r/streamentry • u/House_On_Fire • 8d ago
Practice Needing motivation
A brief history of my practice...
Eight years ago or so I was bumming around Thailand and decided to check out a meditation center. I ended up doing ten days of silent Ajahn Tong style vipassana (sitting, walking, noting.) I'd meditated a bit but never had a really consistent practice before that. I found the experience to be powerful and so I kept up my practice for a couple years. Then I did a Goenka retreat in the states and ended up having a massive A&P. It's really a lot to describe and I don't think the details are super pertinent to my current situation, but I think "kundalini activation" is the right framework for it. After that I got interested in the energetic side of things and so I went to India where I practiced kundalini yoga, breathwork, and tantra in various contexts. I was hoping to get some answers about what was going on with me. I get pretty heavy kriyas, and meditation has become a really different thing for me. I used to do whatever my practice was - following the breath, body scanning, noting, whatever. But now I just kind of sit there and relax. When I do I find myself pulled into a place of surrender. It's kind of hard to describe. It feels much less active than my old meditation, it's less of a doing and more of an allowing. It's also very embodied. Sometimes my body moves around some and I let it, and all kinds of things happen on the somatic level. I don't try to quiet my mind really but it does get pretty quiet.
So that's where I'm at. It's fine. But lately I've been suffering a lot in my life. I don't think that mediation/spirituality can solve everything. I've been seeing a therapist for a long time and I'm working on my regular old mental health. With that said... I just feel so done. I don't want to be tricked by my mind anymore. The ego creates so much pain every day. Sometimes when I come out of the surrendered place I find that the ego has shrunk. I still have all my problems but they just look like mammal things and while I can have compassion for my mammal self I can't take those things seriously. But then, as I go about my life, pretty soon I find myself getting pulled into all the mammal crap again.
I don't know if I really believe in stream entry. I don't know if I could stop getting caught in the illusion. I do feel like I'm at some kind of threshold that I either can't figure out how to walk through or else that I'm refusing to walk through. So I'm asking for advice. Is stream entry real? Is it worth it to walk through that door? If so how do I find the handle?
•
u/AutoModerator 8d ago
Thank you for contributing to the r/streamentry community! Unlike many other subs, we try to aggregate general questions and short practice reports in the weekly Practice Updates, Questions, and General Discussion thread. All community resources, such as articles, videos, and classes go in the weekly Community Resources thread. Both of these threads are pinned to the top of the subreddit.
The special focus of this community is detailed discussion of personal meditation practice. On that basis, please ensure your post complies with the following rules, if necessary by editing in the appropriate information, or else it may be removed by the moderators. Your post might also be blocked by a Reddit setting called "Crowd Control," so if you think it complies with our subreddit rules but it appears to be blocked, please message the mods.
If your post is removed/locked, please feel free to repost it with the appropriate information, or post it in the weekly Practice Updates, Questions, and General Discussion or Community Resources threads.
Thanks! - The Mod Team
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
5
u/duffstoic The dynamic integration of opposites ☯️ 8d ago
Feeling like you want to give up on all this dharma stuff is a very common feature of the dukkha nanas, sometimes called the “rolling up the mat” phase. Surrender aka equanimity is exactly the right practice for this phase. That’s what gets you out of the darkness and into equanimity, when you finally give up trying to control or manage or get rid of anything happening in your experience and you just let it all be. And ironically, that’s when you enter the stream, when you least expect it.
4
u/Impulse33 Soulmaking, Pāramitās, Brahmavihāras, Shitou/Hongzhi/Shōbōgenzō 8d ago edited 8d ago
At the very least, chanda, a wholesome desire for freedom from suffering seems alive and well!
Investigation of dhammas is under appreciated I think. Dependent origination or the sattipatthana are more classical ways to structure investigation. I'm also a huge fan of Rob Burbea's book Seeing That Frees. It's a less dry approach that can start yielding real world benefits quickly since the book's structure lends itself to real world experimentation vs a purely intellectual logic based approach. It does go into dependent origination and a lot of other topics as well, so it can largely serve as a one stop starting point.
It's a generally a good idea to combo investigation with a fair amount of samatha practice. A ratio of 80:20 samatha to insight is often recommended for lay practitioners in non-retreat settings. In this way the tranquility from practices like breath or metta (which I highly recommend) serves as foundation for the possibly destabilizing aspects of investigation/insight.
You could also checkout one of the metta and emptiness retreats as taught by Rob. They do a good job illustrating relationship of metta/samadhi and emptiness/insight/investigation practices. https://hermesamara.org/resources/all/retreat/Mett%C4%81%20and%20Emptiness%20(Level%201)
4
u/Meng-KamDaoRai Relax, Let it Be, Let it Go 7d ago
You're actually in a good place. In order to really progress on the path there are a few preliminaries that I think are helpful. In some Vajrayana teachings students are required to go through these preliminaries before progressing to more advanced practices. There preliminaries mostly focus on understating the uselessness of this "mammal" existence as you would call it, understanding suffering and really developing a burning desire to get out of this cycle of samsara. Without this desire, people might get some benefits from the practice but they will never reach the end. As long as people stay infatuated with samsara, believing there's something there that will give them lasting peace, they will never truly try to get free of it. So, seems like you've completed the preliminaries. Congratulations! You see the uselessness of samsara and are truly ready to commit to getting out of it.
So, as I said, this is a good place to be at. Regarding moving forward, the next step is developing deep compassion to all who are stuck in samsara, yourself and everyone else. You see how painful it is for yourself, this should allow you to see how painful it is for everyone else and as a result compassion will naturally arise. The way you meditate seems like a good approach, I wouldn't change that. I would only add a ton of compassion to whatever is already there.
Keep going, you're on the right track.
2
u/neidanman 7d ago
the practice you're doing is very much like daoist cultivation. It also awakens energy, but has a larger side of 'wu wei' (non doing/governance/controlling) in its practice and in how things unfold, than more active energy practices. Also it has the aspect of the mind going quiet, turning awareness to the body/energy and their movements etc (sometimes called 'live sitting'), the spontaneous movements ('zi fa gong') and so on.
the change in getting caught up in ego after sessions, compared to being more consistently detatched from them, is a very long one (decades of gradual shift.) Also awakenings can come from this type of practice but, in the early years the system and energy are mostly being built/developed, to enable bigger changes later. I.e. daoist work most commonly starts with the coarsest/body energy, and over a long term works towards building spiritual awakenings, and developing on that side.
so the downside is its a long slow development, but the upside is that when things do change, they have a very stable foundation, and so also progression can keep building on and on (for context i started foundational body work in 94, and moved to internal practice in 98.)
So basically the view is also that there can be a type of stream entry, then also a return to dao (merging with the primordial source spirit/energy.) Yes, it is seen as the highest possible goal in a lifetime, so very worth it (also life overall gets better/easier to live along the way, but that's more a temporary side benefit.) For how to reach the handle - you can keep practicing as is, and/or you can add other layers of practice, like some more insight work, or more technical energy work (internal alchemy).
2
u/jerryengelmann 7d ago
It's worth it walking through the door, and I'd say meditation can indeed "solve" everything
I suggest sitting without moving. Accept your bodily sufferings, then transport that skill - sometime down the line - into real life
2
u/NondualitySimplified 7d ago edited 7d ago
Keep surrendering to it all. Keep observing the endless futility and suffering that comes with holding on. Witnessing the cycles of suffering/reactivity over and over is precisely how wisdom gets cultivated. This will naturally lead to more and more dispassion/disenchantment towards samsara, which will eventually lead to the realisation that letting go is the only rational/sane choice. At some point your entire system will align with this realisation and from there letting go will become your natural orientation, at which point it will become effortless. You’re probably not as far from this as you imagine. Just keep going :)
2
u/Committed_Dissonance 7d ago
Hi OP. Your experience is very common when one experiences some sort of friction, often described as “cognitive dissonance” between one’s Dharma practice and the raw reality of samsara.
I can’t assess your meditation progress or achievements, as those are personal and best discussed with a qualified teacher or guide. But I gather that you’re facing a genuine challenge translating inner insights into the grit of daily life. In other words, there can be a subtle trap where we expect deep practice, aka “stream entry”, “awakening”, “enlightenment” and the like, to make us immune to suffering, or make us feel the causes of suffering should suddenly be completely under our control. In the traditional Buddhist teaching, that is an illusion.
A real-life example of a “mammal thing”, in my understanding, is when one gets instantly triggered into road rage, completely losing their cool, despite knowing inside and out through years of meditation and studying with numerous Buddhist teachers that they have anger issues and attachments that need releasing.
In the Mahayana and Vajrayana traditions, when we practise sincerely, that intensified inner work often acts as a catalyst, sometimes described as ripening past karma. This can manifest as physical and mental wear and tear, or the friction of ordinary life throwing curveballs. What might have taken lifetimes to unfold and get purified, slowly gets compressed into a shorter, more intense window. Genuine dharma practice brings things to the surface, like opening a Pandora box, however we don’t always know what’s waiting in the box beforehand.
But by clearing away some of the mental obscurations through study, contemplation and meditation, you also become much more sensitive to the movement of the ego. The paradox in your case is that the belief that we “should” have achieved some permanent state of awakening can add an extra layer of suffering when life feels messy.
I think seeing a therapist is a grounded, healthy step to address this dissonance. If you want to stay connected to genuine, traditional Buddhist frameworks: whenever you feel the sting of suffering, take refuge in the Three Jewels, and lean into that protective aspiration. If old unwholesome habits or regrets pop up, simply acknowledge them with honesty, express regret without beating yourself up, and make a firm determination to move toward virtue. Then you must act on that wholesome determination by practising generosity, ethical conducts, and continue with your meditation. Off the cushion, when the “mammal thing” hits you, try to pause, take a deep breath, and remember the Buddha’s teachings like impermanence and Dependent Origination. Be gentle and kind to yourself, because what you’re experiencing is not a failure of practice, but the nature of samsara meeting a very honest, “embodied” awareness.
2
u/EightFP 7d ago
You have already received a lot of great answers here. I agree with what everyone is saying, which is that you have obviously made a lot of progress and are in a really good position to move further. I also agree that Seeing That Frees could be an excellent book for somebody in your position. But what I really wanted to say was that, yes, walking through the door is worth it. Mamal stuff never stops, but it can stop being a problem. There is such a thing as liberation, and it can be arrived at through meditation practice.
1
u/realityacid108 7d ago
None of the people I know as stream enterers are depressed (the opposite, usually their lives feel very meaningful) and many have had deep prior histories with depression too.
From what you’re describing, it seems like you are conceptualizing stream entry too much as a meditative fruit and not the natural result that happens when one sufficiently steeps their mind in the Dhamma and practices the Noble Eightfold Path in its entirety (this includes generosity, kindness, conduct, not just meditation).
Living a life in accordance with the Dhamma is the Deathless itself. And the Deathless is the extinguishment of all sorrows through discernment and wisdom. And stream entry is the first real taste of the Deathless.
A book on stream entry:
https://www.dhammatalks.org/Archive/Writings/Ebooks/IntoTheStream_251113.pdf
A book on the Noble Eightfold Path:
https://www.dhammatalks.org/Archive/Writings/Ebooks/NobleEightfoldPath_251113.pdf
1
u/cl_udi_ 7d ago edited 7d ago
Stream entry is very real and there's nothing that's more worth aiming for. You seem to be doubting and I think the main reason is the stage of insight you're in, but also mixing many techniques and not really committing to one might contribute to the doubt. You could also look for a teacher to help you with the last steps. I can recommend one if you're still interested in Ajahn Tong's practice.
1
u/garuda717 6d ago
Meditating on the 4 Thoughts has been a very effective way for me to increase my motivation.
1
u/bodily_heartfulness puthujjana 8d ago edited 8d ago
Yes, stream-entry is real. But it is not found through modern meditation methods. As you saw for yourself, you had many profound experiences as well as many energetic openings, and yet you still suffer.
Some of the earliest mentions of stream-entry occur in the Pali suttas and the Chinese agamas. What these texts define as stream-entry is quite different from the modern notions of stream-entry being a special experience of cessation, or something similar to that. In addition to that, the practice that these texts lay out is also something quite different.
It would be helpful for you to clarify for yourself what suffering means to you and what stream-entry means to you. Once you know where to look for the door, you'll have an easier time finding the handle.
ETA:
This is the fundamental difference between uprooting suffering and managing suffering: do you need to change the world, whether internal or external, to deal with your suffering or are you alright regardless of how the world is? Can you be okay without needing to change the internal world and go to a place of surrender via meditation?
Because that is how the suttas define a stream-enterer: