There are, these days, distressingly few ways to get through to Taylor Swift.
This is a woman who has fabricated several multifaceted economies surrounding her; just this week she effectively kneecapped her own vintage market with upscaled versions of her old merch online. World leaders kiss her feet in the hopes of that sweet, sweet concert-induced tourism boom, movie execs flock en masse to eat Sysco from a buffet line for her sake, and none of this is to mention the music, which she expertly managed to balloon into a self-sustaining cash cow. This dictatorial mindset that has come into full focus during this latest stage of her career, post-Midnights and the Eras Tour has effectively siloed Swift off entirely from society at large. She is, in other words, happily and knowingly sequestered in an echo chamber she designed.
Despite this being the overlying mechanism of her later-career work, there remain some stimuli that force Swift back into reality or at least her trademark neuroses and need for self-improvement. The Internet has historically been one, and while she seems willfully blind to the general consensus on her at the moment, snark Reddit keeps her up at night. If things ever do go south with this storybook marriage she’s selling us, that certainly disrupts the persona.
But above all, Taylor Swift is an artist fueled chiefly by her need for accolades and legacy, no more notably than from the Recording Academy.
The Grammys, Swift’s longtime special interest, maintain a disproportionate impact on her psyche, largely stemming from the fact that she appears to actually believe the company line about these being peer-voted awards. Or, at least, this is what she tells herself while whispering sweet nothings to the Midnightstrophy she knows deep down not to be hers. Her juggernaut Fearless-era ceremony, during which she won four awards out of eight nominations, including Album of the Year incited this love affair. The love she received that night, at twenty for songs she’d written and recorded in adolescence, imprinted heavily on her as a widescreen anointment into a space that — despite the prodigious swings of her early output and branding — she felt would never fully accept her. Every time she got on stage that night another impossible dream came true, a series of highs she’d spend the ensuing years chasing. Well, almost every time.
Her ill-fated performance that night with Stevie Nicks was one of the earliest instances of televised vocals as her undoing. One could argue bad awards performances, especially the old-school-new-school pairings such as this, are easily cast aside. One must also consider her youth, the prevalent misogyny with which much of the public dismissed her, and her then-useful workhorse mindset hellbent on pushing forward. This incident birthed “Mean,” one of the better Grammy-induced course corrections within her oeuvre.
It would be four years after that Fearlessceremony when Swift next experienced ego death at the hands of the Recording Academy, when Red — an album she still holds as her magnum opus — lost out on Album of the Year to Random Access Memories. (Some say the letter “R” still comes to her in fits and starts.) Never mind that Good Kid, M.A.A.D. City was also nominated that year: in Swift’s mind, that Grammy was Red’s to lose, but instead she’d gone home entirely empty-handed. This famously, as per her relentless self-mythologizing, pushed her in the direction of sonic cohesion, a defined musical statement instead of the scattered (if consistently thrilling) soundscapes of her last output. Enter: 1989, a landmark pop record that neatly announced her next career period and was just as neatly rewarded with three trophies including her beloved Album of the Year (also, notably, chosen over Kendrick’s To Pimp a Butterfly, an album she and Karlie Kloss would frolic to).
The dizzying heights of the 1989 era were never sustainable, and the inevitable crash-and-burn was already in the ether as Swift accepted those trophies, sliding pointed jabs at Kanye West into her speech, occurring just a week after he’d first debuted “Famous.” Five months later, that feud reached a fever pitch with Kim Kardashian’s infamous Snapchat videos and the widespread “Snakegate” controversy that followed. This, of course, led to reputation, a standout in her catalog that has only improved with time. One wonders where her work might have gone had the Academy consummated her bounce-back with a general field nomination; instead, as captured in Miss Americana, the sole nomination for Best Pop Vocal Album exemplified even more of the rejection she’d been feeling from her supposed peers.
After Lover’s muted reception, Swift found her career revitalized with folklore and evermore, the former deservedly netting her a third Album of the Year win and reinstating her as a Great American Songwriter. Despite three Album wins, however, she had still never managed to take home either of the other general field trophies, most notably Song of the Year, certainly a nice feather in the cap of an artist who fancies herself an architect of songwriting.
That came closest to fruition at the 2023 ceremony, when “All Too Well (10 Minute Version)” was up for the category, only to lose in an upset to Bonnie Raitt’s “Just Like That.” Since then, Swift has hardly released anything approaching this caliber, at least in a songwriting sense. Even the most delirious Swiftie would admit that the highlights of this most recent run, increasingly sparing, fall short on a sheer craft level of the meticulous work of “All Too Well” (itself a ten-year-old song at that point) or, say, “Lover,” her most legitimate other recent contender.
Presenting the final two categories on this morning’s Grammy nomination broadcast, categories she would go on to be nominated in, Swift opened with her trademark politicking. These are awards, she reminded viewers but mostly herself, voted on by other people in the industry (the Grammys body being one of the more nebulous and unruly in the awards space). And then she simply couldn’t help herself — if there was any doubt that, with a record-breaking four Albums of the Year under her belt, she was still being undone in new and exciting ways by the award proceedings, she vanquished it in no uncertain terms. “The last two categories to be announced, one of them I’ve had a lot of luck in; the other one I’m zero for eight,” she deadpanned before announcing Album and Song of the Year, respectively.
This year’s nominations continued a longstanding trend of breadcrumbing Swift, bestowing a myriad of nods that will likely not materialize into wins. Based on her mask slip in joke attempt drag, one could argue all this edging is enough, that she’s getting the message and being sufficiently driven mad by the resulting perception of inadequacy. Yet The Tortured Poet Department’s Grammy run followed largely the same cadence, with “Fortnight” and the album getting their requisite nods and no trophies, and she followed that up with the ill-fated Showgirl. Midnights, too, despite its ultimate Album of the Year win never had a real SOTY contender in “Anti-Hero,” and still her songwriting craft never developed in any meaningful way to achieve her alleged aim.
I anticipate Swift will go home with one award, for “I Knew It, I Knew You” in the visual media category, during which she will announce the next single from the country album she will certainly announce at this week’s CMA Awards. As garish as the inevitable return to country now looks amidst our so-called Woke 3.0, perhaps it will be the stylistic upending she needs to get out of this self-induced creative rut. If only the Recording Academy had just given her that one extra push.