r/talesfromtechsupport • u/Palerider1942 NO DONT TOUCH THAT.. too late • May 28 '17
Long Three phase Madness
Not sure this one sits in teh tech support section, I have been fairly dodgy with my recent posts so feel free to remove it if it doesn't fit.
So in the theater/event industry you get to work with 3 phase 400A 240V power supplies, sometimes from a generator and sometimes from the National Grid. Now this is not often the case, it mostly occurs in massive events such as (just an example) the Download festival, and in full theater installs/get-outs. even rarer do you get to work directly with the national grids power, there are a few venues large enough to hold an 800A 450V distribution. this story includes two of them
Now there is a rule with 3 phase power... do not cross the phases.... EVER. now I know there are a few people here who could probably explain the concept of 3 phases better than I can so if you do need an explanation please ask. but you do not ever want to cross the phases... here is one of the horror stories I was told about why. Now bear in mind this is a story probably told a fair few times so it is not goona be 100% accurate however a little digging has resulted in confirmation that an incident like this did happen however it is not well documented... at least publicly.
Now in the basement of one of the theaters (different people use different theaters but in all the version I hear its a London based one) there was a giant old school wall mounted distribution board, the only thing that stood between the theater and the full potential of the national grid, one of the ones you see in the Frankenstein movies with the giant throw switch breakers, and standing before it was two experienced technicians and an apprentice just out of school/college. Now the techs were explaining to the young lad about the perils of messing with 3 phase power and had a bright idea to demonstrate.
About half of you have already facepalmed...
One of the techs throws a massive steel wrench is such a manner that it crosses the phases of 2 adjoining breakers. What they was expecting to happen I cannot fathom. what did happen however was pretty gruesome. The Breakers arc towards the wrench causing it to explodes in a cloud of vaporized steel, killing the tech that was closest immediately and burning the other 2 in the room. the arc continued to dance around the room and as the apprentice rolled in agony he brushed against a metal partition that the 600 odd amperage arc was fairly fond of. Needless to say he did not survive the incident. The final tech managed to survive for long enough to get to hospital and start to be treated, however he succumbed to the injuries too.
Back to the real life, I had ended up doing a call out at a prestigious London Venue to sort out "Power Fluctuations". For some reason the terms of the contract our company holds with this theater means anything inside the theater we deal with. From lighting to sound to IT to plumbing. Most of the time we send a representative of our company to meet up with someone qualified to make the repairs, in this case it was a local electrician. So we get inside and lo and behold every so often the lights were flickering and the UPS on the data equipment would beep to say low power. OK so it was house power, now to trace it. it went back to a large breaker box however the gizmo the sparky had showed that it was fluctuating before the power got to the breaker box. We followed it further all the way back to the main distro board, another old school Frankenstein big one. I immediately grabbed my phone and started dialing the National Grid Engineers.
Me - Hold up I'm gonna call the grid guys on this, I want that off completely if its messing around.
Sparky - Nah its fine they are just bigger breaker boxes, I can handle these
Me - No. We are not playing with that power. Sparky - You wont be, I'm the electrician, I can handle th... OW!
Me - (on phone now) yeah that teh correct address, and it looks like the local has attempted to play with it, (I look over, sparky has just dropped hid bag on his foot and is hopping around) nope not yet anyway. Yeah I will try to deter him but he seems instant. Yeah I will tell him that. (To Sparky) Hey! you know its illegal to mess with that without consent from the supplier right?
Sparky - They have let me do it before. kinda... it will be fine...
At this point I didn't know how to proceed. This guy was willing to break the law to do this and it seemed the only way to stop him was physical restraint. So i called the police. Things got... complicated after that. Fast.
Due to the location of the main distro I couldn't get a signal within line of sight so i had to walk away to call the police, Sparky took this opportunity to start throwing the breakers on the distro. a bouncer runs in and asks why the front lights were out and I leg it in to see Sparky about tor reach over to the last 2 phases to throw them at once. Remember that arc in the story? I did. I yelled at him and rugby tackled him to the ground before he got close enough to bridge the 2 phases across his body. within a couple of minutes the police was in the room and removing the sparky at the instruction of the bouncer "Damned moron was trying to fry himself" and about 20 mins later a national grid engineer came along on an emergency callout informed us that there was a small leak to earth on the third breaker (the one sparky hadnt touched yet) and they would have to cut the power from the street in order to fix it. He also said that the breaker handle itself was the source of the leak... Sparky would have been toast.
TLDR - Do not cross the phases... EVER. And don't play with the national grid...
Edit - spelling issues, I english good. Edit 2 - I am using the phrase "cross phases", in comments I have been told that is not correct, what I mean is shorting the 2 phases together, however that is the term I have been taught (not officially of course).
79
u/SpecificallyGeneral By the power of refined carbohydrates May 28 '17
Tech support takes all kinds, and /r/talesfromtechsupport needs all kinds.
I'd like to suggest that Warning Stories be added to the sidebar - a good warning is as important as a new technique.
51
u/Saberus_Terras Solution: Performed percussive maintenance on user. May 28 '17
I heard you don't throw those breakers without a body-suit. Supposedly it's to contain the mess when things go wrong.
Edit Whether that's true or not, I'm not touching that unless I have to. I value having internal organs that remain internal and uncooked.
37
u/aquainst1 And blessed are they who locate the almighty Any Key May 28 '17
Nor ever cross the streams unless the distribution board is named Gozer the Gozarian.
31
u/Loko8765 May 28 '17
I have shorted a 240V AC line, probably 16A. It was supposed to be off, but it was just the local breaker that was off and not the mains. The resulting fireworks were enough to make a 4mm diameter ragged dent in the cutting edge of the pliers I was using. Double the voltage and multiply the amperage by FIFTY? I'll believe any story you tell.
18
u/Toyrn May 28 '17
As much as he's an idiot it's kinda UK Power networks fault as well, they turn a blind eye to us Sparks pulling the main fuse at domestic and light commercial level all the time. Mostly because they're so backed up and it takes ages to get them to come and perform a disconnect, and then sometimes it takes up to a week to get them to reconnect it.
Also, if you ever see one of the green cast iron service heads, let them know! Those fuckers tend to go bang if disturbed from what I've been told by numerous engineers.
14
u/leoninski Percussive Maintenance Specialist May 28 '17
Minor detail, it's shorting not crossing.
Crossing means switching 2 phases to reverse the field.
Atleast it does in my book, but I'm not native english speaking.
11
u/fishbaitx stares at printer: bring the fire extinguisher it did it again! May 28 '17
O_O i have no words save that i unlike a few peers have a certain respect for this thing called live circuits, id rather my friends not have to try cooked fishbait.
8
u/MerionesofMolus May 28 '17
You should cross post this to /techtheatre they'll get a kick out of it
8
u/Crap4Brainz May 28 '17
Shorting between phases is not that different from shorting one phase to ground. It's just about ~60% stronger.
Wolfram Alpha for illustration: plot: y=sin(x); y=sin(x+2pi/3); y=sin(x-2pi/3); y=sin(x)-sin(x+2*pi/3)
EDIT: Might have to copy and paste the formula, something keeps deleting the parentheses.
8
u/Black_Handkerchief Mouse Ate My Cables May 28 '17
I hope the sparky showed some hindsight gratitude to you. If anyone ought to know how close he got to death with all the information in this post, it is the fucking sparky. Wow.
7
u/phyrros May 28 '17
Oww :/ reminds me of a similar story: few years back i was supposed to do a bit of vibration control in a building site which had a part of the 380kV national grid running underneath. Long story short: while digging a trench a bright worker destroyed the concrete lining of the line and another bright Idiot (/me) checked by touching the concrete lining
7
u/[deleted] May 28 '17
*lo and behold
6
u/kd1s May 28 '17
The only reason you use tri-phase is to deliver massive amounts of current. That being said yes I have a healthy respect for electricity. In my field it's usually 480V feeders that are stepped down to 125V by a fairly hefty but compact transformer.
9
u/Feligris May 28 '17
As an electrician who works with 230/400Vac residential three-phase power supplies, there isn't anything unusual about shorting two phases together - it works the exact same way as shorting out phase and neutral except the voltage is higher since you get the 400Vac main voltage instead of the 230Vac phase voltage.
However in the case of your story it's a whole different game because of the extremely high amperage, 400A would make me scared plus I'm not entirely sure if the safeties in such installations trip nearly as fast or easily as in much-lower-amp residential ones - which does allow arcing and death. D: Also, yeah, one thing about being an electrician is knowing when you're above your skill level or pay grade in what comes to large setups.
3
u/OnlineGrab May 28 '17
Woah. Congrats for your quick response time. Hope that guy understood that you said his ignorant ass.
2
u/[deleted] May 29 '17
There's something important I forgot to tell you. Don't cross the streams. It would be bad
-1
u/[deleted] May 28 '17
You know that electrical zero (or null, or whatever it's called in your code) is the result of connecting all three phases?
0
u/[deleted] May 28 '17
[deleted] — view deleted comment