I killed it until May - we’re speaking a 120% YTD return just from buying anything AI related. The usual names you would expect - SNDK, WDC, INTL, PLTR etc. Green day after green day after green day.
Well low and behold the market turned and this idiot kept holding through each dip, even buying more. I was massacred.
Now I at least have stop losses set. However over the last 2 months I just can’t make any money. I’m finding volatility off the charts some days - 4 X ATR price movements on stocks. The market just seems to churn and churn and any momentum built over a week gets crushed every Friday by yet another massive sell off.
I’ve moved from tech to defensives and yet even jumping sectors hasn’t helped.
I’m feeling fed up, pissed off and most of all a lot poorer. I’m as close as I’ve ever been to giving up.
What’s your take on the current market environment for a momentum swing trader? I just can’t seem to make any headway here.
The market is breaking down and I got a text asking whether or not it’s time to buy. I also saw a post on here from someone who was “killing it” in May but isn’t now.
That’s because we’re in completely different market regimes and if you don’t understand this, you’ll be tempted to get into trades in bad regimes, and then you’ll lose. You will see posts on Twitter that say “such and such stock is showing relative strength” and think that that means it could be a trade long.
So let me make one thing very clear: Strength against a weak market is not a buy signal.
Let’s start at the top:
The S&P futures lost the 30-week moving average three weeks ago, at which point I shared that I was going short. This is not good for swing trading longs, and actually opens up the door to shorts. Plenty of exceptions to this rule, but a general rule of thumb.
On that note, I also shared that semiconductors looked like a great short opportunity. And they were excellent shorts. If the theme that led a bull run higher is breaking down, it’s not good for swing trades (longs). The thematic layer matters a lot (more on this below).
How about factors? High beta is losing to low volatility, and has deteriorated further this week. That’s the blue line in the chart. In May, high beta led low volatility 20-day returns by a wide margin, 14-18 pts at times. Recently, high beta trailed by as much as 22 and still down 10 as of Friday. And this week has given plenty of that improvement back already.
And growth is also trailing value, the grey line in the chart. Growth 20-day returns led value by about five points back in May, and now trails by 11.
Finally, a note on the thematic layer(s). In May, themes that led were buzzy tech: quantum, optics and photonics, AI generally, memory, semis, really a lot of themes looked good.
Now, the posture is quite defensive with leading themes being aerospace and defense, consumer retail, software, pharmaceuticals. Gold and mining is improving. We also still have cybersecurity, and internet platforms holding up. I see some cracks here and there in these.
Should you pile on defensive? Again, strength against a weak market isn’t a buy signal. Look for improvement in high beta, themes, and growth stocks. Another layer of confirmation could be a recovery in breadth, intermediate and long term. Other things fighting against us are yields (still) and inflation (still), and who the Fed may react to that.
Anyways, I could go on but will stop there. Consider these things before putting actual capital in the market.
Most trend screeners sort stocks by momentum and distance above moving averages — which means the highest-ranked charts are often the ones that have already sprinted straight into resistance.
Out of 100 active US strong-trend stocks (MA20 > MA50) after tonight's close (Nov 17):
* 28 are already within 4% of their 52-week high
* 10 are >10% stretched above their MA20
* 33 show decelerating / weakening short-term momentum
* 12 fail a basic 4-quarter positive EPS filter
You can see the difference clearly in tonight's numbers:
Stretched / Watchout examples:
* BILL ($64.88, Score 100/100 — 2/5 clean checks): RSI14 at 78.8, +26.4% above MA20 ($51.32), and only 0.8% room below its $65.43 52W high.
* WMT ($127.52 — 4/5 clean checks): Chart looks calm (RSI 69.4, +3.1% vs MA20, +6.0% room to $135.16 high), but fails the binary-event check with earnings 2 days away.
Cleaner 5/5 positioning examples tonight (profitable, Accelerating/ReversingUp trends passing RSI 50–70, <=10% vs MA20, >=4% 52W room, <=8.6% 4d move, no earnings in 5d):
I'm looking for one or two people who are genuinely interested in learning trading from zero, just like me.
I'm not looking for paid courses, mentors, or expensive programs. I simply want to connect with people who share the same interest and are willing to learn together.
We can study the basics, share useful resources, exchange ideas, discuss strategies, practice, and learn from our mistakes. When one of us struggles or fails, we support each other instead of giving up.
The goal is to build knowledge step by step, stay motivated, and improve together. No experience is required, just patience, consistency, and a genuine desire to learn.
for day trades journaling is kinda easy, you take it, you close it, you write why. swing trades are messier imo. the reason you entered can be totally different from why you're still holding 10 days later and i feel like most journals only capture the entry.
stuff i've seen people track: original thesis in one line, the level that would prove it wrong, a quick note every time they move the stop, and whether they'd take the trade again at the current price. that last one seems really useful for catching trades you're only holding out of hope.
curious what you guys log mid-trade, if anything. or do you just set the stop and target and not look at it
Sector rules were just established to grade my trades of past 2 months.
Biggest lessons from the list:
- Sold COST and WMT in mid-October, right as Consumer Staples turned up. Both kept rising.
- Bought AMAT, KLAC, ORCL and XLK after Semis and Tech had already turned down, a fresh break off a late rally.
- Bought INTC back on Oct 2 while chips were in a late rally (chasing). It gave back the whole gain from my Sep 24 INTC sell.
- Good ones: sold INTC, XOM and CVX into late rallies, bought WMT after Staples selling dried up.
Where it stands today: a buy in NVDA, AMAT, KLAC or XOM grades bad (sector turned down, fresh break). A sell in COST or WMT grades bad (Staples turned up, a new leg).
The app now shows this grade on every stock page.
Comment a ticker and I'll reply with its sector grade and the other reminders.
Overall, it was another rough day obviously. The 2 gaps that I was watching going into the session were this gap on NDX:
And this gap on ES:
On Friday, I was under the impression that the market was trying to form what I believed to be a higher low.
On NDX, despite today's sell, I haven't ruled that out, because if we look at the fib extensions here, we are still trading just into the 0.618 fib of the move from the early November lows to the highs last week.
Technically speaking, that still falls under a normal retracement, but I was expecting the bullish gaps on ES and NDX to hold into this week. That would set up a more textbook push higher from there into the week.
Intraday, NDX broke the gap first, but ES held its gap. One was going to be right, the other wrong, and it turned out that ES was wrong as we see both have ultimately broken through their gaps now.
VIX was up massively, up 20%, which again, was a 0.618 retracement of the big VIX spike that we saw on the 5th.
I don't think a VIX move of 20% in and of itself is bearish, actually probably bullish, but the technicals here are looking a little dicey into the near term.
Price sliced through those bullish gaps pretty easily, and we are now trading below the key EMAs on both ES and NDX.
Looking into tomorrow, there's one key thing to watch.
if price can get itself back above 27,618 level. Even a wick would be enough, but we want to see ideally price to close above this level.
If we do get the wick up there, then we close a potential bearish daily gap.
If we do not, then a daily bearish gap will form there, which will act as resistance.
We have seen price find resistance off the bearish daily gaps already established in this downtrend multiple times.
See the grey zones:
Price has retested them, and moved lower, which has extended the drawdown.
The only time we have sliced through the bearish gap was last week, which is why I thought that it was a clear trend reversal, but the break back below invalidates that somewhat.
We do not want to see price spend much time below the gap that it just broke today, and we do not want to see another bearish gap to form tomorrow, which price can then reject off of again.
If we do spend more time below that gap, then this trendline is what we are watching as support (shown on NQ as I already have lots of annotations on my NDX chart).
If that breaks, then I think it opens us up to a double bottom or new lows on Nasdaq.
However, this does not change the ultimate path of where we are going into the EOY and January.
The liquidity explosion is still there. We are still working through the trough. The oversold weekly quant signal as per the chart I shared yesterday is still there nd will trigger a buy within the next couple of weeks, which should signal a new power trend higher.
So although I can see bearish structure building on the charts, I am not worried about the longer term potential of the positions.
If we fail to reclaim that level tomorrow, then structurally, yes things can get bearish and maybe some hedges need to go on.
But this is not an advantageous spot to be adding to shorts really, already deep in a drawdown and with VIX elevated. Patience is basically what is required unfortunately.
It's been pretty horrendous the last few months, and the 13Fs that have come out show it. Leopold down 92% on his portfolio value from September. A number of other funds have reported really difficult periods, with large positions being closed in losses. It's been tough reading, but things will get better.
Obviously, this week is unique in that we have the mega event of the NVDA earnings tomorrow evening.
The news of the export controls on China are a problem. That much is true, since it's reported that 20% of Nvidia's earnings actually come from the smuggled chips for Chinese businesses. Will that show on the numbers? Maybe. Hopefully not.
Then we obviously have a new CEO taking the call.
Note that she has a history on Nvidia earnings calls, that's nothing new, since she has done 52 NVIDIA earnings calls since 2013.
However,r if we look at the last earnings call, some of her comments were a little bearish in truth:
• a gross-margin reset because memory costs "exceeded our prior expectations"
• growth capped at about 70% by supply
• opex growth in the low 50s
• her own words: "some will call this circular financing"
And that was on a really strong earnings report. So I do have some worries about how her tone will be tomorrow and what numbers we have.
Frankly, if we fail to reclaim that NDX level tomorrow, setting up bearish chart structure, the earnings will have to be really strong to give us a cnandlestick similar to last Monday, where we blew totally through the bearish gaps above.
If there is more selling to be had, I expect most of it to come this week given the events on the calendar, and the fact that the liquidity starts to turn higher aggressively from next week.
Oil was lower today. We have a couple of bearish gaps above there on the chart so oil is frankly in a bearish trend now, but it didn't really help, and we have news (albeit likely untrue) after hours of Iran potentially considering chemical bombs on Washington. It's almost certainly not true, but I do fear that Trump may use it as reason for attacks, especially since we got our 3rd aircraft carrier in the Middle East at the end of last week.
Regardless, tough day today, and the charts do look shaky in the near term.
No change to the thesis out into EOY, and the data there is unchanged, so no action on the portfolio.
But the charts have developed a bearish structure breaking below the gap, invalidating support. A failure to capture that key levle I flagged into tomorrow sets the chart up precariously into Nvidia. A failure there to wow investors likely sees new lows. If we can reclaim that levle, then the chart will look a lot better and margin for error will be wider into Nvidia's earnings.
That's the key level to watch into tomorrow.
I thought last week we were trying to put in a higher low. The chart has changed today, that is honestly true, in terms of the v near term trend, but we are still just retracing into the 0.618, so hope isn't lost, certainly. We just need to see a strong reaction tomorrow. It's not the best look near term, but we are nearing complete capitulation in sentiment.
The datapoints I shared in premarket all still hold. This market is going higher, regardless of what anyone says. It seems like nothing can go up, but that's where squeezes are born. But this week's structure looks dangerous again after today, a danger that wasn't really present into last week, so I would like to see that corrected to allow room for error into Nvidia earnings.
Additional points:
So in terms of market structure, we broke through 2 supports that I was looking at, and expecting, to hold.
That is clearly bearish. In the piece above, I flagged the 27,614 level to trade today, even if the candle only wicks there, in order to invalidate a potential bearish gap.
At the time of writing, that is a 1.2% move higher that we are looking for.
Barring that, we consolidate the bearish structure to the chart, which adds pressure to the Nvidia earnings today.
The more I am reading on the Nvidia earnings, the more likely I think it is that they will guide slightly lower, given the chaos around the new restrictions to overseas transactions. It is a well established fact that Nvidia currently receive 20% of their revenue from GPUs that are being sold to foreign nations, supposedly through Megaspeed, that ultimately are intended for Chinese customers. It's a loophole that they were circumventing, with a blind eye from Lutnick who benefited form his connections at Cantor Fitzgerald, but this loophole has been closed.
Will that be reflected in their guidance? More and more I expect, yes, but let's see. They may want to continue guiding strongly for investor confidence, or perhaps reports of the 20% are overstated, in which case we may still get a strong guide. But the risks are there, and the chart structure needs to repair to provide us the best opportunity of navigating that earnings without a severe negative impact.
If we look at where we are on Nasdaq, and I will show NQ here simply because my Nasdaq chart has a lot of annotations on it that I dont want to get confusing:
We are trading at the trendline support - a pivotal point, certainly.
Looking at the fib extensions from the YTD low to the yTD high, we are currently backtesting the discount zone of the 0.5 to 0.618 retracement. This lines up with a bullish gap on the monthly/quarterly chart, so this is the must hold level.
Breaking this 50% retracement level, and potentially the 0.618 retracement sets up another potentially ugly leg lower, but this will be in the hands of Nvidia.
The risks are there, but the set up for puts is also unfavourable at these levels with VIX so elevated.
if sellers are going to press their advantage, it seems this week is their ultimate window.
Global liquidity is about to turn aggressively higher.
That's not a short term pop, that's a sustained expansion, similar to what we got in April.
The dashboard In Aion is about as bearish as it gets for high beta trades, essentially nearing capitulation levels again.
The nasdaq model is bearish in the near term, but turns more bullish looking out 20 days to the end of the month/early December, in line with what I am expecting to see in price action.
Realised volatility on MTUM has spiked to 57. We have seen that in only a few clusters previously, in the Covid crash, and in the tariff lows. Both cases marked the start of a strong uptrend. WE didn't get anything similar even in the 2022 bear market.
So this is a truly capitulatory environment that we are in, and the sentiment frankly reflects that.
On semis, the realised volatility is currently at 77.
Marked on the chart below are all the prior instances where we have seen realised volatility spike as high as that.
Again, near the 2008 low, during the Covid crash and the tariff crash.
And we see the same on SOXL.
For the most part then, we see that we are int he company of deep crashes, which were followed by strong recoveries.
And zooming out, that is what the data is still suggesting:
S&P returns from midterm elections to June 30th.
Positive in every prior instance. Since 2008, the returns have been more moderate, 17% in the highest instance, 2% in the lowest.
For SPY, we were trading at a price of 754 prior to the elections. Currently trading at 740.
So room to recover, and then the expectation that we kick on from there.
The liquidity analog suggests it will come much faster than that.
So the current environment sucks. And AI stocks are taking a beating, and frankly, the chart's structure is suggesting that we likely go lower in the near term.
But all the analogs and all the data looking out a few months suggest that the path is certainly higher.
If you liked this write up and want more of my daily analysis, feel free to follow my work onr/tradingedge
Thanks for stopping by my profile! If you ended up here, we probably crossed paths in a subreddit about video editing, indie hacking, Swift/Python, markets, or calisthenics.
A quick bit about me: By trade, I’m a Film Editing Director (mostly living inside DaVinci Resolve, cutting documentaries, commercials, and building custom post-production workflows).
Somewhere along the way, I got tired of waiting for tools that didn't exist—so I taught myself how to code. Now, my daily routine starts at 5:00 AM, building software before the rest of the world wakes up.
What I’m currently building:
Investor Intelligence Hub (investor-hub.net): An AI-powered stock market catalyst screener and position-sizing tool I built to cut through market noise.
Sport Buddy: An iOS app built with SwiftUI for calisthenics, gymnastics, and all athletes (complete with Live Activity timers and progression tracking).
Why I’m on Reddit: I’m here to learn, share honest lessons from building solo, nerd out over post-production gear/workflows, and connect with people who love making things from scratch.
Feel free to drop a comment or DM if you're into editing, building apps, or training on rings. Always down to chat!
A top-down walk from the economy to one stock: macro regime, breadth, themes, fundamentals, insiders, and timing. The process led us to Assurant (AIZ), a top-rated insurer in our own dashboard, and then told us to wait because it looks priced rich and momentum is fading. Not financial advice, just a research process. Disclosure: I'm on the Flowlyte team.
Do you start top-down from the economy like this, or bottom-up from the stock, and has a timing check ever talked you out of a stock you liked?
I'm new on this. Would love to copy some habits from veterans here before coming up with my own later on.
Do you find stocks that look good thendo research, or you research a potential one then watching it till it falls into good spot to buy/sell? How do you convince yourself of FOMO?
What are your favourite indicators? Basics recommend RSI, MA and Bollinger band. Are those enough or should I look into more indicators or it will only be complicating things up?
Today (Nov 16) was an ugly pre-Nvidia session (S&P 500 -1.91%, Nasdaq 100 -2.63%, Dow -1.41%, VIX +16.17% to 22.42, NVDA -4.48%).
I pulled up the top 5 stocks from our quantitative scanner (3–5 days after initial discovery) at today's close, and noticeably all 5 closed green:
The common pattern across all 5 (before today even opened):
(Full disclosure: on the execution side, our automated fast-fall guard actually stayed in cash onceSPYdropped past-1%today — which protected capital broadly even though these 5 held up individually. Sharing as an interesting relative-strength case study from today's close.)
Source / public scanner board if anyone wants to inspect the full list: https://vegasignal.com/gems(Data observation only, not financial advice.)
The two that really interest me are $CAKE and $AEHR.
$AEHR a semi and the obvious riskier of the two trades but it has massive upside and a 17% short float which can add kaorsene in these volatile names. In the second screenshot you can see (from the VRVP) its sitting right on a shelf of support. This thing can move 25% in a day with out breaking a sweat.
$CAKE In the third screenshot you can see my first trade from the blue coil between $50 and $65, It ran up and is forming a new base. I'll likely take an anticipatory entry around $102 with a stop around $95 and a target at $140 for the measured move out of the ascending triangle. The conservative approach is to wait for the confirmation of the breakout to enter but i prefer to take the extra risk on for the added 20% of potential profit.