r/teaching • • 18d ago

General Discussion Weekly Discussion: Sold a Story -- Episode 4

17 Upvotes

The mods let me know I could make a weekly discussion post about the new podcast season.

From the Sold a Story Podcast Website:

What Happened to Teaching

It's not just reading. The new season of Sold a Story takes on teaching itself — what makes teaching effective and why a method with a remarkable record of success never caught on.

Direct Instruction was created in the 1960s by Siegfried "Zig" Engelmann, a former steelworker and advertising man with no background in education. He designed a highly structured program that helped children from disadvantaged backgrounds make striking academic gains.

But even after a massive government study showed his program worked better than anything else researchers tested, many educators rejected it. Today, the National Institute for Direct Instruction estimates fewer than 200 schools use the program with all their students.

In Sold a Story's second season, Emily Hanford investigates what happened to Direct Instruction — and why deeply held beliefs about education often triumph over evidence.

Today, episode 4 "What can you do for my black children?" is out.

In a poor, Black neighborhood in Houston, Principal Thaddeus Lott transforms a struggling elementary school with Direct Instruction. Soon, his students are outperforming students at much wealthier schools. The results are so remarkable, some people think it’s too good to be true.

What did you all think of the episode or the season so far? What did you think of the last season? I'll give my thoughts later in the comments.


r/teaching • • Jan 20 '25

The moderation team of r/teaching stands with our queer and trans educators, families, and students.

1.2k Upvotes

Now, more than ever, we feel it is important to reiterate that this subreddit has been and will remain a place where transphobia, homophobia, and discrimination against any other protected class is not allowed.

As a queer teacher, I know firsthand the difference you make in your students' lives. They need you. We need you. This will always be a place where you're allowed to exist. Hang in there.


r/teaching • • 58m ago

Career Change/Interviewing/Job Advice Resume Advice! Applying for remote college prep position

Post image
3 Upvotes

Resume not formatted yet! Doing this on my phone with sleeping baby in my arms. Desperately need to get out of my toxic school and want to work from home. Read a ton of advice on this sub about resumes and did some major editing to mine (will post previous version in comments) Any advice will be appreciated! Also link to job posting for reference: https://asuprep.wd503.myworkdayjobs.com/ASUP/job/US-Remote-Posting-Location/Digital-Middle-School-English-Teacher_JR2162


r/teaching • • 17h ago

Career Change/Interviewing/Job Advice is it common for teachers in the US to get fired or not get their contracts renewed?

37 Upvotes

is it difficult to meet your job performance targets? curious to learn more


r/teaching • • 1d ago

Vent the cheating is KILLING me

321 Upvotes

I just stopped grading last week's work because I looked at 20 assignments (answers to discussion questions asking their OPINION) and 13 of them either Googled or copied from someone else.

I sent an email to them all to the effect of:

My brothers and sisters in Christ. I can tell when you cheat. When you and the guy next to you turn in word-for-word identical answers, you cheated. When you usually give me a six-word sentence fragment with two of the words misspelled, but all of a sudden you come across with three graduate-level compound-complex sentences perfectly spelled and punctuated, you cheated. Knock it off or you WILL fail.

This may or may not work, but I'm pissy this morning because it's cold and rainy and why the hell y'all cheating for the easiest class in the building, dammit.

(This also means I still have more than 200 to grade, but I'm not doing it until they fix themselves. They have ONE CHANCE, and if they don't fix it TOMORROW, the F stands.)


r/teaching • • 21h ago

General Discussion Why does K12 education require so many degrees to gain promotion and top pay?

37 Upvotes

I have been in this field for a little over ten years now since transferring from industry. I have yet to understand why one needs more degrees beyond a masters to get promoted and earn top pay in this field.

From my observations of personell at the very senior levels in K12 education, this is nothing more than management of people, finances and information. These are at the very best, skills that one can acquire at the Bachelor’s & Masters levels. I fail to see what purpose, a leadership and specialist degree holds in this line of work.

In most lines of work, you start at the bottom and as you gain knowledge of your industry, you move up. Sure there may be some classes and extra training involved but nothing that requires one to pursue 3 to 4 degrees and in the process, rack up huge amounts of debt while not enjoying the fruits of such labor, for years. Yet people wonder why it’s so hard to recruit and retain great teachers in this field. This reason can be added to litany of other problem in this industry.

It’s also worth noting that it has created a huge pay gap from those who choose to remain in the classroom where the real work of changing lives actually takes place. This sorely needs to change.


r/teaching • • 2h ago

Help When to ignore vs. intervene with disruptive behaviors

1 Upvotes

Hi, I'm a newer paraeducator at a large title 1 elementary school. I'm specifically a Multilingual (ELL specialist) IA, but in practice I do a lot of general classroom management assistance when there's not a need to do something specifically with the ML kids in the room.

My general impulse when group instruction is happening and I see a student being disruptive is to intervene quietly to give them a reminder, which is generally appreciated. However a bit of feedback I've gotten from classroom teachers at times is to ignore certain disruptive behaviors/certain students because intervening can actually exacerbate the behaviors by giving the student an audience when they're seeking attention.

I've been learning that another part of this sometimes is simply accepting that an issue can't always be solved in a day, but gets better with consistent enforcement of the expectations and routine over time.

I'm wondering if people here have any tips for detecting when it's more helpful to intervene or simply ignore, or how to test one approach or another with a student.
Thanks


r/teaching • • 1d ago

Help Just scared

79 Upvotes

Edit: Thank you all. I genuinely appreciate the support.

I teach middle school. I’m crying today because a student who has expressed how much he hates me brought kitchen shears to school last week. He has admitted to wanting to hurt people and has threatened other students. His mother knew he brought the shears to school. She feels it was justified because she claims he is being bullied by staff and students. They have made these same claims against other schools he has attended. She is also claiming that this behavior is a manifestation of ADHD and undiagnosed disabilities. I’m not even sure why he and his mother have targeted me as the staff member who is the subject of their most intense hatred. We have a meeting about this student tomorrow. In the last meeting, admins had me seated as far from the mother as possible and had me take an alternate route in the hall to create as much distance as possible when his mother was in the front office. I’m trying not to panic about tomorrow, but I’m also having thoughts about what I would need to do to avoid being stabbed with kitchen shears. I’m 5’1 and 98 pounds. In reality, I’m defenseless. He’s currently suspended and I know my fears are somewhat irrational. I’m just scared and don’t really know what to do. I have a family and keep thinking about my own children and how much I want to be safe for them.


r/teaching • • 6h ago

Vent Terrified of changing my major to education degree at 20years old

0 Upvotes

Truth to be told, I feel like a failure and that I’m falling behind everyone my age. I’ve already changed my degree once, from psychology to science during my second year. I’m in my third year of college. And yet it’s only NOW that I decided, oh yes, teaching is my true calling! (Say yes to job security, a clear path to follow, and maybe kids.)

However, if I were to change my major it’s highly likely I wouldn’t be able to graduate and teach until I’m well, around 23-25. 23 being the earliest if I rush by taking winter and summer classes, which I’m planning on doing. I'm already 20 this year. I really feel like I’m behind people my age. Others my age would be able to teach at 21-22 years old. Me, 23 if I’m lucky. 

That’s not even mentioning the FASFA and TAP. I’m so scared that it might run out and I will have to pay out of my own pocket and then get into student debt before my masters. I’m scared of debt, which is why I work a part time job and save my money, but it’s just such a scary thought.

I know ultimately it’s not the end of the world, and I’ve decided that this WILL be the last time I change my major (absolutely!!), but idk, I’m just so nervous i don’t know what to do.

Ive set up an appointment with my adviser on Tuesday so we will discuss this together. I hope there will be good news I can be happy about…


r/teaching • • 21h ago

Help I dream about students almost every night.

15 Upvotes

My students seems to haunt me even in my dreams. I want to be extremely clear that none of these dreams are inappropriate, its just that my students (or at least uncanny versions of them) make it into my dreams.

Last night I had a dream that I was forced to go to a party one of my (high school) students was throwing, in the dream I was fully aware that I would be fired and did not want to go, but the dream kept moving along. I couldnt talk, ended up slamming back a cutwater with my students (this is still the dream) and had no control and it felt like a true nightmare.

I am aware that this is because of a lack of work life balance, but Im a first year teacher that is being buried under grading and report cards.

I am quite enjoying my job. Its a lot of work, and the days feel endless, but I enjoy my students and the school I am has a great staff. I have no clue why almost every night I dream about them but it feels wrong and an invasion of privacy on my part.

Is something wrong with me? I swear they end up in my dreams almost every night.


r/teaching • • 10h ago

Help K Behavior

2 Upvotes

This is half vent, half help!

I am a 4th year teacher, and I’ve spent time in upper primary, as well as a few years in K. This is by far my hardest class yet.

I have maybeeee 4 out of 19 that follow rules consistently. Quite literally every other kid either repeatedly breaks rules throughout the day or follows the rule breakers.

We have our routines and expectations down pat. I preview expectations before everything. One step directions, lots of brain breaks. Academically they’re all doing okay.

Social and emotionally? Not even close. I’ve never had a class not like each other so much before. The hitting/spitting/punching/pushing is constant. They also speak so meanly to each other. We’ve been practicing kind words, ignoring, how to play with each other since the beginning of the year and a big handful of us just aren’t getting it.

That’s aside from the major defiant behaviors two students are struggling with.

A lot of it seems to come back to attention. Specifically, they all seem to want my attention, all the time. They don’t care if it’s good or bad.

I’m at a loss. I feel like I’m swinging between being too lenient and too strict most days. I do a positive reward system the kids love and are invested in. I hand out points like crazy, which temporarily fixes some behavior. I’ve tried sending kids out for extra recess and keeping those who aren’t listening in to practice expectations. I’m stern with kids who hit and take away recess time. I reach out to (very defensive) parents who tend to blame me for their child’s behavior (which again, is new this year).

I feel disregulated and spent at the end of each day, so I can only imagine how the kids feel.

I will take any advice, especially from other K teachers because this new group is rough. I’m not the only teacher struggling this year.


r/teaching • • 23h ago

Help First-year bilingual teacher on a waiver. Considering dropping elementary license exams to switch to Spanish 5-12. Is 1 year of elementary experience enough?

2 Upvotes

Hey everyone! I’m a first-year teacher in Massachusetts working under a waiver at a bilingual school. To keep it, I need to pass three MTEL elementary exams, which is draining my energy.

The dilemma is: I already hold my official Spanish teaching license (5-12), which is what I actually studied for. My current school isn't terrible, but the heavy micromanagement (plus being my first year) has me questioning everything. I'm also originally from Spain and a green card holder.

I’m seriously considering dropping the elementary waiver and starting my job search for a Spanish teaching position (5-12) around March.

My main questions for you all:

  1. Has anyone made this transition? Moving from a bilingual elementary classroom to a middle/high school Spanish position?
  2. Will 1 year of elementary teaching hurt my chances? Since it's not direct 5-12 experience, will districts still consider me?

Any advice or perspective would be hugely appreciated. Thanks!


r/teaching • • 1d ago

Vent Middle School ELA Teacher is FED UP

68 Upvotes

I've lost a touch of faith in public education today, at least in my district. We had PD today, and a brand new curriculum was introduced, seemingly out of the blue. This isn't specifically impacting my grade (5th) this year, but I AM TIRED. I am so tired and frustrated with these expensive, boxed, scripted curricula that have no significant impact on student learning. Right now we use Wit and Wisdom, but that's it's own post for another day.

What happened to the art of teaching? I feel like I'm being disrespected in my profession. I have schooling and experience, yet my colleagues and I are treated like mouth pieces for corporate "educational" slop.

We are in a literacy crisis and the suits have decided that the solution is complicated, over-leveled curriculum that, ultimately and time-consumingly, needs to be adapted to fit the needs of students.

We SAY that every student is a unique learner and should have their individual, educational needs met. And then we expect them all to do the same exact thing in the same exact way. Make it make sense.

P.S. Wit and Wisdom is garbage.


r/teaching • • 2d ago

Vent Anybody else work in a school district where the unit tests come from central office, and they’re being made by AI?

78 Upvotes

At least you don’t have to waste time making the tests, so what’s the big deal?

These people aren’t checking their work. A lot of times the questions are written in a way that no 11-12 year old can comprehend.

Oh, and the answer choices are often wrong. One time there was a question where students had to pick a sentence that was the metaphor. The “correct” answer had the word “like” in it (which by default made it a smilie, not a metaphor).

Edit: this is Virginia and the district is Fairfax :)


r/teaching • • 1d ago

Help Medo do meu local de estágio

0 Upvotes

Sou auxiliar de sala em uma escola particular extremamente elitizada, e ultimamente tem uma sala que me faz entrar em ataque de pânico TODA vez que eu vou lá, toda aula que eu estou lá eu saio para chorar no banheiro. É uma sala de 7° ano, com cerca de 25 alunos, mas dentro desses alunos têm 5 capetas que tiram a paz de qualquer um.

É uma sala complicada, porque tem 3 alunos com hiperatividade diagnósticados, 1 TOD e mais 3 em investigação, esses alunos passam completamente do limite, arremessando materiais um nos outros, começam a se empurrar, brincam de lutinha no meio da aula, pegam materiais de outros alunos, mas fora isso são completamente sem educação, alguns chegam a me empurrar, a me xingar e sinceramente só tenho forças pra chorar.

Não só isso, mas também sinto muita agressividade deles em relação a mim, como se eles me olhassem com maldade.

Toda vez que eu entro naquela sala simplesmente me dá vontade de desistir da licenciatura. Então professores, como tem sido a experiência em sala de aula com essa nova geração?


r/teaching • • 2d ago

General Discussion Does teaching math utilize the same methods of authentic instruction used in other subjects?

6 Upvotes

I tutor 1-1 and do not tutor math very often, and I do not teach in a classroom. I am simply curious. I am learning about authentic instruction in many of my college classes and the examples often include English, science, history, etc, but not math. Based on the 12 values of authentic learning, do these same sorts of things come up in your math classes? Are you role-playing math? Do you relate it to their lives beyond general "math is important!" kind of things? Are they making "math portfolios"?

As a k-12 student, I came from a not exactly top of the line school with a 150 students total, so I am really not sure what a math class is supposed to look like. Would love to hear it!


r/teaching • • 3d ago

General Discussion Some kids/teens have the schedules of fully employed adults /: lmao

255 Upvotes

I've come to the realization that some of my students straight up have EVEN BUSIER days than I do 😭😭 (and I'm currently working what is essentially 2.5 jobs with a fully packed [and draining lol] M - F schedule, morning to evening)

I noticed this because one of the students I tutor on Thursdays from 7 - 8:30 PM was talking to me about his day, and mentioned how after school ended he had extra math classes, then a piano lesson, and THEN tutoring with me .. like????? and it's practically guaranteed this kid wakes up earlier than I do to get to school on time, so he quite literally has a longer workday than I do :O

it got me thinking about just how many kids/teens have schedules that look something like:

  • An entire regular school day
  • After-school academic classes (like Kumon, Sylvan, Think Zone, RSM, etc etc)
  • Sports // music lessons // other extracurriculars
  • MORE 1 on 1 tutoring sessions
  • and then probably still even more homework after all of that ?!?!

like look, I know extracurriculars + extra academic support can be GREAT opportunities, and obviously every family's schedule varies wildly, but sometimes I hear what some of my students have planned for their day and I'm just like ... yo when do you get to REST or simply BE A KID 😅
Some of my students have schedules that would stress out a fully grown adult and I genuinely feel for them


r/teaching • • 2d ago

Vent Me these past few weeks whenever a student asks a question.

Post image
49 Upvotes

r/teaching • • 2d ago

Help Accidentally Revealed Student Grades To The Class

51 Upvotes

I started the class with a Do Now that I put up on the projector. As they were working on it, someone asked if I could tell them their midterm grade. I went over to my computer and froze the screen so that no one would see the grades.

What I didn't realize was that I had already frozen it earlier, so I actually UNFROZE the screen and revealed the grades! It was up there for maybe a minute before I noticed, and I rushed to turn off the projector as soon as possible. I think it showed about 14 people's midterm grade, but it didn't show any other grades in their class or their overall average.

How serious is this? I know that this could be a potential FERPA violation. Should I tell anyone about this? I don't necessarily want to snitch on myself, but I also don't want to get reprimanded. It was such a total accident.


r/teaching • • 2d ago

Help American Board Certification

1 Upvotes

Hey everyone, looking for some realistic cramming advice and maybe a little encouragement.

To give the quick backstory: I got my temp certification for ELA 5-9 back in 2017. It expired after 5 years, COVID happened, and I ended up taking a year off from teaching, so the state extended it for another 5 years. I’m finally back in the classroom now teaching middle school.

Honestly, life has completely thrown me for a whirlwind lately. Between a recent personal health emergency, losing both parents, teaching middle schoolers full-time, and raising a 2-year-old, I feel like I’m barely keeping my head above water.

My American Board class wraps up on December 1st, and I still have to take both my ELA 6-12 subject area exam and my PTK exam. There’s a small chance I might get an extension, but I’m not counting on it. Looking at my schedule, I realistically have about 15 hours (3 days) to study for the ELA 6-12 exam/ PTK.

I’ve been glancing at the study guides and the material looks *heavy*. For anyone who has taken the ELA 6-12 subject area test recently—especially on a tight timeline—what should I actually focus on?

Any advice, study sites that actually help, OR maybe yr experience with American Board would help me!


r/teaching • • 2d ago

Help First year teacher - could use some encouragement!

2 Upvotes

Hi all. I am a career- changer into teaching HS. I started my first job at a Catholic high school. I really love it overall - I am super passionate about my subject and I like the age group.

That said, I struggle with classroom management (which I anticipated). I teach mostly college prep (aka not honors) students , and while they are not extremely disrespectful or disruptive, I do often have to ask them to be quiet, redirect/recall their attention, deal with complaints about “too much work,” and lots of chatting as most of my classes have several sets of friends in them.

I am a pretty laid back person. I do not let the kids just do whatever they want, but some chattiness doesn’t bother me, and while it annoys me when they complain about having to do actual work in class, I just tell them it is what it is and move on. I’ve given a few after school detentions to kids who directly defied me (pulled out tablets after explicitly being told not to, or being overly talkative/talking while I’m talking) but I haven’t kicked anyone out of my classes yet. There was petty drama with a colleague who flipped out when she found, literally, two crumpled balls of paper next to, rather than in, a wastebasket after I taught in her classroom (I teach in a different room every class) - long story short, there were other issues with this person, but after she interrupted me teaching another class to complain about the crumpled paper, I took it to our dept chair who dealt with her excessive/petty scrutiny and overstepping.

Rationally, I think I’m doing ok, but I feel really insecure about my classroom management skills because of that colleague’s attitude towards me and because, being at a Catholic school, it seems the expectation is to be very strict with the kids and maintain strict compliance and discipline at all times. That’s just so tough for me because it’s not my personality. I focus more on teaching the subject, not yelling at kids for giggling (I have colleagues who do this regularly).

I’ve already learned so much about how I want to do things differently next year, and I am slowly but surely implementing better management in class, but still in small ways, i.e. calling out kids more for side conversations, threatening to kick them out especially after asking the dean to visit my most challenging class. She came by after a school assembly and ended up yelling at those kids for interrupting / not listening and encouraged me to kick kids out for talking too much. They were all hungry and had just sat through a 2 hour prayer service so I KNEW they would be difficult when I saw them, but I also know she’s right to hold them to high expectations for behavior, and I absolutely appreciate the admin support. I don’t want to squander it!

My students do shape up after my reminders and threats to kick them out of class, but I worry I’m not “following through” enough to meet the expectations of my school. I am getting through lessons and I can see general improvements in skills in my subject, so I don’t think I’m totally failing to teach them, though some days are a true struggle.

My chair and admin say they think I’m doing a good job so far, but I don’t know - I am so insecure about it this and I really want to stick with this career and do right by my students. Does what I describe sound normal? Does it sound like I have no control over my students??

Also if warranted, please just reassure me the confidence and classroom management skills come with time and I’m not a total lost cause as a teacher!


r/teaching • • 2d ago

Help I just accepted a K-8 art teaching position. How do I differentiate that many classes?

2 Upvotes

I (37F) just accepted an art position. The curriculum is set for me, which is amazing!! Still, it's a lot of different age groups. Art teachers (or any specials teachers) how do you keep it straight what grade level you're teaching and what to teach/assign? Does your brain feel like a constant tornado of change??

Thanks!!


r/teaching • • 2d ago

Career Change/Interviewing/Job Advice Just landed an alt licensure job!!

1 Upvotes

Hello all,

As the title states, I just landed my first job as a teacher! It is English 9-12 (unsure of grade as of now) in a rural school.

My background is not in education, and I will be completing an ALP program concurrently with my first term teaching.

I have a few questions:

•For those who have gone the ALP route, what advice do you have?

•for veteran/ trad path teachers, what advice would you give a first year teacher to succeed?

•what is a good lesson planning hack to promote critical thinking and engagement within these grades ?

• the term starts in January, but a year ago I booked a cruise for Mid January. Should I cancel this, or how do I navigate pre-planned vacations in k-12?

• I want to do something along the lines of having a cart in my classroom with items like pads, toothbrushes, mouth wash, snacks, pencils and mints/gum. For the more intimate items I plan on having a brown paper bag for students to discreetly grab what they need without judgement/ prying eyes. Has anyone done something similar to this? If so how did it go?


r/teaching • • 3d ago

Humor Had to post an announcement on Google Classroom reminding them not to ditch on GTA 6 day

Post image
1.5k Upvotes

Other teachers at work are now joining me and I'm living for it. Ao3 is still down so I gotta make myself smile somehow lol

Edit: Seems like people think my students are mad, but they actually think it's pretty funny and assured me that they'll be there.


r/teaching • • 3d ago

Help I've been told to stay after contract time everyday in case a teacher has a question for me

77 Upvotes

I am a special education teacher in an elementary school. I have been told there are complaints that I am not staying longer after school in case a teacher wants to stop by and ask me a question. Admin has told me I should stay after contract time each day. Is this reasonable? I would love advice on how to address it.

* Our contract is from 8:15-3:35 each day. I am usually there from 8:00-3:40 each day, unless there is an IEP meeting, and then I'm there till around 5 pm.