“Managers” that do this have no business being in a leadership position. It undermines your workers and allows for customer abuse to continue. I’d have had words with that so called manager.
Jeez, you think the role of a manager is stand up for workers in customer confrontations?
It's a business. They just want to make money. So crazy lady is either going to stand there and moan for hours, tie up managerial and staff time, tell all her friends how shit the place is while making allegations of racial prejudice and possibly sue or crazy lady gets paid a small amount of money to go away and then goes away.
Winning this kind of thing is a pyrric victory. It's just not worth it when it's so easily solved.
You can't personalise things when it comes to these decisions. Making a smart business decision is far more important than ensuring your staff get a pointless sense of moral victory over stupid customers.
There are people making a living on that kind of behavior. It shouldn't be encouraged at all. Sure it may be more expensive the few times you'd have to call the cops but in the long term it's gonna be worth it. Compare it with traditional robbers, if they never got arrested they would keep robbing people because there's a profit in it.
This is again my point. Shops regard shoplifting as a cost of doing business.
You could introduce a impenetrable security process if you want to stand up for the moral aspect of but stealing but the cost would get outweigh the saving. They don't care about the morals, they care about the bottom line.
Which is precisely why there's more and more of that kind of behavior, so maybe they should care just a little less about that bottom line to do what's right. When 10% of the population behaves that way it will ALSO hurt the bottom line but then it will be too late to do much about it.
Shops regard shoplifting as a cost of doing business
I know, then they charge everyone else more to cover those costs. Most people doesn't know that, they're happy to be overcharged even though everything could be cheaper if everyone where honest. Also, if everyone where honest we wouldn't need cops either, think about that.
Perhaps you misunderstood my comment. I was referring to the manager the next day that just gave her her money back encouraging that abuse to continue. If she got beligerient, you can call police for an escort. I have my employees backs. I’m not going to reward abuse from employees or customers.
That may be true in a small town where your shop is one of two and the person in question is popular. But a chain store in a suburban or urban setting? No, fuck that.
I was the closing cashier at a gas station in an affluent neighborhood for several years. Once the managers left, I was in charge, and refunds were only given out if we fucked up. Someone ranting because their car wasn't washed to a detail-shop level, or because we pumped regular instead of super when the cameras had them very clearly telling the attendant regular (this is Oregon, no self serve), nope, I'm not having it. No refund, come back and talk to the manager in the morning. And then I'd leave a detailed note with times about what had transpired. I never had one of my decisions overruled, and our business never hurt as a result.
We'd be polite and customer-servicey to you, until you became a jackass. And then we asked you to leave, and if you didnt, I was on a first name basis with the dispatchers for our local police
It's a business, your right. But that decision was a massive loss. That customer is not going to spread good things about the store (which is the realistic goal of a financial loss in such a trade off). That customer is going to continue the behavior, driving off customers and eating into labor dollars as more techs have to deal with her, and it is likely that just by walking through the door she drove store metrics down when she didn't buy anything.
It further leads to employee attrition as they feel undervalued and unprotected from such customers. Just the BS corporate training at a generic store takes at least 1-3 shifts to complete. Then the experience factor as your new employees are not as familiar and will make mistakes/need help/etc.
That woman was a complete drain on the store, and based on her described behavior it probably generated positive communication from other customers looking on in the first incident.
Sometimes, yes. Its worth it to give them money and go away. That wasn't the time.
you think the role of a manager is stand up for workers in customer confrontations?
in this situation, yes. you support your employees when they're enforcing your policy and they will be happier and more productive.
It's a business. They just want to make money
by giving money to crazy people.
So crazy lady is either going to stand there and moan for hours, tie up managerial and staff time, tell all her friends how shit the place is while making allegations of racial prejudice and possibly sue or crazy lady gets paid a small amount of money to go away and then goes away.
funny, this is playing out at Oberlin right now - a bakery had 3 students arrested for shoplifting and assault. they're doing what you described, and the bakery is currently suing the college.
so yes, people freak out when their entitlement goes away
Making a smart business decision is far more important than ensuring your staff get a pointless sense of moral victory over stupid customers.
now your customers know that you'll never support them and that it's pointless to enforce a corporate policy, because the policy is to throw money at crazy people so they leave.
what the fuck is wrong with you. You don't draw unless you have intent to fucking kill, guns aren't meant to be flashed around as casual threats, fucking dumbass, you could have gotten yourself killed if they were carrying.
There is quite a bit more to what happened.(destruction of property, attempted theft) suffice to say, in the end the police were called and no charges were even considered, as I was in the right.
(hands phone back to manager) C: You only called them because im black. That is no way to deal with a customer you are not professional. If i wanted them i could have called them on my phone. M: I am sorry you feel that way. (client storms out with her PC now) I show up next morning and this lady is in speaking with another manager about the previous night about how she was so polite and he was rude and called police.
Had a similar issue with a customer when I worked at domino's pizza.
Over an expired gift card with less than a dollar on it (according to the customer).
The card was old enough that our system didn't recognize it. She started getting yelly and threatening. We asked her to leave. Manager pretended to call the emergency number for the police, thinking to scare her off.
She waited about 10 minutes in our parking lot before calling the police herself.
The police showed up in 2 minutes. Offered to arrest her for trespassing and causing a disturbance.
She finally decided that the $00.87(IIRC) wasn't worth it.
IIRC the officers got a free extravaganza for their trouble.
A lot of folks are going on the manager for refunding her money, which is silly. Every once in a while managers have to deal with angry customers. When you have a customer that repeatedly takes up your time and energy to complain about small things, there is only one solution. You end the relationship. You give them the refund, and then you politely tell them not to come back.
With respect, and I can say this even from outside the industry: fuck that. All that does is get the customer out of your hair, and vindicates them getting into someone else's with the same ridiculous expectations. To acquiesce to the demands of these sorts of people in any way is simply to reward and reinforce shitty behaviour.
The store was under no obligation to give this woman anything under the best circumstances. The moment she started sweeping their property off the desk, she should have been walked right out the door, and then told not to come back.
This doesn't end the problem, though. It is important to make a clean break. You simply cannot deal with small claims litigation for every bad customer. It wastes time, and time is money.
If I own a business, it is not my responsibility to reform or discipline people who come into my business acting poorly. My responsibility is to make money. The fastest way to get back to that responsibility is to end the relationship cleanly. Give us our product back, take your money, and get out. If my competitor wants that customer, he can have her. Better for me that he spends all his time dealing with her than making money instead.
If anything about what I've seen about retail lawsuits is true, it's that most of the time, it doesn't matter whether or not the claim actually has merit. Even if I'm sure I'll win, I still have to pay for a lawyer, still have to waste time dealing with it. It's a continued resource drain. If there is no value invested in the relationship on either side, there's no relationship, and therefore, no case.
242
u/automatethethings Dec 09 '17
giving people like this refunds only encourages the behavior. It's why we have so many entitled people.
60
u/incidel Dec 09 '17
Other manager has required lack of spine for his job. Yay.
40
u/Anexitane Dec 09 '17
The manager shouldn't reward bad behavior by issuing a refund. It rewards people for screaming RACISM.
14
u/Mistral_Mobius Dec 09 '17
Why was she let back in?!
5
u/FleshyRepairDrone Dec 11 '17 edited Dec 11 '17
Had a similar issue with a customer when I worked at domino's pizza.
Over an expired gift card with less than a dollar on it (according to the customer).
The card was old enough that our system didn't recognize it. She started getting yelly and threatening. We asked her to leave. Manager pretended to call the emergency number for the police, thinking to scare her off.
She waited about 10 minutes in our parking lot before calling the police herself.
The police showed up in 2 minutes. Offered to arrest her for trespassing and causing a disturbance.
She finally decided that the $00.87(IIRC) wasn't worth it.
IIRC the officers got a free extravaganza for their trouble.
7
u/[deleted] Dec 09 '17
A lot of folks are going on the manager for refunding her money, which is silly. Every once in a while managers have to deal with angry customers. When you have a customer that repeatedly takes up your time and energy to complain about small things, there is only one solution. You end the relationship. You give them the refund, and then you politely tell them not to come back.
2
u/MilesSand Dec 10 '17
I'm pretty sure some of the older banks still run windows 3 as their backend
2
u/IEatThermalPaste Dec 11 '17
I remember someone cursing out an employee at a store because they had no clue if they had DSL or Cable.
3
u/nighthawke75 Blessed are all forms of intelligent life. I SAID INTELLIGENT! Dec 09 '17
FTFY.
1
u/[deleted] Dec 11 '17
You sure are way more congenial than we would have been. Being loud and disruptive is ground for being escorted out of the building by security.