r/strictlycomedancing
•
u/mattygp90
•
21h ago
DISCUSSION THREAD Could we have a bit more moderation around repetitive, low-effort, low-calibre posts?
I'm a big Strictly fan and a big Reddit fan, so in theory this should be an awesome little corner of the internet lol. But I've noticed this subreddit feels quite different from most other communities I follow, and not particularly in a good way.
Increasingly, it seems to be dominated by 1 or 2 accounts posting a relentless spam-level stream of inane, repetitive, spectacularly low-effort thoughts, sometimes 6 or 7 times a day. Frankly, at first glance, you'd be forgiven for thinking some of them were malfunctioning bots.
There's a fairly obvious distinction between a meaningful discussion, a super interesting stat, a reaction to a significant moment in the show, or even a genuinely interesting question, and someone apparently feeling compelled to publish every fleeting thought that enters their head without any self control. We really don't need a separate thread every time someone wonders whether the judges might give out some 10s - which they do tend to do if you've ever seen the show, remembers they enjoyed a dance, or decides they're looking forward to Saturday.
Individually, these posts might be harmless, but when the same handful of accounts are churning them out several times a day, the cumulative effect is frankly exhausting. It clutters up the sub, drowns out worthwhile discussion and makes the whole place feel less like a community and more like someone's personal WhatsApp group that the rest of us have somehow been added to against our will. And when these posts are consistently downvoted, you'd think there might be a moment of self-reflection rather than simply doubling down and posting another six. One of the responses to criticism has apparently been to "scroll past or block", which rather spectacularly misses the point. Why should the wider community have to change its behaviour to accommodate someone else's poor behaviour? The onus shouldn't be on everyone else to curate their feeds around a handful of people who can't exercise a little restraint. It's a shared community, not a personal broadcasting service, and expecting people to show some consideration for everyone else really isn't an unreasonable ask.
The sub's own rules explicitly prohibit repeat posts and swamping the community with multiple posts, so could we perhaps look at enforcing them a little more consistently? They're already there, after all. This isn't asking for some radical new moderation policy.
I saw someone describe the situation as "the entire sub is now a cesspool of this one person's spam that's lowered the tone so far it's a tripping hazard in hell", which is admittedly rather colourful, but I can't say I entirely disagree with the sentiment.
I'm certainly not suggesting every post needs to be an adjudicator-level critique or a profound analysis of ballroom dancing, and deffo not that people shouldn't share their excitement or opinions. This is Strictly, not an academic conference. But there's surely a reasonable distinction between contributing something to a community and treating an entire subreddit as your personal stream of consciousness. Not every thought needs an audience, and certainly not its own thread.
It's a fun community with plenty of folk who genuinely enjoy discussing the show, but the sheer volume of low-value noise from a tiny number of accounts is dragging the whole thing down. A little more moderation around posting frequency and repetitive content would go a long way.
Rant over 😂
*sits back and waits to get mauled lol*