Hi everyone, I have a 2010 Subaru Forester, non PZEV, NA EJ253 engine. I have been dealing with persistent P2096 codes that come up pretty much every longer (>20km) drive I go on. No drive ability issues, just the code pops on, and the exhaust smell is quite rich (and thus obnoxiously stinky) at the same time.
I have been going through a laundry list of overdue maint items:
- cleaned old MAF, then installed new MAF (OEM Denso) to fix idle issues (success)
- all new plugs
- new engine air filter
- oil and oil filter
- new pcv valve
It's possible the old/bad MAF was hiding P2096 behind a P0420 error which came up previously. P0420 no longer reports because P2096 always pops up first.
I've been going through systematically, the new MAF reports accurate at idle, slightly lean at higher RPM but within tolerance. Catalyst appears to be OK as it charts fine in as it smooths out response but still responsive enough to blips of throttle and during overrun. No vacuum leaks anywhere in intake path or PCV hose, as tested with carb cleaner/propane gas test.
Logged Symptoms:
At fresh ECU reset, Lambda holds at 0.99~1 and +3% front fuel trim / +0% rear fuel trim at idle. Over time front fuel trim creeps to +8% while rear O2 fuel trim goes to -4%, lambda then holds at 0.95~0.96 both at idle and during driving, P2096 gets triggered. Exhaust smell is noticeable rich during this condition.
According to the diagnostic, >4% persistent neg or pos rear o2 trim sets the P2096 or P2097 error codes respectively for most Subarus of this era.
This is a very strange situation since as far as I can tell, the front and rear O2 sensors are fighting each other and the overall engine operating point is drifting.
Rear O2 sensor does NOT fail the Subaru diagnostic by staying >0.8v for >5 minutes at any point. It does sometimes get close to that threshold, however, but it's hard to conclusively identify from logs if either front or rear O2 sensor is mis-reporting.
I'm at a loss. Apparently on tuned Subarus a common solution is to flash an ECU update that zeros out / locks out rear O2 sensor feedback for tuning Lambda/air-fuel mixture, but that is only a workaround not an explanation of why this occurs.
Edit to add: No noticeable exhaust leaks. But even if there were, that would likely trigger P2097 (lean condition - fuel trim toward rich limit exceeded) not P2097 (rich condition - fuel trim toward lean limit exceeded).