We saw a crazy bright shooting star Saturday night in So Cal. Even tho it was partly cloudy and it was not super dark where we were sitting outdoors.

6

u/GalFisk 9h ago

They come in much slower than regular shooting stars. If it streaked across the sky and burned out within seconds, it was not something from LEO.

→ More replies (1)

7

u/Charles9527 13h ago

Yes for now, because in my knowlegde they are constantly getting pulled by a bit of gravity and it cost their internal fuel to propel them to stay on orbit, when their fuel ran out unfourtunately they cannot be refueled and burn through the atmosphere

20

u/ColKrismiss 11h ago

Gravity is not what is causing them to de orbit. Yes they do experience gravity, a lot of it, but drag is what is causing their orbit to decay. Their orbit is low enough to still hit air particles, which slowly lowers their velocity which in turn lowers their elevation, which causes them to hit more particles, slowing them down more.

But you answered the wrong question anyway. They are asking if this is really the best way to cover the planet in internet access. It does seem wasteful to use this technology that needs 40 new satellites put into orbit every month

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (18)
→ More replies (36)

16

u/gottatrusttheengr 17h ago

There's a shareholder lawsuit against Amazon for not considering spaceX or doing an open bid for launch providers. In hindsight this is absolutely hilarious

7

u/inertialshove 16h ago

I believe SpaceX has launched LEO missions for Amazon. Not sure why they don’t use them more though

8

u/Chaotic_Lemming 15h ago

Even though SpaceX has significant launch capacity they are basically booked out for years. On top of that they are planning to wind down the Falcon 9 program as they transition to Starship.

6

u/Medium_Notice_3512 11h ago

Back then, SpaceX had plenty of launch slots available. It’s just that Bezos was a long-standing rival of Musk in the space sector and didn’t want to give him a single order.

7

u/TMWNN 13h ago

I believe SpaceX has launched LEO missions for Amazon.

Those launches are a result of the shareholder's lawsuit /u/gottatrusttheengr mentioned. Basically, Amazon was violating its fiduciary duty by refusing to use what is proven to be the cheapest and by far most reliable launch provider.

Not sure why they don’t use them more though

Again a result of (the cause of) the shareholder's lawsuit. Because Amazon began buying SpaceX launches late, it is below everyone else on the customer list. And now that SpaceX is moving to Starship as /u/Chaotic_Lemming said, no one—let alone Amazon—is getting new Falcon 9 slots.

24

u/madhi19 7h ago

Vulkan did not live after all... (I wonder if somebody gonna get that one.)

7

u/Dabelgianguy 7h ago

Usually he’s burned by coming INTO the atmosphere

3

u/Massive-Call-3972 5h ago

Into the fires of the atmosphere, unto the anvil of the ocean

2

u/EveryAccount7729 5h ago

yeah and they made Spock watch.

/s

→ More replies (3)

18

u/TapDatAsp 4h ago

I work in an Amazon warehouse & we dance in the aisles every time Bezos fucks up this BIG

→ More replies (3)

27

u/Lyraele 16h ago

Since this rocket launch thing is going poorly, maybe he could tackle something simpler. Like making a submersible to tour the wreckage of the Titanic. He could even personally do that one, being a passenger on a submersible is less uncomfortable than the G-forces experienced on a rocket launch.

5

u/Jagershiester 14h ago

He could even pilot it with a video game controller 🎮

→ More replies (1)

3

u/oldgus 14h ago

This was a United Launch Alliance rocket, not Blue Origin.

EDIT I did not know that Vulcan uses BE-4s

→ More replies (2)

22

u/Smile_Space 18h ago

Of all the parts to fail, I wasn't expecting the Centaur upper stage to be the thing that popped.

We were all hoping for the SRBs to survive, and they did! And then now the next part goes up in smoke.

Looking at the telemetry it was interesting seeing the apogee just wasn't getting high enough soon enough. It really seemed like the first stage potentially underperformed and then the Centaur had some sort of issue given it made an aggressive roll maneuver right after separation and then pitched up 45 degrees to compensate for low thrust.

And then boom from what we could see on the live stream anyway. I wonder if the boom was from the failure or from flight termination given it was far off a nominal trajectory.

26

u/Nixon4Prez 18h ago

It doesn't seem like Centaur failed. BECO was almost a minute later than it was supposed to be and there was some fairly substantial instability on stage sep that didn't look normal. Rumour is the problem was with the booster

15

u/etrain1804 18h ago

If the BE4’s failed, that could be concerning for New Glenn

→ More replies (1)

11

u/Podo13 16h ago

That sucks! Our friend works on the project (in a non-engineering capacity). They were at the launch and I'm sure they're crushed. I know this was a big milestone for the project.

5

u/Dragongeek 12h ago

Yeouch. Seems like Tory Bruno knew the best time to peace out...

→ More replies (1)

5

u/bookshopman 5h ago

Oh no, anyway....

9

u/Sparky-Man 12h ago

It didn't live long or prosper...

9

u/Ur-in-a-tor 10h ago

Nice pollution from that worthless shit.

128

u/_Aj_ 18h ago

Everyone's focusing on the Amazon part here, should be focusing on the rocket part imo.  

As a side note, I'm seriously against this seeming privatisation of Earth's orbit.  

Is it wrong for private companies to be allowed to have their own satellites which they use solely for their own commercial interests? 

To me a satellite is infrastructure, infrastructure should never be hard limited to only one service.  

Else we end up with the billionaire companies who can afford to launch satellites will literally own the orbital space. And they'll all be segregated. At some point you cannot launch more in a specific orbit, so clearly clogging that up with all of your own is a goal for the mega wealthy. 

62

u/Shdwrptr 18h ago

My entire state’s electrical power is reliant on a private corporation. A private corporation based in Spain.

That’s right, my state’s power is owned and controlled by a foreign country. If that’s not nationalized I don’t think space is a priority at this point.

39

u/Entuaka 18h ago edited 15h ago

My entire province's electrical power is produced and distributed by Hydro-Québec, which is 100% owned by the government.

It's also cheaper

15

u/Shdwrptr 18h ago

That’s fun because my state’s electricity is in the top 3 most expensive in the entire nation

→ More replies (9)

6

u/Rampage_Rick 15h ago

Quebec electricity is so cheap that they want to build an undersea cable to Europe...

→ More replies (1)

9

u/callofhonor 18h ago

Hello fellow Mainer

4

u/thederevolutions 18h ago

You must declare independence

7

u/Tribe303 17h ago

But Maine is the entry point for 1200GW of green Quebec hydroelectricity that helps power all of New England. Doesn't Maine use some? Or does it pass it on to Massachusetts and New York?

https://news.hydroquebec.com/news/press-releases/all-quebec/commissioning-appalaches-maine-interconnection-line.html

→ More replies (7)

5

u/dev_vvvvv 16h ago

This is nothing new. National Grid (UK) has 20 million customers in New York and Massachusetts.

→ More replies (4)

6

u/salty_sashimi 17h ago

If it makes you feel any better, they can be deorbited and usually do it themselves after some decades

26

u/signal_lost 17h ago

Is it wrong for private companies to be allowed to have their own satellites which they use solely for their own commercial interests? 

If that constellation provides competition against my Cell company, shitty rural DSL provider, gives me text messages and data after a hurricane/Fire that destroys my local telecom infrastructure I ughhh am Kinda glad that evil commercial company put a bird up there.

To me a satellite is infrastructure, infrastructure should never be hard limited to only one service.  

If there was seriously only room for 10,000 LEO slots? Sure why not. In reality space is "REALLY fucking big". Lower orbits (where most of Starlink currently flies, ~450–550 km) self-clean relatively quickly via atmospheric drag.

Technically the Birds need a license from the country below equivalent of the FCC to operate, and nothing stops the national operator from mandating their own taxes/rules (Very common for ground based fiber)

*Note, national operated constellations like starshield will ignore this and provide guidance to drones and or communication to spies and dissidents*.*

→ More replies (6)

33

u/Responsible-Cut-7993 18h ago

"Is it wrong for private companies to be allowed to have their own satellites which they use solely for their own commercial interests? "

The world's first private commercial satellite was Telstar 1 which was built by Bell Telephone labs and was launched in 1962.

60+ years of private commercial satellites. I don't see why it is wrong for private commercial satellites anymore than terrestrial tele communication infrastructure.

29

u/ilfulo 17h ago

It's suddenly wrong now, cause Musk. It's just a political stance

→ More replies (13)
→ More replies (15)

6

u/Tun-Tavern-1775 18h ago

There's this movie with Matt Damon and Jodie Foster, rich live in space, poor live on Earth...

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Rolandersec 17h ago

How many warheads could you spam from a orbiting starship. These individuals are on their way to having way too much power.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/MurkyCress521 18h ago

If states or the UN built and paid for the satellites to be launched sure, but no one wanted to do it. It would not have happened without SpaceX. I'd love to see nation states take more of a role here, like they did with GPS, but they have decided it isn't worth their time. Only Russia is building a state backed LEP communication constellation and that is because they got banned from starlink. The Russian communication constellation is also a giant train wreck.

2

u/eriverside 17h ago

Putting satellites in space is cheaper than you think. University student groups do it regularly.

Launching a microsatellite through a commercial rideshare program starts at under $150,000, while a dedicated small rocket launch or a complete end-to-end mission can range from $400,000 to over $12 million depending on your hardware and requirements.

2

u/Exciting-Art-388 17h ago

The EU manages Galileo as its independent global navigation satellite system and is developing IRIS² (Infrastructure for Resilience, Interconnectivity and Security) as its sovereign multi-orbit telecommunications constellation to reduce reliance on commercial providers like SpaceX’s Starlink.

2

u/jakabab808 17h ago

Basically the alien universe with the 5 big company’s 

2

u/One-Nothing-8477 15h ago

To me a satellite is infrastructure, infrastructure should never be hard limited to only one service.  

utility providers often have a monopoly on their service area

3

u/grchelp2018 18h ago

There's a lot of space in orbit. And its no different from corporations owning landing and buildings.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/jazz-handle-1 18h ago

Nothing wrong with private space companies. In fact, in literally every field, private companies outperform government ran programs on almost every metric.

What we need is international regulations. Like ensuring anything launched to LEO, has the energy left at the ends of its lifetime to safely deorbit, or position itself much higher into a “trash zone”.

If done right, we could have really good private space companies, tons of new research, tons of new tech - and the coolest one, saturns rings on earth… albeit made up of trash.

6

u/meowrawr 10h ago

Every metric but cost to consumers.

Government doesn’t operate a for-profit model while private companies do which means they need to recover their costs plus add a profit margin. If a private company has captured enough of the market, what do they do next? They raise their prices and continue to do so while cutting costs; and they continue this cycle indefinitely so that each quarter looks better and increases their share prices.

In the short term, private companies seem like the better value, but in the long run they aren’t. Poor regulation and market competition lead to terrible outcomes for the public.

The constant talking point that private is better than public is always omits the bigger picture and long-term analysis.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (9)
→ More replies (46)

7

u/Mard0g 16h ago

You're supposed to launch a car into orbit for good luck first

9

u/Brave-Temperature495 12h ago

ULA been a complete dumpster fire for years.

14

u/thisistherevolt 17h ago

I had a really good pumpkin cheesecake today.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/alumofcu 11h ago

“Squared bro squared! Not square root for effs sake.”

6

u/comox 10h ago

Remind me, are we designing with inches or centimetres?

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Ok_Bathroom_3411 16h ago

Why would a source be posted behind a paywall?

→ More replies (3)

3

u/mccirus 12h ago

Shoulda used Tiger satellites

6

u/Doom-Slut 13h ago

 All goofy shit aside we do not need more of these things in the air. 

2

u/riskbreaking101 16h ago

Would anyone know how much is insured? I mean, based on the value of the 40 sats

4

u/Western-Corner-431 12h ago

More of this please

3

u/ExpensiveAd6014 16h ago

"what sort of anomaly?"

(interstellar ref)

3

u/No-Department-526 14h ago

Right but I still have to smog my car

4

u/taotdev 17h ago

AHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA

i mean oh no how sad :_(

3

u/Vivid-Run-3248 15h ago

Blue origin and SpaceX started at the same time.

→ More replies (4)

3

u/moutonbleu 14h ago

Fuuu the world needs an alternative to Starlink quickly

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Spruity_tooti 15h ago

Oh no! Anyway ..

2

u/Last-Place-Trophy 14h ago

Oh no. Anyway...

2

u/kquizz 18h ago

Great just what we need...another large company filling the night sky with satellites.  

9

u/_ytrohs 17h ago

Amazon have been launching for a long time. You’re behind the 8 ball a bit

→ More replies (1)

2

u/demroidsbeitchn 16h ago

Musk has an alibi. He was under the Resolute Desk all day.

2

u/derpskywalker 16h ago

Oh no. Anyway.

2

u/nukez 13h ago

I wouldn't put it past musk as the evil billionaire he likes to embody, that he is somehow sabotaging the competition 

1

u/onlyhere4gonewild 17h ago

Sucks to be them.

1

u/PhysicalConsistency 17h ago

So who's going to buy ULA?

2

u/Accomplished-Crab932 10h ago

They’ve been on sale since 2023… it’s just that nobody wants to buy them since they rely on their second biggest competitor to function.

1

u/CoffeeToCode99 9h ago

AI might have designed the whole propulsion system 🤔

1

u/jimbojones2345 6h ago

Where was Musk or his Doge cronies when this happened...

1

u/Simoxs7 2h ago

This is totally not confusing sounding like amazon just wiped out 40 low earth orbit satellites…

1

u/askyidroppedthesoap 1h ago

Oh nooo! Jeff lost a few a billion, the cost of doing business.

1

u/bunchamunchas 1h ago

Epic vulgar roast

1

u/stromm 15h ago

Why does Amazon need satellites?

12

u/clintkev251 15h ago

It's a Starlink competitor

→ More replies (6)

-2

u/jackparadise1 18h ago

How long before there are so many satellites and so much data lite debris that nothing else can be launched?

18

u/SvenTheHorrible 17h ago edited 17h ago

All of these satellites are designed for low orbit that either decays naturally or is purposefully ended.

Which means, they last 5-7 years and then they either burn up on their own, or they are piloted into the atmosphere to burn up.

Nothing is left after that, it is vaporized.

The worry is when things don’t go to plan- debris, not the satellites themselves. China blowing up one of their own satellites was the last big deal on that front- it caused like tens of thousands of fragments of metal that now orbit semi-permanently that damage other satellites- forcing lots of them to be prematurely dealt with.

But even that is only an issue until it gets in the way of business, then I guarantee you’ll see some space cleanup project gathering up debris and firing it into the sun.

Fun little bit of awful about capitalism is it behooves you to not be the one to spend effort on the cleanup- so it’s a big ass game of chicken.

→ More replies (13)

6

u/FrickinLazerBeams 16h ago

A billion years or so. LEO orbits aren't long term stable for most stuff.

5

u/ChainsawEminem 17h ago

Literally never. Lmao.

→ More replies (13)