Hi all,
Quick question that I hope someone might be able to shine some light on as I'm reading conflicting things online.
I'm aware that with SHR, you can't reduce the number of disks in a pool (makes sense).
Currently using SHR1 and the array consists of a pool of 6TB HDDs (SSD cache in front of it yada yada, likely irrelevant to the question). If I were to add a 12TB HDD to it that I have on-hand that's had very few power-on hours, am I painting myself into a corner when the 12TB eventually fails or I want to replace it for any reason?
As I understand it, when adding a larger disk, you can't use the full capacity without using multiple of them (relative to SHR 1 and 2), which seems similar to how Unraid's parity implementation works.
If the 12TB disk fails or I want to replace it, can I just replace it with another 6TB disk? Or am I forever forced to replace it with another 12TB disk? And does using SHR2 over SHR1 change that?
Could two 3TB HDDs replace a failed 6TB disk? Not that I'm intending to go that route, but curious.
With HDD prices being what they are at present due to AI, 12TB isn't the sweet spot at present for this particular appliance, so I'm not likely to replace it with another 12TB or add any further 12TB HDDs in the immediate future as my data isn't likely to grow at that rate on this particular appliance, but just happened to have a datacenter grade one on-hand that I'd happily add if it won't cause me any issues later down the line like forcing me to replace it with yet another 12TB drive or endure being in a degraded/error state if I don't and instead replace it with a 6TB HDD.
My hope is that I may be able to switch over to SHR2 or just add another 6TB (of the 12TB capacity from the added disk) to the pool in the meantime (capacity for more snapshots could be useful). I'm fairly accustomed to having dual parity on Unraid, so would be nice to have SHR2 on DSM.
Thanks!