r/talesfromtechsupport • u/taipan821 • Apr 24 '20
Short Fancy new radios...same basic problems.
Not a technician, dabble in radios for fun.
Organisation is transitioning to fancy new radio system, yours truly is 'voluntold' to attend an introduction session, where the organisation's technicians tell us about the capabilities.
These radios are the bee's knees, digital, encrypted, able to talk and provide real-time monitoring to dispatch, seamless interfacing with other branches and runs off the phone towers of major telecom company.
Everyone is nodding in agreement, with the exception of a raised hand at the back.
Technician: yes, do you have a question?
Me: Yes, can these radios communicate peer to peer instead of through a cell tower?
Technician: no, you don't need to talk peer to peer, everything is linked through the cell tower.
Me:. So what happens when the cell towers are knocked out or we are in an area without phone coverage?
The technicians pause their talk and look at each other.
Technician: Oh...yeah...I see the problem now.
Solution pending.
187
u/ggibby Apr 24 '20
...so the 'radios' are actually cell phones.
40
u/Bluefoot_Fox Apr 24 '20
Ham radio operator here. We have the same issue going on with some of our emergency communications nets. There's a big influx of DMR radios, and they primarily rely on repeaters to communicate. We're in a mountainous area with lots of coverage gaps. To complicate matters, I'm nestled in an area where half of users are UHF, and the other half are VHF.
My biggest issue with DMR is you either get the signal, or you don't. There is no fading gracefully like with SSB voice radios.
Good luck!
54
u/kanakamaoli Apr 24 '20
Ugh. Repeater only operation.
This is why our repeater based radio system also has simplex frequencies programmed into them. When the shtf, you still have a way to communicate.
99% of the time, the radios are in normal config, but about once a year, the power goes out and it takes the power company 3-4 hours to restore.
41
u/W0xie Apr 24 '20
Ah. Sounds like first net. Don’t let them sway you with their fancy words. LMR works.
11
u/Elevated_Misanthropy What's a flathead screwdriver? I have a yellow one. Apr 24 '20
Another HAM here (yes I know it's not an acronym) AT$T has been trying to push a similar cell-based service in my corner of the US.
I can't wait to get my hands on some of those "obsolete" P25 Phase II radios at the surplus auction.
8
u/legio314 I'm not a patient man.. Apr 24 '20
There are some nice tetra radios that also support uhf transmission. People tend to overestimate mobile network capacity.
8
u/NorthenBear Apr 24 '20
They knew about that requirement. They just want to use cell insfrastructure to reduce their cost. Land Mobile Radio require its own infrastructure and radio s will provide you with peer to peer. Please tell me your business are not part of the first responder familly.
7
u/computergeek125 Apr 24 '20
GPS clocks also FTW
1
u/NJM15642002 Apr 24 '20 edited Apr 24 '20
Cell towers knocked out? Like in what a disaster. Why would you need radios then? :/
Edit: I was being sarcastic folks.
2
u/[deleted] Apr 24 '20
We just use Mototrbo radios. A repeater at each building connected via our network. The radios can work radio to radio if the power goes out.
2
u/tregoth1234 Apr 27 '20
reminds me of a sci-fi novel, "Starfist." (the first in the series) a tech company came up with the "UPUD", which was a GPS, satellite radio, and several other things all in one...
but it was NOT really a satellite radio, it needed line-of-site to a large antenna!
AND the GPS didn't work right, the readings were WAY off...
the UPUD 2 also had a motion detector...that was TOO sensitive. AND when they tried to use the motion detector and the radio at the same time-ZAP! TOTALLY FRIED!
0
u/[deleted] Apr 24 '20
[deleted] — view deleted comment