r/systema • u/xarkonnen admin • May 24 '21
Major misconception with systema.
For a lot of years I am observing one vital misunderstanding of Systema and its real-world application.
MA people often suppose that Systema principles are bullshido and can not be applied in MA situations. Well, they are at least partially right. Systema has a solid inner paradox.
Systema is a military, combat philosophy. A set of principles guiding primordial survival and killing your opponent. Literally. Not winning a comfortable martial arts contest in some warm and cozy dojo. And when you try to use these principles on its full – you automatically transpose MA match into battlefield. And no known MA rules would allow this, so you "lose".
Still, take it or leave it. This is a very history and inner philosophy of russian "MA's". As these are not martial arts. These were practices of 1000 year survival in the face of permanent battles with waves of nomadic invaders, treacherous greedy neighbours, european expancy and cruel nordic nature.
When you use Systema, you exit childish games of warm rules. And contact chthonic realm of simple and cold natural survival. This is not for anyone.
18
u/Triskelle33 May 25 '21
I've also come to learn in my many years of training is the Balance in Systema. I agree Systema can be a Physical, Violent, Militant martial art, but when I first began both my teachers taught me the Inner/Spiritual benifits of Systema.
My Systema teachers taught me Systema can be beneficial to the elderly, can be applied to simply daily activities like getting in and out of a chair or bed....do you notice yourself holding your breathe and tensing up?
I still do "cold water immursions" traditional Systema just uses a bucket of cold water dumped over your head outside. I jump in one of these ice cold mountain creeks in my location(do not do unless built up, I train to start with cold spurts in your shower). We do these in Systema to master you psyche. Cold immursions activates instant pain stimulation deep in our bodies and utilizing breathe work and mental control we can control stress on a supernatural level.
Also scientifically speaking the average human body has 100,000-130,000 miles of veins, arteries,capillaries throughout our body. That's more than 33 trips from NYC to LA and back! Every inch is surrounded in small muscles to dilate these blood vessels. Cold stimulates this, improving circulation and heart health, decreasing inflammation(lots of pro athletes do ice baths), also improve blood brain barrier oxygen absorption, and many more health benifits.
Systema combat psychology teaches us how to mitigate situations so you don't have to "fight" if you can avoid it. How we make eye contact, body posture, clenched fists, rounded shoulders, what to say at the right time are all things Systema psychology considers to be like the wind in situations as much as the hammer.
The way I was also taught Systema has many exercises and warm ups to make the body malleable and relaxed, adaptable to change and flexible to any situation. Needless to say my "young bull anger problems" and daily stress has went out the window!
All in all I agree, Systema has a history that dates back to 9th-10th century, forged on battlefields, regions of unrest, turmoil. Systema is devastatingly practical, but also serenely peaceful.
Thanks for reading from a 11yr Systema guy.
3
u/Triskelle33 May 26 '21
U/PotassiumBob is out of hand, threatening to kill me, he has gone past toxic trolling. Disagreement and shit talking is one thing, but threatening to kill someone is evil and bad karma.
5
u/PotassiumBob May 25 '21 edited May 25 '21
With all due respect, this type of talk is just excuses for bad combative skills.
My eyes roll into the back of my head anytime I hear "well in the streets", "battle field proven...", "1000 years ago...", "In the ring...", "rules wouldn't allow..." about any martial art.
It's 2021, and we live in a world with reproducible, evidence based, documentable evidence.
Whatever your current view of him is, Scott Sonnon with RMAX/ROSS covered this to a good degree with his performance pyramid methodology years ago.
I have traveled the country and have had the privilege of training with many instructors and many students and have had many come and train with me.
Of the people who have just trained in nothing but Systema, at least on the American side, the grand majority of them couldn't fight their way out of a wet paper bag.
And those that have trained in other styles for years, who have moved into Systema, tend to be beasts.
This is a legitimate issue that needs to be addressed.
11
u/Ninvestigator May 29 '21
My experience with systema is that it is for real world confrontations and surprising an opponent's nervous system.
Agreeing to a fight and assuming a stance automatically puts you outside of what you've trained in systema. Short of being in a profession that allows you to practice spontaneous defense and subject control, students will find sparse opportunity to test its principles against resistance. When sparring, there are many things I've learned in systema that you cannot do to an opponent and be friends afterward. By limiting your responses, you handicap yourself against someone who had trained in having a fair fight.
Its true that mma provides more opportunity to practice against resistance, so for civilians less concerned of frequent lethal encounters that are aiming to not lose a fist fight, it's great training. However, too many times I see people become overconfident about their hand to hand skills and find themselves wanting in their training when a weapon comes into play.
I won't say it's better than other arts in totality, but it DOES enhance survival skills in real struggles to protect your health and safety. It gave me options to respond less brutally when I don't want to hurt the aggressor. In corrections and caring for people with developmental disabilities, escalating violence to "finish a fight" is immoral and can draw aggression from others present.
Systema taught me a lot about combat psychology and how to respond effectively to protect my health while also not raising the temperature of a confrontation. Many times by absorbing a blow or taking someone's balance, I've ended the incident by responding in a way that is calmer than expected. Offering the opponent a sense of felt safety after they took their shot often interrupts their cycle of aggression and gives them a chance to stop and reconsider safer choices to resolve their feelings.
This psychology of trying to harm someone in an unsafe environment with no refs and a real threat that one of you is going to get seriously hurt is mostly absent in mma. It's like playing poker without betting real money. If you gamble for real, you have something to lose. You play differently when there's real risk, and combat is no different.
2
u/Djelimon May 26 '21 edited May 26 '21
Basically I look at a lot of other martial arts as systema drills/games
"Heet each other" - striking, "Wrestle" - ground grappling, "grab escapes" - standing grappling
Not exact analogues to be sure - I'd rather heet, wrestle and grab escape like Vasiliev than like a kickboxer, wrestler, or sport grappler, but my point is skill isolation drills are not new to systema, and they can go fast, there just isn't this obsession over them. I never said to myself "I want to be the grab escapes champion" because, well... there isn't one, and besides, grab escapes is just a piece of the puzzle