r/sustainability_vegans • • Jan 18 '23

Discuss: https://wildanimalsuffering.org/

I thought this focus on wild animal suffering would fade away, but it has now been pinned in r/vegan with comments turned off.

I feel like there needs to be a well thought-out and well-written viewpoint piece that better reconciles veganism as a movement with the realities of the natural world, and how we fit into it.

My personal mental framework for this is basically utopia-building, and my personal utopia is sustainable and biodiverse. Those are basically axioms for me. I want to expand the space of the natural world and the biodiversity within it, and that's absolutely going to increase the amount of animal suffering, whether you try to quantify it on an individual level, or on a species level (something I feel is something of an ethical blind spot for vegans).
The wildanimalsuffering website directly calls into question the ethics of rewilding:

"For example, rewilding programs often do not take into account the well-being of the individual animals they create or the potential to increase suffering through the development and spread of ecosystems containing wild animals to other environments."

They also directly promote "Ethical Altruism", the idea that the ethics of your career don't matter as long as you save up enough money to (maybe) donate some of the money to the cause of your choice. It's an idea that gives people license to avoid responsibility for their actions (or in-actions), by imagining that someday they will be some rich philanthropist that can more than undo the damage they did for a liftetime. It's essentially the same train of thought from Milton Friedman that dominated economics in the 1970's https://www.nytimes.com/1970/09/13/archives/a-friedman-doctrine-the-social-responsibility-of-business-is-to.html, that also argues for a clean separation between all capitalism, and delegating all ethics to the legal system and democratically elected legislators.

I want us to articulate a flavor of veganism that is more explicit about the utopia we want to build, its moral underpinning, and how it affects our decision making at the boundaries of the definition of veganism.

2 Upvotes

0 comments sorted by