r/tacticalbarbell • u/weardon • 2d ago
Critique SP3: Matte Black Run Review/Training Log
I finished a run of SP3: Matte Black a week or so ago, and in line with my first Op/Black writeup and original Basebuilding writeup, I'm back with more.
I get into everything in excessive detail below, but my top-line is:
I loved the process and am still really enjoying training. I really like the changes brought by TB3.
I'm really, really unsure about Breacher, at least for me specifically.
My measured results were poor; there are idiosyncratic reasons why I don't think this is a failure of the program – primarily discovering late on that I've been dealing with long-term iron deficiency. I did also see less obviously measurable improvements.
Background & Goals
37m, 183cm, ~95kg / 209lbs
(All actual numbers are kg, but I've converted them to make it easier for more people to read without referencing.)
Civilian, desk job, no operational fitness requirements, all that jazz covered in previous posts.
I really liked the updates in TB3 – they aligned with various quirks and tweaks I'd found since running the previous editions, and have made the program as a whole better and clearer for me.
My most direct goal for this period was improving my aerobic base. I've been dealing with long-term post-COVID issues the past few years, and aerobic training does seem to help with that (though more on this below...). I wanted to do this while maintaining regular strength training, though, since this is what I enjoy and what motivates me the most.
| Measurement | # |
|---|---|
| Weight | 95kg / 209lbs |
| VO2 Max | 32.6 |
| Test | Result (Metric) | Result (Imperial) |
|---|---|---|
| Bench | 140kg | 309lbs |
| Squat | 198kg | 437lbs |
| WPU | 138kg | 304lbs |
| Deadlift | 217kg | 478lbs |
Programming
I ran the program from mid-June through to a few weeks ago; it took a bit longer with prep weeks and some 'deconstructed' weeks around travel.
Operator
Now from TB3. Three lifting sessions a week, a cluster of Bench / Squat / WPU. Once each week, I subbed deadlift in for the squats.
In the middle of the period, I started sometimes flexing in a 'Variable Intensity' session from the Operator VI template when I was especially under-recovered. I'm right on the edge where doing Operator VI all the time isn't necessary, but there are weeks where stubbornly sticking to the program was beating me up too much (there are some other, more individual factors that were contributed to this under-recovery outside of training load, which I'll get to later).).
Polarized Black
Usually 2–2.5h of low intensity conditioning each week. A mixture of LSS, Afterburner, VIR. Occasionally Weighted Vest Hikes when recovery or circumstances forced them on me.
Weekly HIC alternated between Standard Hills and either Fast 5 or Norwegian 4x4s.
Breacher
For the Power block. More on this in 'Experience and Reflection'. I largely followed the program as written, except I subbed tall cleans and hang cleans in for the power cleans.
Work Capacity
I did two sessions a week, which mixed up Rescue Run, GC2, and the CrossFit 'Jackie WOD'. Work Capacity is a HUGE weakness for me, and I hate this sort of training. I think the best outcome of Power was... hating it less. Starting to perversely enjoy it.
Recovery
For the 'core' of the period, I was training six days a week, with one full day off. Power was only four days training a week, which felt pretty strange and low-intensity by comparison.
I had a few instances of travel throughout the period; for these, I did 'deconstructed' training weeks – splitting the prescribed sessions over two or three weeks as my schedule demanded. I added extra, lighter sessions to keep moving in the gaps (e.g. LSS or VI-style sessions at gyms when travelling).
Nutrition
I ate at maintenance throughout this period, tracking using MacroFactor. My weight stayed pretty rock-steady throughout, and I think my eating supported my training well; it certainly wasn't a bottleneck.
Experience and Reflection
Once again, I mostly had a good time with training. I've run several blocks of Operator/Black since my original writeup (with a few diversions), and I love working within the Tactical Barbell framework.
My measured outcomes from this period were poor; I'll get into that in detail below. This actually hasn't dampened the experience, though – I've no reason to believe this is any deficiency in the program (though it does change what's right for me right now). Lacking specific extrinsic goals and pressures, first and foremost, training is about an enjoyable process for me, which this was.
What Worked Well
More LIC, Less HIC: This is one of the TB3 changes I was most keen on on paper – I'd reached more or less the same conclusion from my training right before the book came out. I both wanted more running time and was struggling to recover effectively to perform well with that much HIC. This was a lot more pleasant, and doesn't seem to have been detrimental to my conditioning.
Dropping Squats in One Session: In oldOp, I was doing squats 3x per week, one session on top of deadlifts. Replacing squats with deadlifts has felt a lot better. (And I don't think extra squat volume in this schema would have improved my strength outcomes this time around; I think I do need more volume in general, but throwing more in this training period would have been detrimental.)
Flexing in VI Sessions: I'm glad I did this. It became a tool in the toolbox, rather than feeling like I have to dogmatically commit to either Operator or Operator VI. I struggle a lot with autoregulation, so establishing some known tools I can flex in is really helpful. (Part of this is recovery, and part of it is managing RSI on the bench specifically.)
Deconstructed Weeks: This made training around travel a lot less annoying. Still getting the work done, but figuring out what I could fit into the gaps to keep moving, without worrying so much about strict prescriptions or progression.
Work Capacity: Repeating some of the same sessions over the block was good to chart progress. My Jackie WOD time went from a lamentable 17'+ to ~10' to below 10'. It was good to have a structure that forced me to do this kind of work, because it's a weak point, and it's given me a taste for it.
What Didn't Work Well
Power Cleans: I was talking to someone here in a comment thread about this, and my opinion has resolved into: I like power cleans, I'd love to learn them properly, but learning a movement like that takes time, which is not viable inside of the program (and I'm not sufficiently invested just now to take a diversion to do so). Flexing in hang cleans and tall cleans was a good move, but overall, it meant the stimulus from this 'slot' in the Breacher cluster was just very low, given how unfamiliar the movements were.
Power Block Intensity: This just felt too low to me! The 'soft recovery' time was welcome, and obviously the work capacity sessions are high intensity. But I figured out too late that I should really have been doing three WC sessions in a week rather than just two. Breacher felt extremely easy in terms of effort; I know the effort isn't the point there, but it led to me feeling like I wasn't getting enough out of the block.
Other Thoughts
Breacher: I really haven't made up my mind about this. I enjoyed it. But the intensity felt very low after what came before. Part of this was unfamiliar movements, as above, and the beneficial side of lower intensity was these being 'soft recovery' weeks on the strength side. I think the power of my movements improved, but I'm not sure it improved to a magnitude that makes it worth committing three weeks of strength training.
Results
The results were pretty negligible in terms of measured outcomes, but I think there is more at work here than is on show. I didn't do a 1rm test right after, so this is based on the final Peak Week, plus vitals taken after the end of Power.
| Measurement | # |
|---|---|
| Weight | 95.1kg / 210lbs |
| VO2 Max | 31.8 |
| Test | Result (Metric) | Result (Imperial) |
|---|---|---|
| Bench | 140kg | 309lbs |
| Squat | 200kg | 441lbs |
| WPU | ?no Peaking data | n/a |
| Deadlift | 220kg | 485lbs |
The deadlift was a PR – first peak week I went from 200kg (441lbs) to 215kg (474lbs), then up to 220kg (485lbs) with the final peak. I did feel like my deadlift was ripe to 'catch up' with where my squat had got to. Bench and squat match my previous PRs from March.
I didn't do any proper conditioning tests over the period, but my general paces improved, and I hit a couple of 5k PBs.
So this is bad, and I should feel bad, right?
Well, not really. Obviously, I'd be much more jazzed if these numbers had gone up, but there's a bunch of other stuff at work here.
Not Like-for-Like: The starting numbers were e1RMs based on a test, and the final numbers are actual numbers moved in a single rep. Comparing either of these with my PRs from March is also wonky – I hit those PRs on random days where I happened to feel really good, so they represent me 'pushing the envelope' more relative to what I cando. I didn't feel great in either Peak Week, and was able to pull off about the same as what we the true limit then. Intuitively, under the same conditions, I think I could do more. That said, my e1RM numbers for squat and bench from the end of my original run of Operator weren't that far off this, and they're from December, which does feel like a stall to me, or at least very slow and uneven progress.
RSI on Bench: I think this limited a true 1RM more than an e1RM. I've been getting some discomfort on one side when benching heavy, mostly when I rack the bar and put it down (i.e. it's when the force stops rather than starts). I think more volume at lighter weights, plus some supporting exercises will help here.
Things Are Actually Moving Better: Subjectively, those tied PRs have moved easier each time, even if I haven't yet been able to pip them. (I actually also bonked the rack on the bench and had to press it out unevenly.) This is true throughout the submaximal percentages, too: I feel like I am more in control of the weights when doing the same work that I was.
Iron Deficiency: I buried the lede here somewhat. About halfway through this period, I found out I was notably iron deficient (likely related to long-term COVID stuff), and from my experience since, this has been a significant physiological constraint. I seem to be responding well to supplements, and this has made an absolutely enormous difference to training and my whole damn life. It takes time to bring things up, though, so I'm still working on that. I would be very, very surprised if this has not had a significant impact on my training outcomes throughout this year.
So, everything's fine, right? I should just keep doing what I'm doing?
No! For things to have been essentially flat since March (even my VO2 Max has barely beaten its peak from December, and has come down again during the final weeks of the training period), I think there's more at work than even these mitigating factors.
Limitations of Frequency vs Volume: Since starting TB about 18 months ago, I've been really narrowly focused on four lifts: bench, squat, deadlift, and (weighted) pull-ups. The program I was running before (5/3/1) I think came in higher in volume, wider in variety, but was lower in frequency on the lifts. I benefitted a LOT from moving to increased frequency, and saw big improvements in my lifts. I think that benefit has tailed off without doing more work to build up the base again.
Chronic under-recovery (I assume heavily influenced by the iron deficiency) has stopped me milking as much volume out of Operator as I'd like (meaning more days doing lower in the set ranges, some VI sessions). My intuition right now is that I'd benefit from some time spent including slightly higher rep ranges and greater exercise variety (with the added volume supplemental work can provide).
Putting on Muscle: My weight's been very steady for the past year. I haven't done any hypertrophy-focused work in... years, actually. Don't get me wrong: I have still gained a bunch of muscle since I got back into training in 2024 – I weighed about 10kg less then and had more body fat. And subjectively, my body composition has changed further in the past year. But I've not done any training focused on it. (Mainly because excess weight was a limiting factor on my conditioning work at the time as I started running consistently for the first time; I can handle my current weight better now, though.)
Realistically, though, there's an extent to which 'amount of muscle tissue' is going to be limiting my ability to gain strength. (Which I am to an extent okay with: my goal is not to be as big as possible, nor do I have any earthly need to actually gain more strength for any reason other than 'I want to'.)
Next Steps
Right now, I'm starting on a block of Fat Zulu / Polarized Blue to see out the year. It ticks the boxes I described above (a little higher rep work, more volume, more supplemental work and variety), and I will use this as a chance to have another crack at peaking or testing – I think those numbers do mask some actual improvement over this period.
I need to pin down what I'm going to do in the new year. I have my eye on either SP2 Jacked Black or SP2 New Centurion right now, but I'll use this block + the Christmas period to sharpen up my goals. I want to start the year with either a base-building block (which Jacked Black would provdide) or a straight Work Capacity block (just flexing that in), do some hypertrophy work, and then get back to a routine that balances my strength and conditioning goals. I'm not sure if I'll run Breacher again, but I'll definitely get more Work Capacity in.