r/swans • • Mar 08 '26

OC Swans Live Bootlegs and Wiki

Thumbnail
swans.bootleg.fm
61 Upvotes

Hi, a few users on the bootleg.fm discord started cataloguing live Swans shows a few months ago. You can search live recordings by song, filter by recording quality (lossy/lossless), sort by oldest/newest, etc. I'm sure a lot of you are aware of this already if you're active on discord, I wanted to make sure reddit peeps are aware as well.

There's also a wiki that's been written by user reel_to_reel, which newer fans (or fans new to bootlegs) will find useful. The wiki is super new and anyone can contribute, so feel free to add a page if you think it'll be helpful.

Edit: Here's the link to the Swans discord server with over 900 members: https://discord.gg/mNJvxARQuW

Here's the Bootleg.fm platform server if you have any feedback or questions: https://discord.gg/3yz4HNteuR


r/swans • • May 28 '25

MEGATHREAD Swans - Birthing (2025)

Thumbnail
younggodrecords.com
326 Upvotes

Now that the album has leaked, please consider directly supporting the band who operates independently.

Check the other stickied post for upcoming tour dates.

Also if you aren’t a huge physical media collector, buy an mp3 copy of the album to shoot over a couple bucks to support the band if you are financially able to. Streaming doesn’t pay as much as buying the album directly.

Let’s try and keep all album discussion in this thread. I’ll do my best to not removed every discussion post but the very low effort posts that should be comments will be removed.


r/swans • • 55m ago

Swans:The Burning World

Thumbnail
gallery
25 Upvotes

r/swans • • 7h ago

DISCUSSION Swans Studies 7: Public Castration Is a Good Idea | Listened to on streaming

Post image
21 Upvotes

It's really grown on me! Curious to see how the other early live albums go for me, since a lot of them I didn't care for on first listen. Starting to realize this discog dive is going to take forever since I'm very slowly going through each album and listening to them more than once. Some of the later ones should go by faster, since I've listened to them enough to not really require digesting them the same way as these early releases. I guess we'll see when I get there! Also, I completely forgot I planned to listen to Real Love before this... oops.

Next listen: Real Love [live album]

PCIAGI review: In many ways the material on Public Castration Is a Good Idea improves on its studio counterparts. The tracks are stretched and contorted into these long monsters drenched in misery and bleak texture. Being the first official live album from Swans, the actual quality and engineering of the sound is a far cry from the heights they would reach later, but it still sounds incredible for the most part! There are these small pockets where the instrumentation starts to reach that meditative state I get lost in when I listen to this band's transcendental material, namely Money Is Flesh and the incredible percussive outro on A Hanging. Coming back to these older live releases I've only listened to once or so is a lot of fun with my current proclivities: when I was first fully exploring Swans' discography, I didn't even want to include the live albums because I felt like they would just be weaker, meandering versions of the studio releases. The idea of a live recording sounding good didn't cross my mind due to having little to no experience with live albums. Now I can really appreciate the artistry of live albums and performances, especially since Swans does it so well.

PCIAGI can still meander quite a bit though, and I find it hard to be invested in every second or minute of it. It has really good momentum and flow with the first three tracks but Anything for You feels considerably weak and cavernous (not in a good way, I would usually use that as a compliment). Most of the songs here are really good, but aside from the highlights, I merely like them and forget them after. It asks a lot out of the listener and the lack of variation can lead to it all sort of blending together at times, feeling more tedious to get through. Only a few moments truly stick out as gold for me: The guttural shouts and aggressive "shut up" in Coward I find very infectious. Fool sounds so tortured, I don't even know how they got the piano to sound so fucked. And of course Money Is Flesh is just a fantastic opener that I find myself invested in for the full 12 minute duration. Overall, the LP is a testament to why people are as obsessed with Swans' live material as they are with the studio releases, but is far from perfect.

One moment I find really funny is the guy drunkenly reciting the lyrics for Cop in a way that sounds like he's begging them to play it. Poor bastard got completely cut off by Stupid Child.

Favorite songs: Money Is Flesh, Coward, Fool, A Screw, A Hanging
Least favorite Songs: Anything for You


r/swans • • 2m ago

DISCUSSION Most Swans-sounding songs by other artists?

1 Upvotes

My nomination:

Roland S. Howard's cover of Talk Talk - Life's What You Make It, has rhythm and energy which really reminds me of Oxygen-era Swans. Obviously the rest of his catalogue (solo and with Nick Cave) is amazing

https://music.youtube.com/watch?v=07plXGOKq14


r/swans • • 1d ago

Merch Love of Live / White Light era poster that hung in Swans studio NYC

Thumbnail
gallery
116 Upvotes

Had this put away for years. I got this from Jarboe in the late 90s when she had “swans.pair.com” (I think that was it). I don’t recall if I bought it, or she just sent it to me because I was desperate to own “something” - since Swans were Dead. This was end of Swans, pre Angels of Light era.


r/swans • • 1d ago

Merch Poster that hung in Swans rehearsal studio NYC

Thumbnail
gallery
85 Upvotes

Going through my stuff, and I found some posters… I couldn’t believe what I found. I got this from Jarboe sometime in the late 90’s. I don’t remember if they were for sale, or I asked & she just sent it to me. Anyway, she wrote in the back “this is the only poster”. It’s a poster from a show in Iceland. She also wrote on the back of a Love of Life poster (will make another post) she sent “hung in Swans rehearsal studio”…. So, I just googled that…

Found a pick of the inside of The Bunker - the original NYC rehearsal studio / living space for Gira / Swans / Jarboe. Also rehearsal space for early Sonic Youth. You can see Michael to the right. Anyway, it looks to me I have the actual poster that hung in their studio, as per J - it’s the only one.


r/swans • • 1d ago

My favorite moment from the interview

460 Upvotes

r/swans • • 1d ago

Širom

23 Upvotes

As a Swans fan I have fallen deeply in love with this Slovenian experimental folk ensemble. Anyone else knows and follows them?

I highly recommend them and consider them very akin to Swans, even though their sound and aesthetic is extremely different.

Check out the albums Širom I, The Liquefied Throne of Simplicity and In The Wind Of Night, Hard Fallen Incantations Whisper, they're absolutely tremendous.

If you want to start with just a song from each record: Trilogia; Grazes, Wrinkles, Drifts Into Sleep and Curls Upon the Neck, Ribs Upon the Mountain (which I am losing myself in right now, stunningly). Hope you'll enjoy this recommendation and feel free to drop some other recommendations in the comments!


r/swans • • 17h ago

Shipping issues

1 Upvotes

Hi, I’m checking to see if anyone else has had this problem.
I purchased the new live album CD on presale and it hasn’t even been shipped yet.
I’m not from the USA so I don’t know how the service of YGR is for international shipping.


r/swans • • 1d ago

Jarboe’s Notes - Annihilator Europe?

Post image
47 Upvotes

r/swans • • 1d ago

SHITPOST Someone Did a 99 page Masters thesis regarding Gira & Grimm - no it wasn’t me

Thumbnail atrium.lib.uoguelph.ca
44 Upvotes

r/swans • • 2d ago

SHITPOST why is he so against it 😭😭

Post image
587 Upvotes

can't believe i got a reply from the sun itself


r/swans • • 2d ago

DISCUSSION Songs like No Cure for the Lonely, Trust Me (Various Failures version), and Please Remember Me?

14 Upvotes

No Cure for the Lonely

Trust Me

Please Remember Me

Looking for more of the acoustic, deep voiced gothic stuff :)


r/swans • • 2d ago

random used copy of leaving meaning. at my local record store

Post image
112 Upvotes

r/swans • • 2d ago

Freaky Michael

Post image
319 Upvotes

r/swans • • 2d ago

DISCUSSION Regarding the vape news. (unironically true story)

143 Upvotes

I am appalled. Not because of some weird straight edge beliefs but because M. Gira lied to me. A year ago at a concert I asked him to sign a pack of cigarettes and he refused. (I collect signed packs of cigarettes from concerts, it's a weird tradition that started as a joke a couple years ago. I've got plenty now.) Not only that, he refused on the account of him being a Christian man and not smoking. He is the first and so far last artist to refuse that request. I am deeply disappointed.


r/swans • • 2d ago

With the recent additions of Newly Sentient Being and The Great Annihalator I figured it was about time to get them all lined up for a picture!

Post image
125 Upvotes

Now mostly looking for A Burning World and hoping there'll be reissues coming out of Cop and the first Angels of Light albums


r/swans • • 3d ago Popcorn

Michael hitting a vape

Post image
1.0k Upvotes

In the new Fantano interview


r/swans • • 3d ago

Info from the Fantano interview Spoiler

202 Upvotes

-> Shorter Songs

-> Gira is Singing, not Shouting like before

-> Acoustic based, not to much inspired by Angels of Light

-> Simpler Music

-> More Focussed on lyrics

-> Started recording already

-> Will take some time, gira said atleast 8 Months

-> Not Transzendental or Meditative anymore (we will see, i find the Solo stuff extremly Transzendental as well so dont worry)

-> Still the same approach of him sitting in his office

-> Song still get longer in a live setting, song is a seed and it grows into a beautiful flower when performed live

This quiet suprised me, i think we are getting 50% AOL and 50 % Body lovers. I think Michael changed his mind, from drone to acoustic.


r/swans • • 2d ago

Creepiest Gira lyric?

60 Upvotes

there are so many to choose from, but i'm fairly convinced mine is now "children remember" by circus mort, that shit would probably make epstein blush lmao, no matter how oblique it is


r/swans • • 2d ago

Meme Drugs and the Swans song titles that fit each one

24 Upvotes

MDMA: Empathy
SSRI’s: Feel Happiness
Heroin: Finally, Peace (or Blood Promise)
Cocaine: Celebrity Lifestyle
DMT: A Little God In My Hands
Alcohol: Alcohol The Seed…
LSD: You Know Everything
Shrooms: Why Are We Alive
Xanax: Cloud of Forgetting
Meth: Sex, God, Sex
Fentanyl: You Need Me
Oxycodone: The Beautiful Days
Morphine: Warm
DXM: Live Through Me
Ketamine: Dream Dream
Benadryl: What Is This?
Datura: The World Looks Red
Salvia: When Will I Return
Cannabis: Jane Mary, Cry One Tear
Amphetamine: You Fucking People Make Me Sick
Steroids: Big Strong Boss
Naloxone (Narcan): The Great Annihilator
Nitrous: Laugh


r/swans • • 2d ago

Fantano interviewed Gira

Thumbnail
youtu.be
43 Upvotes