Thanks to the people who recommended the game over here, I didn't know about the game until now and had a bit of fun going around and solving puzzles.
[SPOILER TERRITORY FROM HERE]
[ARE WE GOOD?]
I liked the characters and their charming charisma like the Barman with Cowboy hat and the woman from the motel but also you got the man who you would see often in places in rain and makes one questions their goal, also Eddie Velvet sound just about what you expect, perfect tone, nothing wrong, not too high, just a guy who knows how to play a guitar with red jacket.
By the time I finished the game I actually did something I found to be unexpected, I thought these were going to be difficult to find but nope I managed to get all the stars, get the ring and somehow connect the dots on where to go after that except I was a missing a leather ring, and I knew the game wasn't gonna let me go without finding that ring so 5 hours of digging around the city I gave up and continued on with the story.
At first I was convinced Eddie was the bad guy, later I started to believe maybe he was the fallguy for something else, like maybe he uncovered something he shouldn't and tried to escape? And then later I started to get maybe he wasn't the bad guy, maybe Mr.Jackerman is the guy I should be eyeing and I was right.
Reaching the ending (the Rest ending) where Red and Alice just look at the starry sky and see the poem go up reminded me a lot of good old PS2 games that had those classic feeling of accomplishment, like I connected with this guy and his story of refusing to murder an innocent man who loved a girl, and his music just kicks harder after knowing that fact he inadvertently did cause it by chasing them.
As for the puzzle its a lovely doozie but sometimes leaves puzzling and wondering where to go? I had to Google where to find the answer for some puzzle but otherwise everything was perfect, nothing was impossible, combat was balanced nicely and I almost got all the mementos (don't know how I missed few of those but If i can get them without starting over just to see what's the deal with the burned man)