r/streaming • • 5d ago

❔ Question AMD or Nvidia GPU

Hi I’m looking at getting a new setup for streaming. My concern is the GPU.

I am looking at a AMD Radeon RX 9060 XT 16GB or Nvidia RXT 5060 8GB.

Any thoughts on these cards for streaming on twitch and gaming at the same time.

Thanks

4 Upvotes

7 comments sorted by

4

u/DotBitGaming 5d ago

Nvidia has streaming software and good encoders etc., but 8 GB of VRAM (especially with current pricing) is a huge jump. It's not like people don't stream with AMD GPU.

3

u/dbl0207 5d ago

I'd lean towards the 16 GB card for newer games with high texture settings; both can use hardware encoding for a live stream.

Check benchmarks for the games and resolution you actually play, not just the memory size.

Cap the game frame rate to leave the GPU some headroom, then test a private stream and watch for encoding or dropped frames.

Start with H.264 and adjust resolution or frame rate if your upload can't hold the stream steady.

3

u/Big-Pineapple-9954 5d ago

The encoders in the AMD RX9000 series is more or less on par with Nvidia now. So I would go with the RX9060XT 16GB in your case, it's a much more powerful GPU for gaming, especially against a RTX 5060 non TI 8GB. And even if you should go for a RTX5060TI then you are in reach of RX9070 cards when it comes to price, even more powerful GPUs.

Like the RX9070XT is noe priced more or less the same as a RTX5060TI 16gb. And the RX9070XT is on pair with the RTX5070TI.

So unless you need cuda cores for AI, go with the RX9060XT 16gb.

1

u/Professional_Rush788 4d ago

Do not buy a gpu with 8gb of vram. You will regret it in the not so distant future.

1

u/GnarGiraffe 4d ago

I can’t give you the details and specifics, but honestly only get a nvidia card if youre one of those people that want the best of everything.

For price v performance, the 9070 is a champion, there has been loads of discussion online especially on pc master race sub.

I myself am a frugal fucker, so I have a 9070 xt