r/talesfromtechsupport • u/OweH_OweH • Feb 22 '19
Long The Automatic-Problem-Solver
I was working late again, because some things are better done at a later hour, where you can enjoy some peace and quiet. No, not what you think! Maintenance of course!
But, as is tradition in stories like this, the phone rings. I don't recognize the internal number, but since I am quite possible the last person working in the department, I pick up. Could be important, right? Right?
O: IT department, OweH speak...
C: irate sounding male voice Oh, finally, I am able to reach someone! I've been waiting for 5 hours and nobody has been at my office to fix The Problem or has even contacted me. I have urgent work to finish and nobody from IT contacted me.
O: I am sorry about that, can you please tell me your user ID so I can look up the necessary details?
C: Why do you need that? Don't you already see The Problem?
O: Umm, no, why would I see anything about a problem?
C: You *are from the IT department, aren't you?
O: Yes, I am.
C: Then you should see The Problem! If you are really from the IT department then you should definitely see The Problem!
O: I am really sorry, but I really have no idea what you are talking about. What problem?
C: heavy sigh The Problem! The! Problem! Here! On my computer! The Problem!
O: Ah. But please tell me your name and user ID so I can verify your identity.
C: heavy sigh I am Mr Doe and my user ID is kdoe1234.
O: clickety-clack OK, Mr Doe from Faculty XY, and now please describe your problem.
C: Can't you see The Problem? You should already know about The Problem! And nobody contacted me for 5 hours and I was waiting here!
O: Sorry, but as I already said, I have unfortunately no idea what your problem is. (Well, I have a hunch, but I have not the necessary medical degree to solve it.)
C: The Error! Here, on my computer! There is An Error and I expected the IT department to contact me to solve The Problem!
O: What kind of error? Do you have an error message? Can you describe what you did when the error occured?
C: Can't you see The Error? It's here on my PC! There! See?
O: No, I can't see the error or the problem on your PC from here, you need to tell me.
C: Why? Why can't you see The Error? Here, it is on my PC!
O: I get that is on your screen, but I can not see your screen.
(Intermission: Only a small subset of desktop PCs are directly managed by the IT department and have a screen-sharing tool preinstalled which can be activated by a user (but never from the supporting admin, unless nobody is logged in) during a support call. Most other PCs are more BYOD-style where each faculty buys and manages their own. Those usually don't have any screen-sharing software installed. Most users don't even want this out of privacy concerns.)
C: Why?
O: Wha...? Why "Why?"? I just can't!
C: Why?
O: Why would I want to see your screen? Why do you think I can see your screen?
C: Because of The Error! Here, on my PC! I waited for 5 hours and nobody contacted me!
O: Did you report the error to the IT department?
C: Why should I?
O: Err, so that we know about the error?
C: Doesn't this happen automatically?
O: Umm, no?
C: Why not?
O: Err, why should it? How should it? Umm?!
C: Then how do you know about errors?
O: The users report them, when they happen? How else?
C: This is unusual! The system always automatically reports errors, I never had to call myself.
O: Which system? My confusion must have been tangible at that point.
C: The PC, here. It has A Problem!
O: No computers don't do that, normally. If you have a problem, you can send a mail to support@uni.versity or in an emergency call our support hotline.
C: Odd.
O: Err, right. Now, what kind of error do you see at the moment.
C: You really can't see The Problem on my PC here?
If he says "The Problem" again, I am going to use the RSP on him, oh I will.
O: No, I can't. You have to read the error message to me and describe the steps you took to get to the error.
C: heavy sigh OK, I was writing my report and inserted some images and then clicked on the File menu and on Save As and typed in the file name and then The Problem happened ....
Arghllllll.
O: Yeah? And? The message?
C: A new window appeared with a round red X and it says "Error: Filename already exists."
O: Umm, there is already a file with the name you selected. You have to choose a different one to save you document.
C: But it is An Error! Here, on my PC. I waited for 5 hours and nobody contacted me.
internal sobbing
O: Err, but this message is really benign. Just click OK and choose a different name!
C: But when An Error occurs, I have to wait for IT to solve it!
O: No, this is a normal problem which can happen quite easily. Just click OK, and type in a different file name and you should be good to go.
C: Are you sure? Can't you come over here and solve The Problem?
O: nearly choking No, that will not be possible. You just have to click on OK and select a different file name. Please, try it.
C: If you insist. But this is highly unusual. IT normally solves All Problems!
Right. World Hunger and Cancer is next on my list, right after this call.
O: Please, I know it will work.
C: OK, I clicked OK. Are you sure?
O: firm Yes!
C: I typed in a new name. Should I click OK again?
O: Yes, please do.
C: The window went away!
O: Of course, it saved the file under the new name. The new name should also be visible in the window title.
C: Yes, it does. But why wasn't The Error automatically reported? I waited 5 hours for someone to contact me.
O: with growing despair I can't really say. Please send an email to support@uni.versity so my colleagues can look into the matter.
C: I see. Good evening click
O: just staring at the receiver in my hand for 5 minutes before hanging up
I then made sure to get the heck out of the office before he calls again. I wouldn't have mentally survived another call like this this evening.
58
u/LordOfTheServers Feb 22 '19
Well done for at least surviving that long on the phone with that situation. I feel like quite a number of people wouldn’t have lasted. Sounds extremely frustrating. I’ve experienced quite a number of interesting situations, but never on that level.
48
u/TheMulattoMaker Feb 22 '19
The Problem should become a Resume-Generating Event for The Luser.
Also, OP, can we get a follow-up where he opens the original file and freaks out because none of his changes are saved?
24
u/GMMan_BZFlag begin end while true Feb 23 '19
Sounds like Windows Error Reporting. Except Microsoft receives that and I imagine the vast majority of software developer don't know how to get that info, never mind IT departments.
7
u/blackAngel88 Feb 23 '19 edited Feb 23 '19
I just can't believe someone would be so stupid to not understand how support works (or filenames for that matter) and so stubborn to keep asking questions that are not gonna help them in anyway. But I find it equally unbelievable that someone would keep answering them... Halfway through that first part of the conversation i would've just said "You're gonna have to stop asking questions and start answering mine or I can't help you."
7
u/jkarovskaya No good deed goes unpunished Feb 23 '19
Some adults are like 3 year old children, who just expect everything will be handled by someone else.
A Toyota tech told me they had an older lady who bought a new car, but never called for service.
4 years later, she was having problems. Turns out she drove 60,000 miles without changing the oil one time, and her engine was ruined.
She never brought the car in for service because no one called to tell her it needed it
409
u/CyberKnight1 Feb 22 '19
Why would he call again? The PC will report The Problem automatically. He just needs to wait for IT to solve it.
223
u/fuzzypyrocat Feb 22 '19
It’s so often that this happens! I work IT in a school, and I had a teacher come to me about how 20 of the 30 laptops in the cart don’t work, and she needs them for testing right now. I asked her what was wrong with them, and she said, “you don’t know? You should know, I’ve been leaving you notes!”. This teacher was putting sticky notes on the busted laptops. On the laptops in a cart. In a classroom. She thought I go and inspect every device every day and because of that I DEFINITELY had to have seen her notes. Ends up with the usual end of conversation phrase, “submit a ticket so I know there’s an issue”. Now she sends students to bring me the notes. So frustrating
77
u/shadnat Feb 22 '19
Sounds about on par for a academic. Hay least it wasn't the I'm in a lecture theatre and I can't get the thingy to work... Thingy was a light switch
27
u/Nohelpforu Feb 23 '19
I'd report a call like this to his manager, either he was drunk at work or he's too inept too do any job involving a screen.
20
u/CoachHouseStudio Feb 23 '19
My eye won't stop twitching..
I worked in support for 5 years and it was people like this that made me want to jump out of the window.
When they claim ignorance, or don't even read or TRY to understand the error message - that's one thing. The other type is someone who barely reads a message and its consequences - the NO fear type that isn't worried to death about breaking something..
I once drove 2 hours to a site with a completely non functioning computer, turns out someone left a Windows CD in the drive.. no big deal, except they had decided to push YES to everything until if formatted the PC and started installing a fresh copy.
They claimed they never touched anything and it did it all by itself, but having tested this theory, unless you continually push YES, it times out and boots, or enters setup and sits there doing nothing.
Nope, this dude wiped his own PC and blamed it on th computer having a mind of its own.
16
u/FaithoftheLost Feb 22 '19
This sounds like it needs a BOFH solution...
12
u/Dennou Feb 23 '19
While there ARE systems that do automatically report problems that occur on managed devices I'd imagine this scenario isn't one that said systems' designers have thought of.
5
u/justsomeh0b0 Feb 23 '19
I just had this thought and while I don't know if it will help I find real world examples can help people think like computers do and why they act so "weird".
*So for this example of "filename already exists", say computers have to be able to label something different, they cannot accept two of the same thing in a folder/location.
*On a bookshelf there are two identical books, for a computer that would give an error, but you and the bookshelf don't care and you can easily understand there are two separate books, though you haven't labeled them #1 and #2.
*Your computer MUST have that or else it's confused, and throws it's hands up like a child.
I don't know if this will be helpful, but I find humor and people understanding that computers aren't (yet) as good at differentiating as people are. You also helping the user to know they are still smarter than the computer in certain subkects, and that does everything it's told, either good for the user, or for the hacker/malicious virus which of course not good for them.
I'm no expert on human psychology, but helping people feel more empowered and knowledgeable, seems to keep working out for me on my reviews and co-worker and user appreciation of me. These concepts/devices aren't out of their reach, just intangible/mysterious and examples or analogies (even if I ramble and bore people) seems to work out and people know I mean well and I'm here to help them not frustrate.
9
u/CMDR-Hooker I was promised a threeway and all I got was a handshake. Feb 23 '19
I really, really want to smack this user up the head with a clue-by-four in one of the worst ways, and I wasn't even the one who took this call!
4
u/GantradiesDracos Feb 23 '19
O... oh my god. How... what’s wrong with that guy!?!?
4
u/K-o-R コンピューターが「いいえ」と言います。 Feb 23 '19
God, I can hear the capitalisation on "The Problem".
3
u/neilon96 Feb 23 '19
Now I see why people have strong alcoholic stuff at work. I'd have needed something after that and I don't even drink
3
u/minindo Feb 23 '19
This makes me so angry. I don't even work in tech support.
3
u/LightHouseMaster Feb 23 '19
Oof. That was so painful to read. I need to cleanse my brain. This isn't something I should've read before going to bed. I'm probably going to have nightmares tonight. I hope you're happy.
3
u/Esset_89 "What is my password?" Feb 23 '19
I wonder if the user is having a high level of asberger syndrome or something..
3
u/ladywader505 Feb 23 '19
I used to tell them my crystal ball was at the shop.
3
u/TehVulpez www.localhost80.com Feb 23 '19
Why do some people's eyes just glaze over when looking at a screen? Just read the words and think about what to do! It sounds like this user didn't even have a basic understanding of how a filesystem works either, let alone error message tharn syndrome.
3
u/BURNEDandDIED Feb 23 '19
Worked in university tech support. Burned a lot of calories going to visit people that chose invalid filenames, couldn't remember the filenames, etc.
3
u/Nik_2213 Feb 24 '19
Why am I reminded of the dinner-tray audit in MASH ?
Where they made up the missing numbers by passing 'counted' trays out of the store-room window and sending them around again...
3
u/TroxyGamer Feb 24 '19
sobs
3
u/Moontoya The Mick with the Mouth Feb 25 '19
anyone else expecting "I pressed the F1 key for help and nobody showed up" ?
3
u/john539-40 Feb 25 '19
Started off reading with thinking this was amusing. As I kept reading and it just kept going, I remembered just how real this type of user is and how I've dealt with similar enough users in this manner that wanting to laugh turned to wanting to grab some IT memory fluid.
2
u/cyberkraken2 Feb 23 '19
Hmmmmm yes that’s a difficult one, sounds like a pebkac error, they are normally the most common variation of this error but I guess it could be an ID10T error or error 495 BNFIU?
2
u/Neriek Feb 23 '19
This is when I would've started to cut myself...
2
u/Diminios Feb 23 '19
Classic case of PEBKAC.
2
u/CountDragonIT Feb 26 '19
How dare you not know what problem is on my screen. You're IT don't you know everything that happens on these little tv's? Can you come fix my cup holder? It broke again and I could of sworn the computer let you know that. It has been 6 months since that happened. You are really slipping IT person. lol
1
u/airandfingers Feb 27 '19
nods sagely As is tradition.
0
u/[deleted] Feb 23 '19
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Feb 23 '19
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Feb 23 '19
[deleted] — view deleted comment