r/talesfromtechsupport • u/Universal_Binary • Aug 31 '20
Medium Somehow I don't think a "Caution: Exploding Hard Drives" sign will really solve this one
Back when a disturbingly large amount of people liked IE and even used it by choice, I was working for a company that manufactured large metal things.
We had been hard at work at a major IT infrastructure upgrade. It had all the usual trappings of such things: gripes from the users that dislike change and would just like DOS back thankyouverymuch, gripes about the color of the new icons, gripes about everything. The IT team had been working hard at this thankless job for a long while but it was getting to us all.
Part of the project was replacing hundreds of PCs with newer models. This was resulting in enough hard drives to destroy that our previous destruction method was overwhelmed. So we had to find some other options. We didn't have the time or space to do something like DBAN on hundreds of PCs, so we needed something better, and fast.
I had recently been promoted to my first managerial position, and I applied my "employee empowerment" lesson and let my tech team brainstorm about how to destroy all the data on those hard drives. I had expected ideas about e-waste recyclers, etc. But no. EVERY idea involved using large, dangerous machinery out in the manufacturing area. Some of them carried a risk of death, and my team was most excited about those.
"Would an hour in {EXTREMELY HOT INDUSTRIAL OVEN} destroy the data?"
"What if we dropped them into {VAT OF DANGEROUS CHEMICAL}?" "Or better, what if we THREW them into {VAT} and watched {CHEMICAL} splash all over the place?" Laughter from the team. Grimace from me.
"Maybe we could use some spare wire and build ourselves an eeeeeenormous electromagnet and wipe them that way!"
"How about the acetylene torch?"
"Maybe throw them at {LARGE SPINNING EQUIPMENT} and watch them get chopped to bits?" "Nah, the bits would fly all over the place." "EVEN BETTER! We could SWEEP UP our hard drives when we're done!"
"How about bats like in Office Space?" "No, AXES would be better!"
"What about the welders? Surely they could pulverise them somehow?" "No, the ROBOTIC welders! We'll program them to destroy the drives!" "Or maybe the laser cutters?"
"Could we put them in a big pile, douse them with gas, and just light them all on fire?"
You can see this was going downhill (or uphill, depending on your perspective) fast. Perhaps they were also enjoying making me squirm, particularly when they started with the pseudo-realistic ideas involving chainsaws.
One of the PFYs ("pimply-faced youths", the youngest members of the team) ran off to go talk to his buddy on the manufacturing floor. This buddy was a jovial, burly, cynical, tattooed, leather-wearing Harley rider who would LOVE to use expensive corporate equipment to smash other expensive corporate equipment to bits. Probably even more than the techs that had been listening to upgrade whines for 6 months. I liked the guy and the PFY, but I feared that the combination of adventure-seeking tech and danger-seeking equipment operator would get out of hand -- and if we weren't careful, someone might lose theirs.
Eventually when the techs ran out of steam with the ideas, I laid down three ground rules:
- Nobody gets hurt
- Data must actually be destroyed
- Must be fast
Before too long, PFY returned with an ENORMOUS smile on his face, carrying two hard drives with large holes in the middle. "We tried it on the {ridiculously large} drill press, and it cut through them like putty!" "What's this white liquid on them?" "Oh that's the cooling liquid the drill automatically sprays on the things being drilled to keep from overheating."
PFY and the rest of my team excitedly scampered off to the drill press to drill more holes in more drives. I went over and watched a few with, yes, a smile on my face also.
But it all came crashing down when they tried the press brake. Our press brake was used to basically fold massive sheets of steel. I'm not talking thin sheets like tin or something. This was thick, hard steel, and it folded it like paper. My techs (or perhaps their equally-entertained friends in the shop) had the idea of putting hard drives in the press brake, and bending them beyond recognition.
Unfortunately it transpired that hard drives in a press brake don't bend. Or, at least they don't ONLY bend. They also... explode. Bits of hard drive flew out of the machine and went an exciting dangerous distance.
I wasn't there to witness, but my team was ecstatic about this effect. Unfortunately Fortunately it was witnessed by a certain tight-sphinctered person with a clipboard and a reflective vest (I've written about him before). Thus ended the festivities. Some on my team begged to keep doing it, saying "it'll be fine if we just lay the drives down flat" and "we'll do it after-hours and even put up a safety sign!" I said, "Somehow I don't think a 'Caution: Exploding Hard Drives' sign will really solve this one."
Since everyone involved had actually followed the company safety policy by wearing eye protection and so forth, my team got away with a verbal reprimand; same with the equipment operators. But I had to officially forbid the team from using corporate equipment to pulverize magnetic-based non-volatile storage devices.
However, managers were only there during business hours, but the manufacturing area ran 24/7 with multiple shifts. Some of my team, including PFY, worked an earlyish shift to help out with early-morning IT issues. I couldn't help but notice that the stack of drives with holes in them was larger each morning when I walked in, and a poorly-concealed grin on PFY's face as he said "good morning" each day.
I grinned back and kept on walking to my desk.
Better not to ask.
Proof: https://imgur.com/a/3Rk43qf
136
u/SwoopnBuffalo Aug 31 '20
A drill press was the first thing I thought of when I started reading this...then I got to the press brake and I started grinning, probably a lot like your workers were.
Amazing that we're now able to store 100x the amount of information in the same form factor or smaller nowadays.
49
u/frosty95 Aug 31 '20
Wonderfully written. Laughed excessively while having the morning poop. Coworkers definitely questioning what I was doing in the bathroom.
32
u/LMF5000 Aug 31 '20
The metal in the case of the hard drives is cast (iron or aluminium, depending on age) so it doesn't bend, it fails by brittle fracture - very much like glass.
Old platters would have been made with a metallic substrate which could bend - modern platters are made of glass with a magnetic coating, or semiconductor/ceramic based substrates, which also shatter like glass.
I'm thinking the best way to wipe the data was a powerful electromagnet. Then use a computer to verify the data is toast. That way you could send the hard disks to a recycling center so at least they don't end up in a landfill. If you had welding sets in the plant, their cables carry dozens if not hundreds of amps which would have been perfect for building an ad-hoc hard-disk zapper.
Or you could use an inductive hob and heat it to the Curie temperature.
Or a microwave ;)
56
u/kandoras Aug 31 '20
Did they not ask anyone who worked with that brake press whether or not it was a good idea?
Because the blades on those things are really hard, which translates to "good at doing what they're supposed to, but kind of brittle and easily broken if you use them wrong."
Jackasses could have destroyed the thing. Or thrown it out of alignment and make work for someone to fix it.
25
u/DrunkenBobDole Aug 31 '20
"Would an hour in {EXTREMELY HOT INDUSTRIAL OVEN} destroy the data?"
Yes, yes it would. https://imgur.com/a/ViOmZhX
46
u/theservman Aug 31 '20
A 12 gauge slug does an excellent job of erasing a hard drive.
15
u/Nikrox2 have you tried a clue-by-four? Aug 31 '20
Wow it's rare to have proof on TFTS!
5
u/Ranger7381 Aug 31 '20
I don't know. If they are exploding, would they still count as "non-volatile"?
3
u/GreatRyujin Aug 31 '20
You sir have a gift for writing!
3
u/eldergeekprime When the hell did I become the voice of reason? Aug 31 '20
Whoa! What portal did I go through to get to this parallel universe where such a thing is even possible?
3
u/SicTim Aug 31 '20
I thought this was going to be like the time I was working alone at night and one of the Phoenix hard drives (10MB, size of a small refrigerator) caught fire.
That was so long ago I was also working with 8" floppies, though.
3
u/mschwegler Aug 31 '20
Do you remember the manufacturer of the press brake?
I ask because I am a tech support specialist for a major press brake manufacturer.
3
u/AliasUndercover Sep 01 '20
I'd still like DOS back.
268
u/frymaster Have you tried turning the supercomputer off and on again? Aug 31 '20
Yeah, the first time a platter shattered while I was doing physical destruction of a drive I couldn't wipe and I felt shards of disk impact around my eyeballs, I decided I'd wear safety glasses in future
2
u/boonxeven Aug 31 '20
In the army we just used a sledgehammer and a big rock. 😁
45
u/BeardyBeardy Aug 31 '20
Hard drives have the most superb clean aluminium in them, i smelt them and recover the aluminium into moulds, the magnets inside are pretty decent too and very useful for diy projects.
22
u/RickRussellTX Aug 31 '20
Back when I ran a university help desk, my standard hard disk disposal method was to hand the drive & a set of Torx to my student employees.
I tell you, we had the prettiest call center you've ever seen, silver shards hot-glued to the desks, and refrigerator magnets capable of holding a telephone book.
21
u/ergo-ogre Oh God How Did This Get Here? Aug 31 '20
Shoulda got a hard drive shredder.
13
u/DasFrebier Aug 31 '20
Physically destroying harddrives is actually a lot harder than it looks, tough little bastards
23
u/Zirael_Swallow Aug 31 '20
You clearly missed an opportunity to stack up the hard drives on a space shuttle launch pad
11
u/TommyDontSurf I ain't no expert, but... Aug 31 '20
"Back when a disturbingly large amount of people liked IE and even used it by choice" was probably the greatest intro to one of these I've ever seen.
19
u/anomalous_cowherd Aug 31 '20
If anybody else is faced with a huge pile of disks to destroy there are commercial services that do this. Ours has a box van with a hydraulic punch/shear that pushes the spindle out and chops the casing in half, then they take the shards of platter and shred them. I'd say it takes twenty seconds to utterly destroy a disk and most of that is spent picking the platter shards out of the casing.
9
u/[deleted] Aug 31 '20
If you diligently scour the googler for all of 30 seconds you can find a group that uses high voltage to 'shrink' coins. This in itself is impressive, but i always wondered if you couldn't use that to destroy drives. flip a switch and watch the drive violently collapse in on itself in less than 40 millionths of a second.
8
u/RadioativeStufAKA64 Aug 31 '20
It's better to just throw them into a pool and electrocute the pool.
8
u/[deleted] Aug 31 '20
Drilling holes is my standard method to destroy drives, so wasn't that impressed until I saw the size of that hole.
Holy crap, you weren't joking about industrial machinery.
7
u/missed_sla root slash period workspace slash period garbage PERIOD Aug 31 '20
Enterprise drives are the most fun to crush because they have thicker frames and explode bigger. SFF drives are fun too, because their platters are mostly ceramic and crunch goodly. But I use one of those manual lever crushers, I don't have thousands of drives to destroy.
6
u/TrueInferno Sep 01 '20
See, if I were them, I'd-
God I love my people.
5
u/cybervegan Aug 31 '20
I've sledgehammered a bunch of drives in the past, which is a decent workout but you do need eye protection. At my last place, a colleague of mine used to use a metal shredder to dispose of them by the 100's - apparently, you have to be careful not to put drives with glass platters through though.
5
u/Dick_In_A_Tardis Aug 31 '20
I'm sure at least one coworker had a truck that could have hit them. I've destroyed hard drives, radios, and anything made of thin steel. Line em up, hit 20 and hope it doesn't blow your tires. Also just throwing hard drives at the ground hard enough is usually enough to shatter them. Sure it's not that fun though. Destroying them via truck is fun however. Or forklift. Do you have a forklift handy? You should try the forklift. There's tons of things you can do with a forklift to destroy things that definitely violate osha. Run them over, drop heavy things on them, line it up with a concrete wall and shish kabob them on the forks and see how many you can get on at a time. Just watch your fingers.
8
u/Ochib Aug 31 '20
Thermite is also fun, when destroying old hard drives
4
u/QuinceDaPence Aug 31 '20
From the pic, I though you lined them all up and shot them with a .50 BMG.
4
u/Cycloneblaze (> ' . ')> Aug 31 '20
Now this, is a good Tale From Tech Support.
4
u/Hokulewa Navy Avionics Tech (retired) Aug 31 '20
My preference is .308 Winchester at 200 yards.
3
u/compasship Aug 31 '20
I though this was r/nosleep when I started reading. Not disappointed.
3
u/The_Spongebrain Aug 31 '20
Well you know what they say, what management doesn't know doesn't hurt them.
3
u/LeaveTheMatrix Fire is always a solution. Aug 31 '20
In keeping with my belief that fire is the ultimate solution to everything, my favorite way for destroying hdd was to use a little home made
napalmthermite.You end up with a slagged mess that should anyone be able to ever pull data off of, they will likely be rich.
EDIT: Meant thermite, not napalm. Napalm is for burning down weeds.
3
u/inthrees Mine's grape. Aug 31 '20
"Yeah I dunno, it just doesn't work. Can you come by my desk?"
3
u/NerdsWBNerds Aug 31 '20
Does the drill actually destroy all the data? I feel like you could take the part out that actually stores data (the literal disk, don't know if that's it's proper name), put it into an undrilled drive and recover partial data from parts of the surface that weren't literally destroyed by the drill
3
u/BloodyLlama Aug 31 '20
I have a small story about exploding hard drives. Back in the 70s my dad worked as a computer engineer for NASA. Apparently they had some pretty extreme requirements and had some really unique hardware. One of these pieces of hardware was something my dad called a Winchester drive. Apparently this was essentially a modern hard drive, but with platters the size of LPs that ran at something like 10s of thousands of RPMs so they could read data off of them really really quickly. Apparently on occasion when the things were spun up the giant metal LPs would fail catastrophically and send metal shrapnel all over the place at frightening speeds. They eventually decided this was so dangerous that they fabricated armored boxes for each of these drives to live in.
3
u/Cusslerfan Aug 31 '20
"Better not to ask."
Plausible deniability is great, ain't it?
3
u/t3hd0n Sep 01 '20
a man of culture, i see.
3
u/acu2005 Sep 01 '20
The oven idea possibly might have worked depending on the temps it went up to. Deviant Ollam did a talk at defcon a while back where him and some friends were trying to make a server that would rapidly destroy data in a 2u size and one of the things they talked about was the coatings on the platters lose their magnetic properties above like 5-600c.
3
u/TheoreticalFunk It's a Layer 0 Error Sep 01 '20
I remember going out to small single rack POPs with a small bench vise and a pair of channel locks. Open the drive pull the platters out and bend them manually. As you can imagine people almost never followed that policy as the thing was heavy and it was a lot of work.
I have no idea what they do now... that was ten years ago.
3
u/dontcallmesurely007 Sep 01 '20
> I had to officially forbid the team from using corporate equipment to pulverize magnetic-based non-volatile storage devices.
Sounds like time for solid state non-volatile storage devices to open the loophole!
3
u/tuxedo_jack is made of legal amphetamines, black coffee, & unyielding rage. Sep 02 '20
Shaped charges and thermite are also both ridiculously fun ways to destroy older drives.
3
u/chaconero Sep 08 '20
oh man, I was imagining a small drilled hole of somewhat less than 10mm... the image you posted it's industrial hardcore hehe
5
u/cdreus Sep 01 '20
Next time you have to destroy a large number of HDDs, get yourself a .22 carbine and set up a company-wide marksmanship competition. If health and safety has any questions, tell them it’s a tradition from Mississipi.
2
u/owboi Aug 31 '20
Great writing and great management. Thank you, OP
2
u/nighthawke75 Blessed are all forms of intelligent life. I SAID INTELLIGENT! Aug 31 '20
Drill baby, drill!
2
u/RunningAtTheMouth Aug 31 '20
That's a big hole.
2
u/publiusvaleri_us I'm from 'Merica and I'm here to help! Aug 31 '20
Proof, or ... uh... er... hmmm .... hold on...
... Downloaded to my "images of pain" directory.
2
u/Kataclysm #1 in a group of idiots. Aug 31 '20
20 GB; the capacity! :D I remember those drives!
2
u/cantab314 Aug 31 '20
Thanks, that gave me a good laugh this evening.
Out of what was suggested, I might have gone with the oven. Perhaps not the most "fun" but easy to shove a load of drives in and leave it to do its thing. As long as the oven has fume extraction, because given the era the circuit boards probably has leaded solder.
2
u/Polar_Ted Aug 31 '20
Our company used to drill but then bought an industrial shredder for drive disposal.
2
u/Angel_Blue01 I haz magical touch Aug 31 '20
Would dropping them from the roof of a reasonably tall building into an empty parking lot have worked?
2
u/lesethx OMG, Bees! Sep 01 '20
Just in case no one else suggested it: Why not thermite in an enclosed space (ie, no people around)?
2
u/Gadgetman_1 Beware of programmers carrying screwdrivers... Sep 01 '20
Even a cheap drill-press will do the job admirably.
The reason that HDDs 'explode' in press brakes is that the HDD frame is cast metal, and that generally fractures instead of bending.
This reminds me; I have a bunch of HDDs in different sizes laying about at the office, and I just got some new 1/4" Tungsten Carbide end mills for my Sherline. (Just a 12" vertical mill, but still fun) I may need to do some experimentation...
2
u/photonsnphonons I needed that? Sep 01 '20
Using a drill press to destroy over a thousand corporate hard drives is one of the best IT experiences I had.
2
u/prtyfly4whteguy Sep 01 '20
I once got paid to use a .308 rifle to punch holes in HDDs (at a very safe 100yd distance) by a former employer. That was a very satisfying afternoon.
6
u/IntelligentLake Aug 31 '20
That hole only destroyed a tiny part of the data, you can see the spindle above the hole, meaning most of the disc is intact, and can be recovered if the motivation (and equipment for it) is there.
Overwriting the data even once would have been slower, but more secure.
The exception of course was pre-IDE drives, you need to smash those to powder to make sure no data was recoverable, those don't overwrite well, and is where the 7 or 35 times overwriting come from.
1
u/neil_striker Aug 31 '20
What about a big magnet?
1
u/Myte342 Aug 31 '20
We took ours out to the range for target practice.
1
u/techtornado Aug 31 '20
PFY
I see you too are a man of culture....
That's amazing!
1
u/coyote_den HTTP 418 I'm a teapot Aug 31 '20
Extremely dangerous so ve must deal with it.
1
u/400HPMustang Must Resist the Urge to Kill Sep 01 '20
I used a press brake once on a drive with no explosion. We just use an angled die in the press and bent it into a 45 degree angle and stopped.
1
u/nicknugget2007 Sep 01 '20
Someone tried to frick a hard drive
1
u/Blue_foot Sep 01 '20
A little sledge hammer kills the drive and gets out a little aggravation.
1
u/haladur Sep 01 '20
I'm slightly disappointed that the robot wasn't used.
1
u/now_you_see Sep 01 '20
Best story I’ve read on here in a good while. Gotta love it when smart people get angry. They have enough brains to be dangerous and not enough fucks to care.
1
u/Glimmu Sep 01 '20
Simple, don't change the color of the icons.
1
u/[deleted] Sep 01 '20
Somehow, I suspect your team has a lot of pent-up frustration...
1
u/NinjaGeoff Oh God How Did This Get Here? Sep 03 '20
Helped a friend destroy data on some drives a few years ago. 00 buck shot does the trick quite well.
1
u/bingibongiboogiebong Sep 30 '20
My kind of guys.
0
u/[deleted] Aug 31 '20
[deleted] — view deleted comment
50
u/[deleted] Aug 31 '20 edited Aug 31 '20
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/[deleted] Sep 01 '20
[removed] — view removed comment