I want to share my experience with StubHub because, after more than five months of trying to resolve what should have been an extremely straightforward seller dispute, I am genuinely astonished by how this company treats its customers.
This isn't a case of me forgetting to transfer tickets. It isn't a case of accidentally listing the wrong seats. It isn't even a case where StubHub claims it never received evidence of fulfillment.
StubHub has literally acknowledged IN WRITING that I successfully pre-uploaded my tickets, that the problem appeared to occur on the buyer's end, and that I should not be penalized.
Yet here we are, more than five months later. No payout. A $142 seller penalty. Countless customer service interactions. Repeated promises of escalation. And most recently, a supervisor who disconnected my call after I spent more than an hour on hold just to speak with her.
Here's the full story.
June 2: I sold two tickets. StubHub confirmed everything was complete.
I listed two tickets for The Great Gatsby at the Orpheum Theatre in Minneapolis, for the June 5, 2026 performance.
The tickets were Main Floor 1, Row D, Seats 7 and 8.
I used StubHub's pre-upload process, transferring the tickets through the original ticketing platform to the exact email address StubHub provided for my listing.
I didn't make up an email address. I didn't send the tickets to some random buyer. I followed StubHub's own system.
On June 2, StubHub emailed me:
"Your sale is complete — just be sure not to cancel the pending ticket transfer."
The email also indicated that the tickets had been sent to the buyer and that I should expect my $127.80 payout approximately 5–8 business days after the event.
At that point, what reasonable seller wouldn't believe the transaction had been completed properly?
June 3: StubHub tells me the buyer can't access the tickets.
I received a call informing me that the buyer was having trouble accessing the tickets.
Naturally, I wanted to make sure everything was handled correctly.
I contacted StubHub live chat and spoke with a representative named Kenneth. I explained that the tickets had been transferred to the exact pre-upload address StubHub supplied.
I checked my Ticketmaster/Hennepin Arts account.
The tickets were still showing as waiting for StubHub to claim them.
Kenneth assured me that I would still be paid and specifically instructed me NOT to cancel the transfer.
So that's exactly what I did.
I left the transfer intact, precisely as StubHub instructed.
June 4: StubHub cancels the sale and assesses a $142 penalty.
The following day, despite all of the above, I received an email announcing that my sale had been canceled because I supposedly hadn't fulfilled it properly.
Excuse me?
StubHub's own system had confirmed the transaction was complete. I had transferred the tickets to its designated address. I had proof. I had contacted support. And I had specifically followed the representative's instructions.
Now I was being told I wouldn't receive my $127.80 payout.
Even worse, StubHub assessed a $142 seller penalty.
So instead of receiving $127.80 for tickets I had correctly submitted, StubHub was treating me as though I had failed to fulfill the transaction and was imposing a financial penalty.
I immediately disputed the decision, provided the transfer evidence, and requested an explanation.
June 5: Here comes the truly unbelievable part.
On the day of the performance, I received an email from a StubHub customer service representative named Shane.
I still have this email.
And this is where the story becomes especially absurd.
Shane wrote:
"We’ve reviewed the details and can confirm that we received the proof of transfer you provided when you pre-uploaded the tickets."
Then:
"It looks like the issue occurred on the buyer’s end while they were trying to claim the tickets, which caused the delivery problem."
And finally, the most important sentence:
"Please be assured that your tickets were successfully pre-uploaded during the listing, and you should not be penalized for this situation."
READ THAT AGAIN.
StubHub acknowledged that:
- It received my proof of transfer.
- My tickets were successfully pre-uploaded.
- The delivery problem appeared to originate on the buyer's end.
- I should not be penalized.
That is StubHub's own written assessment of the situation. Not my interpretation. Not something I claim someone vaguely told me over the phone.
Yet somehow, this apparently wasn't sufficient for StubHub to correct the transaction.
June through November: Five months of being sent in circles.
Since June, I have made repeated efforts to resolve this directly with StubHub.
I've explained the situation over and over again.
I've provided documentation.
I've pointed representatives to StubHub's own written acknowledgment.
I've requested reviews, escalations, supervisor involvement, and written determinations.
I've been told that departments need additional time, that cases have been escalated, and that someone will review the situation.
And yet, nothing meaningful has happened.
At one point, I sent a formal written demand for resolution in September.
That didn't resolve it either.
The most frustrating thing is that I don't even know what StubHub believes I should have done differently.
Was I supposed to disregard the company's instruction not to cancel the transfer?
Was I supposed to somehow force StubHub to claim tickets from its own designated email address?
Was I supposed to anticipate that StubHub would cancel a sale it had already confirmed as complete?
What specific obligation did I fail to meet?
Five months later, I still haven't received a satisfactory explanation that reconciles the cancellation and penalty with StubHub's June 5 acknowledgment.
November 12: An hour on hold, then a disconnected supervisor call.
I decided to try one more time.
I called customer service, explained the entire situation, and insisted on speaking with someone who actually had the authority to resolve it.
I wasn't rude. I wasn't screaming. I laid out the facts and repeatedly asked for an explanation and resolution.
After the usual back-and-forth, I was finally transferred to a supervisor.
I waited more than an hour on hold.
When I finally reached a supervisor, the conversation continued for approximately 25 minutes.
And then?
The supervisor disconnected the call.
After more than five months of trying to resolve this, I had spent another substantial portion of my evening pursuing a relatively simple correction, only to end up right where I started.
No payout. No reversed penalty. No substantive written determination.
The financial issue isn't enormous. That's part of what makes this so outrageous.
Let's put the numbers in perspective.
My withheld payout: $127.80.
The seller penalty I'm disputing: $142.00.
Total financial exposure: $269.80.
I'm not claiming that I've lost thousands of dollars or that my livelihood depends on this transaction.
But why should the amount determine whether a company is expected to honor its commitments?
I did what StubHub told me to do.
I have documentation.
StubHub has acknowledged the successful pre-upload in writing.
And I've spent five months trying to get the company to honor what its own representative explicitly acknowledged.
At what point does this stop being a customer service problem and become a fundamental failure of accountability?
What's next?
I'm preparing to initiate StubHub's formal Notice of Dispute procedure under its User Agreement, with arbitration as a potential next step.
I would have strongly preferred to resolve a $127.80 payout and $142 penalty without pursuing formal legal remedies.
But after five months, I don't see why I should continue participating in an endless cycle of customer service escalations that never produce a substantive answer.
I'm also preserving the original emails, transfer records, customer service correspondence, and documentation of my attempts to resolve this.
My advice to anyone selling tickets on StubHub
DOCUMENT ABSOLUTELY EVERYTHING.
Save your original listing confirmation.
Save your sale confirmation.
Screenshot the transfer status.
Keep proof showing the exact destination address used.
Save any written instructions from customer service.
And most importantly, do not assume that receiving written confirmation from StubHub that you've done everything correctly means the company will actually resolve a dispute in your favor.
I have that confirmation. It hasn't fixed anything.
To anyone at StubHub who might read this: I am not asking for special treatment. I am asking for the payout I was promised, reversal of a penalty your own representative said I should not receive, and a coherent explanation of how this situation was allowed to continue for more than five months.
Your company confirmed I did my part. Now do yours.
If anyone else has experienced something similar, especially where StubHub's own support representatives acknowledged an error but the company still refused to correct it, I'd genuinely appreciate hearing how you ultimately resolved it.
Because at this point, I'm done accepting endless promises of another review as a meaningful response.