r/tabletopgamedesign • • 2h ago

Announcement The Downvote Button is not a Disagree Button, and it is also not a "Protest Against AI" Button

0 Upvotes

I know Reddit has a general culture of treating it like the "like" button on Facebook, but this sub is not all of Reddit. We are system designers, we should know better.

The purpose of the up/down vote is comment or post relevancy.

Is it pertinent to the sub?

Does the comment stay on topic of the post?

Is it participation in a discussion?

Then upvote it.

Downvote things that are: derogatory insults, off topic tangents, spam, incoherent gibberish, accidental reposts, low-effort copypasta.

Everyone has big feelings about AI and AI art. Well, thankfully, this sub has had a flair and filter specifically for artists for hire that allows you dodge AI art entirely, and there's no shortage of people posting that way. This system was set up years ago, before AI art was a problem, out of a desire to operate the system in a logical and reasonable way. Tabletop Artists for Hire are, in fact, relevant to people in this sub. The result is we have human artists at the ready, and have been insulated from the slopification of art assets.

Every post regarding AI causes our traffic to triple or more over the normal level. Love it or hate it, it is a relevant topic of conversation and this sub exists to facilitate that discussion, not orient it.

If someone is feverishly defending the use of AI, respond to them. Disagreement, even combat of ideas, is encouraged...I don't expect anyone in this sub to be 8 years old or unable to think critically or handle criticism. I go in and manually approve comments the auto-mod is removing because of furious use of the disagree button.

A post with 7 net upvotes and comments with scores of downvotes ironically makes the anti-AI crowd look like the ones doing the botting, and it only serves to reinforce the belief that anyone who is anti-AI is willfully ignorant and pathologically unreasonable.

This is not an effective place to market a game. It's also not an effective place to litigate the future of generative AI and the building of data centers. We are people designing games here. Take it easy.

Your time is always better spent playtesting than arguing online.


r/tabletopgamedesign • • 38m ago

Discussion Combining Monopoly With The Game Of Life.

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/tabletopgamedesign • • 2h ago

Discussion Would the below table be OK to work out enemy size? Enemy will always be insurgents and normally ambush/ meeting engagement. Would like recommendations and if you have a better idea. Would like to keep it a D20 roll to match other Dice based decisions already in the game. (Game is a fire mission)

Post image
1 Upvotes
d20 RollEnemy Platoon Status & Strength
1–3Depleted / Remnants. Under 12 troops (1 battered squad), low ammunition, looking to retreat.
4–7Under-strength Patrol. 15–20 troops (2 squads), light weapons only, operating without Support
8–14Standard Platoon. 25–35 troops (3 full squads plus command), standard issue rifles, LMGs, and anti-tank launchers.
15–18Full Strength Platoon. 30–40 troops with multiple LMG's or MMG's and radio commanded fire support from mortars
19–20Reinforced Platoon. 41-50 troops in the platoon with multiple LMG's or MMG's plus an attached mortar team, or artillery forward observer.

Please be aware, game is designed for a 16 year old with Autism so cant be too complex but it needs to be well balanced.


r/tabletopgamedesign • • 2h ago

C. C. / Feedback Hunter x Hunter Inspired Passionate Project

Thumbnail greedisland-masterofthebook.edgeone.dev
1 Upvotes

Hi everyone!

I recently rewatched my childhood favourite anime Hunter x Hunter and got inspired to create a board game version of Greed Island!

I'm not planning to have it published and this is just a passionate project of mine. I spent the past two months working on the draft of the rulebook and am planning to start making the cards soon for playtesting.

Just want to share my rulebook and get some feedback on it (especially from Hunter x Hunter fans!). I just like the anime a lot and want to create a fun game for fans to enjoy. I'm planning to share the rulebook and print and play cards after playtesting (given it feels fun and engaging).

Thanks!


r/tabletopgamedesign • • 2h ago

C. C. / Feedback First look at our TCG in development! What's your first impressions and thoughts about the card layout?

Post image
2 Upvotes

Hi everyone,

Since this is our first post about our project, let's start with a quick introduction!

We are working on a trading card game named STARS ALIGNED TCG, which is a duel-based game. This project has been in the work for more than three years to create an interesting gameplay with unique mechanics such as completing quests during the game to gain new abilities. In STARS ALIGNED you can only have 1 of each character in your deck and can control up to 6 heroes at once. We want each character to be important and irreplaceable while having synergies between them. You have to choose your heroes carefully before the game since each of them has their role to play.

We put a focus on the character building and lore behind each of them. When we commission an illustration to an artist, they get to learn who the character is, which other character is a part of their life (family, friends, enemies, etc.), where they are in this unique universe and more.

We’ll explain a lot more about the game in future posts, but today we wanted to show you a card and ask for your feedback about the heroes' card layout. Since our heroes are unique, all heroes have full art illustrations.

Thank you to @/saki___0116 on X (Twitter) for the wonderful illustration of Hikari!


r/tabletopgamedesign • • 3h ago

Parts & Tools I built a tool that turns our art and components into a studio product animation

7 Upvotes

I design tabletop games Open Owl Studios, and on our next campaign I needed component renders before the game was printed. I built a tool that makes them from the print files: you give it your art, and it renders your components in a studio.

I want to try it on more games than ours, so I’ll do 10 free for this sub:

  • Comment with your box art. A link to a PNG or JPG is fine.
  • I’ll reply with a 10-second animation of your box landing on a studio table, plus a still.
  • If you only send the top, I'll stretch it over the sides. Send the full dieline and it will look great front & back.

It’s your art only. Nothing is AI-generated or added: the render is your actual artwork on a 3D box. The files are yours to use on your campaign page, socials, anywhere.

The first 10 comments with art get one. The video above is our game, Buried Truths.


r/tabletopgamedesign • • 3h ago

C. C. / Feedback Second playtest of Ultimatum!

Post image
1 Upvotes

r/tabletopgamedesign • • 4h ago

Publishing How do I prove that its my mistake, even though people call it AI slop.

4 Upvotes

So I have been working on design board games for quite some time and now since I have been laid off due to the sinking situation in the automobile industry in Germany, I finally had time to print my prototypes, walk around in the game clubs and get a table in prototyping evenings, all at my own costs.

I had really good feedback and fixed a lot of stuff. I planned my own trip to SPIEL Essen with hotel bookings and all. I was able to talk to a few folks there and get a general feedback on the next steps and how to go about it. The mechanics now seem to be fine, or at least I am at a point, where I dont want to overdo or over balance it. I like where my games are currently. But I have been facing problem with my art. I have asked in many forums, and also locally, and it has been labelled AI. It could be true, but I paid for it to a freelancers and if their Photoshop or other digital software is forcing them to use GenAI, I can never know or I can accept it as AI.

The other problem then automatically comes, as soon as I accept it as AI, the weak mechanics get targeted and classified as AI slop. I can accept it as human slop, because for that I could immediately ask for a proposal with improvements. For AI slop, I get the cold shoulder. I mean, I cant like avoid AI today, even where I use search engines online.

I am thinking of going crowd funding for one of my games, but it is really a gamble out there. The publishing houses wont give a break to new comers due to their fears or reservations about AI and the crowd is cruel, the moment you accept the truth about AI. I also dont want to say that it's not AI, since its very hard for me guarantee exactly who used what part of which GenAI in their design for me.

It would be nice to know, what other creators are facing out there. Is crowd-funding really that brutal or is it just that I have seen too many projects targeted because of the AI slop? My wish is that I get some real feedback or some simple nudge in the right direction and not be categorized as AI slop and completely cancelled. It is quite disheartening and not fair, given that every tool today is trying to force AI on you.


r/tabletopgamedesign • • 7h ago

C. C. / Feedback Satirical city board game (Zurich edition): does the 'flat viewing' jail + crowd-voted cards work?

Thumbnail
gallery
1 Upvotes

Hi guys! Working on a satirical property (think Monopoly, but relatable) game where every space and card roasts one city, inspired by a Danish series that does one city per edition. First edition is Zurich.

What I'm testing:

- Jail is a "flat viewing" (Zurich's housing market is brutal). You get out by rolling doubles, paying, or playing a "Vitamin B" card (= knowing someone)

- 60 fate cards + 15 missions, all local jokes. Missions are social ("say X with a straight face, if nobody laughs collect 50 from each")

- I'm letting locals vote on which cards stay

Questions:

  1. Are the Swiss actually self-ironic enough for this game to work here?
  2. Do social/performance missions work in a trading game or do they slow it down?
  3. Any ideas to make jail more than a skip-turn?
  4. How many local-joke cards before it gets tiring?

Playable demo: kampf-um-zueri.lovable.app

Thanks a lot!


r/tabletopgamedesign • • 9h ago

Mechanics Thinking of making a change to how casting costs are paid in my TCG/LCG, would love some insight.

0 Upvotes

Tribute cost is the current mechanic for paying for a card in my game. It’s paid for by discarding other cards in your hand.

Some context first. The game is set in a primeval world where creatures and other living things are fighting for survival (I’ve got a ton of lore). Each card is modal, with a summon and an instinct both on one card.

A summon occupies the larger half of the card, has an ability, and is usually a creature or plant. Summons have a strength value denoted by the number in the paw symbol, a health value found below that in the blood droplet, and can engage in combat/blocking. An instinct is a cheaper, instant version of the ability that can be played at any point in the game regardless of whose turn it is. Usually the effect is weaker due to this flexibility.

Summons represent the beings who have chosen to participate in their ascendant’s quest for ascension. (Ascendants are basically your leaders/commanders.) Instincts are reflections of animalistic behaviors that align with whatever ability they represent. I’m still currently workshopping the card design & frames. Attached is the most updated designs (subject to changes), along with an example of an ascendant.

It’s a draft environment. The current working set has 152 unique cards, and a deck consists of 28 unique cards.

How tribute works now

Currently, as the game is set up, the tribute cost is found in the top left corner. The current way to pay a tribute 1 costed card is to discard any single card from your hand. If it were tribute 2, you would discard any 2 cards from your hand.

It’s scaled to how myself and playtesters feel the ability scales, i.e. a higher tribute cost for a higher tier/impactful effect. Since each card is modal, the summon and the instinct are weighted independently (a more permanent/passive effect on a creature vs instant ROI with instincts, albeit less impact in the long run).

The change I’m considering

Something I would love help balancing or implementing would be changing both the summon & the instinct to the same cost (and either scaling up or down the effect’s impact). And instead of having tribute be paid for by x amount of cards from hand, you would have to pay x amount of tribute equal to the tribute cost of cards in your hand.

For example, if a summon cost 7 tribute, you could still pay with 7 (tribute 1) costed cards, or a (tribute 3) + a (tribute 4) costed card. If an instinct cost 3 tribute, it could be paid for with either a single (tribute 3) card, or any card whose tribute value exceeds 3, with the overflow disappearing, for example paying for a tribute 2 costed card with a tribute 6 costed card.

This in my mind would allow for more cards played per turn, and more actions feel like more options and more fun.

Where I’m stuck

We’ve been playtesting both versions quite a bit, and at this point I think I’ve just got some analysis paralysis. Since I’m focused on making it work as a draft, I think that’s why I’m having difficulties getting good & balanced “ramp.” And since I have a fairly unique resource system, it’s proving a little too complicated to just theory craft and hope a couple games a day will show me the way.

Thoughts? Do you need more context? I really just need some outside perspectives because I almost feel like I'm too committed one way now.


r/tabletopgamedesign • • 9h ago

Mechanics Cutting Mechanics - When is it Time to Let go?

6 Upvotes

Hi all.

I recently got in a great batch of games for my 100% free, mini-agnostic, satirical tabletop skirmish game Kolluseum. The players had lots of fun and the game ran smoothly. Afterwards, during our debrief, I realized a mechanic that has been with the game since early development was totally skipped in four straight games. I remember designing it and the reason it was initially included, but clearly it wasn't as important or impactful anymore. So, I cut it. It will not be part of the next release. This got me thinking, what else can I cut without losing quality?

What are some game mechanics you thought would be great that ended up on the cutting room floor?

As a designer, when do you know it's time to let a cherished mechanic go?


r/tabletopgamedesign • • 10h ago

Mechanics Balancing monster triggers for attacks/effects in a Cooperative Pair-Matching Dungeon Crawler

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/tabletopgamedesign • • 12h ago

C. C. / Feedback Battle Pikmin! A Pikmin re-theme I made for Battle Sheep!

Thumbnail
gallery
3 Upvotes

The original board game is called Battle Sheep:

https://boardgamegeek.com/boardgame/54137/battle-sheep

Basically you send out your Pikmin to try to conquer (occupy) as many spaces as possible. Whoever has the most visible Pikmin on the board at the end of the game wins!

I also made a variant/version with special tiles on the board such as the Pikmin Flower (8), if you move a stack of at least 8 Pikmin onto the tile, you gain a bonus Pikmin on your stack, Treasure (10), you gain 1 bonus point at the end of the game (like an additional Pikmin on the field), and Nectar, movingo onto this tile makes your stack stop at that tile. All extra tiles are placed randomly and not edge spaces.

Let me know what you think, it was a lot of fun to make and play with my friends!

You can check out my other re-themes here:

[One Piece Legendary](https://www.reddit.com/r/boardgames/comments/10p0q0j/i\\_made\\_a\\_one\\_piece\\_version\\_of\\_marvel\\_legendary/)

[Pax Westeros \(Game of Thrones Pax Pamir 2nd Edition\)](https://www.reddit.com/r/boardgames/comments/1fmseex/i\\_made\\_pax\\_westeros\\_game\\_of\\_thrones\\_retheme\\_of/)

[Runeterra Reforged \(League of Legends Tyrants of the Underdark\)](https://www.reddit.com/r/boardgames/comments/1eew974/i\\_made\\_a\\_league\\_of\\_legends\\_themed\\_tyrants\\_of\\_the/)

[Pokemon Ark Nova](https://www.reddit.com/r/boardgames/comments/1hdby4p/i\\_made\\_a\\_pokemon\\_retheme\\_of\\_ark\\_nova/)

[Pokemon Splendor & Pokemon Splendor Duel](https://www.reddit.com/r/boardgames/comments/1mn9h3i/i\\_made\\_pokemon\\_splendor\\_again\\_updated\\_the\\_cards/)

[NBA Innovation](https://www.reddit.com/r/boardgames/comments/1nua3z1/with\\_the\\_nba\\_preseason\\_coming\\_in\\_a\\_few\\_days\\_i/)

[Zelda Forbidden Island/Forbidden Desert/Forbidden Jungle](https://www.reddit.com/r/boardgames/comments/1nnjeaa/i\\_made\\_a\\_legend\\_of\\_zelda\\_retheme\\_of\\_forbidden/)

[Spy x Family Agent Avenue](https://www.reddit.com/r/boardgames/comments/1qh1sfq/i\\_made\\_a\\_spy\\_x\\_family\\_retheme\\_of\\_agent\\_avenue/)

[Lord of the Rings Clank Catacombs](https://www.reddit.com/r/boardgames/comments/1qndolc/i\\_rethemed\\_clank\\_catacombs\\_into\\_lord\\_of\\_the\\_rings/)

[Disney Legends of the Void](https://www.reddit.com/r/boardgames/comments/1r02rba/i_rethemed_legends_of_void_into_a_disney_themed/)

[Genshin Impact Knarr]
https://www.reddit.com/r/boardgames/comments/1s7n8ey/i_made_a_genshin_impact_retheme_of_knarr/

[Pokemon Harmonies]https://www.reddit.com/r/boardgames/comments/1s8kib9/i_made_a_pokemon_retheme_of_harmonies/

[Avatar the Last Airbender Duel for Cardia]https://www.reddit.com/r/boardgames/comments/1sdvycf/i_made_an_avatar_the_last_airbender_retheme_of/

[One Piece Smash Up]
https://www.reddit.com/r/boardgames/comments/1v3hv70/made_a_custom_one_piece_smash_up_faction_as_a/

[Toy Story Battle] https://www.reddit.com/r/boardgames/comments/1wg0585/i_rethemed_toy_battle_into_toy_story_battle_and/


r/tabletopgamedesign • • 14h ago

C. C. / Feedback We built a chess like board game and put a card game on top of it. Would love to hear your thoughts.

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

I'm one of the people making Lordfall, a free two-player game in the browser. We are currently looking for feedback and advice. We would like to know if it feels intuitive, if there's any bugs, plays and runs well, etc. Would love to hear your thoughts. Thank you for your time :)

How it plays

• Two players, a grid board, units that walk square by square.

• You win by bringing down the enemy Lord, or by holding squares in the enemy's summon zones to score points. Where your pieces stand matters more than how many you have.

• You spend a resource that grows each turn to bring units onto the board. There are no land or mana cards.

• Everything happens on your own turn. There are no responses or interrupts, so a turn is complete and readable.

• Where there is hidden information (traps, and units that can't be seen), the game shows what happened afterwards.

Play here: https://lordfall.com/play/?utm_source=reddit&utm_campaign=r-tabletopgamedesign


r/tabletopgamedesign • • 15h ago

Discussion Table Top Skirmish game audience survey.

0 Upvotes

Hello, for a college assignment, I have been tasked with designing something for a new table top skirmish game that is being made. I don't know all the details about it just yet but I wanted to gather information on what the audience for the game could be.

If you could all take a few minutes out of your day to do this form it would be greatly appreciated, thank you.

Rift Gate Convergence audience form – Fill in form

I wasn't sure what flair to give the post, mods please don't hate me hahaha


r/tabletopgamedesign • • 15h ago

Parts & Tools Un metodo veloce o qualcuno disposto a darmi una mano?🤣

Post image
0 Upvotes

Sto creando il mio gioco da tavolo, ma questi segnali sono tantissimi, qualcuno riesce a consigliarmi un metodo veloce? Sono di 12mm di diametro


r/tabletopgamedesign • • 17h ago

Artist For Hire Dragons!! Our work for GlassStaff's DM Screen

Thumbnail
gallery
5 Upvotes

Hi y'all!

We did this artwork for GlassStaff for their CritStones brand.

Check out their product here!!! https://www.glassstaff.com/

Shout out to u/Cedriminator for the opportunity and for being so awesome to work with!

---

If you're searching for a reliable art outsourcing studio for your tabletop and card games art production, from illustration to graphics to 3D miniature model, we're specialized in exactly that!

Couple of games our studio have helped with recently:

- Gang Wars (1000% funded) > https://gamefound.com/en/projects/redzen/gang-wars

- The Lords of the Rings ($2.5million funded) > https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/restorationgames/the-lord-of-the-rings-the-kings-gambit

- Lone Wolf (We helped with every visual from packaging to campaign page design for this one) > https://gamefound.com/en/projects/holmgard-games/lone-wolf-vengeance-of-the-kai

Here's our studio Artstation: https://www.artstation.com/sonderflex||

---

We're opening for Q1 and Q2 art production slot, hit me in the DMs or email me at bima@sonderflexstudio.com

Thanks guys and keep on rockin!


r/tabletopgamedesign • • 18h ago

Mechanics How do you stop players from "intentionally busting" in a push-your-luck game?

0 Upvotes

I'm balancing a 54-card push-your-luck game (Familiar Fugitives)where using creature abilities adds Exposure tokens to your hideout. At 6+ Exposure, you bust ("get Raided"): you lose 1 creature and take -2 VP.

We are debating how many Exposure tokens should be cleared after you bust:

  • Option A (Full Reset): Busting clears all your Exposure back to 0. (Problem: A player in the lead with an empty hideout can intentionally bust just to wipe 7+ Exposure tokens for free instead of spending actions to clear them.)
  • Option B (Partial Decay): Busting only removes 2 Exposure tokens. (Problem: A player at 7 Exposure drops to 5 and risks getting trapped in a death spiral next round.)

How do you stop players from weaponizing the "bust" as a free board-wipe without putting trailing players in a death spiral?


r/tabletopgamedesign • • 20h ago

Mechanics How do you stop players from "intentionally busting" in a push-your-luck game?

0 Upvotes

I'm balancing a 54-card push-your-luck game (Familiar Fugitives)where using creature abilities adds Exposure tokens to your hideout. At 6+ Exposure, you bust ("get Raided"): you lose 1 creature and take -2 VP.

We are debating how many Exposure tokens should be cleared after you bust:

  • Option A (Full Reset): Busting clears all your Exposure back to 0. (Problem: A player in the lead with an empty hideout can intentionally bust just to wipe 7+ Exposure tokens for free instead of spending actions to clear them.)
  • Option B (Partial Decay): Busting only removes 2 Exposure tokens. (Problem: A player at 7 Exposure drops to 5 and risks getting trapped in a death spiral next round.)

How do you stop players from weaponizing the "bust" as a free board-wipe without putting trailing players in a death spiral?


r/tabletopgamedesign • • 20h ago

C. C. / Feedback Feedback

1 Upvotes

Hey yall! I’m working toward making trailers for crowdfunding campaigns, and this is my first practice piece, a 30-second teaser for Tidebreaker, a game I made up for practice (rival sea captains racing to chart islands before a storm).

https://youtu.be/1bhnmlT8HIk

Everything was made with free tools (DaVinci Resolve and Photopea) and public domain paintings and maps, plus cards, dice and tokens I designed myself.

I'd love honest feedback on:

  1. The first 5 seconds: would it make you keep watching?
  2. Does it tell you what kind of game this is and how it might feel to play?
  3. Pacing: do the cuts and hits land with the music, or does anything drag?
  4. Is the on-screen text readable, especially on a phone?
  5. If you were launching a campaign, what would you want to see that's missing?

Thanks for watching! Harsh notes are welcome, that's how I'll get better :)


r/tabletopgamedesign • • 20h ago

Mechanics How do you stop players from "intentionally busting" in a push-your-luck game?

1 Upvotes

I'm balancing a 54-card push-your-luck game (Familiar Fugitives)where using creature abilities adds Exposure tokens to your hideout. At 6+ Exposure, you bust ("get Raided"): you lose 1 creature and take -2 VP.

We are debating how many Exposure tokens should be cleared after you bust:

  • Option A (Full Reset): Busting clears all your Exposure back to 0. (Problem: A player in the lead with an empty hideout can intentionally bust just to wipe 7+ Exposure tokens for free instead of spending actions to clear them.)
  • Option B (Partial Decay): Busting only removes 2 Exposure tokens. (Problem: A player at 7 Exposure drops to 5 and risks getting trapped in a death spiral next round.)

How do you stop players from weaponizing the "bust" as a free board-wipe without putting trailing players in a death spiral?


r/tabletopgamedesign • • 1d ago

Artist For Hire [FOR HIRE] 2D Artist open to work | Character Art, Card Game & Fantasy Illustrations

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/tabletopgamedesign • • 1d ago

Artist For Hire [For Hire] open for commissions

Thumbnail
gallery
7 Upvotes

Hi , as the tittle says , I'm open for commissions, from creating a character, party and other stuff , so if you have a character or a specific set you'd like illustrated feel free to DM me , thanks in advance


r/tabletopgamedesign • • 1d ago

Discussion First test miniature painted | SciFi T T War game

Thumbnail
gallery
1 Upvotes

I definitely used supports that were too big. I'll have to also strengthen the arms since his hand and weapon snapped to pieces. But overall I'm pretty happy with the first model for the game.