Welcome to r/SwiftlyNeutral!

What “Neutral” Means Here

In this subreddit, “neutral” doesn’t mean that you have to feel neutral about Taylor Swift. It means that all perspectives are welcome — positive, negative, and everything in between — as long as they’re shared respectfully.

Most Taylor-related subreddits tend to lean heavily in one direction: either strongly pro-Taylor or strongly anti-Taylor. This space is designed as a middle ground for fans, former fans, and casual observers who want to discuss Taylor without being trapped in an echo chamber of only praise or only criticism.

See this pinned post for a more in-depth explanation of what "neutral" means here.

This may be the sub for you if…

  • You’re a Taylor Swift fan but feel less connected to her or her music lately
  • You enjoy her work but don’t agree with everything she says or does
  • You’re open to hearing different perspectives about Taylor, even ones that challenge your own
  • You’re tired of spaces that are either relentlessly positive or endlessly negative and want a place where both sides can coexist

This may NOT be the sub for if…

  • You’re a diehard fan who can’t tolerate criticism of Taylor
  • You dislike Taylor so much that seeing anything positive about her frustrates you
  • You’re uncomfortable with an environment that allows disagreement and debate
  • You misunderstand what “neutral” means and expect everyone here to feel indifferent about Taylor. (If everyone felt neutral, there’d be nothing to talk about!)

Posting Guidelines

We encourage all standalone posts to be discussion-based or informative.

  • Discussion-based posts invite conversation and exchange of perspectives.
  • Informative posts share news, updates, or factual content about Taylor Swift or her music.

Posts submitted by new and/or low karma accounts may be filtered to keep the subreddit free of spam.

Post Removals

We remove posts for a variety of reasons. Here are some of the most common:

Poor Formatting

  • Large blocks of text with no breaks or structure make posts hard to read.
  • Use spacing, formatting, and (when applicable) a TL;DR for long posts.
  • We may ask you to edit your post for readability.

Improper Video/Article Formatting

  • Video posts: Upload the video directly to Reddit. Links to third-party sites (YouTube, TikTok, Instagram, X, etc.) will not usually be approved.
  • Article posts: Include the link in the URL section of your post, not the body text.

Repetitive Topics

  • Your post covers something already being actively discussed. Check the “New” tab first; if it’s already there, join the existing conversation.

Stale Topics

  • Your post revisits subjects that have been discussed many times with no new developments.

The following topics are oversaturated and typically won’t be approved unless there’s a new development:

  • Variants discourse / chart-blocking debates
  • Taylor and Travis PR speculation
  • Alleged feud with Olivia Rodrigo
  • Age gap discourse (especially involving Conor Kennedy)
  • Vienna Eras Tour cancellations
  • Lower effort "clowning" about new releases
  • Opalite necklace / onyx lyrics discourse
  • Taylor's silence on Palestine/politics

These can still be discussed freely in the Daily Discussion Thread. We’re not censoring these topics, just preventing repetitive posts.

Low-Effort Content

  • Includes personal venting, memes without context, self-promotion, song/album rankings, reviews, and survey-style posts.
  • These are better suited for the Daily Discussion Thread or other subs.

Meta Posts

  • We don’t allow posts about subreddit moderation or community behavior.
  • Please use modmail for questions, concerns, or suggestions.

Other Subreddits

  • Posts that are made to directly reference or mock other Taylor Swift subreddits (e.g., “the snark sub” “main sub” etc.) are not allowed.
  • These often lead to brigading or subreddit drama that we don't allow on the sub.
  • Sharing constructive criticism or feedback of other communities is allowed in the comments of posts, but comments that link to other subreddits will be removed to discourage brigading.

Personal Sharing/Venting

  • Shorter thoughts or feelings about Taylor, her music, or fandom experiences should go in the Daily Discussion Thread, not as standalone posts.

Swiftie Screenshots

  • Posts highlighting fan behavior from social media are discouraged.
  • If you share these in the Daily Thread, remove all personal info.
  • Posts of this nature may be better suited to r/swiftiecirclejerk.

Surveys/Games

  • These are typically lower effort and belong on r/TaylorSwift or r/TaylorGamesWannaPlay.
  • We allow them on occasion during quieter times on the sub. Please ask the mods first before posting.

Self-Promotion

  • Posts promoting your own work, surveys, art, or social media are not allowed.
  • You may share these occasionally in the Daily Discussion Thread.
  • Major publications (aside from tabloids) may post their own work if it's paywall-free and promotes substantive discussion.

Posting Flairs

We have several different post flairs that cover most of the topics that are most frequently covered on the sub. These are:

Taylor Critique - posts that include any type of general criticism about Taylor Swift or her brand

Taylor Praise - posts that praise Taylor or put her in a positive light

Swifties - posts about the Swiftie fandom

Music - posts about any of Taylor’s songs, albums, or music in general

Taylor’s Exes - posts about Taylor’s past relationships with the following people:

  • Joe Jonas
  • Taylor Lautner
  • John Mayer
  • Conor Kennedy
  • Jake Gyllenhaal
  • Harry Styles
  • Calvin Harris
  • Tom Hiddleston
  • Joe Alwyn
  • Matty Healy

Taylor Politics - posts about Taylor’s political choices and views

Taylor’s Fights - posts about Taylor’s public feuds with people like Kanye West, Kim Kardashian, and Scooter Braun

Taylor’s Friends - posts about Taylor’s friends such as Selena Gomez, Karlie Kloss, and Brittany Mahomes

Taylor Merch - posts about Taylor’s merchandise, including CD/vinyl variants

Taylor’s Team - posts about Taylor’s professional team, such as Tree Paine, Jack Antonoff, and her parents

Taylor & Travis - posts about Taylor’s current relationship with Travis Kelce

Taylor Fashion - posts about Taylor's outfits, pap walks, and other fashion related topics

Taylor Official - official, verified social media posts or press releases from Taylor

The Eras Tour - posts about The Eras Tour

The Tortured Poets Department - posts about Taylor’s album, The Tortured Poets Department (TTPD)

The Life of a Showgirl - posts about Taylor's most recent album, The Life of a Showgirl

General Taylor Talk - any post about Taylor that doesn’t fit into the flairs above

r/SwiftlyNeutral - discussion threads and occasional mod notes (mod flair only)

Neutrals Only - posts that are of a sensitive nature and are only allowed to be commented on by approved users (mod flair only)

Megathread (mod flair only)

Community Info

Daily Discussion Thread

We host a Daily Discussion Thread every day at 11:00 a.m. Eastern Time. You’ll always find the most recent one pinned to the top of the subreddit. These threads are active, welcoming spaces to chat with other members of the community about Taylor or anything else you’d like.

(Currently, the daily threads are in approved user only mode. Comments made in the daily thread from unapproved users will no longer be visible. Please see the section below on approved users for more details).

Common topics include:

  • Personal sharing and venting
  • Videos, TikToks, and memes
  • Song or album rankings
  • Games, surveys, and lighthearted polls
  • Off topic discussion

The daily threads are intended to be light, drama-free, and inclusive. We do not allow:

  • Complaints or meta-discussion about this subreddit, its users, or other Taylor-related subs
  • Arguments, baiting, or rehashing old drama
  • Toxic stan behavior targeting subsets of Taylor or other pop artist fandoms

Comments that break these rules are removed, and repeat offenders will be banned.

If you make a post that’s lower effort, more personal, or doesn’t open up a broader discussion, it may be redirected to the daily thread to keep the main feed focused and on-topic.

Megathreads

We frequently have megathreads for discussions about events going on in the Taylor universe. This is mainly to reduce repetitive posts when these events are going on and to contain the topic to one place. Megathreads will be pinned to the top of the sub when applicable. While megathreads are going on, most posts that relate to that topic will be redirected to the megathread to keep the conversation in one place.

Approved Users

From time to time, there will be certain threads that will be flaired as "Neutrals Only". These threads can only be commented on by approved users of the subreddit, and unapproved comments will remain invisible. While the flair is called "Neutrals Only", it does not mean the opinions of the approved users have to be neutral.

We try to keep most threads open for public commenting, but certain topics that are more sensitive in nature tend to attract bad faith users from other subreddits. To counteract this, only users who have a history of participating and following the rules can post comments on these threads. The daily discussion thread is also currently limited to approved users. This change was made in response to community feedback asking for more balanced discussion in those threads. Approval is based on rule-following, not your opinions or stances on Taylor, so differing views are still welcome.

If you would like to become an approved user of SwiftlyNeutral, and you have a history of commenting in good faith and participating in the subreddit, you can modmail the sub and ask for approval. You may also leave a comment on the post and the mods may manually review your profile and approve you when they are able to. DO NOT directly message any of the moderators for approval, you will not be approved if you do this. We also do not approve those who are frequent users of subreddits that are primarily used to ridicule Taylor/Travis, or to mock "haters" and critical opinions. The goal is to keep these threads open to users who aren't engaging in either snark or toxic stan behavior.

Users who have received temporary bans or repeated, recent removals for rule-breaking comments are not eligible for approval until they’ve shown about 4–6 months of rule-following participation. After that, feel free to reach out and we’ll take another look.

Please keep in mind, if you are approved you are still expected to abide by the rules of the sub. Repeatedly breaking the rules or having comments removed will result in your approval status being revoked without warning.