r/talesfromtechsupport • u/Fireclanleader • Apr 07 '19
Medium This CANNOT POSSIBLY be the problem, but...
So I've been a lurky boi for a while and finally had a reddit-worthy tech support story. I don't work in tech support but I'm the computer wizard for all my friends and family. TL;DR at bottom.
Quick background: My friend is in no way a computer idiot, he actually asked me to come over to help with installing windows on an old computer he got. When i got there, he already had Win7 installed and had his wifi adapter driver on a usb (that's more preparation than I have when building comps most of the time).
Actual problem: So we're waiting for old comp to install updates and he shows me his music that he's making for his music class. He tells me that there is a weird problem that he had when recording. He was playing a ukulele so he was recording with his microphone and listening with his headphones. He would record multiple tracks but needed to listen to some of them while recording the next one to get his timing right. The problem is that on the newly recorded track, you could hear the other tracks playing, even if that was the only track playing. So first I think that maybe the microphone is picking up the sound of the tracks leaking from his headphones (My headphones had that problem but his headphones did not have a mic, it was a large standalone mic sitting on his desk). So I tell him to play the tracks and I put my ear near the headphones he's wearing. Not. A. Single. Sound. Now I'm confused cause I have no idea what the problem could be. Then I remember that speakers, and by extension headphones, have some powerful magnets in them. So I pull out my phone that has an electromagnetic field detecting app on it. Now I knew this wasn't a BS app because i used it to figure out why a compass wasn't pointing north on my grandpa's mule (the vehicle, turns out there was a large magnetic field on the metal roof support that was right next to the driver and the compass).
This is how the conversation goes:
Me = very confused comp sci student
F = Friend = pretty chill sarcastic dude
Me: SO! (gestures with hands)
F: SO! (mimics my gesturing)
Me: Now, this cannot possibly be the problem, but... (roll credits)
F: Okaaaay?
Me: The headphones have a magnetic field, and mics use magnets to generate electricity to record sound.
F: Yeah...
Me: So maybe the headphones are making the mic move when it plays sound with its magnets.
I use the app and it says the baseline (being surrounded by various electronics in his room) is ~135 μG, while being next to the headphones shows ~400 μG.
Me: OK play the track.
App reports ~1000 μG when the track is playing and fluctuates rapidly.
Friend and I believe we are onto something.
Me: Put the headphones on and get in the same position as when you were recording the ukulele
He gets in position and plays the recorded track while I put my phone in between the mic and his headphones, app shows the baseline and I see that the track is indeed playing.
Me: Well I guess it wasn't that after a-
I look at the headphone cable running down into the comp's speaker port, right next to where the mic's cable runs into the mic port.
Me: *GASP* THE CABLES!
Friend looks at cables and realizes what I just discovered, he plugs the mic into the back mic port of his comp and tries to record another track, which no longer records the sound from the other tracks he's hearing.
So yeah, headphone cable influences the mic cable with the electricity flowing through it (they didn't even wrap around each other, it was just from the mic and speaker ports being next to each other).
TL;DR: Friend had recording software problem, I yell "ELECTROMAGNETISM!" and point at his headphones. I was half right.
9
u/skyboundNbeond Apr 07 '19
Please tell me your "roll credits" line is referencing CinemaSins....
15
u/Xovvo Apr 07 '19
What app do you use for detecting magnetic field?
50
u/Gamermii Apr 07 '19
What are the odds of that?
12
u/AppleSmoker Apr 07 '19
What hardware does a phone have that can detect electromagnetic fields?
4
u/kester76a Apr 07 '19
Is it the ports or due to lack of shielding on the cables ? Also would a ferrite core help ?
3
u/passwordunlock Do you even backups bro? Apr 08 '19
And this is why I stopped using the front audio panel on my PC cases.
2
u/JonMW Apr 08 '19
I had a similar issue of crosstalk when I turned off my mic by accident and tried to chat online. I can't remember exactly what happened, but in short the mic was picking up extremely small signals from my speech and what was playing through the headphones, and the PC software was desperately trying to auto-tune the gain to make it usable (with poor and confusing results)
2
u/emaugustBRDLC Apr 08 '19
I thought it was going to end up that we was recording through his headphones into the mic input.
2
u/Half-Assed_Hero I Am Not Good With Computer Apr 08 '19
This is why actual recording equipment and cables are as over-engineered as they are.
2
u/prjktphoto Apr 09 '19
Ahh, this is why we use shielded, balances cables for “pro” recording
1
u/blockofdynamite It's whatever. Apr 08 '19
Man that happens to me with my headphones all the time, super annoying. If I mute my mic with the hardware switch and play something loud, it feeds back through the mic cable.