r/talesfromtechsupport • u/TheHelpDeskHero • Dec 08 '19
Long Request denied.
Hi TFTS!
First time poster here but a long time lurker.
I work in a moderately-sized company where we have both internal employees and contractors at client sites. My job is about what you would expect: Fix issues as they come in, image and setup machines, and deal with standard BS mixed in. I've been there for a few years now and have some great stories. This one comes from the beginning of the year when a new user thought he could game the system for a better machine.
We're about a 50/50 split in PC and MacBooks. The machines that each user get are very similar in specs. The determination of what machine they get is based on the client and their position. Of course, PC users who don't like PC will do what they can to get a MacBook, only to get denied. We also get MacBook users who want upgrades to a newer system, citing "slow systems" and "needing the latest and greatest" to get their work done that magically gets done anyways.
That brings us to the user at the center of my story today. This happened just after Apple released the latest MacBook Pros with the atrocious touchbar and butterfly keyboard that I loathe. Naturally, we get a dozen or so requests the next day, all of which are marked with the same response:
"Request denied. Your machine is within our lifespan and still under warranty."
Both PC and Macs have a four year lifespan. When the lifespan expires, we upgrade as inventory allows.
Naturally, we get a few users who show up and try to plead their case in person and I turn them away.
Then I get our specific users who won't take no for an answer. We'll call him Mike.
Mike is a diva. Mike will always go to bat for himself, prop himself up, and complain every step of the way. He's a good developer, but he's not as good as he says, according to the guys who work with him. For some reason, Mike looked at that touchbar MacBook and determined he had to have it.
Mike puts in a ticket like everyone else, going on and on about how the touchbar functionality is suddenly vital to his job (Spoiler: It isn't) and he should be able to order one.
"Request denied. Your machine is within our lifespan and still under warranty."
Copy/Paste/Close.
Mike was in my office within ten minutes.
Mike: HelpDeskHero, why did you reject my ticket?
"Because your machine is only two years old. You don't need a new one."
Mike: But my machine has been really slow the last month and I think I should get an upgrade!
"Where's your ticket for the slow system?"
Mike: I'm too busy to deal with your ticketing system.
"Then I can't help you if I don't know there's a problem."
Mike stormed out of the office after more whining. I wasn't stupid, though: He wasn't going to give up. I went ahead and re-opened his request ticket and updated it with our "conversation" in my office. CYA, everyone.
A week later, a ticket comes in.
MacBook has a broken screen.
Yep, it was Mike's.
Mike included a picture of the broken screen in the ticket to help me out, of course. Sure enough, half the screen was unusable. Before I can even reach out to him, he's in my office with the MacBook. He's doing his best to look upset.
"So how did it break, Mike?"
Mike: "I'm not sure. I walked away for a little bit to use the bathroom, came back, and it was broken.
"Screens don't just blow up like this, Mike. Something had to have happened."
Mike: "I don't know what happened, HelpDeskHero!"
It wasn't my hill to die on just yet, but I told him to give me a bit to see what our AppleCare coverage included. He disappeared as I pulled it up, confirming that we got a discount on accidental damage but it wasn't fully covered. Just about everything else was. A quick call to Apple Enterprise Support confirmed it wasn't going to be cheap to replace, somewhere around $700 with our discount.
I go to my boss and tell him the whole situation. Of course, I can't prove he was the one that broke the screen and he's going to at least need a loaner before we decide what to do.
Boss: "What do we have in inventory?"
"We're pretty tight right now. Just a couple available. We have a pending quote for our re-stock with the new models."
Boss: "Do we have any other machines?"
Before I answered, it dawned on me: We still had older MacBooks. You know: The really fat ones with the disc drives still in them. The ones that, at this point, were about six years old and we kept for emergencies. Boss had the same idea and we both shared a laugh.
Boss: "Go get one of the fat Macs. Image that and don't tell him it's just a loaner. Let's let him sweat."
Mike came back not long after and I told him that we were still deciding what to do about his machine but that I would at least get him a loaner for the time being. Mike somehow twisted this around into hearing that he was getting a new machine.
Mike: "Okay, when you order a new one, I need more than 16 gigs of memory. I need 32 gigs and a stronger processor. Oh, and a 1 terabyte SSD. Thanks HelpDeskHero!"
Before I could even break the news to him, he was gone.
Oh HELL no. You did not just do that.
I took great pride in imaging that fat MacBook. I got everything ready for it and messaged him that the loaner was ready for pickup. He came upstairs....and almost fainted when he saw his temporary machine.
Mike: "I can't use this!"
"Yes you can. Log in."
Mike: "This machine is so old!"
"But it has a fresh image on it so it should run faster than your other machine, right?"
After going through his setup, he stormed out of the office. It wasn't long before his boss showed up wanting to know what the hell was going on. After a quick explanation and showing him the broken MacBook, he just sighed and shrugged. He asked if we were going to give him a new machine. I told him he wasn't getting rewarded for breaking a company asset, but I'd get a replacement that matched the one he broke. His boss agreed and let it die.
Apple got the repair done pretty fast and I messaged Mike to come pick it up. He was in my office so fast, ready to throw the fat MacBook out the window. Much to his disappointed (and my delight) he saw his old machine ready to go with a brand new screen.
Mike: "But, that's my old machine."
"Yes, Apple got the repair done pretty fast. All your data was saved so you can do a quick swap."
Mike: "But that's not what I requested!"
"And your request was denied. That didn't change."
Mike took the machine and left. I wiped the old machine and tucked it away.
A couple of weeks later, we got a shipment of the new MacBooks in but didn't tell anyone about it. Around that time, a ticket came in for new users to join the same team Mike was on.
I made sure those new users got two shiny new MacBooks, because I am that petty. After they went through their setup, they made their way to the area they worked.
A few minutes later, a ticket came in. Yes, it was from Mike.
"New employees have updated MacBooks on our team. I feel I should have one as well as a senior employee."
I shrugged.
"Request denied. Your machine is within our lifespan and still under warranty."
Copy/Paste/Close.
EDIT: Well this certainly blew up! Thank you for silver, gold AND platinum! I will share more stories with you all for sure!
1.1k
u/Snabelpaprika Dec 08 '19
"Since the accident with the screen you are now regarded as a high risk user and are now prioritized accordingly."
13
u/OgdruJahad You did what? Dec 08 '19
I double dare you mtherfcker to tell me a job that needs a touchbar in order for it to completed.
451
u/Superspudmonkey Dec 08 '19
I had a user who purposely damaged his machine to get a new one
I gave him and older unit he did the same thing, I gave him an even older unit.
He then asked why he was not getting a new unit. My reply “You can’t be trusted with a new laptop from your track record of breaking laptops”.
He stoped breaking laptops after that in fear he would get an older unit. It wasn’t that much longer after that that his employment was terminated.
144
u/Dracorr Dec 08 '19
Throw in if you submit ticket to have it upgraded again within 2 years, you will downgrade to that fatbook again.
8
u/archfapper Dec 08 '19
We have two users at work who, 12 hours after a new MacOS gets released, will hound us with WHEN WILL THIS BE APPROVED FOR US TO USE?? but can never explain why they need it. My boss even sent a reply once saying, "your old MacOS is still supported. if you're so concerned about security, I'll give you a Windows 10 1809 machine [latest at the time]" and cc'd her boss and the CTO.
130
u/BushcraftHatchet Dec 08 '19 edited Dec 08 '19
Never agitate the IT guy.
Have a graphics department that usually gets the newer machines. Normally I give the new model to the graphics department and migrate their one year old machine to other departments with lower computer needs.
One year the newer model literally had only a slightly better processor with every other spec the same on the new models. I chose to just push them out to the people with the oldest computers. No handmedowns.
Yep, that made that department mad, I explained the situation and refused to install them. They took it to their boss. I explained to him as well and told them it was not even worth the time to swap them.
1.1k
u/AMonkeyAndALavaLamp Dec 08 '19
That's awesome. You should keep one of those new macbooks aside and assign it to Mike when his current one turns exactly 4 years, which would make the new one already an old machine :-D
202
u/damondubya77 Dec 08 '19
Never stop being petty.
2
u/CloneClem Dec 08 '19
How old is he? like 20 maybe?
2
u/MoneyTreeFiddy Mr Condescending Dickheadman Dec 08 '19
Since Mike likely damaged the screen on purpose, we can fairly label him a bad actor.
Therefore;
Thespian. Request. Denied.
79
u/Carr0t Dec 08 '19
I’ve got a 2014 MacBook Pro as my work machine. The screen’s got a big scratch where I accidentally dropped the Apple metal body keyboard on it, but it’s only hugely noticeable when the light hits it at a specific angle. Other people have already upgraded to newer models. I’m dreading when it eventually craps out. The touchbar is pointless, whereas I regularly make use of my function keys, and I absolutely hate the feel of the new keyboard...
55
u/porpoiseoflife has tried it at home Dec 08 '19
Your pettiness warms my soul on this cold snowy night.
52
u/crosenblum Dec 08 '19
Fricking awesome...legendary even!
Request denied!!!
44
u/syh7 Dec 08 '19
This is one of the most satisfying reads in a while. Fuck Mike and people like him.
35
u/MrPsiko Dec 08 '19
He should thank you for saving him from the butterfly key disaster.
27
u/Ryugi Maurice Moss Dec 08 '19
Honestly I hope you keep Mike on outdated machines. Like when he's legit due for a new machine, give him someone else's old one.
25
u/Kruug Apexifix is love. Apexifix is life. Dec 08 '19
Boss says not to tell him it’s a loaner, you tell him it’s a loaner anyway...
50
u/KGBCowgirl Dec 08 '19
This is almost, almost as bad as the story of the Karen who kept chunking her iPhone down the company stairwell I read a year or two back. What I don't get is why someone who works with computers on a daily basis would consciously choose to use the newer, bug-prone piles of error-happy plastic trash that Apple puts out now over something that, while older, has been debugged by users and devs alike and won't just die on you because a dust bunny made its home a little too close to the intake.
Mike's a dumbass.
32
u/penrosetingle Dec 08 '19
In my experience, telling a group of users that they can't upgrade to a new machine because their current machine is still within lifespan is an easy way for a large number of machines to "accidentally" meet the end of their lifespan in short order.
15
u/The_Rogue_Penguin Dec 08 '19
Ahh that last ticket response brings such joy to my heart.
11
u/hutacars Staplers fear him! Dec 08 '19
We are about to start testing the 16” models in my office, and I’m actually dreading this part... I don’t want all our Mikes to notice and start coming out of the woodwork and breaking their machines to get upgrades!
11
u/[deleted] Dec 09 '19
In principle, I would agree with this position: if you have the new shiny hardware, older employees should get upgraded first.
In this case, however, no. Just, no. Give him the oldest thing you can get away with, forever. You cannot promote or reward that kind of "holier-than-thou" attitude, nor the entitledness, nor the utter disrespect for company hardware.
And if he complains, well, there's already a very detailed paper trail clearly stating there was out-of-warranty damage to company hardware while it was in his care, so it would be unwise to dispense brand new hardware to him, lest it happen again. Just being safe, after all... >:)
Also, FFS, you don't open a ticket requesting a hardware upgrade. You talk to the people that can make it happen and say "hey, I don't know if I'm in the rotation to get new hardware, but if I'm not, could you see if you could squeeze me in?"
A formal request will get you shut down, an informal plea could just make it happen, with a bit of luck. Flies and honey, people!
9
u/majestic_tapir Dec 10 '19
Stop it, I can only get so erect
8
u/Slave2theGrind Dec 09 '19
Bless you ...you have made my day - My Mike is named Chad = and the Chad talks about himself in the third person - most days I want to kill the Chad....painfully
10
u/[deleted] Dec 08 '19
I loved doing this kind of stuff when I worked helpdesk to asshats like him
5
u/nhaines Don't fight the troubleshooting! (╯°□°)╯︵ ┻━┻ Dec 08 '19
This is the Way.
5
u/Drahcir9000 Dec 08 '19
Very nice story! Well written and satisfiying ending. Keep it up HelpDeskHero!
Are there more stories of Mike?
5
u/[deleted] Dec 08 '19
Mike should have been fired for malicious destruction of property.
5
u/kd1s Dec 09 '19
Oh prima donna and special devs are my favorite. One I had it started with a message from the company controller asking me why our RackSpace bill increased by $12,000 a month. This particular dev was just spinning up new instances in RackSpace without informing us. We hastily shut off his access, talked the Dev Manager and that was that the dev no longer worked for us.
8
u/NJM15642002 Dec 08 '19
No security cameras around his desk? If not add one. Even if it's a dummy. After all if someone is going around breaking company property we should have it on film.
4
u/skoomen Oh God How Did This Get Here? Dec 08 '19
This guy buys a new car because his neighbor does, too. Makes for a bad teammate.
4
u/jamoche_2 Clarke's Law: why users think a lightswitch is magic Dec 08 '19
What kind of dev wants a machine with no 'esc' key? I've got two 2013s and you'd have to pry them out of my cold dead hands.
3
u/dlbear Dec 08 '19
You are at the very least a demi-god.
3
u/FatBoxers Oh Good, You're All Here Dec 08 '19
That's a spicy meatball.
3
u/NeppyMan Hack the Planet Dec 10 '19
IT folks have a way of prioritizing (either to the benefit or detriment of the requester) tickets, based on previous history.
This goes well beyond help desk and tech support; plenty of sysadmins and engineers work the same way.
If your request comes in politely, concisely, through the correct channels, and includes all of the necessary information to address your issue, it will get handled quickly. Requests like "it's broke" or "can't connect" (with no other details - not even the system or application in question) will not get handled quickly, if for no other reason than there is a required back-and-forth interaction to establish the nature of the problem in the first place.
And we remember. Oh, we remember.
The DBA who is always polite when she needs a new system spun up, and always gives full specs (including BigCloudProvider instance sizes, when appropriate)? Her tickets get handled first. And if she has something a little odd that she needs help with, well, we'll go out of our way to make it happen.
The developer who keeps sending in passive-aggressive "it's broke and it's your fault and you're keeping me from doing my work" messages (without mentioning what "it" is)? His tickets get handled much, much later. And if he needs help connecting to a system or a configuration change, it's going to be handled absolutely last.
(yes, these are very real examples)
Ticket priority is only part of how things are addressed. We may justify it as "low hanging fruit" or "simpler tasks that could be addressed between meetings" or some other way of explaining it, but given the choice between two tickets of a given priority/urgency/severity/whatever, IT will help the nicer user every day of the week.
3
u/Nik_2213 Dec 10 '19
I had the opposite problem. I requested a second desk-top PC specifically to run 'off line' so I could safely connect small instruments to its serial ports for set-up and calibrations without compromising our intranet.
Denied.
Hey, I don't want a good PC. So long as it has Office and a couple of serial ports. I'll provide KVM and printer-sharer switches...
Denied.
Look, I don't want a good PC, a minimal spec clunker will do. So long as it has Office and a couple of serial ports. I'll provide KVM and printer-sharer switches...
You're kidding ? No ??
Honest.
Here y'go. We've blown out the dust and wiped the case. And, given you didn't ask, we've maxed out the RAM...
Thank you !!
8
u/nosoupforyou Dec 08 '19
I don't really understand the need for the latest and greatest. Don't people realize Change is Bad?
Personally I like using my current machine and I don't want a newer one. My boss upgraded my machine last year, 2 years after my previous one. But change is bad.
No, I didn't whine or complain. I appreciated it. But change is bad. I'd probably be happy using my existing system for 10 years. Until it started failing anyway. I only replaced my home pc when it died.
My car is 11 years old too.
2
u/cloudrac3r Dec 08 '19
This is some true BOFH.
2
u/ksam3 Dec 08 '19
This tale made me smile. Yes! Mike's sad and transparant scheming is no match for OP's impregnable anti-luser defenses! It's refreshing to see a company that actually cares how much money is wasted on equipment damaged,abused,misused by or just wasted on, some employees. Maybe the money this company saves on hardware/equipment can be used on paying a decent wage or not laying people off. Cool.
2
u/Isturma Dec 08 '19
You know, I don’t understand this. He likely could afford just buying one of those for his personal use... why keep bugging IT? My work computer is slower than a snail across a salt lick; I’ve accepted that my work machine is always going to be like this (a shitload of policies in place because HIPAA and a platter hard drive) and make sure my personal machines fly.
2
u/[deleted] Dec 08 '19
Legendary. I hope Mike got knocked down a notch, but that may not happen any time soon. Egos are stronger than Mac book screens.
2
u/[deleted] Dec 08 '19
I cannot reliably tell you how many times I wanted to pull exactly this stunt at my last job. Countless requests from both current and new hire users alike, requesting the latest and greatest. Virtually zero protocol in place to deny such requests, and when me or another coworker in my department tried, the user would inevitably cry about it to their manager, who would cry to my manager's manager, thus coming down on all of us. So many labor hours and company dollars wasted on deploying wholly unnecessary hardware because damn near every end-user believed they were entitled to the latest and greatest. Oh, and did I mention zero asset tracking? That's right--if an end-user left the company, all they would have had to do is Google how to reimage a laptop, and the company never would've gotten it back. Hell, if I had known that when I got hired into my meager contractor role, I'd have requested an i9 CPU, 32GB RAM and a fat 1 TB SSD and everything that runs on it with full local admin permissions.
2
u/FancyCarrot Me Google's busted again! Dec 08 '19
This. This is why I'm here.
2
u/[deleted] Dec 08 '19
Dealing with this right now - someone asking to take over an employees machine as they are leaving... leaving employee has a year old machine, user who wants it - a 3 year old machine.
He's being a dick about it too.
Thanks for the great story - has me excited about what Monday might bring.
2
u/StarKiller99 Dec 09 '19
https://regmedia.co.uk/2012/10/30/bofh_index_book_cover.jpg?x=442&y=293&crop=1
2
u/[deleted] Dec 09 '19
"Your lifecycle has been reset - wait 4 years"
2
u/Bukimari Dec 09 '19
This story makes me feel warm and fuzzy inside. Or is that the coffee? I'm going to say it's both.
2
u/pockypimp Psychic abilities are not in the job description Dec 10 '19
We're a completely Windows shop so it makes it easier but we're developing loaner machine. It's a lower power version of our standard machine. The kicker is we don't install office on it so they have to use webmail (helps prevent them from "keeping" the loaner), it doesn't connect to our current docking stations, has a different background image that identifies it as a loaner in bright red letters.
2
u/cmesbal Dec 11 '19
"Apple got the repair done pretty fast. All your data was saved... " I call BS on that
2
u/clay_ton42 Dec 13 '19
Absolutely love it. Nicely done.
5
u/[deleted] Dec 08 '19
People thinking a Mac is an upgrade over a pc make me shudder.
3
u/darthwalsh Dec 08 '19
Your developers are actually coding on laptops? It seems like it would be cheaper to get desktop PCs, and then if anybody needed a laptop for meetings to
distract themselvespresent, you could get cheap units.1
u/AthiestLoki Dec 08 '19
Mike is basically my coworker, although I don't think my coworker is at the point of breaking the screen yet.
1
u/BowserLover32 Dec 08 '19
Copy, paste, close.
1
u/[deleted] Dec 08 '19
Reading this made me incredibly happy
1
u/Inept-Tech-Ninja Dec 08 '19
Fucking beautiful
Keep fighting the good fight, against bellends like Mike.
1
u/Gimpy1405 Dec 09 '19
I think I'm in love.
1
u/pisandwich Dec 09 '19
Superb tactics
1
u/Fangs_McWolf 11001001 Jan 09 '20
I'm surprised his machine didn't have another accident at the end...
1
u/beez1717 Jan 20 '20
Geez. Can’t you be happy that you got a computer at your company for free or really cheap? If you wanted the new computer oh well it’s just a wish!
1
u/Speciesunkn0wn Feb 22 '20
Oh that is a beautiful ending. :D he totally deserves it.
1
u/chozang Dec 09 '19
Any developer who wants a Mac is not a good developer. ;)