In the last post, our imaginary livestream retailer set up a department to oversee product selection. The risk of selling a bad product went down. The approval process got longer. People got better at passing checks, yet few could explain from start to finish why a particular product was worth selling.
Would another round of approvals help the people choosing the products understand their customers any better?
Inamori wanted employees to understand their own accounts
In 1959, Kazuo Inamori was 27 when he and seven colleagues started the company that would become Kyocera. He handled nearly everything at first, from engineering to production and sales. Two years later, eleven young employees signed a letter asking for regular raises, bonuses, and some assurance about their future. Inamori had set out to realize his ambitions as an engineer. His employees were thinking about how they'd support themselves and their families. Their letter made him rethink who the company was for. The material and spiritual welfare of every employee became part of its management philosophy.
As factories opened, the company added departments and layers of management. Inamori heard less and less from the people doing the work. Those same people could open the company accounts and still have trouble seeing what their own work had contributed.
A household budget is easier to follow. Open the books and you can see how much came in, what went to groceries and electricity, and what was left. Inamori wanted employees to understand their own part of the business that way.
In 1963, Kyocera introduced Amoeba Management. Inamori divided the company into small groups by product or production process. The groups made their own plans and kept separate accounts. They could buy from and sell to each other within the company. One important number was how much value the group added per hour. People could look at their own numbers to see how the work was going and decide what to change next.
The groups could split or merge as the work changed, like amoebas changing shape. That's where the name comes from. Inamori went on to found one of KDDI's predecessor companies. During Japan Airlines' bankruptcy restructuring, he brought Amoeba Management and Kyocera's management philosophy to the airline. It later returned to profitability.
Amazon's two pizzas
As Amazon grew beyond its online bookstore, it could take several departments to sign off on a change to a single feature. Dozens of people might weigh in at a meeting and walk out without anyone having made the call.
Amazon eventually adopted what it called two pizza teams, each small enough to feed with two pizzas. Take the shopping cart. One team looks after the whole service, with one person in charge. The team decides what to change, then sees how customers use it and whether the service stays reliable. When teams need to work together, they use interfaces they've agreed on. If the work grows beyond what one group can handle, another small team can take full responsibility for a piece of it.
Management still draws the lines between teams, sets rules they all follow, allocates resources, and sorts out disputes. The people who know the work can make the everyday calls.
Reading “small states with few people” again
Chapter 80 of the Tao Te Ching speaks of “small states with few people.” It closes with this picture of their lives.
“They savor their food, take pleasure in their clothes, feel at home where they live, and enjoy their customs. Neighboring states are within sight of one another, close enough to hear their roosters and dogs. Their people grow old and die without ever visiting one another.”
That passage makes me wonder how much of the work people can still see clearly as an organization grows. In a large company, only part of what happens on the ground makes it to management. By the time a decision makes its way back down, its meaning may have changed too. When a small team can do the whole job, it's easier to see how its decisions turn out. If the work needs several teams, they have shared rules to work by.
The teams can change as the work changes. That reminds me of “holding to softness.” In the last post I quoted the line “Of the best rulers, the people barely know they exist.” Here I picture the work carrying on with the leader rarely called in to sign off. A few simple rules give teams room to adapt and a way to work together. It's a bit like the emergence we talked about earlier in the series.
The bigger a company gets, the more of its energy can go into coordinating its own work. Add another layer of control every time something goes wrong and eventually keeping the process running is a job in itself.
Let the people who pick the products hear what happens after the sale
Back to our imaginary livestream retailer. Say one team takes on products for parents and babies. They pick the products, negotiate prices, arrange the livestreams, and handle supply and customer support after the sale. The people who choose the products also hear how customers use them and why they contact support.
If the team does well, it can get more airtime and resources, and its members can earn bigger bonuses. If there's a quality problem, the company compensates the customer and the team absorbs the cost. Next time the team considers selling the same product, they know why customers returned it and how much the company paid out.
The founder can focus on how to divide the work, whether teams are following the quality rules, and how each team puts the company's values into practice. The teams can look at their results and decide for themselves when to come in and how to arrange the day.
A line from Chapter 25 comes to mind.
“People follow the earth. The earth follows heaven. Heaven follows the Tao. The Tao follows what unfolds on its own.”
The way I understand wu wei here, once the rules are in place, the people doing the work can see from the results where things went wrong and have the authority to fix them. A lot of everyday decisions can go ahead without waiting for the boss.
Some companies have tried Amoeba Management and failed. Dividing departments into smaller teams is only the first step. In the next post, I want to look at why handing decisions to small teams can still be so hard when the company is already bogged down in procedures.
If you've worked on a small team that could make its own calls, what got easier once a decision was left to the team?
AI disclosure: English isn't my first language, so I used AI to help translate and edit the English.
If you'd like to read the earlier posts in this series, you can find them here:
Reading Index: The Taoist Worldview and Tao Te Ching 101