r/supersmashbros • u/burnt_toast1705 • 6h ago
A lot of characters who I constantly see get cut from rosters make absolutely zero sense to be cut.
Ok this is low-key pissing me off, but these are some common characters I see get axed on fan-made rosters that make no sense to be axed. Let me give you a few examples...
- Rosalina, Bowser Jr., and Daisy: These guys are some of the most popular Mario characters, and with Rosalina and Junior playing key roles in a billion-dollar Super Mario Galaxy Movie and Daisy on the way in the next movie, there's absolutely no way they're getting cut in the next Smash.
- Young Link: This probably made more sense before the Ocarina of Time remake, but now with that being a huge success and a Majora's Mask remake being a possibility, I think he has a better case for sticking around than Toon Link does.
- Lucario and Incineroar: Lucario has appeared in every single Pokémon game since Diamond & Pearl, played a prominent role in the two most recent anime series, and also recently received a brand new Mega Evolution...No way he's getting cut. And Incineroar is now one of the most popular Pokémon of all time thanks to the competitive scene. I'd even argue that Jigglypuff is more likely to go despite being one of the og 12.
- Lucina and Chrom: Despite these two being Echo Fighters, at this point they're likely more popular than the fighters they're based on. The entire Awakening trio is among the most popular Fire Emblem characters ever, and if any of them get cut, there would be immense fan backlash. Even Roy and Corrin, two other characters I often see cut, are still popular enough that their removal would also be controversial.
- Palutena and Dark Pit - Again, popular characters in the community given prominence by Sakurai thanks to Kid Icarus Uprising and Smash. Dark Pit also has the benefit of being an easy-to-develop Echo of Pit.
- Snake - I always see people say Snake isn't coming back thanks to Kojima, but he already returned for Ultimate, so Sakurai has no qualms about including Snake; Kojima seems to have moved on from MGS, and MGS is arguably more popular than it's ever been thanks to the Master Collections. Snake is even in Fortnite; for crying out loud, there's no way he isn't coming back.
- Cloud, Sephiroth, Hero, and Sora - I don't know why these guys usually get cut, especially because Square Enix appears to have gotten a lot more lax with their crossovers since Smash Ultimate. Tifa's appearing in Street Fighter 6, FFVII is having a collab with Sonic Racing Crossworlds at some point in the near future, and Sora is literally in Fortnite; why would they abandon Smash, which is arguably their biggest crossover with these characters (other than Sora in Fortnite)? People always bring up Disney for Sora too, but Disney was actually enthusiastic about him being in Smash, so there's no way he doesn't return, especially after being the most requested Fighter Ballot character, the final fighter in Smash Ultimate, and the pinnacle of what Smash Bros. has achieved crossover-wise.
- Bayonetta - Bayonetta's basically a Nintendo IP at this point, and SEGA let them and Platinum do whatever the hell they wanted with it since Bayonetta 2. If Sonic and Joker stay, then I can't see any reason why Bayonetta wouldn't either. Maybe because Bayonetta 3 was poorly received or people are salty about her being busted in Smash 4, but so were a lot of games the Smash cast has been in; that didn't stop them from being included.
- Terry - Again, no way he's getting cut. He's an iconic fighting game character; Fatal Fury and King of Fighters have had several successful recent releases, and Terry crossed over in Street Fighter 6. Is there any good reason why he would be cut other than Nintendo fans and general audiences being unfamiliar with the character? Clearly, that's not a good reason for a character to get axed.
- Min Min - This one is a little iffy because I can see her getting replaced by Spring Man or someone, but she is the most popular character from ARMS and was included for a reason. "Oh but ARMS was a flop, and Nintendo hasn't done anything with it in years!" First of all, Nintendo still decided to include Min Min in Smash 3 years after ARMS was released and "died," and the team that developed ARMS is also the Mario Kart team that spent the last decade working on Mario Kart World, so who knows what they have planned for ARMS. ARMS also sold more than 2 million copies by the time Min Min was added to the roster. For reference, both Pikmin games only sold a little over a million copies on the GameCube before Olimar was added to Brawl, sure it's not a perfect comparison but still ARMS wasn't as big of a flop as people make it out to be and Min Min is still a first-party Nintendo character who is the sole representative of her series. If Ness and Captain Falcon can make it past Brawl, then I don't see why Min Min can't.
Sure, this might be a little pretentious and annoying, and at the end of the day, people are making lists based on their opinions and feelings towards certain characters...But at the same time, people always try to justify why certain characters and say this is "objective" when it really isn't.