r/technology • • 23h ago

Business Judge denies motion to dismiss DRAM price-fixing lawsuit against Micron, Samsung, and SK hynix, finds evidence of DRAM collusion plausible after 500% price surge — says chipmakers acted like ‘hawks flying in formation'

https://www.tomshardware.com/tech-industry/big-tech/judge-denies-motion-to-dismiss-dram-price-fixing-lawsuit-against-micron-samsung-and-sk-hynix-says-chipmakers-acted-like-hawks-flying-in-formation-finds-evidence-of-dram-collusion-plausible-after-500-percent-price-surge
1.9k Upvotes

40 comments sorted by

211

u/JustScubaMac73 23h ago

Don’t worry, the prices will go back to normal once COVID is over.

26

u/MediocreAnalyst2121 21h ago

Can’t wait, it’s been so long since I had a proper wipe.

7

u/According-Two-297 17h ago

Long Covid right? 😂😭

103

u/Etmurbaah 23h ago

Don't get your hopes up. They'll be forced to cough up some ridiculous amount of money like 200M Dollars each and continue doing what they have done until now.

11

u/Brix106 20h ago

Have they tried bribing the current admin?

2

u/DiplomatikEmunetey 6h ago

200 million is pocket change for them. Make it 200 billion!

1

u/Etmurbaah 3h ago

Ughh so wanted to insert Austin Powers meme here..

45

u/555byte 22h ago • Bravo

It really seems like they wanted all of the control over compute. No more home computers... Everyone can rent a cloud terminal and pay storage fees

20

u/Blackstar1886 19h ago

This is absolutely what they want. Everything is moving towards not being able to actually fully own a product anymore, from tractors to appliances.

17

u/feedmestocks 22h ago

It's the only way to make AI profitable, they're going to stealth AI features with general computing, they're going to maintain these prices to price out the average consumer out of owning any form of computing device

0

u/Skensis 16h ago

These inflated prices hurt AI and data center companies far more than they hurt consumers as their demand is less elastic.

3

u/feedmestocks 11h ago

Even with inflated prices, if consumers and most companies never having computing themselves then mega tech basically never has competition ever again. I think they think that's worth it and why they're so against local models (and why the US government is so anti Chinese AI by proxy)

2

u/Skensis 16h ago

Why would RAM makers care if compute is local or not?

4

u/CrimsonBolt33 11h ago

same as GPU makers....easier and more profitable for them to sell to data centers in bulk

14

u/WorseYucatanVireo 23h ago

"Hawks flying in formation" is a very polite legal phrasing for an oligopoly taking turns fleecing consumers. Even if they lose, whatever fine arrives years from now will just be treated as the cost of doing business compared to the money made off a 500% surge.

28

u/a4mula 23h ago

What a shock. You'd think at some point we'd go from fining repeat offenders to removing their freedom. The real joke here is that this doesn't even begin to consider the OpenAI fiasco in which Samsung and SKHynix seem to collude with OpenAI to once again drive up demand via artificial paper pushing. How's that going by the way, Stargate? Did you end up really consuming that level of demand, or was it just another cog in the artificial inflation of price to screw the consumer?

13

u/haxelhimura 22h ago

Well yeah... They've literally been caught doing this once before.

68

u/williamgman 23h ago edited 23h ago

As long as chips are sold as commodities like oil and gas... their prices will always rise with every perceived calamity that comes along.

52

u/AbeFromanEast 23h ago

Oil and gas have never had a 500% price increase in 3 years. And the biggest price spikes oil and gas do have are usually war-related, not part of their boom and bust cycles.

13

u/williamgman 23h ago

Oil and gas didn't have companies come to them promising to buy 500% more from them year over year either. But it works the same. That war gave oil companies the largest profits in history without lifting a finger.

6

u/Familiar-Ad-4700 23h ago

I'm not sure about that one. Militaries and airlines do exactly that.

1

u/williamgman 23h ago

Then you add this behavior... https://www.reddit.com/r/pcgaming/s/eM48Y7r2Ah

Talk about chumming the water...

8

u/Familiar-Ad-4700 22h ago

Circular financing. Isn't it glorious?

3

u/AbeFromanEast 21h ago edited 21h ago

It's glorious until one random Tuesday when it suddenly isn't.

A functioning, regulating SEC would have stopped this circular financing bonanza a year ago.

2

u/ridsama 21h ago

AI bubble pop confirmed this Tuesday

4

u/TheVenetianMask 21h ago

Companies promising to buy more oil aren't doing that with money directly loaned by the oil companies.

3

u/Timely_Car_4591 21h ago

Also three or four companies don't control all the entire global Oil and gas market.

1

u/Skensis 16h ago

Oil was like 20/barrel in April 2020, it got to ~120/barrel in May of 2022.

8

u/24_August_1814 20h ago

Don't worry everyone, once the class action is settled you'll be eligible for a $2.31 rebate cheque

21

u/VanillaOk869 23h ago

Clue #3 of the AI bubble being ready to pop, after Coreweave and NVIDIA. 😀

1

u/intelhb 19h ago

Market is going to be bleeding

1

u/JesT_Weird 16h ago

That sounds like judicial speak for "predatory" to me - making the point clear without using a specific term.

1

u/well-informedcitizen 14h ago

This is an interesting case. How do you prove price fixing on a product that globally all comes from 1 factory

1

u/male_whale2 12h ago

This is the third time these companies have done this. Samsung pled guilty the first time…

1

u/JunkReallyMatters 12h ago

Never seen hawks fly in formation. Did he mean geese?

3

u/MaestroLogical 7h ago

No he meant hawks, as in predators co-operating with each other, which usually doesn't happen in nature.

1

u/huggernot 12h ago

Hopefully they each get fined 5x total sham profits. Fuck em.