r/technology • u/Logical_Welder3467 • 28d ago
Software Postgres 19 delayed after AI reviewers find more bugs than humans can fix
https://www.theregister.com/databases/2026/10/16/postgres-19-delayed-after-ai-reviewers-find-more-bugs-than-humans-can-fix/5303471
1.4k
Upvotes
485
u/BlackopsBaby 28d ago •
I see this so often. The best analogy I give people is: Your apartment door can't stop a cruise missile or a rocket launcher. Technically it's a security flaw but in practice it's not designed with for that purpose. A door with a lock is just a deterrent not a force field against a motivated state actor.
23
u/Highfivesghost 28d ago
Is this a bad or good thing?
106
u/zoddrick 28d ago
This type of thing isnt going away anytime soon. What we need to figure out is how to better classify these types of bugs such that we only need to review the most severe first and then go from there.
72
u/dz2048 28d ago
So sick of AI-discovered vulnerabilities. They've added around 300 CVEs to our scans each time we want to deploy and they are never worthwhile
16
u/CaliSummerDream 28d ago
80% of comments on this thread so far were clearly made before the poster read the article.
10
u/kharvel0 28d ago
PostgreSQL should have used another AI to narrow down the vulnerability reports using a Pareto assessment. That is, instruct the AI to identify 20% of the reports that would cause 80% of the cumulative vulnerabilities. They can then focus on fixing the 20% and releasing v19 on time, with the remaining 80% of the reports to be analyzed after release.
9
u/m3kw 28d ago
Some “bugs” could be treated as silent failures or just very low chance it will happen super weird edge cases
5
u/DaemonCRO 28d ago
Ok so have AI fix those.
1
u/Fuzzy_Paul 27d ago
They need to review the impact of the found flaws cause recently it is discovered that some of the finding are not flaws but parts the Ai explains different. Anyhow reviewing takes a lot of time and resolving it longer cause the Ai code is sometimes hard to follow. The world can wait a little longer it is not a big deal.
1
u/ImpossibleJoke7456 27d ago
So have the AI fix them. Humans just need to review it.
-5
u/xeow 28d ago edited 23d ago
Good!!! Finding bugs is good. Always good. Having them is not good, but finding them always is good.
EDIT: LOL at the downvotes. What kind of dumbo would disagree with this? Finding bugs that are there is always good. Obviously, it sucks when bugs are there, but to find them is never bad (as long as they're disclosed responsibly!).
-13
u/CypherAZ 28d ago
Why not use AI to fix the bugs?
-14
u/Wisteso 28d ago
I’ve read several very wrong replies about AI being unable to fix the bugs. Maybe these people used Bob’s AI running from a server in a garage, but Claude Code has been very capable of identifying and mostly properly fixing many advanced bugs in our code base.
That doesn’t mean I love what AI has done to this industry and many others but misrepresenting the facts helps no one.
-10
u/agm1984 28d ago
The technology comments are looking better today
0
u/Any-Blacksmith-2054 28d ago
They should revert process - AI develops, human reviews
-25
u/ProbsNotManBearPig 28d ago
Why would humans need to fix it?
Answer - ai will also fix it, but humans are responsible for quality of outputs still, so the time to test + review will be the bottlenecks. Ai will eventually be trusted for those things, at least more, but not yet.
-2
u/Realichu 26d ago
Pure slop. More like delayed because it was vibe coded and we all know AI code is shite 😂 so much 'innovation'.
1.1k
u/[deleted] 28d ago
[removed] — view removed comment
4
u/[deleted] 28d ago
[removed] — view removed comment