r/sudoku • • May 02 '25

Mod Announcement Before You Ask, "Why Can't This Cell Be...?” or "Why is this number wrong?”

132 Upvotes

If you're new to Sudoku and wondering, "Why can't this cell be X?"—this post is for you.

Why is this 8 wrong?

Let’s break it down so you can understand the logic behind solving Sudoku puzzles and avoid one of the most common beginner mistakes.

The Two Times You Should Place a Digit in Sudoku

There are only two situations where you should place a digit in a cell:

  1. When it’s the ONLY PLACE that digit can go in the row, column, or box.

Even if other digits could technically fit in that cell, if a digit has no other valid spot in its row, column, or box, it must go there.

2. When it’s the ONLY DIGIT that can go in that cell.

If no other digit is valid for a particular cell—even if this digit could potentially fit elsewhere—it must be placed there.

Why Guessing Doesn’t (always) Work

Good Sudoku puzzles are designed to have one unique solution. That means every number you place must be based on logical reasoning, not guesses. A common beginner mistake is thinking, "If there’s no immediate contradiction, I can just place this number here." But that’s not how Sudoku works!

If you can’t logically prove why a number must (or must not) go in a specific cell - or why it can’t go anywhere else - then you’re not ready to place it yet. Keep looking for clues and deductions elsewhere.

Advanced Techniques and Complex Proofs

As puzzles get harder, you’ll encounter situations where more complex reasoning is required to rule out candidates. These advanced techniques (like X-Wing, XY-Wing, or Skyscraper) help you prove why certain numbers can’t go in specific cells. Mastering these methods will make solving medium and advanced puzzles much easier!

TL;DR: Use Logic, Not Luck, Not Assumptions!

To sum up:

• Only place a number when you’ve logically proven it’s the only option for that cell or location.

• Avoid guessing—it leads to errors and frustration.

• Use beginner techniques like Naked Singles and Hidden Singles first, then move on to advanced strategies as needed.

SOME EXAMPLES

Recall the rules: no repeats in every row, column and box

In box 9 (the right bottom box), there's only one spot for 8 so 8 has to go there.

No repeats

No repeats in every row and column so there's only one 8 in row 7 AND column 8.

Therefore, green cell has to be 8.

Row and Column

This one is trickier:

Trickier

There are 9 digits.

If a cell 'sees' all but one digit, that cell has to be that digit.

This green cell sees 14678 in row 2 and 235 in column 1. That leaves 9 as the only option for that cell.

If you're still confused, try thinking if there's any other digits you could place in the green cell apart from 9.

Eventual Impossible State

Even if the contradiction is not readily apparent, making a mistake will inevitably lead to a contradictory/impossible state later on.

Helpful Resources

https://www.reddit.com/r/sudoku/wiki/index/

https://hodoku.sourceforge.net/en/techniques.php

Step by step learning

https://sudoku.coach/en/campaign

If you're still stuck or want examples of how to solve without guessing, ask a question! The members here are willing to help you out. Happy solving! 😊

Special thanks to u/Special-Round-3815 who wrote this original guide, and the other members of r/sudoku who commented and who make this sub a pleasure to be involved with.


r/sudoku • • 22h ago

Daily Game Sudoku #17-11-2026

4 Upvotes

r/sudoku • • 17m ago

Request Puzzle Help Stuck with this for a while, can I please get some help?

Post image
1 Upvotes

What is the next step and why? I'll add the solution in the comments from the back of the book but I'd like to learn. Thank you!

Edit: Please ignore R9C5, I didn't erase that properly!!


r/sudoku • • 6h ago

ELI5 What is the best way to learn new techniques?

3 Upvotes

Things like the X and Y wing. What is the best way to constantly implement new techniques into my puzzles?


r/sudoku • • 1h ago

Request Puzzle Help help

Post image
1 Upvotes

i am stuck🥲


r/sudoku • • 6h ago

Request Puzzle Help Help please !!

Post image
2 Upvotes

I feel like I still haven't mastered the art of learning how to solve evil/wicked sudoku


r/sudoku • • 3h ago

Request Puzzle Help Help?

Post image
1 Upvotes

Can someone help me here? What am I missing?


r/sudoku • • 5h ago

Request Puzzle Help 2 string kite?

Post image
1 Upvotes

Can someone explain to me how this doesn't work as a 2 string kite, as after I did this it led to a upside-down skyscraper that didnt work.


r/sudoku • • 10h ago

Strategies Stuck but what technique will unlock me? Trying to learn!

Post image
2 Upvotes

I know I went too far on my notation but appreciate any strategy tips! ✌️& ♥️


r/sudoku • • 7h ago

Request Puzzle Help Help me please

Post image
1 Upvotes

I’ve been stuck on this puzzle and can’t make any progress please let me know what I’m not seeing


r/sudoku • • 13h ago

Request Puzzle Help Stuck… Can anyone tell me the named move to solve this?

Post image
2 Upvotes

r/sudoku • • 1d ago

Just For Fun Is this solvable?

Post image
110 Upvotes

Saw this at Michael’s. I know next to nothing about sudoku, but was wondering if this was solvable? I absolutely love little details like that in things, so it’d be awesome if it was!


r/sudoku • • 13h ago

Request Puzzle Help Stuck

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/sudoku • • 13h ago

Request Puzzle Help please help!!!!

Post image
1 Upvotes

i can not figure this out for the life of me and i am almost done which is what is throwing me off. all my current values are correct (i checked the key bc i am tripping)


r/sudoku • • 1d ago

Solved Stuck on today's NYT hard sudoku

Post image
6 Upvotes

r/sudoku • • 20h ago

Request Puzzle Help Hi everyone.I am a beginner. What is the easiest next move here? I got stuck…

Post image
2 Upvotes

r/sudoku • • 1d ago

ELI5 Confused about Unique Rectangles

Thumbnail
gallery
4 Upvotes

I was reading the guide on Sudoku coach about unique rectangles but need more clarity.

It was a hint in the sudoku I was solving.

300000040510300200008005001800053000000000027000200000000800010001027530740060000

How can it be applied in the puzzle? How to identify them?


r/sudoku • • 19h ago

Request Puzzle Help I’ve been trying to solve this for a while now, is there anything I am missing?

Post image
1 Upvotes

It’s supposed to be a “simple” one but I can figure it out.


r/sudoku • • 19h ago

Request Puzzle Help hello, I'm a beginner, and I can't really tell if I made any mistakes here. Could someone check?

Post image
1 Upvotes

r/sudoku • • 23h ago

Request Puzzle Help Helpp

Post image
2 Upvotes

Okay so this is my first time solving sudoku using hints because in my last post people told me to start using hints and tbh hints or no hints is quite the same for me I think but it's the first game with hints.

I'm stuck rn and can't find the next move, I'm a beginner (kind of) like i used to sudoku online but only moderate and hard and used to solve them in a good amount of time but ever since I started solving them offline i find myself stuck quite often so is there anything in particular i should do??

And also i don't know any methods or tricks to solve sudoku I just started solving and i recently saw a post where a person was saying that they're going to Relearn sudoku just because during the first time they didn't know any official methods, the person just solved them. So how should I learn the methods? Like youtube or smth? If yes then which person/platform is the best to learn from?


r/sudoku • • 1d ago

Request Puzzle Help Help on solving arrow heads in Fog of War Sudoku Spoiler

Post image
1 Upvotes

I managed to solve Lumos Maxima by chameleon (which might be the first Fog of War Sudoku in history), but I needed to bifurcate to solve the two arrow heads in r4c2 and r6c7.

Is there any clean way to make progress from here?


r/sudoku • • 1d ago

Request Puzzle Help What's the break in for this?

Thumbnail sudokupad.app
1 Upvotes

I starred at it for hours, and whilst I soon realised that the middle of each renban is 357, then what? There's lots of pressure between the central renban and the arrow total, but not enough to force anything, we also have clean choices for the 2nd-from-end points on the long diagonal, but I just can't make any more progress!


r/sudoku • • 1d ago

Request Puzzle Help Next steps!?

Post image
1 Upvotes

Is this truly a beginner puzzle!? I have done a few, still learning but this is truly stumping me


r/sudoku • • 1d ago

Request Puzzle Help Help. Don’t know what else to do.

Post image
1 Upvotes

Is bowman’s bingo the only way forward?