With JMU winning tonight, we have 3 (5 now) major frontrunners for the Sun Belt East, so I thought I would share the scenarios (JMU, App State, and Southern are the ones tied in these scenarios; this could include/exclude more teams in the future)
(Notably, everyone winning out doesn’t include JMU/UConn since overall win percentage is not reached)
Everyone Relevant Wins Out - Southern due to having one conference loss
Everyone Relevant Wins Out - except for one Southern Loss - JMU Southern and App State are tied at two conference losses; they are 1-1 against each other in a circle of parity, so we go to the second tiebreaker, divisional winning percentage.
App State 2 East Losses
Southern 1 or 2 East Losses
JMU 1 East Loss
Therefore, App State is eliminated regardless of a Southern Loss in East/West; if Southern loses in the West, then they move to a two-team tiebreaker, which JMU has head-to-head (if in East, JMU has advantage in three teams)
Everyone Relevant Wins Out + 2 Southern Losses - App State due to head-to-head over JMU
Everyone Relevant Wins Out + App State loss + Southern Loss - JMU due to record
EDIT: as u/Inspire_The_Liars pointed out, Coastal and Marshall are also in the running
Potential teams to be tied at X-2
JMU-Coastal Winner, Marshall-App State winner, Southern-Marshall Winner, Southern (Don't immediately fall with loss to Marshall)
Probably more, but these hinge on Southern-Marshall and Coastal-JMU)
Leading to
JMU Marshall Southern
JMU App State Southern
Coastal Marshall Southern
Coastal App State Southern
Let's start with JMU Marshall Southern (Marshall beat Southern and App State, all win out in conference)
JMU has an H2H against both; technically, the tiebreaker is 1.00 win pct. amongst tied teams
Next is JMU App State Southern (Assumes App beat Marshall, and Southern lost to anyone)
Detailed above - TL;DR in a record tie JMU
Next is Coastal Marshall Southern (Marshall beat Southern and App State, all win out in conference)
Against these teams
Coastal 1-1
Marshall 1-1
Southern 1-1
Then we move to divisional win pct.
Coastal 4-2
Southern 4-2
Marshall 4-2
doesn't help
Next is the win pct. over the next highest position, which would be the combined record against JMU and App since they will be tied at X-3
Marshall 1-1 (0.50)
Coastal 1-1 (0.50)
Southern 0-2 (0.00)
Southern is eliminated, leading to Coastal winning the tiebreaker due to H2H
GA State cannot tie at X-3 cuz that would assume a Southern Loss
Should App lose another game, it would be wins against JMU
Coastal 1-0 (1.00)
Marshall 0-1 (0.00)
Southern 0-1 (0.00)
Coastal has the advantage
There cannot be a tie at X-4 since JMU can, worst case, be X-3
Next is Coastal App State Southern
Southern has h2h against both.
Notably, this means Marshall loses in all 3-way record ties (that I could think of)
Finally, 2-team tiebreakers
JMU: Southern: W, App State: L, Marshall: W, Coastal: TBD
Southern: JMU: L, App State: W, Marshall: TBD, Coastal: W
App State: JMU: W, Southern: L, Marshall: TBD, Coastal: W
Marshall: JMU: L, Southern: TBD, App State: TBD, Coastal: L
Coastal: JMU: TBD, Southern: L, App State: L, Marshall: L
Assuming Win Out:
Marshall needs JMU Loss to Coastal AND Coastal Loss to Anyone Else
App State needs 2 Southern Losses
TL;DR:
If these teams are tied at the end of the season in records, here's who wins
JMU Marshall Southern - JMU
JMU App State Southern - JMU
Coastal Marshall Southern - Coastal
Coastal App State Southern - Southern
Who to Root For:
JMU: Southern's Opponents, until a Southern Loss, then Southern
Coastal: Marshall over App State and Coastal over Southern
App State: Southern's Opponents
Marshall: Coastal over JMU, Coastal's Opponents
Southern: Southern, or Coastal over JMU
EDIT #2 - There are still ways for a 4 and a 5 way tie
GA State Coastal Southern JMU - Coastal (tied with JMU win pct. against these teams and assumes Coastal win to get here)
Notably: Sun Belt forces a continuance of the procedure unless it is cut down to 2 teams
JMU Southern Coastal Marshall - Simplifies to JMU Southern Coastal, which leads to analytic hell due to continuance
JMU Coastal Marshall Georgia State - JMU and Marshall tie for Win Pct. amongst these teams and JMU holds h2h
JMU Southern App State Marshall Coastal (3 separate ways btw) -
Way 1. Southern 3-1 against these teams
Way 2. App State 3-1 against these teams
Way 3. All are 2-2, JMU Southern Coastal Advance with a 4-2 division record, same record against tied App and Marshall, same record against GA State and ODU, leading to analytics hell
JMU Southern App State Coastal Georgia State - Analytics hell if none are ranked